Options
PCGS has the screws down
clackamas
Posts: 5,615 ✭
Got my orders back today, all I can say is that the screws are down to the point of being near absurd, at least with Jeffersons. time to send some coins in for grade guarantee.
0
Comments
myCCset
<< <i>Hey, I got Canadian Proof dollars back last week that were PR69DCAM.
and how many PR68DCAMs???
<< <i>the screws are down to the point of being near absurd >>
I find that right now there's this dicotomy at PCGS. I only submit Mercury Dimes so I can sympathize with the above because the grades on Mercury Dimes are off 2-3 points this year versus last year (MANY threads on this topic on the Registry Set forum). 65FB/66FB coins are going in to 63FB/64FB holders or MS holders with No Bands; MS61FB and MS62FB coins are getting graded AU58, little MS63 (and higher) coinage is crossing, etc. Certain denominations are getting HAMMERED when it comes to grading while others seem to be getting better than anticipated grades
I believe you guys didn't develop instant amnesia and have forgotten how to grade coins, all of a sudden, and neither have I. I hope these strange grading patterns go away, and quickly...or at least change to favor Mercury Dimes so I can submit a boat load of coins
<< <i>
<< <i>Hey, I got Canadian Proof dollars back last week that were PR69DCAM.
and how many PR68DCAMs??? >>
How many of these do you have???
keets,
It's good to see you posting again.
<< <i>PCGS has the screws down >>
See above for understatement.
Pop quiz!
Q: How can you guarantee you'll get a cameo SMS coin out of PCGS right now?
A: Submit a DEEP CAMEO.
<< <i>the screws are down to the point of being near absurd >>
Not "near" absurd, they already crossed that line in to stupid territory.
Russ, NCNE
The Ludlow Brilliant Collection (1938-64)
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>please don't tell me that first time in my life I have coins in for crossover and grading >>
Actually, that means it is good for the grade guarantee coin I have in (since 3/24/05 in their system with no news!!!!!). Should be a "no-brainer" downgrade and pay the Bochiman!
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
<< <i>Still wondering about this one >>
This one just graded NO CAM:
There were also two cameo 1965's on the same submission that went NO CAM. The only SMS that graded cameo is a 1967 that's almost a DCAM.
Russ, NCNE
Knowledge is the enemy of fear
<< <i>I just got back an ms65rd 1966 Lincoln that I thought would be a lock ms67. I wonder if I sold it for the $0.50 they think it's worth, and the buyer upgraded it to 67rd in a few years, and sold it for $5000, if I could somehow sue or have a case vs pcgs. >>
Well, the great (yeah right) thing about America is anyone can sue for anything (want a cup of hot coffee?). However, since they state they are "giving opinions" and that your coin does not grade BELOW what they state, I doubt you would win.
I've been told I tolerate fools poorly...that may explain things if I have a problem with you. Current ebay items - Nothing at the moment
It's good to see so much life still in these forums after all this time.
Looks like instead of you fighting your dealer on a grade you have to read the "mood" of the experts by your coin barcode. Maybe some of your guys could put together a book and sell.
Maybe their just getting back at some of the dealer on this board bragging about all thier upgades. Now it's your turn to lose......DO YOU FEEL LUCKY?........
Where else would future upgrades come from???
<< <i>Well this is exactly why I got out of coins in 1987 before all the grading services. I for one thinks it makes PCGS look bad, grade the D** coin by whatever standard you set and stick to it! Everytime the price goes up the grades go down or is this just a grading services "pride" thing? PCGS, NGC, ANACS, and maybe ICG are the only coins I trust but if this turns into a "look we have the highest standards" contest I'm out for one. Grade the coin the same in 2005 as you'll be doing in 2025 this shows me the "science of coin grading" isn't even agreed among the "experts"
Looks like instead of you fighting your dealer on a grade you have to read the "mood" of the experts by your coin barcode. Maybe some of your guys could put together a book and sell.
Maybe their just getting back at some of the dealer on this board bragging about all thier upgades. Now it's your turn to lose......DO YOU FEEL LUCKY?........
This is all the more reason to buy coins with eye appeal. A pretty coin will always be a pretty coin.
Knowledge is the enemy of fear
<< <i>
<< <i>Well this is exactly why I got out of coins in 1987 before all the grading services. I for one thinks it makes PCGS look bad, grade the D** coin by whatever standard you set and stick to it! Everytime the price goes up the grades go down or is this just a grading services "pride" thing? PCGS, NGC, ANACS, and maybe ICG are the only coins I trust but if this turns into a "look we have the highest standards" contest I'm out for one. Grade the coin the same in 2005 as you'll be doing in 2025 this shows me the "science of coin grading" isn't even agreed among the "experts"
Looks like instead of you fighting your dealer on a grade you have to read the "mood" of the experts by your coin barcode. Maybe some of your guys could put together a book and sell.
Maybe their just getting back at some of the dealer on this board bragging about all thier upgades. Now it's your turn to lose......DO YOU FEEL LUCKY?........
This is all the more reason to buy coins with eye appeal. A pretty coin will always be a pretty coin. >>
Like all those high $$$$ toned coins...are you feeling lucky?
Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Well this is exactly why I got out of coins in 1987 before all the grading services. I for one thinks it makes PCGS look bad, grade the D** coin by whatever standard you set and stick to it! Everytime the price goes up the grades go down or is this just a grading services "pride" thing? PCGS, NGC, ANACS, and maybe ICG are the only coins I trust but if this turns into a "look we have the highest standards" contest I'm out for one. Grade the coin the same in 2005 as you'll be doing in 2025 this shows me the "science of coin grading" isn't even agreed among the "experts"
Looks like instead of you fighting your dealer on a grade you have to read the "mood" of the experts by your coin barcode. Maybe some of your guys could put together a book and sell.
Maybe their just getting back at some of the dealer on this board bragging about all thier upgades. Now it's your turn to lose......DO YOU FEEL LUCKY?........
This is all the more reason to buy coins with eye appeal. A pretty coin will always be a pretty coin. >>
Like all those high $$$$ toned coins...are you feeling lucky?
Maybe I do feel lucky
Knowledge is the enemy of fear
I have submitted several times across the street and they have gotten just as bad if not worse.
Those guys are hurting me big time. Coins that had been slabbed cams and cracked are no longer cameos.
They still look like cameo to me. But what do I know. I'm just a collector and not a grader!!GGGRRRRR!!
-----------
etexmike
about 2-3 months ago i started paying more attention to MS64-65FS coins for some of the tougher dates in current PCGS holders.
<< <i>I have still never submitted any coins to PCGS. Sounds like I'm missing all the fun. Then again, I'm not a hard-core masochist. Hey, send 'em through again! What's another round of submission fees and postage both ways? once they get slabbed like you want em to, you'll sell for those "obscene profits", right?
Agreed!
<< <i>i seem to be getting hit at the "money grade" with many of the Jeffersons i've been submitting lately. that means i get 65FS instead of what i screen as 66FS. i try to be optimistic by telling myself they're PQ for the grade but in the end it doesn't matter since the coins are for my FS collection.
about 2-3 months ago i started paying more attention to MS64-65FS coins for some of the tougher dates in current PCGS holders. >>
Exactly Keets. Also on big money coins in any grade in FS they seem to use any excuse. if a step is even a tad weak, no way, the step is there but any weakness, even sligt get the thumbs down. The other thing is that any nick, even if it does not bridge a step is an automatic disqualifier.
The difference between them is so blatant that PCGs should have to regrade correctly that coin! I see the presidential review is $20 I wonder if that is worth the effort, and if it does get upgraded - correctly - you should be refunded on the earlier grading cost!!
I will be writing them about this - as new customer and collector, and member of their system, I am not pleased.
<< <i>I hate to admit it, but I think PCGS has actually gotten less conservative with their grading as of late. >>
Actually when it comes to classic coins, that's true. The differences between PCGS and NGC in general have been narrowing in recent years. There were always some NGC coins that were as good or better than their PCGS counterparts. Now that is is happening more and more.
As for moderns, welcome to the world of market control, guys. The stuff you are getting graded is quite common, and to keep the prices up the number of high grade pieces in the holder has to be controled. If PCGS put a lot of MS-67 or PR-69, cameo coins out there the prices would fall, even among the cult members who pay the big bucks. AND the complaints would be a lot worse thant the grousing that starated this thread.
Someone (with lots of money) should run a crackout experiment.
NoEbayAuctionsForNow
<< <i>I've got some MS 62 Washingtons that are infinetly better than some of the MS 66 Omaha Bank Hoard coins I own. You tell me why... >>
The biggest reason is that the services don't spend a lot of time agonizing over the grades of common date coins. The grades at the services have quotas. They must grade a large number of coins in a day. When they see a roll of common date coins come in, they just run though them and grading consistency suffers. I’ve seen this with common date Walking Liberty half dollars. There are Walkers in MS-64 holders that are better than coins in MS-65 holders, yet the MS-64 cost less than half as much. Aside from registry considerations the smart collectors buy the “PQ” MS-64s.
I see the presidential review is $20 I wonder if that is worth the effort
Been there, done that, have about a half a dozen tee shirts...it's pointless. DH will either agree with the stated grade, somehow rationalizing it, or will simply ignore providing feedback on coins that any collectors can see are improperly graded. Can't say that's the norm, but at least this has been my experience with Presidential review -- it's a tax on naive people
In all fairness to DH, though, he was very pleasant/cordial in the responses/comments he did make.
<< <i>As for moderns, welcome to the world of market control, guys. The stuff you are getting graded is quite common, and to keep the prices up the number of high grade pieces in the holder has to be controled. >>
That's an interesting theory, Bill. I assume it was formulated based on your extensive experience handling and submitting moderns.
Strangely, though, it falls flat with most of the coins we're discussing. Take, for example, the coins 66Tbird and I posted about in this very thread. None of them are worth more than $100 at the top end even with the cameo designations that they should have received.
The PCGS shaft is universal across the entire value spectrum, not just the insane, ripoff, stupid money, idiot level pop tops.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>
<< <i>As for moderns, welcome to the world of market control, guys. The stuff you are getting graded is quite common, and to keep the prices up the number of high grade pieces in the holder has to be controled. >>
That's an interesting theory, Bill. I assume it was formulated based on your extensive experience handling and submitting moderns.
Strangely, though, it falls flat with most of the coins we're discussing. Take, for example, the coins 66Tbird and I posted about in this very thread. None of them are worth more than $100 at the top end even with the cameo designations that they should have received.
The PCGS shaft is universal across the entire value spectrum, not just the insane, ripoff, stupid money, idiot level pop tops.
Russ, NCNE >>
Don't be a put down artist, Russ.
I've looked at a lot of Walkers in 63, 64 and 65 since I had to do some want list work.
And no I don't send in Walkers for grading. Almost EVERY MS-64 graded common date Walker is a mistake. The reason being that you can't sell them for enought to pay for a nice raw coin plus the grading fees and shipping.