Options
1954 Wilson Franks Ted Williams PSA 1(MK)
So would this count as a "-1" on the set registry? 
I guess this is one of those cards that's desirable in ANY grade...
ebay auction link

I guess this is one of those cards that's desirable in ANY grade...
ebay auction link

0
Comments
Always looking for N690 Kalamazoo Bats and Newsboy Cabinets
What kept this from being graded as authentic only?
The fact that it is fairly intact? The fact that it is a highly desireable card?
Just curious if there is a set rule.
Thanks,
Keith
These do I exist I also have one though although nowhere near as valuable as the Teddy hot dog card is much nicer.
And resides in my 29 KAshin Set . I wonder if it drags down my GPA?
Website: http://www.qualitycards.com
Am I missing something? Unless the back is trashed, that is a High End PSA 1 or low end PSA 9!
How about a scan of the back? That has to be the answer. Beautiful card for the grade, nonetheless.
JEB.
Card has the overall eye appeal of a high end PSA 7 or 8 ... with one tiny detail a pin hole at the bottom of the card I thought this card would get a PSA 3 or 4 MK when submitting this but I was wrong. Probably the nicest PSA -1 (for set purposes). But it is a gorgeous card that I paid all of $12.00 for including slabbing.
Much better than Teddy over there.
Technically it doesn't seem like you should be penalized for adding a card to your set, regardless of how atrocious it is.
So if someone built a set of PSA 1's w/qualifiers they would have a negative set rating?