Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Politics and the Grading of Coins

I find it pretty pathetic in todays world that grading services have come to the point in time in which their subjective grading abilities have evolved into whothlessness....I thought the whole idea was to have coins graded to create a fair and just market in which to buy and sell coins...but they have turned it into a circus...it is no better than it was when people bought and sold and traded coins amoung themselves...why waste $15 more on a coin to have it graded when you will not receive the grade that it deserves...maybe oneday these grading services will also get their fraudulant grading award....maybe the key is that it is so subjective!!! try putting up coins in MS65 holders against MS62 holders and finding the 62's are much nicer...yeah are they creating their own demize...maybe just maybe!!!!!! Time will tell.

Comments

  • Options
    originalisbestoriginalisbest Posts: 5,970 ✭✭✭✭
    What are you talking about?

    In all probability you are likely, not as good at grading as you might think. To expect 100% consistency out of humans is not rational, not at grading, or with any other endeavor.
  • Options
    clackamasclackamas Posts: 5,615 ✭
    It does seem weird sometimes that certain people seem to get the grades. I have had a few of the coins that I sold upgrade and those upgrades were big money. I do not think that the day to day operations permit favoring one submitter over another but the special invitionals sure do. If PCGS would do away with them I would start submitting again but for now I have stopped. It is simply disheartening to see a coin you know is an MS67 go though 3 times on your dime only to be sold and make it first time for a multi thousand dollar hit.
  • Options
    FrattLawFrattLaw Posts: 3,290 ✭✭


    << <i>I do not think that the day to day operations permit favoring one submitter over another >>



    Think again, unfortunately.

    Michael
  • Options
    nankrautnankraut Posts: 4,565 ✭✭✭
    Based on the backlog @ pcgs, a lot of people apparantly disagree with you.image
    I'm the Proud recipient of a genuine "you suck" award dated 1/24/05. I was accepted into the "Circle of Trust" on 3/9/09.
  • Options
    PlacidPlacid Posts: 11,299 ✭✭✭
    Anyone care to provide some actual proof that its intentionally being done and not just human inconsistency?
  • Options
    roadrunnerroadrunner Posts: 28,374 ✭✭✭✭✭
    that backlog is due to the fact that the market is hot, esp. in moderns, and dealers & collectors alike are sending in all the product they can while prices are up and items are saleable. It has nothing to do with the ability of PCGS. PCGS is THE place in town if you want top dollar for your moderns (and classics). Even if PCGS and NGC lowered their consistency further, a path would still be beaten to their door, as coins for the most part still have to be certified to get sold for the best price to the widest audience.

    It's not about politics right now, it's about profits, and PCGS is offering those profits to anyone who gets blessed with a grade.
    Hence, the backlog.

    roadrunner
    Barbarous Relic No More, LSCC -GoldSeek--shadow stats--SafeHaven--321gold
  • Options
    darktonedarktone Posts: 8,437 ✭✭✭


    << <i>I find it pretty pathetic in todays world that grading services have come to the point in time in which their subjective grading abilities have evolved into whothlessness....I thought the whole idea was to have coins graded to create a fair and just market in which to buy and sell coins...but they have turned it into a circus...it is no better than it was when people bought and sold and traded coins amoung themselves...why waste $15 more on a coin to have it graded when you will not receive the grade that it deserves...maybe oneday these grading services will also get their fraudulant grading award....maybe the key is that it is so subjective!!! try putting up coins in MS65 holders against MS62 holders and finding the 62's are much nicer...yeah are they creating their own demize...maybe just maybe!!!!!! Time will tell. >>
      WOW! one body bag and you are talking about fraud? Come on face the fact you messed up on a couple of coins and get over it- learn what PCGS saw that you did not see. image mike
    • Options
      fivecentsfivecents Posts: 11,207 ✭✭✭✭✭


      << <i>try putting up coins in MS65 holders against MS62 holders and finding the 62's are much nicer...yeah are they creating their own demize...maybe just maybe!!!!!! >>


      Ever consider it might be your grading skills need some improvement?
    • Options
      ShamikaShamika Posts: 18,785 ✭✭✭✭
      I don't know if there ever is any favoratism at the TPG's, but anyone who does or ever has worked in an industry that has customers knows that certain customers get better "service" than others.

      Just an observation.

      Buyer and seller of vintage coin boards!
    • Options
      jeffnpcbjeffnpcb Posts: 1,943 ✭
      Russ' resubmission several times whit the 2 cent shield is a prime example of what you are talking about! It was BB'd once and recieved a variety of grades before it came back a lot higher than first submitted. The backlog at PCGS has nothing to do with grading accuracy, or tell you how many re-submits and crackouts to get a decent grade.
      And don't even get me going about their copper grading!
      HEAD TUCKED AND ROLLING ALONG ENJOYING THE VIEW! [Most people I know!]

      NEVER LET HIPPO MOUTH OVERLOAD HUMMINGBIRD BUTT!!!

      WORK HARDER!!!!
      Millions on WELFARE depend on you!
    • Options
      nwcsnwcs Posts: 13,386 ✭✭✭
      Still, the fact is that PCGS graders - by and large - are better than the vast majority of us collectors. I don't always agree with them, and sometimes they are wrong, but their opinion carries far more experience and knowledge than mine.
    • Options
      PlacidPlacid Posts: 11,299 ✭✭✭
      Russ' resubmission several times whit the 2 cent shield is a prime example of what you are talking about!

      He tried to cross it from a ngc slab. It got a bodybag (dnc) for altered surfaces.
      He then submitted it raw and it got a bodybag for altered surfaces.
      He then submitted it raw and it got graded ms65 bn.

      Either the coin has altered surfaces and the third time that was missed or the person(s) at pcgs that looked at it the first two times were wrong about it.

      I don't understand the part about how it ended up graded alot higher than it was the first time as it started in a ngc holder.

      Yes it sucks that Russ had to pay for grading three times but that dosen't mean pcgs bagged his coin two times for the same reason just because they don't like him.
    • Options
      BillJonesBillJones Posts: 36,025 ✭✭✭✭✭
      Is politics ever involved in third party coin grading? Yes. One need only look at the King of Siam Proof set. One service graded the coins, then the other leading service regrading them each one point higher in a less than subtle play to have those pretegious coins slabbed with their brand name. Any one other that a coin collecting novice could see through that foolishness.

      Still, by in large the certification services do render a useful service. My expeience has been that I often got what I deserved; sometimes I have gotten more than I deserved and in a few instances I was shafted or short changed for no good reason at all.

      The grading services are not perfect. Part of the reason is that graders are human and make mistakes. Another reason is that sometimes I don't think that they take the time to really study the coins sometimes.

      But hey so far as I'm concerned the coin collecting community has benefited greatly from the influece of the big three grading services, and have gotten some benefit from most of the others.
      Retired dealer and avid collector of U.S. type coins, 19th century presidential campaign medalets and selected medals. In recent years I have been working on a set of British coins - at least one coin from each king or queen who issued pieces that are collectible. I am also collecting at least one coin for each Roman emperor from Julius Caesar to ... ?
    • Options
      nOoBiEeEnOoBiEeE Posts: 1,011 ✭✭
      Before having a stroke, take some pictures of the coins and post them here so we can see what you are talking about. For those who did not see his grades, here is the thread..

      Crack them out and send them to NGC and see if you get the same type of grades, then well...
    • Options
      I will post the pics when I receive the coins back....time will tell...there are many coins out there misgraded if these are what they say they are....all you need is to put them side by side...in time their excuse as its all subjective will takes its toll...
    • Options
      BillJonesBillJones Posts: 36,025 ✭✭✭✭✭
      Yes the grading services are inconsistent. But the advantage to that is sometimes you can cherry pick a nice coin in a conservatively graded holder. Not everything that is undergraded gets cracked out. Sometimes it's not worth cracking, and sometimes the owner just does not want to mess with it.

      The Liberty $2.50 that is in my collection is as good an MS-64+ as you are every going to see. Yet it's in a "green label" PCGS MS-63 slab. The difference between MS-63 and 64 "bid" is not enough to both cracking it right now. BUT if standards keep slipping it might be worth it to crack the coin one day and perhaps I'll get a 65 out it OR the price of MS-64 coins will rise enough to make it worth while.
      Retired dealer and avid collector of U.S. type coins, 19th century presidential campaign medalets and selected medals. In recent years I have been working on a set of British coins - at least one coin from each king or queen who issued pieces that are collectible. I am also collecting at least one coin for each Roman emperor from Julius Caesar to ... ?
    • Options
      ManorcourtmanManorcourtman Posts: 8,514 ✭✭✭✭✭
      Dlimb2,

      I can understand your anger. I felt the same way on several of my first submissions. I was so certain PCGS screwed me and that I couldn't possibly be wrong....... I was furious. I still have those coins. When I look at them now I think to myself "what were you thinking when you sent those coins in? Did you think that the graders were not going to see those blemishes or those wear spots?" Looking back on it now I just laugh at how spotty my grading ability actually was. I continued to submit and learned more and more about grading and what PCGS was looking for. I also bought the PCGS grading book and what I think really made the biggest difference....I bought a Reveal light bulb and have it in an overhead lamp. I use the same lighting that the graders use. What a huge difference that makes. Looking at coins under normal light or room light is very deceiving. Until you see what they see you are literally in the dark. Just a few ramblings that I hope you take to heart. They are not out to screw anyone, but you better be on your game because they don't give mulligans and they don't hand out door prizes just for showing up.

      Chrisimage
    • Options
      FrattLawFrattLaw Posts: 3,290 ✭✭
      I personally think that many of the services are beholden to a few "big" submitters. It's the nature of their business. I also personally know that many "favors" are performed for these "big" submitters. I'm not at liberty to give specifics, so please don't ask.

      Is it wrong? Yes. Should it be the norm? No. Does it happen regularly. Yes. Does it happen through out the industry. Yes.

      But before we condemn TPGs and start asking for their heads, ask this question. Is the hobby/industry better off with a imperfect system or would it be better with no third party grading services at all?

      I think the answer is fairly obvious. There certainly is "politics" of grading. I doubt though it really effects anyone here too often.

      I am sure that certain coins might not get the bump if you or I submitted them, but might get there if a "big" submitter did. That's called business. Every business operates in it's own parameters. If you realize this, then perhaps it will bother you less. Once you know the rules, it's much easier to play the game. If you don't like the rules then perhaps you shouldn't play.

      As a collector it doesn't bother me. However, if I was a dealer, I would be quite miffed if coins I submitted were not given bumps while my competition was getting them and making more $$$.

      Michael
    • Options
      BaleyBaley Posts: 22,663 ✭✭✭✭✭
      maybe sometimes a collector will think a coin he (she) owns is nicer than it really is,
      or nicer than it would grade if it is seen and evaluated by a neutral third party.

      some call this "the ownership bias" or some similar name for the concept.

      new submitters to the TPGs sometimes expect higher grades than they end up receiving.

      of course, the TPGs sometimes err, and usually it is on the conservative side for the top tier graders,

      and on the liberal side for the bottom tier grading companies.

      If a new submitter would like to receive higher grades on his "slabs", he can either resubmit to PCGS (try, try again, as they say) or he can try sending them to a more liberal grading company.

      Or, he can just keep them raw and know that his coins are okay and spend the submission expenses on more coins instead. (even freebies have "postage", right? so they're not really "free." plus there's the membership charge...)

      "slabbing" coins is great, for rare and valuable coins, but the coins you submitted, imo, don't warrant it.

      edited for spelling

      Liberty: Parent of Science & Industry

    • Options

      This is not about "grading inconsistency", since that's human nature and to be expected. I have no problem with getting 3 different grades on the same coin that is submitted 3 different times (assuming the spread is something reasonable like MS-60, 61 and 62).

      The real problem is that favors are asked and received. Some "players" do indeed get special grades and certain times. Do I have proof? Absolutely. Will I share my proof? Nope. If I did, I would either get banned or I would be at the bottom of Lake Michigan with my new pair of concrete sneakers.

      I agree with the comments made by Bill Jones and FrattLaw. We are better off with companies like PCGS and NGC than we were in the days of the wild, raw West. It's not a perfect system, but it works. If there ever was a TPG that truly offered unbiased, third party grading (not influenced by ANY outside factors), then we would have a great (not perfect) solution for our hobby.

      www.jaderarecoin.com - Updated 6/8/06. Many new coins added!

      Our eBay auctions - TRUE auctions: start at $0.01, no reserve, 30 day unconditional return privilege & free shipping!

    Leave a Comment

    BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
    Emoji
    Image
    Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
    Drop image/file