Options
Question about dealers that specialize.
Because a dealer specializes in a series or type, can (should) you expect to pay a premium for their expertise? And is it warranted?
- There are 10 kinds of people in this world...those who understand binary and those who don't!
0
Comments
<< <i>Because a dealer specializes in a series or type, can (should) you expect to pay a premium for their expertise? And is it warranted? >>
No. No.
Specializing in 1854 and 1855 large FE patterns
<
<< <i>And is it warranted? >>
If you find someone that really knows their stuff, then yes it's more than worth it.
Russ, NCNE
Not necessarily, but a lot depends on how you present yourself
Coin's for sale/trade.
Tom Pilitowski
US Rare Coin Investments
800-624-1870
<< <i>Assuming the collector does not want to engage in the study and research necessary to be able to comfortably purchase the series on their own then the answer would be yes. The dealer's expertise can be of great value and is certainly worth a premium.
Russ, NCNE >>
What you say is true Russ but not all inclusively true. There will always be someone who knows more about coins than you (not you literally but you in a general sense). Advice or help from that person(s) that happens to know more is very valuable IMO.
Example: there is one dealer who attends local shows in my state and buys every single liberty cap and draped bust large cent in the room during the dealer hour. When the collectors enter the show, there is no copper for sale in the entire room except on his table. He actually has the nerve to leave the other dealers' coins in his case in a big pile with their handwriting still on it, and he won't sell those coins during the show. At the next show, the "fresh" coins appear in his case priced at high, high retail.
<< <i>Dealer who specializes = a dealer who pays full retail for coins from other dealers or at auction, then marks the coins up again and puts them in inventory. These people drive the prices through the roof. Often buyback prices are disappointing; sometimes buyback is not even offered, or the dealer will only take coins back in trade. In the long run, the collector generally loses a lot of money dealing with this kind of person, and what it boils down to is that their coins are no better than anyone else's; expertise doesn't make the coins worth more.
Example: there is one dealer who attends local shows in my state and buys every single liberty cap and draped bust large cent in the room during the dealer hour. When the collectors enter the show, there is no copper for sale in the entire room except on his table. He actually has the nerve to leave the other dealers' coins in his case in a big pile with their handwriting still on it, and he won't sell those coins during the show. At the next show, the "fresh" coins appear in his case priced at high, high retail. >>
This is a bit of an overgeneralization. Check out my prices. Most are lower than you'll find elsewhere.
Specializing in 1854 and 1855 large FE patterns
<
OK, but I bet that even you can think of 5 or 6 guys offhand that meet this description.
no no no and no no no
Don’t get me wrong, I had no one in mind when I asked the question. I’ve noticed when I look outside of my “circle of knowledge™” , and this is by no means a tough challenge. I find it to be true. I don’t mind paying for that knowledge or expertise because I know that what I am paying for is peace of mind.
<< <i>Because a dealer specializes in a series or type, can (should) you expect to pay a premium for their expertise? And is it warranted? >>
I say yes and yes. My preferred series is the Capped Bust Half Dime. There are 91 known die marriages in the series. If I find a dealer who specializes in these coins, I expect that dealer will offer properly attributed and properly graded coins. I also expect that he/she will charge me more for an R-6 or higher die marriage than he/she would for the many R-1 and R-2 marriages. Each of us is accustomed to paying a premium for expertise in our daily lives, and numismatics is no different. If you had to have a complicated surgery performed on your heart, wouldn't you pay a premium for a surgeon who specializes on the heart rather than have your child's pediatrician do it for less money? Just MHO.
<< <i>
<< <i>Assuming the collector does not want to engage in the study and research necessary to be able to comfortably purchase the series on their own then the answer would be yes. The dealer's expertise can be of great value and is certainly worth a premium. Russ, NCNE >>
What you say is true Russ but not all inclusively true. There will always be someone who knows more about coins than you (not you literally but you in a general sense). Advice or help from that person(s) that happens to know more is very valuable IMO. >>
I am willing to pay a premium if I am dealing with an expert that helps me achieve something.
"Something" might be n my case (I collect Morgan Dollars) helping me find attractive and not so common VAM varieties for example.
If the dealer performs a service for me by tracking down some rare variety that I had put on my want list and it is not just a case of his looking at the PCGS #'s on the holder at some trade show, then why shouldn't I compensate the service he renders?
At one time or another most of us will be willing to pay for the services of all kinds of specialists of one kind or another such as graphic artists, photographers, attorneys (bless their generous hearts), Medical Doctors (all of whom only have the Hippocratic Oath foremost in their minds), PR specialists, Coin Grading Services, Architects, Cooks, Wine Tasters and so forth.
And even if he does go through tons of slabs at a trade show and does find whatever it is I am looking for, I think such specialization deserves to be paid for within reason. I think many of us forget that dealers and collectors often coincide. To have become a dealer you generally will have started as a collector and will have spent long hours studying coins and related subjects.
I think what I don't like the idea of paying for is getting ripped off. That can happen when I find myself paying twice the market price for a common coin or even an uncommon coin.
True, there is a rule of thumb called Supply and Demand. That doesn't authorize an excess charge.
So I guess if the bottom line is, in my view, if the dealer is an expert and asks for a "reasonable" markup that may make his coins be "a bit" more expensive in absolute terms than those of his/her competitors and you are pleased with what he has sold you overall, the money is well spent.
Collecting since the 1980's
Morgan Dollars Circ. Strikes
- Basic Set - Varieties - Prooflike Basic Set - Date Set
- Carson City - Early S Mint Short Set - Mintmark Type Set
Morgan Dollars Proof
- Basic Set - Varieties
Peace Circ.
Just a couple of thoughts...
K
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
<< <i>If you pay a premium, it's not because the specialist deserves it. You pay it because you can't find the same coin for less elsewhere. >>
If the specialist has the coin you cannot find elsewhere than he deserves the premium since, obviously, he has made the effort to cultivate better sources.
Russ, NCNE
Didn't wanna get me no trade
Never want to be like papa
Working for the boss every night and day
--"Happy", by the Rolling Stones (1972)
However, if you are not an expert in your chosen area, then it makes sense to work closely with a "specialized dealer" who can better advise you as to when paying a premium IS most warranted. Further, Make sure your "specialized dealer" is truly experienced and reputable.
Partner / Executive VP
Heritage Auctions
For me, I would look to a specialized dealer for selection; but would not necessarily pay more for a coin from that dealer than I would elsewhere. As coins depend on eye appeal, rarity, popularity, etc.. for their value, even a non specialist may end up with a desirable coin that I would pay a premium for.
In other words - the premium is for the coin, not for the dealer who sells it.
The good thing about specialist dealers, is that they have a large selection of the coins I'm interested in.
The bad thing about them, is that I can't cherrypick them.
Ray
As a collector I may not get a super bargain price from the specialist but I WILL be paying current fair market value for a decent product. I much prefer buying from, and selling to, series specialists over other dealers.
President, Racine Numismatic Society 2013-2014; Variety Resource Dimes; See 6/8/12 CDN for my article on Winged Liberty Dimes; Ebay