I believe firmly that "freedom of religion" also covers my freedom from religion. However, I don't see any reason for "hyper sensitive PC whining" about it either. I believe what I believe, and four words on a quarter aren't all that much of a threat, are they?
Well, first you need to understand why it is there.
A Christian minister from Pennsylvania wrote Secretary of the Treasury Chase in 1861:
"One fact touching our currency has hitherto been seriously overlooked. I mean the recognotion of the Almighty God in some form on our coins. I shall propose.....the words "God, liberty, law" This would make a beautiful coin, to which no citizen could object. This would place us openly under the Divine protection we have personally claimed."
Secretary Chase to Mint Director Pollock:
"No nation can be strong except in the strength of God. The trust of our people in God should be declared on our national coins."
Pollock considered the issue for more than a year, and in 1863, suggested two mottoes, "God, Our Trust" and "Our Country; Our God".
Chase wrote back that he liked "In God we trust". Final authority was given by an act of April 22, 1864 so that the Mint Director could place the motto on the two-cent piece which was introduced in 1864.
Juedo-Christian history is a big part of this country, but according to that radical First Admendment clause of the US Constitution, a government endorsed religion is prohibited in this country.
However, the Supreme Court has stated that it is a generic God and not specific to a religion , so it remains.
Allah-o-Akbar - now can you imagine the whinning if that was on coins
What I find amazing is that the people that want "IN GOD WE TRUST" taken off our money seem to have NO problem using that money and accepting it and spending it, etc, etc, etc.....leave it alone and get over the religion stuff I say!!
Live like you were dying. ------------------------------- Bridget ---------- (My beautiful children!!)
<< <i>I get so pissed at people who can't read or won't read a simple document. Nowhere in the constitution does it say that "no government property or entity can display items relating to God." These "PC weenies," as Russ so eloquently put it, should crawl back under their rocks and hate people from a distance. I don't want them involved in telling me what I can see or cannot see based on their twisted beliefs. Leave the phrase on the coins, it doesn't hurt anyone with two brain cells to rub together. >>
And why has religion become such an issue in the past 15 years????? Used to be if you were an AMERICAN then we were all for one....now religion plays such a huge roll it's insane...just be an American and get over it.
Live like you were dying. ------------------------------- Bridget ---------- (My beautiful children!!)
Maybe someone's looking for a good argument, without dragging Legend/Laura into it? >>
I'm all over that, not the former part, was and am ambivalent about that, there's bigger fish to fry.
(shh, gotta whisper, it's been an hour and a half since the last post, almost off second page. time for this thread to be forgotten again, i hope...be vewy quiet...)
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes?
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
I can't see any good reason to remove "IN GOD WE TRUST". I believe it is proper to have it on US coins. Some of the reasons given for removing it DO concern me, but then, in this country we all have the right to our own opinion and the freedom to express it.
People who do not believe in a God also concern me. Always wondered why non-believers would ever care to be good moral people when they have no fear of offending their God.
I collect Capped Bust series by variety in PCGS AU/MS grades.
Well since the motto is already on existing designs there's no point in removing them. However for instance someone makes a commem and it's very artistically done, excellently minted and delivers a powerful message about the American people or Liberty etc should it be obligated to carry that motto when the existing message in that piece is very positive? The designer could have no agenda at all and could simply feel that the IGWT or E Pluribus Unum wasn't really necessary.
I'm not averse to it remaining -- there's much to be said for tradition, and this is and always has been a very Christian country -- but not having the phrase on coins does not amount to depriving anyone's free exercise, as many here have intimated.
<< <i>I can't see any good reason to remove "IN GOD WE TRUST". I believe it is proper to have it on US coins. Some of the reasons given for removing it DO concern me, but then, in this country we all have the right to our own opinion and the freedom to express it. >>
Exactly... well, at least the "right to our own opinion part" anyway. Overall, the majority has spoken, and they want IGWT left there. Majority rules. From a traditional/historical perspective, it doesn't bother me. A "loose" expression such as IGWT can be taken by many believers to mean whatever they want, or just plain ignored. It's not the same as gov't regulating and controling your religious choices and/or institutions. I've heard the "it's a slippery slope" argument from many, and even made a few of 'em in my time, but I just ain't in the mood to play today.
<< <i>People who do not believe in a God also concern me. Always wondered why non-believers would ever care to be good moral people when they have no fear of offending their God. >>
Statements like that put me in the mood... but I'll behave before we go too far OT.
Said simply... While true that our founding fathers, in large part, fled to this country for freedom of religion, I feel strongly this freedom should include the choice of no religion. By using God's name on a coin the implicit assumption of a God-worshiping nation is made, and incorrectly in my opinion.
Another argument is that this motto makes no sense. In God we trust. Trust to do what? Trust for what?
Realistically, the motto will stay because there is no political will to remove it and the religious right is too powerful. The politicians would rather spend their time removing our freedoms in the name of security, and the religious right would rather continue to subjugate the masses as they've done for millenia. Religion is a crutch for the weak-minded and politics is a game of the power-hungry, and I have no confidence in either...Mike
Collector of Large Cents, US Type, and modern pocket change.
<< <i>Realistically, the motto will stay because there is no political will to remove it and the religious right is too powerful. The politicians would rather spend their time removing our freedoms in the name of security, and the religious right would rather continue to subjugate the masses as they've done for millenia. Religion is a crutch for the weak-minded and politics is a game of the power-hungry, and I have no confidence in either...Mike >>
The motto was added during a period of revivalist religion in the middle of the nineteenth century. "Under God" was added to out Pledge of Allegiance during an anti-communist phase in the 1950s. Were it not for these particular contexts, neither phrase would have been visited upon these pre-existing items.
Once such sentiments are added, though, many seem to believe that they thereby take on some especial and permanent privilege, that obviously did not exist for them prior to their insertion.
I have little interest in warring with such people over their removal, just because I think we've got more important things to debate and resolve.
I do not like people imposing their priorities permanently on the rest of us, though. It's sort of like that representative out of Virginia deciding that Jefferson has to remain hereafter and forever on the nickel.
I co-wrote a song called "In God We Still Trust" that was recently cut by Diamond Rio (my co-writer Bill Nash performed it and it went to #1 on the Independent charts last year).
Diamond Rio has been getting a standing ovation at all of their performances, and the song is scheduled for release on their new album this summer. We reference the money issue in the song.
Seriously, I'm into coin design and one day I'd like to be designing coins myself. If I make something really inspiring is it absolutely imperative to have these mottos?
Personally I think it should stay. I am sick and tired of the few who are offended by the majorities way of life or being in this country. The constant whining about my right to live how I choose and then forcing the masses to conform so they are not offended which offends my way of life but they do not want to hear about that. I have my God and my guns and will always have them. The ACLU (Anti Christian Lawyers Union) has made it so honest hard working people have to watch what they say about and where they put God. This was a Christian state when it was formed and it should always be. If you read the Supreme court decision that removed prayer and 10 Commandments from school and compare it to the Constitution, it is like reading totally opposite writings. PETA and ACLU and all the other liberal groups who try and tell me how I should live so I dont offend anybody can go stick it where the sun don't shine and let me live my life how I want to and they can go do the same.
I have read evey single post of this thread, very interesting.
I got to laugh at all of the folks (the majority) who say "The Constitution does not prohibit In God We Trust" on our coinage. You are correct of course. Now, if one cared to understand that our system is the Constitution combined with court opinions intepreting that document as well as ammendments that have become part of the document, one might reach a different conclusion.
I am happy to say that I am an agnostic and I am very, very tired of being told that this is a Christian nation. It is a nation of numerous faiths; as well as millions who do not have belief in a supreme being. One poster questioned how a person could be moral without fearing a higher power. That is a hilarious statement. Yes, the folks who came here did so in part so that they could worship as they pleased. Read some history though: in many of the early colonies those who did not believe as the edlers of the colony believed were bannished. Real tolerant eh? I am a moral person and believ eit or not, have raised two very fine children who have been held out by the parents of their peers as paragons of behavior and comportment. How did that happen?
So, the Constitution does not prohibit mention of the Christian god?
Neither does it prohibit slavery. Let's bring that back, I would much rather go buy a couple of folks to do my lawn work than have to pay market rates to get the work done.
Women don't have the vote in the consitution so hey, no more of that nonsense!
If you have any sort of an ability to be intellectually honest you will have to admit that the Constitution's prohibition of establishment of a state religion, and the numerous specific legal opinions based upon that clause, very clearly point to the fact that no government in the United States is to endorse a specific creed, creator or religion.
I do not care hwo you worship, if you worship at all. Worship at a catholic church or an ashram or worship hopping tree frogs. Just do not presume that because you believe, I have to be exposed to the artifacts of your beliefs.
Them's my three cents. I do like the engraving of IGWT onb the Morgan a lot.
Proud recipient of YOU SUCK more than once and less than 100 times.
My oh my, this thread has risen like a phoenix. I posted it on 12-16-2004 and it drew many responses that day and the next. Almost 6 months later and less than 4 hours ago it was resurrected and sent to the top. Since that time 31 new responses have been posted. All are very interesting reads.
I guess I will calendar to TTT this post again in another 6 months to stir up the pot once again and see what opinions float to the top. Keep posting away everyone with your replies. SanctionII.
Hey Russ, what if it said "In Allah we trust"? Would you still want the motto there?
Honestly though, it's nothing to whine over.
Saddam and bin Laden don't trust in God, both are ultra hard-core Islamic and neither has any qualms about stashing/smuggling millions of US dollars, in cash, all of which has the "IGWT" motto. I guess if it's good enough for them then it must be good enough for all of us. Right Russ?
This country was founded on "Godly" principles by our Founding Fathers. This cannot be disputed. God was clearly in the minds of our founders when they formed this nation.
That does not mean this is a "Christian" nation; the Founding Fathers advocated freedom of religion - any religion. You are free to worship any "god" you choose, or to not worship or believe at all.
I don't think the motto on currency influences anyone to believe or not to believe.
IGWT doesn't offend me and I could care less if it were to be removed from future coinage. It certainly doesn't seem to have been a guiding prinicple for our collective behavior from 1860's to the present. How did the Buffalo Nickel escape?
I am what you might call an agnostic. "I God We Trust" is a little broad. Do I believe in an watchful God? No. Do i believe in a higher power? Yes. Are they/Them/It watching us and care? No.
I think it should be optional, not required. Small coins have trouble with putting all the required items on the coin and still having something resembling the ability to create a pleasing image.
Anytime you inject religion into something the government is involved with you will have the usual suspects beating their chests. I really dont care from the religion aspect with regard to coins. It would be nice to return to beautiful simplistic coins, the seated Liberty comes to mind.
Retired United States Mint guy, now working on an Everyman Type Set.
I find it interesting that many people say they don't care who is offended by what is on the money. I have a sneaking suspicion those same people would be VERY offended if the coin mentioned another God. They would want it removed because they were offended. I don't care if this country was founded on "Christianity." It was ALSO founded on slavery. Just because it is history doesn't make it right...that is just not enough justification though some of the OTHER reasons for keeping it make a lot more sense.
However, I really don't care about the matter at all. Let it go, let it stay, I could care less really. I am not an advocate of it being removed. It just doesn't matter to me.
People say we have freedom of religion. They are correct.
People say we have freedom FROM religion. They are also correct.
There will ALWAYS be this argument and it grows rather tiring doesn't it?
Let us be glad that we can argue things like this in this country and not resort to roadside bombs to get our message across...
<< <i>I find it interesting that many people say they don't care who is offended by what is on the money. I have a sneaking suspicion those same people would be VERY offended if the coin mentioned another God. They would want it removed because they were offended. I don't care if this country was founded on "Christianity." It was ALSO founded on slavery. Just because it is history doesn't make it right...that is just not enough justification though some of the OTHER reasons for keeping it make a lot more sense.
However, I really don't care about the matter at all. Let it go, let it stay, I could care less really. I am not an advocate of it being removed. It just doesn't matter to me.
People say we have freedom of religion. They are correct.
People say we have freedom FROM religion. They are also correct.
There will ALWAYS be this argument and it grows rather tiring doesn't it?
Let us be glad that we can argue things like this in this country and not resort to roadside bombs to get our message across... >>
I don't care what they do. The arguments used by either camp upset the other. Such a stupid thing to waste thought and energy on. It is up to the individual to "trust in God" or to trust in money.
Today's mighty oak is just yesterday's nut that held its ground.
I see no reason to tak eit off the currency, it's not offensive and it does recognize the spiritual foundation upon which this country was built. I think traditions like this are important.
<< <i>I agree with Russ, the reason anyone would lobby for its removal is probably because it offends an atheist or a group that does not believe in God.Tbig >>
I am an atheist, and I'm not in the least offended by this being on our money. I am after all just an average every day A$$hole, and could be wrong.
I also don't understand the big stink about saying the pledge of allegance? It contains "One nation under god" but is not specific about any particular god. If your in our country going to our schools you should.
I don't believe people should be forced to pray in school. But would have no problem with elective courses in religion in public schools. Such a class should touch on all religions. I think there would be less trouble in our schools if teachers could use more OLD FASHION methods. Like NUNS use to. (no I went to public school)
We are getting to be to mamby pamby. And as a result to many (not all) kids have no respect for anything or any one. Safety, safety coodle, coodle, BAAAAA!!!!!!! PAIN IS A GOOD TEACHER. OOOOOps sorry about the rant. Just my opinion pz
(Old man) Look I had a lovely supper, and all I said to my wife was, “That piece of halibut was good enough for Jehovah”.
(Priest) BLASPHEMY he said it again, did you hear him?
<< <i> This was a Christian state when it was formed and it should always be. >>
Please substantiate this statement...Mike >>
At the time the Constitution was written, the predominate religious faith was Christianity in this country. the establishment of religion statement was so the Government would not be telling you how to worship God and you cando so however you chose. That was one of the major reasons for leaving England and escaping the Church of England. The "separation of church and state " was only mentioned one time and it was in a private letter from Thomas Jefferson. Slavery was to be abolished inthe Constitution but it would not have been ratified as such. Jefferson and Washington both said that a free nation cannot survive on slavery. When I have more time I will post all of the court decisions and Constutional clauses and ammendments for comparison. The University of Houston completed a study as to what made us a country. The findings found that almost all of the writings that founded this nation were from a Christian origin in one way or another. Chek out Eric Barger's"Rise Fall and Redemption of America". It goes into great detail about this subject.
I will be patiently waiting for more good info from you on this subject, as you said you would do when you have more time. We seem to be on the same train of thought.
I collect Capped Bust series by variety in PCGS AU/MS grades.
It should stay. However, all OTHER deities should be added in the interest of harmony, diversity, and all the other "ities" that make our nation great. And each political party also. While this may clutter a coin design, it could work just swell on the paper money. Or squeeze the coins out a whole lot bigger like bracteates. This may be inconvenient and possibly dangerous to small children (but some of whom would be spared a lifetime of agony from swallowing our present coinage) and cause some loss of commerce to less conscientious nations, but what does that matter so long as not one individual is left out of the mix in the interest of fostering self-esteem to the extent that we have something to think about other than a global effort to make us do silly things?
IGWT has become more tradition than religious on coins. I really don't care if it changes or not. Maybe we should change it to: "In something we may or may not trust" That'll make everyone happy.
I think it should be removed. It says "In God We Trust" so I assume that the "we" represents Americans. Some americans don't believe in the christian god, or any god at all. It's almost like forccing christianity on others. I don't like the fact that americans mix religion and government... especially since this was part of the reason that they left england to come here.
Please download this app to help fight cancer at 0 cost. At no extra cost to you purchases from Amazon and other participating retailers will benefit research!
or maybe the guy who first placed the motto on the coin didn't know how to spell GOLD?..."in Gold we trust"...?...was the motto first introduced on a gold coin?
Comments
<< <i>Wonder why this thread got resurrected? >>
Maybe someone's looking for a good argument, without dragging Legend/Laura into it?
A Christian minister from Pennsylvania wrote Secretary of the Treasury Chase in 1861:
"One fact touching our currency has hitherto been seriously overlooked. I mean the recognotion of the Almighty God in some form on our coins. I shall propose.....the words "God, liberty, law" This would make a beautiful coin, to which no citizen could object. This would place us openly under the Divine protection we have personally claimed."
Secretary Chase to Mint Director Pollock:
"No nation can be strong except in the strength of God. The trust of our people in God should be declared on our national coins."
Pollock considered the issue for more than a year, and in 1863, suggested two mottoes, "God, Our Trust" and "Our Country; Our God".
Chase wrote back that he liked "In God we trust". Final authority was given by an act of April 22, 1864 so that the Mint Director could place the motto on the two-cent piece which was introduced in 1864.
Juedo-Christian history is a big part of this country, but according to that radical First Admendment clause of the US Constitution, a government endorsed religion is prohibited in this country.
However, the Supreme Court has stated that it is a generic God and not specific to a religion
Allah-o-Akbar - now can you imagine the whinning if that was on coins
My posts viewed
since 8/1/6
-------------------------------
Bridget
----------
(My beautiful children!!)
<< <i>I don't really care. I would rather see people actually trust in God more than see a good motto rendered meaningless. >>
-------------------------------
Bridget
----------
(My beautiful children!!)
<< <i>I get so pissed at people who can't read or won't read a simple document. Nowhere in the constitution does it say that "no government property or entity can display items relating to God." These "PC weenies," as Russ so eloquently put it, should crawl back under their rocks and hate people from a distance. I don't want them involved in telling me what I can see or cannot see based on their twisted beliefs. Leave the phrase on the coins, it doesn't hurt anyone with two brain cells to rub together. >>
And why has religion become such an issue in the past 15 years????? Used to be if you were an AMERICAN then we were all for one....now religion plays such a huge roll it's insane...just be an American and get over it.
-------------------------------
Bridget
----------
(My beautiful children!!)
<< <i>
<< <i>Wonder why this thread got resurrected? >>
Maybe someone's looking for a good argument, without dragging Legend/Laura into it?
I'm all over that, not the former part, was and am ambivalent about that, there's bigger fish to fry.
(shh, gotta whisper, it's been an hour and a half since the last post, almost off second page. time for this thread to be forgotten again, i hope...be vewy quiet...)
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
People who do not believe in a God also concern me. Always wondered why non-believers would ever care to be good moral people when they have no fear of offending their God.
Tiger trout, Deerfield River, c. 2001.
<< <i>I can't see any good reason to remove "IN GOD WE TRUST". I believe it is proper to have it on US coins. Some of the reasons given for removing it DO concern me, but then, in this country we all have the right to our own opinion and the freedom to express it. >>
Exactly... well, at least the "right to our own opinion part" anyway. Overall, the majority has spoken, and they want IGWT left there. Majority rules. From a traditional/historical perspective, it doesn't bother me. A "loose" expression such as IGWT can be taken by many believers to mean whatever they want, or just plain ignored. It's not the same as gov't regulating and controling your religious choices and/or institutions. I've heard the "it's a slippery slope" argument from many, and even made a few of 'em in my time, but I just ain't in the mood to play today.
<< <i>People who do not believe in a God also concern me. Always wondered why non-believers would ever care to be good moral people when they have no fear of offending their God. >>
Statements like that put me in the mood... but I'll behave before we go too far OT.
Said simply... While true that our founding fathers, in large part, fled to this country for freedom of religion, I feel strongly this freedom should include the choice of no religion. By using God's name on a coin the implicit assumption of a God-worshiping nation is made, and incorrectly in my opinion.
Another argument is that this motto makes no sense. In God we trust. Trust to do what? Trust for what?
Realistically, the motto will stay because there is no political will to remove it and the religious right is too powerful. The politicians would rather spend their time removing our freedoms in the name of security, and the religious right would rather continue to subjugate the masses as they've done for millenia. Religion is a crutch for the weak-minded and politics is a game of the power-hungry, and I have no confidence in either...Mike
<< <i>Realistically, the motto will stay because there is no political will to remove it and the religious right is too powerful. The politicians would rather spend their time removing our freedoms in the name of security, and the religious right would rather continue to subjugate the masses as they've done for millenia. Religion is a crutch for the weak-minded and politics is a game of the power-hungry, and I have no confidence in either...Mike >>
Now you did it!
More chance for something that has doubling.
<< <i>Keep it.
More chance for something that has doubling. >>
Best argument so far.
Once such sentiments are added, though, many seem to believe that they thereby take on some especial and permanent privilege, that obviously did not exist for them prior to their insertion.
I have little interest in warring with such people over their removal, just because I think we've got more important things to debate and resolve.
I do not like people imposing their priorities permanently on the rest of us, though. It's sort of like that representative out of Virginia deciding that Jefferson has to remain hereafter and forever on the nickel.
Here's a warning parable for coin collectors...
<< <i>It should stay. Why? Because there is no legitimate reason to remove it.
(Note: The whining of hyper-sensitive PC weenie busy-body control freaks is not legitimate.)
Russ, NCNE >>
Amen
1) It is unconstitutional (First Amendment)
2) It is anti-Christian (Matthew 22:19-21)
Whose God are we talking about, anyway? There are so many of them...
Diamond Rio has been getting a standing ovation at all of their performances, and the song is scheduled for release on their new album this summer. We reference the money issue in the song.
Bottom line: keep it!
<< <i> This was a Christian state when it was formed and it should always be. >>
Please substantiate this statement...Mike
I got to laugh at all of the folks (the majority) who say "The Constitution does not prohibit In God We Trust" on our coinage. You are correct of course. Now, if one cared to understand that our system is the Constitution combined with court opinions intepreting that document as well as ammendments that have become part of the document, one might reach a different conclusion.
I am happy to say that I am an agnostic and I am very, very tired of being told that this is a Christian nation. It is a nation of numerous faiths; as well as millions who do not have belief in a supreme being. One poster questioned how a person could be moral without fearing a higher power. That is a hilarious statement. Yes, the folks who came here did so in part so that they could worship as they pleased. Read some history though: in many of the early colonies those who did not believe as the edlers of the colony believed were bannished. Real tolerant eh? I am a moral person and believ eit or not, have raised two very fine children who have been held out by the parents of their peers as paragons of behavior and comportment. How did that happen?
So, the Constitution does not prohibit mention of the Christian god?
Neither does it prohibit slavery. Let's bring that back, I would much rather go buy a couple of folks to do my lawn work than have to pay market rates to get the work done.
Women don't have the vote in the consitution so hey, no more of that nonsense!
If you have any sort of an ability to be intellectually honest you will have to admit that the Constitution's prohibition of establishment of a state religion, and the numerous specific legal opinions based upon that clause, very clearly point to the fact that no government in the United States is to endorse a specific creed, creator or religion.
I do not care hwo you worship, if you worship at all. Worship at a catholic church or an ashram or worship hopping tree frogs. Just do not presume that because you believe, I have to be exposed to the artifacts of your beliefs.
Them's my three cents. I do like the engraving of IGWT onb the Morgan a lot.
I guess I will calendar to TTT this post again in another 6 months to stir up the pot once again and see what opinions float to the top. Keep posting away everyone with your replies. SanctionII.
Hey Russ, what if it said "In Allah we trust"? Would you still want the motto there?
Honestly though, it's nothing to whine over.
Saddam and bin Laden don't trust in God, both are ultra hard-core Islamic and neither has any qualms about stashing/smuggling millions of US dollars, in cash, all of which has the "IGWT" motto. I guess if it's good enough for them then it must be good enough for all of us. Right Russ?
That does not mean this is a "Christian" nation; the Founding Fathers advocated freedom of religion - any religion. You are free to worship any "god" you choose, or to not worship or believe at all.
I don't think the motto on currency influences anyone to believe or not to believe.
"In God We Trust"?
As far as I can throw em.
jm agnostic o
W.C. Fields
If I only had a dollar for every VAM I have...err...nevermind...I do!!
My "Fun With 21D" Die State Collection - QX5 Pics Attached
-----
Proud Owner of
2 –DAMMIT BOY!!! ® Awards
Anytime you inject religion into something the government is involved with you will have the usual suspects beating their chests. I really dont care from the religion aspect with regard to coins. It would be nice to return to beautiful simplistic coins, the seated Liberty comes to mind.
However, I really don't care about the matter at all. Let it go, let it stay, I could care less really. I am not an advocate of it being removed. It just doesn't matter to me.
People say we have freedom of religion.
They are correct.
People say we have freedom FROM religion.
They are also correct.
There will ALWAYS be this argument and it grows rather tiring doesn't it?
Let us be glad that we can argue things like this in this country and not resort to roadside bombs to get our message across...
<< <i>I find it interesting that many people say they don't care who is offended by what is on the money. I have a sneaking suspicion those same people would be VERY offended if the coin mentioned another God. They would want it removed because they were offended. I don't care if this country was founded on "Christianity." It was ALSO founded on slavery. Just because it is history doesn't make it right...that is just not enough justification though some of the OTHER reasons for keeping it make a lot more sense.
However, I really don't care about the matter at all. Let it go, let it stay, I could care less really. I am not an advocate of it being removed. It just doesn't matter to me.
People say we have freedom of religion.
They are correct.
People say we have freedom FROM religion.
They are also correct.
There will ALWAYS be this argument and it grows rather tiring doesn't it?
Let us be glad that we can argue things like this in this country and not resort to roadside bombs to get our message across... >>
Well said! Amen!
If they could do it back in the early 1800's, with a screw press mind you, then it can be done today.
Just a thought.
Fred
BTW - it should stay because it is tradition.
<< <i>I agree with Russ, the reason anyone would lobby for its removal is probably because it offends an atheist or a group that does not believe in God.Tbig >>
I am an atheist, and I'm not in the least offended by this being on our money. I am after all just an average every day A$$hole, and could be wrong.
I also don't understand the big stink about saying the pledge of allegance? It contains "One nation under god" but is not specific about any particular god. If your in our country going to our schools you should.
I don't believe people should be forced to pray in school. But would have no problem with elective courses in religion in public schools.
Such a class should touch on all religions. I think there would be less trouble in our schools if teachers could use more OLD FASHION methods. Like NUNS use to. (no I went to public school)
We are getting to be to mamby pamby. And as a result to many (not all) kids have no respect for anything or any one.
Safety, safety coodle, coodle,
BAAAAA!!!!!!!
PAIN IS A GOOD TEACHER.
OOOOOps sorry about the rant.
Just my opinion
pz
(Priest) BLASPHEMY he said it again, did you hear him?
<< <i>
<< <i> This was a Christian state when it was formed and it should always be. >>
Please substantiate this statement...Mike >>
At the time the Constitution was written, the predominate religious faith was Christianity in this country. the establishment of religion statement was so the Government would not be telling you how to worship God and you cando so however you chose. That was one of the major reasons for leaving England and escaping the Church of England. The "separation of church and state " was only mentioned one time and it was in a private letter from Thomas Jefferson. Slavery was to be abolished inthe Constitution but it would not have been ratified as such. Jefferson and Washington both said that a free nation cannot survive on slavery. When I have more time I will post all of the court decisions and Constutional clauses and ammendments for comparison. The University of Houston completed a study as to what made us a country. The findings found that almost all of the writings that founded this nation were from a Christian origin in one way or another. Chek out Eric Barger's"Rise Fall and Redemption of America". It goes into great detail about this subject.
I will be patiently waiting for more good info from you on this subject, as you said you would do when you have more time. We seem to be on the same train of thought.
<< <i>Just Move it to the edge of the coin! >>
Good idea, I'll do that if/when I make a US coin design.
While this may clutter a coin design, it could work just swell on the paper money. Or squeeze the coins out a whole lot bigger like bracteates. This may be inconvenient and possibly dangerous to small children (but some of whom would be spared a lifetime of agony from swallowing our present coinage) and cause some loss of commerce to less conscientious nations, but what does that matter so long as not one individual is left out of the mix in the interest of fostering self-esteem to the extent that we have something to think about other than a global effort to make us do silly things?
http://my.affinity.is/cancer-research?referral_code=MjI4Nzgz