Just got back from Central States with a prize

MrD · May 8, 2004 3:36PM

I just wanted to share the new MS67 1952s Franklin I just brought back

ms70 · May 8, 2004 3:36PM

Niiiiiiiiiiice!

coingame2000 · May 8, 2004 3:40PM

Gorgeous coin Dick -- but you'd better get your asbestos suit ready.

Mikey

coingame2000 · May 8, 2004 3:41PM

Gorgeous coin Dick -- but you'd better get your asbestos suit ready.

Mikey

CoinAddict · May 8, 2004 3:42PM

That is a very stunning Franklin. Can you take a picture of the reverse to share also?

MrD · May 8, 2004 3:42PM

I know I'm a bit slow but what does mean Mikey?

MrD · May 8, 2004 3:44PM

Didn't take a picture of the reverse but the business side is the better one

LucyBop · May 8, 2004 3:45PM

A stunning NGC Holdered coin......

the HepKitty labels that one, "HepKitty Approved!"

coingame2000 · May 8, 2004 3:50PM

Dick...you gotta figure that out yourself -- now go to bed, it's late back there. Oh, I heard you on the recorder while I was entering this reply but I'm to pooped to talk now so I'm gonna hit the sack.

Mikey

LucyBop · May 8, 2004 3:54PM

if anybody flames over this Frankie they'll deal with the HepKitty!

and I fight dirty....

I take it you paid strong money here......

This coin should command a premium....... it is a unique piece.....

MrD · May 8, 2004 3:55PM

I paid plenty but lucky for me it didn't have FBL although they are fairly strong

Bear · May 8, 2004 3:55PM

I LOVE THAT COIN> You did real good and should be very proud of yourself.

So who did you get the coin from. a little background if you dont mind.

LucyBop · May 8, 2004 3:58PM

<< <i>I paid plenty but lucky for me it didn't have FBL although they are fairly strong >>

I'll tell you, I love the look of a toner in the white NGC holder......

But if that one crossed as a FBL to PCGs, you have a very major major score........ did I say major?

MrD · May 8, 2004 3:58PM

Unfortunately I've gotten myself in trouble for mentioning names in the past so if you don't mind I'll take a pass. These are the type of coins I like to handle although I can't always get as many as I would like

Bear · May 8, 2004 3:59PM

Well, any coin with Lucy Bops seal of approval is a winner.

dan1ecu · May 8, 2004 4:23PM

VERY beautiful! ...and rare!

darktone · May 8, 2004 9:14PM

That coin has GREAT TONING

mike

ksteelheader · May 8, 2004 10:57PM

Nice coin.....

Lakesammman · May 9, 2004 12:57AM

Holy Mackerel Andy, that IS a beauty....congrats!

MrD · May 9, 2004 12:59AM

Thank you

millennium · May 9, 2004 1:00AM

I really like the coin...Does the spot near the lapel look like it might cause trouble in the future?

ConstellatioCollector · May 9, 2004 1:02AM

Wow, Wow, Wow!!!

MrD · May 9, 2004 1:04AM

I don't think its any problem

braddick · May 9, 2004 1:06AM

Don't these 1952-S's usually come washed out gray with a lack of appeal? I'd trade the "FBL" on the insert for color and lack of marks anyday! Nice score Richard.
I've got to imagine the Seller is waking up this morning having seconds thoughts on selling that one. . .

WWW · May 9, 2004 1:07AM

Wow! A very pretty coin. Let's see what else you bought at CS.

MrD · May 9, 2004 1:09AM

I didn't get my auction lots yet but the coins were very cool!!!!

cosmicdebris · May 9, 2004 1:10AM

Excellent Frankie

FC57Coins · May 9, 2004 1:29AM

Excellent find with gorgeous toning and in a top grade - congratulations!!

TONEDDOLLARS · May 9, 2004 1:30AM

Not as nice as your 57's

MrD · May 9, 2004 1:33AM

You are right!! ....but PCGS doesn't see it that way:

disgust;

Stuart · May 9, 2004 1:54AM

MrD: Beautiful Coin!! -- Congratulations !!

Nic · May 9, 2004 3:00AM

WOW.

. K

MFH · May 9, 2004 3:07AM

If that's not your best toned Franklin Half, I'd kill to see which one is !!!

Great coin, unbelievable color.

As a novice to Franklins, what caused this color ? Bank wrapper or cloth bag or album toning ? I have seen Morgan Dollars with great toning but this coin is surreal.

Nice find !

rainbowroosie · May 9, 2004 9:39AM

His best toned frankie is a 48D....Dick, dig it out and show us a picture!!!!

Colorfulcoins · May 9, 2004 2:07PM

northcoin · May 9, 2004 2:25PM

I only have a few multi hue rainbow toned coins, and they are mostlyl Morgans so I know little about toned Franklins, but if that were a Morgan it would be difficult for me to determine if it was AT or not. What gives those of you more experienced with toned coins the confidence to throw dollars after a coin that might be AT? I bought a "Monster" rainbow colored Morgan in a PCGS holder for a hefty premium before I knew anything about AT. I sure hope it is not AT, but I wonder if I am just kidding myself since the seller seems to have dozens of toned "monster" coins for sale on a repeated basis.

Since learning how pervasive artificial toning has become, now when I read about someone paying multiples of a coin's value based upon rainbow toning alone I can't help but recall the story of the Emperor's New Clothing. I have to ask myself, if it looks too good to be true, maybe it is.

I think what our hobby needs is a definitive book on the art of artificial toning with multiple examples along the lines of the grading books (Photograde comes to mind) and counterfit detection books that were available in the past.

nederveit · May 9, 2004 2:32PM

Holy Crap!! Can I say that here?

joecool · May 9, 2004 3:20PM

Very nice......

foodude · May 9, 2004 3:33PM

I just got back from Central States, so I'll just say "ditto" with the positive comments

northcoin · May 9, 2004 4:33PM

My comments above were not intended to rain on your parade. I like the coin and if it is not AT you have a coin to prize. Unfortunately there is no litmus test that I know of to tell for sure - but if there is I'd sure like to learn about it. If I understand correctly, the major grading services won't even guarantee a coin is not AT when they do holder them.

It would be a major contribution to the hobby if a definitive book with multiple examples could be made available to educate the average collector on the subject of natural vs. artificial toning. I wonder if this is a project that Q. David Bowers or someone of his stature would be willing to tackle?