Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

Consigning coins to a dealer or non-dealer - some things that each party should consider about price

coinguy1coinguy1 Posts: 13,484 ✭✭✭
A recent thread on another forum highlighted, what, for me, at least, can be a difficult/interesting /tricky/treacherous/pertinent/delicate type of situation :

What price/level should one accept coins on consignment at and what level to offer them at?

The answers might be easy in the case of a common, generic type of coin. When dealing with a particularly rare and/or esoteric and/or low pop item, however, the right price might be very difficult, if not impossible, to come by.

And, (I think) one needs to consider factors such as : 1) a fair price for the consignor; 2) a fair price for the potential buyer/client; 3) the effect that the list price might have on the reputation of the seller who lists the consigned coin for sale.

I occasionally see coins listed for sale on Ebay or in someone's inventory, where I think to myself, something along the lines of "The guy who is offering this coin is either REALLY greedy and/or he has no clue what he's doing".

I believe that there are certain situations, where it is best to say no to a consignor who wants an "absurd" price for a given coin. Even in saying that, I realize that what is "absurd" to one person, is not necessarily "absurd" to another. In some instances, the money that might be made in selling a consigned item, might be more than offset by the potential harm to the reputation of the seller, if current or potential clients think or know that the seller's prices are out of line.

There have been several occasions where we have said no to would-be consignors, because we didn't feel that we could accept their consignments at their requested prices and then offer the coins to others at realistic levels. There have also been times when we have consigned our coins or clients' coins to public auctions, because we suspected that the coins might bring more than we would dare ask, in good conscience.

I think it is important that both the consignor and the person/company to whom he is consigning a coin, are aware of the intricacies involved in accepting coins on consignment and the potential consequences (both good and bad) to all parties.








Comments

  • Options
    Dog97Dog97 Posts: 7,874 ✭✭✭
    A dealer selling coins on consignment is not like a Personal Injury lawyer where you only have to pay their outrageous fees if you get any $$.
    So therefore it is best for a dealer's pocketbook to accommodate any cosigner @ any price.
    Change that we can believe in is that change which is 90% silver.
  • Options
    ClankeyeClankeye Posts: 3,928 ✭


    << <i>So therefore it is best for a dealer's pocketbook to accommodate any cosigner @ any price. >>



    Not sure I agree with that, Dog. There are people out there who take note of what prices are asked by coin dealers under their banner. Regardless of if the coin is a consignment or not, it reflects on the seller.

    It's very frustrating to approach a dealer about a coin they are offering, only to find out their hands are tied about offering it at what you consider to be a reasonable market price.

    If this happens enough, I think it can start to hurt dealers in the long run.

    I think a responsible dealer should offer realistic advice to a potential consignor on the value of their coin, or stay away from it.
    It makes them look bad otherwise. IMO.

    Clankeye
    Brevity is the soul of wit. --William Shakespeare
  • Options
    wingedlibertywingedliberty Posts: 4,805 ✭✭✭
    Clankeye:
    Well said, I agree 100%.


    Brian.
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭


    << <i>A dealer selling coins on consignment is not like a Personal Injury lawyer where you only have to pay their outrageous fees if you get any $$.
    So therefore it is best for a dealer's pocketbook to accommodate any cosigner @ any price. >>



    Does a dealer make money on consigned coins even when they don't sell?

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    JulianJulian Posts: 3,370 ✭✭✭
    This is a very interesting topic, Mark.

    I try to accommodate customers, if they have scarce to rare coins, and do take them on consignment at prices that may seem high. Often these coins will be of interest to other advanced collectors and the price will be acceptable.

    There are always instances where the price is too high, and since there is no force involved, I try to offer them at slightly higher prices to a consumer. If something is totally out of reason, I guess that I would turn it down, but I try to keep an open mind when accepting consignments. I can always tell a customer that it is a consigned item and that I would be happy to relay an offer.

    I am more with Dog's philosophy on consignments, but I do see your thoughts about the potential harm to the seller's reputation.
    PNG member, numismatic dealer since 1965. Operates a retail store, also has exhibited at over 1000 shows.
    I firmly believe in numismatics as the world's greatest hobby, but recognize that this is a luxury and without collectors, we can all spend/melt our collections/inventories.

    eBaystore
  • Options
    FinallyHereFinallyHere Posts: 821 ✭✭✭
    Mark,

    This post struck a chord with me for sure. Everything you said has happened to me in one way shape or form over the years and is certainly worth bringing to light.

    I can remember last year I had a very good client and dear friend who wanted to give me some very exciting early type coins to sell for him, but the prices he wanted to net were simply unrealistically high (even though the coins were extremely nice and for the most part extremely rare as well). His philsophy was "So what if it is a little expensive.....it will either sell or it won't, but there is nothing to lose by trying". I tried to explain to him that several bad things would happen in this scenario. 1) I would not list a coin for what I thought was simply way too much money even considering how nice the coins were. Those that saw the posted coins would not have any indication that the coins were consigned to me, which in all honesty should not make any difference anyway. They would simply see coins that were grossly overpriced and draw their own conclusions. 2) He would be "burning" his coins by using this approach. He stood little chance of selling them, and they would be posted for many to see so they would then be recognizable if they were to ever be sent to auction.

    I recommended that if he really believed the coins would fetch that much, he allow us to work out a favorable auction agreement for him and to assign realistic reserves and see what happens. In some cases he was correct and the coins brought more than I would have felt comfortable asking. However, in many cases the coins sold for what was seemingly good prices and in some cases strong, but not the kind of money he was asking me to attempt to sell them for.

    A good thread Mark!!! I hate it that I have to say you posted yet another good thread Mark....but I'll do it anyway since I'm a nice guy!!

    Edit: I guess I should point out that I will always try to be flexible, especially on rarer and harder to price coins. But, at some point if the price the client is looking to net is simply not realistic, I have to pass on taking the coins.

    Mike Printz
    Mike Printz
    Harlan J. Berk, Ltd.
    https://hjbltd.com/#!/department/us-coins
  • Options
    Coinguy1, good points. I've occasionally come across a dealer (and interestingly, sellers of classic Hot Wheels) who will admit that a particular coin or coins on consignment are overpriced with comments to the effect of "He's asking $400, but he ain't gonna get it." That's okay to me if a dealer wants to say that and make that determination, but I can see how harmful it could be to his reputation if he accepts too much overpriced consignments.




    << <i> occasionally see coins listed for sale on Ebay or in someone's inventory, where I think to myself, something along the lines of "The guy who is offering this coin is either REALLY greedy and/or he has no clue what he's doing". >>



    Me too, though if it's slightly over I think of them as "unmotivated sellers."
    Lurking proudly on internet forums since 2001
  • Options
    ClankeyeClankeye Posts: 3,928 ✭
    I know this thread isn't about individual firms, but I do want to say that I recently consigned something with Pinnacle. I thought they could have doubled--even tripled--the amount of profit they took as the sellers and it would have been well within the realm of legitimate.

    That they chose not to--offering the coins at what they deemed as good a price as possible to their clients--impressed me. If the amount they were offering me from the consignment was not enough I would have passed. That would have been my perogative.

    Coin dealers supposedly have experience and savy about the market. To me they should share this with their clients on both ends of a transaction. You can throw something out on the market at any price you want to. But, I am certainly more impressed when I see realistic numbers and not someone hoping for that one obsessed collector, or some other pie in the sky.

    Clankeye
    Brevity is the soul of wit. --William Shakespeare
  • Options
    Dog97Dog97 Posts: 7,874 ✭✭✭
    Russ quotes me then asks: Does a dealer make money on consigned coins even when they don't sell?

    Well Russ, dealers are always coming on here talking about how they need to charge us for cheap no-account stuff like tape, staples, bubblemailers, wear & tear on their car, time spent waiting in line @ the Post Office so I don't think they will go to the Post Office to sign for your coins, take the time to make pictures & enhance them, write a description, pay to list them on eBay or their website and bear responsibility for the liability of possessing them for FREE.

    Change that we can believe in is that change which is 90% silver.
  • Options
    RussRuss Posts: 48,514 ✭✭✭
    Clank,

    When you consigned the coins to Pinnacle, was there any agreement that you'd have to pay them anything if the coins didn't sell?

    Russ, NCNE
  • Options
    ClankeyeClankeye Posts: 3,928 ✭
    Russ--

    No.

    Mark said this exactly "If your disgusting 'widgets' don't sell. You won't have to pay us anything. Now get out of here."

    Clankeye
    Brevity is the soul of wit. --William Shakespeare
  • Options
    michaelmichael Posts: 9,524 ✭✭✭
    i am happy i am not a full service dealer having to not only deal with all the customers but please everyone

    sincerely michael

  • Options
    Unfortunately the issues discussed here are too often the only issues considered by collectors consigning coins to a dealer. First you had better determine whether that dealer carries insurance that will protect your consignment in case of loss. You would be surprised how rarely that question is asked, how many dealers do not carry insurance (usually the line is that it's 'too expensive') and how often consigned coins are lost/stolen while in a dealer's care.
  • Options
    BarryBarry Posts: 10,100 ✭✭✭
    I believe a dealer showing overpriced consignment coins can cause a negative impact on his own sales.
    Suppose I'm browsing the tables. I see a few coins I like. I ask the dealer how much for the first one. He gives me some outrageous number. I wouldn't even bother asking about the others. Lost business results.
  • Options
    It's probably more common for a dealer to toss you the off the wall price and then attempt to justify it by saying that that coin is 'on consignment.'

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file