Options
original coins can look ugly too
The dipping controversy never seems to end.
I prefer "original" coins but let's face it, original can be hideous. I get a chuckle when I see countless ads describing coins with "lovely" golden toning or splashes of this and crescents of that. On the flip side, a beautifully colored and evenly toned silver coin can be a knockout but there seem to less of them and more of the blotchy, stained, streaky, cloudy specimens. Sellers often refer to the originality of their coins, but can we really differentiate between the lightly dipped coins that have naturally retoned in a very beautiful way, from the untouched originals? Putting euphemisms aside, tarnish is really what we are talking about. Light gold is beautiful on a silver or nickel coin. Bright centers fading into dark toning near the edges can be breathtaking. A blotch of charcoal gray tarnish on liberty's chin stinks! I cannot believe the high grades some of these heavily tarnished coins receive. The color and luster is so awful, it looks just short of damage. How does one accurately grade these things? In general, original is better, but I would not automatically disregard a lightly dipped attractive coin with full cartwheel luster.
I prefer "original" coins but let's face it, original can be hideous. I get a chuckle when I see countless ads describing coins with "lovely" golden toning or splashes of this and crescents of that. On the flip side, a beautifully colored and evenly toned silver coin can be a knockout but there seem to less of them and more of the blotchy, stained, streaky, cloudy specimens. Sellers often refer to the originality of their coins, but can we really differentiate between the lightly dipped coins that have naturally retoned in a very beautiful way, from the untouched originals? Putting euphemisms aside, tarnish is really what we are talking about. Light gold is beautiful on a silver or nickel coin. Bright centers fading into dark toning near the edges can be breathtaking. A blotch of charcoal gray tarnish on liberty's chin stinks! I cannot believe the high grades some of these heavily tarnished coins receive. The color and luster is so awful, it looks just short of damage. How does one accurately grade these things? In general, original is better, but I would not automatically disregard a lightly dipped attractive coin with full cartwheel luster.
0
Comments
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
The other thing is that "original" is often used to describe very unattractive coins. As if the fact that it's "original" is supposed to make us forget that the silver coin is almost very dark, almost black, and that the old coppers *are* black.
While attractive, truly original coins are the most desirable, IMO, there are plenty of unoriginal coins that have good eye appeal, and there are plenty of original coins that look like crap.
<< <i>While attractive, truly original coins are the most desirable, IMO, there are plenty of unoriginal coins that have good eye appeal, and there are plenty of original coins that look like crap. >>
Well said Ziggy 29.
Ms 64 for a brown tarnished, so-called original coin? Give me a break. How does the grader accurately view the surface? Does he have x-ray vision?
Multicolored toning? The instances when that looks good are few and far between. Oh, and don't forget "Patina", though sometimes beautiful, a word that often puts a happy face on dull and lifeless.
some of the surfaces up close to really understand the ugliness. BUT, it could also mean some of us old grumpy collectors
have lost our mind and don't know what eye-appeal is anymore.
And yet, if some of these "Ugly" coins have only been viewed by pictures on the Internet for their Luster, or lack of, it cannot
be an accurate observation IMO. I'll take as many of these worn out dull crusty "ugly" coins as my checkbook will allow.
This Bust half even has gunk, that oozes in the denticles and many of the other devices. Is there help for me?
<< <i>Sometimes it takes a whole lot of years to appreciate an "Ugly" Crusty old coin. Perhaps it might involve really studying
some of the surfaces up close to really understand the ugliness. BUT, it could also mean some of us old grumpy collectors
have lost our mind and don't know what eye-appeal is anymore.
>>
Please don't misunderstand me. An original uncleaned worn coin with a few spots, dirt and dark coloring is perfectly fine with me. What I don't like are the uncirculated examples with unnattractive tarnish that are advertised with positive attributes and high grades. How can an uncirculated coin have positive eye-appeal when it has a deep brown muted color covering the once brilliant surface?
<< <i>ill never torget the NGC ms-67 merc I saw that was so fugly, I couldn't even believe it GOT a grade! Sorry..at that point, dip the sucker! Then again, you might be left with a pitted surface underneath! It is Russian roulette I guess....! >>
I know what you mean. That is another reason why heavy toning can be a big problem. What is really going on below that color? If it were a valuable coin like that, I would not dip it for the reason you stated.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>stman, RYK---Those coins are beautiful and shouldn't be dipped (obviously). But what about the other toned coins that are unattractive? What do you guys suggest we do with those coins? >>
Don't buy them if ya don't like them. It's really very simple.
<< <i>stman, RYK---Those coins are beautiful and shouldn't be dipped (obviously). But what about the other toned coins that are unattractive? What do you guys suggest we do with those coins? >>
If a coin is really unnatractive because of ugly tarnish, it should not be called choice or gem. If a heavily toned coin were dipped succesfully and it received a high grade, that would not be a problem for me to buy.
Now, dipping the coin myself? Personally, if I had a poorly toned valuable coin, I WOULD LEAVE IT ALONE. If someone else buys it, then let that person can take the chance. There is a big risk in doing this.
<< <i>
<< <i>stman, RYK---Those coins are beautiful and shouldn't be dipped (obviously). But what about the other toned coins that are unattractive? What do you guys suggest we do with those coins? >>
Don't buy them if ya don't like them. It's really very simple.
What are dealers supposed to do with them if you and evryone else "don't buy them". Melt them down? Toss them in the trash? Or dip them and sell them? Don't get me wrong. I like attractive original coins and don't want to see them getting dipped. But what are dealers supposed to do with the ones with ugly toning and finger prints?
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
Original is beautiful.
Like ...original... SIN.
It has its place.