Options
PCGS MS-65 Set of two Wisconsin extra leaf 25c closes at $1099!
Rick Snow (Eagle Eye Rare Coins) had 7 sets of PCGS graded MS-65s and 4 of MS-64 PCGS sets left. Bidding started at $524 for the MS-65s and $374 IIRC for the lesser graded coins. I don't think this a fluke. I admit, I was skeptical at first, thinking many more would be found, and although that still could happen, I believe the national publicity and the interest of the general public may turn out to make these coins worth having.
With raw ones, most likely NOT MS-65 and most likely MS-63/4 at best, selling for $600 or so on eBay, I don't think the final price was that outrageous.
As a dealer, I think all this coin publicity will be good for the hobby.
Just as an aside, I spoke to Rick Snow last week about these coins and he said that visually, the NGC MS-66 examples were virtually indentical to the PCGS Ms-65s, for what that's worth. I believe Rick has many more at PCGS just waiting for their return from the grading service. Don't expect a starting price of $524 for the two-piece set this time!
Ira
With raw ones, most likely NOT MS-65 and most likely MS-63/4 at best, selling for $600 or so on eBay, I don't think the final price was that outrageous.
As a dealer, I think all this coin publicity will be good for the hobby.
Just as an aside, I spoke to Rick Snow last week about these coins and he said that visually, the NGC MS-66 examples were virtually indentical to the PCGS Ms-65s, for what that's worth. I believe Rick has many more at PCGS just waiting for their return from the grading service. Don't expect a starting price of $524 for the two-piece set this time!
Ira
Dealer/old-time collector
0
Comments
San Diego, CA
Stupid money from stupid people.
Only an idiot would pay that for modern crap.
Okay, I took care of that for you modern bashers, so you can just move on to another thread.
Russ, NCNE
for that money.....To each his(her) own
San Diego, CA
<< <i>I would guess that a 1980-p nickel on cent planchet is much rarer than these coins and that only cost around $200.00 . If this is worth $1000.00 than the 1980-p nickel on cent should be worth at least $10,000.00 . >>
Its all about DEMAND!!
<< <i>I would guess that a 1980-p nickel on cent planchet is much rarer than these coins and that only cost around $200.00 . >>
I know we've had this discussion many times before here, but rarity does not equate to value. Demand does. Need I dust off the ol' 1909-S VDB example?
Edited: My trigger finger ain't what it used to be, Bajjarfan!
Here's a warning parable for coin collectors...
Agreed, that is why the commercials during the Super Bowl was so expensive.
They call that pump and dump in the stock market.
San Diego, CA
San Diego, CA
<< <i>There's a sucker born every minute.
Stupid money from stupid people.
Only an idiot would pay that for modern crap.
Okay, I took care of that for you modern bashers, so you can just move on to another thread.
Russ, NCNE >>
Thank you, Russ, for saving me the time and effort to respond.
Still Have you ever noticed how some people can write something like "Modern coins suck," which has NEVER been my position, and never draw a response from the modern coin enthusiasts? Yet if others make the comment that the price paid seemed to be a bit high, the modern enthusiasts attack those people like a pack of wild dogs?
I think that it might have something more to do with profits and selling things for high prices than a TRUE love of modern coinage.
This time you've got rarity and demand, Big Media driven demand, only 1 or 2 actual (not anecdotal) finds of relatively few versus the number who want them and are currently looking.
Remember human nature, gents? You really think after all these people strike out on finding one, they will give up? They will want one = demand. All of them will want one. At present, there is probably one complete set for about every thousand people who want one. As business people, what does that suggest to you?
Apropos of the coin posse/aka caca: "The longer he spoke of his honor, the tighter I held to my purse."
<< <i>How long before the Bubble burst???? >>
12-18 months.
<< <i>pump, pump, pump!!! >>
Hey, its all a demand game now! Especially since the world had learned about these from all the media attention. I must admit that the prices seem really outrageous right now but this event is true for litterally anything that everybody, or what appears to be everybody, wants!
The reality is that these are super hot right now and if your in the business, modern crap or not, you want to take advantage of this surge in interest just for the profit potential!
If I lived closer to Tuscon(sp), I would have been down there in a heart beat!
The name is LEE!
To use these unusual, different, intriguing, even fascinating anomalies to defend a $10,000 price tag on a pop 1 1987-d MS70 FS cameo nickel because of its "conditional rarity" (when there are 410,000,000 other MS examples out there) is just bizarre.
--Severian the Lame
<< <i>Hey, its all a demand game now! >>
Really? Than why the heavy promotion by dealers who haven't had much to say on these boards until now?
<< <i>At present, there is probably one complete set for about every thousand people who want one. >>
Talk about anecdotal.
And Rick Snow? Right place at the right time. You have any idea how much he has made from these things??? I saw him at the FUN show with ROLLS of them...
----Lloyd
P.S. You guys are talking about a "bubble bust". You think it will really change someone's life that drastically if the prices go from $1000 to $200??? WHO CARES!!!!!!!!!
<< <i>pop 1 1987-d MS70 FS cameo nickel >>
I've never seen an MS70CAM 1987-D Nickel. They must be very, very rare.
Russ, NCNE
I still have coins in to PCGS (The "WOW!" rolls we call them) and should have them at Long Beach. We made a deal with Bob Ford, the guy who discovered these. We will be offering NGC 3-piece sets with Bob's signature on the label (inside the holder). Only 110 possible sets, but not all will get even grades, so we think 75-90 sets. We'll have those at Long Beach as well. Bob Ford will be at out table as well. (Table 442).
I gave a free set to Samuel (Notlogical) for writing up an article for Central States. I wrote an article for The Numismatist regarding this experience.
You can't deny that the State Quarter Program alone has accelerated interest and demand so much, more than any other time in what, decades? I bet that (some of) you dealers here can point to the year 1999 as the year your business started to really grow. It was modern coinage that you have to thank for that. Personally, I dig all coins, and I think having a quarter that changes its reverse five times a year, is the freshest idea the U.S. Mint has ever come up with. Fresh = good. I'm looking forward to the new nickels, can't wait to see what Alaska is going to look like, while I search for a really nice half-cent.
If a person pays $1000 for a coin he is totally and completely happy with, ANY coin, does that make him stupid?
<< <i>And bill jones, typical - always the little boy on the outside looking in. >>
Nice put-down, really classy.
Do you own a nearly complete type set of U.S. from 1793 to the present? Do you have a 1907 High Relief $20 gold, which is that basis for your signature coin? How many holes are in your collection?
Everything is relative. No I don’t have one of these defective Wisconsin quarters, and I don’t really want one. It doesn’t do anything for me just like my 1863 Salamander Civil War token might not do anything for you. But I could get $2,500 or more for it, and there are only about 15 of them known. Everything is relative.
Do you have an example of the 1976 “bell ringer” Bicentennial dollar? Yes, there was such thing that came from a defective broken die, which looked the Liberty Bell was swinging. You don’t hear of it now. But it could have been promoted back than, just like this mint oddity.
Yes it’s fun to be the first your block to have the something, but sometimes it can get expensive. Just ask those who paid high prices for the 1995 doubled die cents until we found out that there were too many of them to sustain a high price. All I advise people is to look before you leap. It’ fun to sell things for high prices, but it’s no fun to get stuck with them. At it’s also no fun to stick a good customer with a coin falls in value by large amounts.
You want to call me “a little boy” for an opinion go ahead. I’ll just consider the source
<<Heck, a pretty nice g6 1795 half dollar for $1k (give or take a few dollars) >>
$1k will still get you a magnificent Indian gold eagle in 63 or so, see 1926 or 1932 at the PCGS guide:
the pcgs guide
and I suspect that several of the Indian gold eagles at Heritage today will go for about $1k when bidding is done:
heritage Indian gold eagles, 11 Feb 05
Really worn ugly crap!
<< <i>$1k will still get you a magnificent Indian gold eagle in 63 or so, >>
Common expensive crap!
Buzz-Log: What the world is searching for
Cha-ching! An error in printing the Wisconsin quarter sent searches on coins climbing...
Popular Quarter Searches
1. Wisconsin quarter
2. Quarter collecting
3. State quarters
4. Rare quarters
--Severian the Lame
in 1965 when I led the cheer and I love it in 2005 when it's all the rage. We now have two
generations of coinage in circulation which was hjated or ignored when it was issued and prac-
tically every day since. There are huge numbers of rare and desirable coins in circulation just
because they exist no where else. It never seemed possible to have neat coins to collect when
I was a boy simply because everything was checked and rechecked before I ever had a chance
see it. Other collectors with far more resources saved vast numbers of coins negating the poss-
ibility that I could ever have something rare that others didn't. It didn't seem possible that soon
everyone else would simply turn their collective backs on coins and leave it all to me. But then
clad coins were issued, the roll market collapsed and other collectors started chasing Morgans or
anything old. Now circulation is littered with rare crappy coins and for the main part there are
still very few looking.
But there are many thousands who have taken up collecting coins from circulation in the last few
years and many thousands more in the last few days. Those who think that the future isn't com-
ing have been wrong for decades and are wrong now.
<< <i>You modern guys are strange. This isn't a "modern", any more than a 1972dd is a "modern" or the 1998 JKF Matte is a "modern". There is something intrinsically different about these quarters. They are interesting, they are (apparently) rare. They are from a limited, widely collected, design- and date-specific series. They will be just as collectible in circulated condition as they are uncirculated. Don't believe me? Bet you'll check every WI quarter you get for the next several years.
To use these unusual, different, intriguing, even fascinating anomalies to defend a $10,000 price tag on a pop 1 1987-d MS70 FS cameo nickel because of its "conditional rarity" (when there are 410,000,000 other MS examples out there) is just bizarre. >>
and Lloyd then writes:
<< <i>Weiss is right. And bill jones, typical - always the little boy on the outside looking in. These quarters have had AMAZING press!!! ALL OVER. So naturally, every Tom, Dick and Harry want a set. I have a set, and if I could sell it for $1000+ now, I wouldnt. Because I WANT the set. This is not considered a typical "Modern Coin" . Buying a high condition Jefferson Nickel, when they made 400 Million of them, to me, is foolish. These Wisconsin quarters already have a great story. THE MINT DOESN'T REALLY HAVE AN ANSWER ON HOW IT HAPPENED!!! Sure, there may be 1000's out there, but not millions. Look at the 1955 DDO cent. You could buy one every day no problem if you wanted to. But they aint cheap! High demand, and low supply. That is the beauty of capitalism.
And Rick Snow? Right place at the right time. You have any idea how much he has made from these things??? I saw him at the FUN show with ROLLS of them...
----Lloyd
P.S. You guys are talking about a "bubble bust". You think it will really change someone's life that drastically if the prices go from $1000 to $200??? WHO CARES!!!!!!!!! >>
I started this topic today, and although I am a dealer, I have not taken a seller position on these coins. I bought a few sets, sold the rest last week, and kept one for myself. If one of the folks who asked me for a set would sell one back to me at a decent profit for them, I'd listen.
I had a chance to buy many from Rick Snow at the FUN show, thought they were interesting, but really didn't think about it much, for as you know, I tend to specialize in high-grade key dates in most series as well as early Type and Lincoln cents.
You have never seen me touting modern material, and that's not because I'm a snob. It just that I believe the true rarities tend to be in the "classics." But, I don't put down the collecting interests of those who do collect modern. I have nothing to gain if the set goes up to $5000 unless I decide to sell my own set of two, which I don't see happening.
What so many seem to be missing here is that this is really a VERY BIG DEAL!
It looks to me as if some mint employee or two softened a pair of working dies, engraved an extra leaf of two diiferent designs into that die, hardened it again, and thus struck of hundreds or thousands from each design. Then, they replaced the dies with the normal ones and if they had any sense, destroyed the renegade dies.
This is NOT Lincoln smoking a pipe as on those novelty cents. This modification was added to a working die and coins were struck, at the Denver facility, from those dies.
This is significant. Both PCGS and NGC have given unique coin numbers to these two specific coins and these "oddities" or variations will at least be mentioned in the 2006 Redbook.
Again, I am NOT promoting these variations, but clearly they ARE significant and I expect they will have long-lived collector demand. Whether the current values hold, surpass these levels, or drop down to 1/10 of what they are selling for today is not for me to predict, so I won't.
But these variations can be clearly seen with the naked eye, unlike the highly promoted 1995 doubled dies, and it appears as if the occurence of these specific Wisconsin quarters minted in Denver has so far been far, far less than those 1995 doubled die cents!
Rick Snow was fortunate to be in the right place at the right time. He treated the selling of these coins professionionally and honorably, as I would come to expect from Rick, and no one can or should fault him in any way for his merchandising of this significant footnote to the State Quarter series.
Ira
Cladking, you haven't fallen for WI quarters' siren song, have you?
Well there was a lot of disclosure about the coins, and I recall frequent updates right on these forums about the number of coins found, plus plenty of disclaimers about lack of knowledge concerning how the coins came to be and total numbers in existence. While I'm not sold on the purported "investment" potential of the WI quarters (and I'm usually game for a gamble), certainly the disclosures went a long way to educating people around here so they could make an informed decision about purchasing a set.
1. Can't afford spending money on money right now.
2. The error itself doesn't appeal to me....I prefer clips, off-centers & that ilk.
3. I've never bought coins for investment, and I won't start now.
My opinion is that interest won't last, because it's one of those "need to compare it to a normal one to see what's wrong" kind of errors. I prefer errors that stand on their own without needing a companion coin.
However, someone did make the point that it's a nice easily visible error, unlike the 1995 cent...I hadn't previously considered that when thinking about collector interest.
My cynical side says that big numbers of these will turn up somewhere and the hype will be for naught. But who knows, with the story now hitting the general media, perhaps the non-collectors will create some additional demand.
<< <i>Rick Snow was fortunate to be in the right place at the right time. He treated the selling of these coins professionionally and honorably, as I would come to expect from Rick, and no one can or should fault him in any way for his merchandising of this significant footnote to the State Quarter series.
Well there was a lot of disclosure about the coins, and I recall frequent updates right on these forums about the number of coins found, plus plenty of disclaimers about lack of knowledge concerning how the coins came to be and total numbers in existence. While I'm not sold on the purported "investment" potential of the WI quarters (and I'm usually game for a gamble), certainly the disclosures went a long way to educating people around here so they could make an informed decision about purchasing a set. >>
I also am not predicting any type of investment "potential" for these unusual Wisconsin quarters. But, then, I've never sold coins as "investments." I've been around so long I remember the bloodbath people took, both "investors,", collectors as well as dealers when there was an abrupt reversal in prices in the early '80's and then also about ten years later. Most of that involved heavy promotion of rather common material an rather outrageous prices. Folks are still suffering from the after effects of those debacles. Talk of Wall Street getting involved along with several major brokerage houses fueled this catastrophe, and I'd NEVER want to see this repeated. I sell coins as collectibes with a "store of value." They may be worth more or less or stay the same as when purchased 3,5 or ten years earlier. Since I sell mainy key dates in many series as well as the classics, some if not many might reap a respectable profit if they were to resell into a strong market like today. But that notwithstanding, I do not treat coins as investments.
Would anyone treat a plasma of LCD Hi Definition TV as an investment? You enjoy it, get pleasure out of viiewing it, but there's little programming now that will let us realize its full potential, we know prices will come down dramatically, yet many tens of thosusands of these are sold monthly, if not more.
We buy them becuase we want to, we will enjoy them, and I hope many buy their numismatic treasures beacuse they truly want them and enjoy them and not because of hopes of massive gains in the future. They are round bits of history and reflects mores of the times, and whether you collect modern, classics, Lincoln cents of all stripes, participate in competitive Registry set rankings, or anything else, it should be an enjoyable pastime, a HOBBY, not a lottery.
Ira
Back in the 1970s early 1980s a bunch of sharks almost ruined this hobby by selling overgraded, amssively overpriced coins to buyers who did not know what they were doing. A lot of dealers sat by and viewed these croioks as "colleagues" and refused to condemn their actions. Some legitimate dealers even supplied these unscrupulous sellers with "sliders" which provided the scam artists with material to sell. Too late some dealers came to realize that these crooks were hit and run artists who were runining their business and the hobby.
Third party grading fixed much of the problem, but overpromotion of the latest "hot item" at wildly inflated prices remains a problem. People can collect whatever they like, but I advise them to use caution. Losing a lot of money is NO FUN, and it's the first step toward turning budding collectors off to the hobby.
<< <i>I would guess that a 1980-p nickel on cent planchet is much rarer than these coins and that only cost around $200.00 . If this is worth $1000.00 than the 1980-p nickel on cent should be worth at least $10,000.00 . >>
Apples and oranges.
a) There are estimated to be 130 million State quarter collectors.. how many nickel on cent planchet collectors are there??.. How many Jefferson Nickel collectors are there??..
b) These got national press a few days ago..
c) Ira is nobody's fool.. when he gets into these, that should tell you something.. he was skeptical about them.. then he bought some..
I just watched a coin and jewelry dealer in Ohio put up four fixed price eBay auctions for low leafies.. he ran one with a fixed price of $175.00 each for three coins.. it lasted 15 minutes. He listed three more at $175.00 each. That one lasted two minutes. He listed a few more. That one lasted two minutes. Then he listed a fourth auction at $199.00. That one was gone in a few minutes..
Well duh.
Why did he list coins that are bringing $400 to $500 for $175.00 instant purchase??.. Because he's mainly a jewelry dealer??.. After his first auction sold out in 15 minutes, would it not be right to assume he should think "Wait a minute, something's going on here, and I don't know what it is, do I, Mister Jones".. but it did it again, the same way, twice, and they sold even faster.. duh.. D'oh!!.. so in his fourth auction he jacks it up to $199.00 and they still sell just as fast..
All he had to do was look at closed auctions to see what they've been selling for the past few days.. why didn't he??.. Or did he??.. Who knows..
Hey, I could write a book here, but I've gotta work on some magazine articles, so have fun. If you think these leafy coins are dopey, then don't buy them. If you missed out when they were cheap, then just say so, and lick your wounds. They're still going up. Hell, I don't give a rat's patoot about a lot of collectible fields, but if someone gave me the tip of the decade, and a way to make a fast 1000% profit, I could ake a lot of money to buy things I really like, or pay the bills, or whatever.. whether I was into what I was speculating on or not.. it's free money, dude, and those opportunities don't come around very often..
I am not telling anyone to take my advice, because afterall, who am I to tell people how to spend their money, and there's no guarantee in any of this, but I've been watching these quarters like a hawk for two weeks, I see a trend here, and the big boys see a trend, and if you think when Rick Snow gets his second load in from PCGS that he's going to be posting them at the same price as he did his first load, dream on.. but ultimately, it's your money.. and your free will to do what you want with it..
Harv
- John Wayne, "The Shootist" (1976.. his final film)..
<< <i>Those who think that the future isn't coming have been wrong for decades and are wrong now.
Cladking, you haven't fallen for WI quarters' siren song, have you? >>
There is a very timeless song drifting in the wind. It is the final notes in a game of
musical chairs as well as the "fat lady" warming up. There is a siren song that is a
music which has always played and can be heard by anyone who is willing to listen
with his heart over time.
Yes, there is certainly a siren song with this new coin and in time I'll almost certainly
heed it, but in the mean time I'll merely observe. It matters little to me that the cost
may be much higher when it's time to add it to a collection because the new verses
will make up the difference.
A lot of dealers sat by and viewed these croioks as "colleagues" and refused to condemn their actions.
Seems like there hasn't been much change along these lines...
<< <i>and if you think when Rick Snow gets his second load in from PCGS that he's going to be posting them at the same price as he did his first load, dream on.. but ultimately, it's your money.. and your free will to do what you want with it.. >>
-Do you work for Rick Snow?
Was it the quarter variety that got you posting again?
<< <i>
<< <i>and if you think when Rick Snow gets his second load in from PCGS that he's going to be posting them at the same price as he did his first load, dream on.. but ultimately, it's your money.. and your free will to do what you want with it.. >>
-Do you work for Rick Snow?
Was it the quarter variety that got you posting again? >>
This is the second time you've asked why I started posting again.. it's called keeping up with a hot trend. It's called research and education. I could just as easily lurk here and not post anything, and I'm sure there are hundreds if not thousands of people who are doing exactly that.
I don't work for Rick Snow. I work for me. I write for computer magazines. I'm not sure if I've ever even met him, unless it was at a Long Beach show. I bought a couple of these leafy slabs from him, he shipped them to me by Express mail for free, I'm merely a satisfied customer. I've never stepped foot in his store. I've been in AZ, in Phoenix, in Flagsaff, in Scottsdale, in other places, but never Tucson. Probably wouldn't recognize him on the street..
Maybe someday, if I hit the lottery, I'll buy an 1856 Flyer from him. Or from Ira. Fat chance, but you never know.
Harv
- John Wayne, "The Shootist" (1976.. his final film)..
I gave a free set to Samuel (Notlogical) for writing up an article for Central States. I wrote an article for The Numismatist regarding this experience.
BIG Kudos out to Rick for supporting Samuel, a very enthusiastic YN!!
I collect State Quarters (modern crap) in NGC pfuc70 and bought from Rick Snow when I first heard about
them and i"m a very satisfied customer. He was nice and sent the set very quick. I'm not trying to resell just
wanted a NGC set before 1,050,000 other State Quarter collectors started looking for them. This my first
purchase of anything modern under MS67 because it's unique and I think other State Quarter collectors will
want a set also.
There are many people here who are questioning the value of these coins, or stating "I wouldn't pay 50¢ for one" etc... Since this is a new thing, I can appreciate these views. I woudn't buy one if they came out in New York, or somewhere else. I do Indian Cents, not State-Quarters. But to each their own. Imagine a collector coming into the hobby asking, "Why would someone pay $2,000 for a 1829 N-4 Large Cent in VF when the 1829 N-3 is only $750. Must be an idiot!" (just picked a random variety Large Cent). We'll if you do your research and see the track record of the coins you ARE interested in you see what is the going rate. If you are not interested in Large Cents then the price difference is whacky, stupid, insane! If you are a State Quarter-Collector who wants one of the WI varieties you check the ebay sales and guage your comfort level and buy. Or don't buy. In an internet world price history from yesterday is old news.
I feel the value of these will settle around $500 per coin for average MS64's. That's based on the values of other varieties of similar population (1982 No P dime) and the demand expected for the state-quarter series.
You are usually dealer-bashing, gloom and doom, and so negative. It gets old. I'll bet my "biggest" $10 Indian Eagle is worth more than your WHOLE type set. I'll give you a clue - it was the last year they made them. I do have a HR 1907 $20, thank you very much. And it's a nice one. (only $20 I have!!!).
You and another guy (I made a truce with) make my blood boil. Worry about yourself. Sometimes I have to be unclassy and negative. You leave me no choice. You said consider the source. I am just a passionate collector, that hopes the rest of the U.S. loves the beauty of all coins like me.
----Lloyd
<< <i>Just in case you all missed this in Rick Snows post:
I gave a free set to Samuel (Notlogical) for writing up an article for Central States. >>
BST successful dealings with:MsMorrisine, goldman86
I think it is great for us to state our opinions about this (and other issues), but I am disappointed that something like this should result in mean-spirited posts.
and placed him on the Wisconsin 25c where he could become popular again. NGC could add the Bridgeport to the 3 coin Wisconsin set to make a nice 4 coin set. And for those really looking to expand, maybe a Kennedy looking at Lincoln penny for a rousing 5th! I'd buy all the sets up! But do those 5 coins count as 5 in a box of 20? hmmmm?
I guess I missed out on the pissing minuteman 25c and have now done the same on the Wisconsin. Two major league mistakes in a few years!
roadrunner