@mbogoman said:
I was all in until I saw it. It looks cheap to me (the privy).
I'll get one to keep the collection complete. With that said, I picked the wrong series to collect, but I'm so far into it now.I can't stop. I am sick of these privies beyond all words.
@Goldbully said:
Just for grins, I asked AI to take the coin and have it reflect its beauty on Lake Tahoe.
you're voted to go to lake tahoe and actually recreate this
I would love to, but finding a tiny branch floating in the lake and then putting those tiny gold coins on edge could be quite a challenge. Not to mention water ripples. 😂
@JWP The Mint hasn't posted it yet as far as I can tell, but you can bracket it. The coin holds 0.1000 troy oz of .9999 gold (3.110 g), so the metal alone is worth about 0.1 × $4,043.30 = $404.33 at spot early this afternoon Eastern.
The Mint doesn't price its numismatic gold at a fixed markup over that. It uses a published pricing table that steps the price up or down with the weekly average gold price, and the final number usually shows up on the product page shortly before release. So whatever it lands at, the gap between that price and roughly $404 of gold is the premium you're paying for the anniversary design and the packaging. Expect it to be well above melt, the way the Mint's other fractional collector gold usually is.
If gold moves $100 an ounce between now and release, the gold content only moves about $10, so the price bracket on the table matters more than day-to-day spot.
Just the math on the gold content, not financial advice.
Ballparking it from the price guide and the gold spot.
Also, other relative items in the catalog ... (sometimes I'm lazy and go by other similar items current price, not the correct method, I know)
The 2026 1/10 AGE proof is $580 right now. This relates to the $4150-$4199.99 spot.
The 1 oz AGE proof is $5050 at this spot, and the 1 oz Buffalo is $40 higher at $5090.
So, maybe in the $580 to $600 range?? $585 (580 + 1/10 of 40 with "fudge factor")?? shrug
If spot is lower at $4k - $4049.99, 1/10 AGE would be $570, so this maybe $570 or $575+.
I wonder if they add any premium for privy or anything? Cant be much tho.
Damn! I'm liking this coin. Now I really want to pick 1 up.
But going forward I would only keep going with the Buffalo series if they offered 1/4 oz. Gold is too high, making the premium too rich for my blood.
This year the BOM series really sent me for a loop.
Ballparking it from the price guide and the gold spot.
Also, other relative items in the catalog ... (sometimes I'm lazy and go by other similar items current price, not the correct method, I know)
The 2026 1/10 AGE proof is $580 right now. This relates to the $4150-$4199.99 spot.
The 1 oz AGE proof is $5050 at this spot, and the 1 oz Buffalo is $40 higher at $5090.
So, maybe in the $580 to $600 range?? $585 (580 + 1/10 of 40 with "fudge factor")?? shrug
If spot is lower at $4k - $4049.99, 1/10 AGE would be $570, so this maybe $570 or $575+.
I wonder if they add any premium for privy or anything? Cant be much tho.
Why are you ballparking from other things? It's the first column in the grid
Ballparking it from the price guide and the gold spot.
Also, other relative items in the catalog ... (sometimes I'm lazy and go by other similar items current price, not the correct method, I know)
The 2026 1/10 AGE proof is $580 right now. This relates to the $4150-$4199.99 spot.
The 1 oz AGE proof is $5050 at this spot, and the 1 oz Buffalo is $40 higher at $5090.
So, maybe in the $580 to $600 range?? $585 (580 + 1/10 of 40 with "fudge factor")?? shrug
If spot is lower at $4k - $4049.99, 1/10 AGE would be $570, so this maybe $570 or $575+.
I wonder if they add any premium for privy or anything? Cant be much tho.
Why are you ballparking from other things? It's the first column in the grid
Ballparking it from the price guide and the gold spot.
Also, other relative items in the catalog ... (sometimes I'm lazy and go by other similar items current price, not the correct method, I know)
The 2026 1/10 AGE proof is $580 right now. This relates to the $4150-$4199.99 spot.
The 1 oz AGE proof is $5050 at this spot, and the 1 oz Buffalo is $40 higher at $5090.
So, maybe in the $580 to $600 range?? $585 (580 + 1/10 of 40 with "fudge factor")?? shrug
If spot is lower at $4k - $4049.99, 1/10 AGE would be $570, so this maybe $570 or $575+.
I wonder if they add any premium for privy or anything? Cant be much tho.
Why are you ballparking from other things? It's the first column in the grid
I like the old days when you had a chance to buy these on the U.S. Mint website. Today Gettysburg Quarters on sale and wait time is 57 min and that 20 min prior to 12 pm sales. Looks like I may head to DC gift shop to buy fractional buffalo.
@HalfDime said:
Anyone hoping to buy this through the mint website has the same chance of getting hit by lightning if ats 6000 is correct.
There no chance they only sell 6000 of these! I bet the ATS will be well over 100k when the product is offered. They are greedy and know they can sell a boatload at a substantial profit.
@Manorcourtman said:
here no chance they only sell 6000 of these! I bet the ATS will be well over 100k when the product is offered. They are greedy and know they can sell a boatload at a substantial profit.
Why didn't they get greedy with the Gettysburg Quarters that sold out in 5 minutes today? They even put a HHL of 2 on them to make sure only half as many could get them.
I could see someone at the mint claiming these bombed in 2008 so they bomb in 2026. Also they had to order the special blanks so I doubt it is high mintage, but maybe you are right. They have changed numbers, and no mintage limit posted yet.
If it is 6000 for us though they will sell out before we can blink.
I was on the fence until I saw Goldbully's post - not that it matters, but for me the coin is WAAAAAAY to gimmicky and the anniversary. garbage on it is just more slam jammed onto a small flan. Yikes! Also the 1/10 oz size is not a good one - 1/4 would have been MUCH better.
Love that Milled British (1830-1960) Well, just Love coins, period.
Just another gold trinket that is not worth the markup. 2008 was a black swan year for gold and silver mint products due to blank scarcity that led to very limited, unplanned mintages. It was a banner year for flippers that will not be seen again until a blank shortage pops up again just after initial sales.
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
That represents a very significant markup to the tenth ounce proof AGE. The AGE had a mintage limit of 29K. I guess it makes sense if they limit these to 20K. But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
@NJCoin said:
But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
@NJCoin said:
But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
If you want bullion, they sell bullion products with much lower markup. That's probably more your speed.
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium. The premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage. You can complain all you want, we'd all like to pay less, but things are worth what they're worth. If you don't see the numismatic value, then you should probably stick with the bullion.
@NJCoin said:
But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
If you want bullion, they sell bullion products with much lower markup. That's probably more your speed.
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium. The premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage. You can complain all you want, we'd all like to pay less, but things are worth what they're worth. If you don't see the numismatic value, then you should probably stick with the bullion.
What if I don't want bullion, and also don't want to be ripped off?
Also, not sure exactly what you mean by "the premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage," but it's been a while since they've had a sellout this year. This mintage is probably going to be 20K, not the 6K you might be thinking.
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So, yeah, I like the coins, and, no, I really don't see the numismatic value of $2250 a per ounce premium on a NCLT coin with a mintage of 20K. I was interested, and now I'm not. I will reevaluate if the mintage turns out to be 6K.
@NJCoin said:
But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
If you want bullion, they sell bullion products with much lower markup. That's probably more your speed.
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium. The premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage. You can complain all you want, we'd all like to pay less, but things are worth what they're worth. If you don't see the numismatic value, then you should probably stick with the bullion.
What if I don't want bullion, and also don't want to be ripped off?
What if I want to buy a Ferrari but I don't want to pay MSRP? I guess I don't get a Ferrari. They'll sell it to someone who will.
Also, not sure exactly what you mean by "the premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage," but it's been a while since they've had a sellout this year. This mintage is probably going to be 20K, not the 6K you might be thinking.
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So if it sells out in a reasonable period of time, then what's the issue? The mint has done its job. They will have met market demand and priced it perfectly for the market. Just not perfectly for cheap skates who want numismatics for the price of bullion.
@NJCoin said:
But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
If you want bullion, they sell bullion products with much lower markup. That's probably more your speed.
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium. The premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage. You can complain all you want, we'd all like to pay less, but things are worth what they're worth. If you don't see the numismatic value, then you should probably stick with the bullion.
What if I don't want bullion, and also don't want to be ripped off?
What if I want to buy a Ferrari but I don't want to pay MSRP? I guess I don't get a Ferrari. They'll sell it to someone who will.
Also, not sure exactly what you mean by "the premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage," but it's been a while since they've had a sellout this year. This mintage is probably going to be 20K, not the 6K you might be thinking.
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So if it sells out in a reasonable period of time, then what's the issue? The mint has done its job. They will have met market demand and priced it perfectly for the market. Just not perfectly for cheap skates who want numismatics for the price of bullion.
Understood. But this isn't a Ferrari. It's a brand spanking new 1/10 ounce gold coin with $390 worth of gold being sold for a $225 premium, with a mintage of 20K. Hard pass.
Maybe I'm a cheapskate. Maybe I just don't like being constantly taken advantage of, and want a little value for my money.
TBD what "market demand is" if they do nothing nothing in the secondary market. The gold Liberty Bells should have taught you that if they taught you anything. In the meantime, you should enjoy.
@NJCoin said:
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So, yeah, I like the coins, and, no, I really don't see the numismatic value of $2250 a per ounce premium on a NCLT coin with a mintage of 20K. I was interested, and now I'm not. I reevaluate if the mintage turns out to be 6K.
The same thing was said back in 2008 and how did that turn out?
@NJCoin said:
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So, yeah, I like the coins, and, no, I really don't see the numismatic value of $2250 a per ounce premium on a NCLT coin with a mintage of 20K. I was interested, and now I'm not. I reevaluate if the mintage turns out to be 6K.
The same thing was said back in 2008 and how did that turn out?
True. How much did they sell for then? And, what was the dollar premium over spot?
The same thing was said back in 2008 and how did that turn out?
True. How much did they sell for then? And, what was the dollar premium over spot?
I had to go look, as this conversation had me curious:
When the U.S. Mint released the 2008-W $5 (1/10 oz) American Gold Buffalo coins on July 22, 2008, the initial prices to collectors were $159.95 for the Proof version and $129.95 for the Burnished Uncirculated version
The Mint adjusted the proof coin on Nov 13, 2008 to $164.95 during a pricing update.
• Because gold spot was roughly $947 per ounce at launch, the 1/10 oz coin contained about $94.70 worth of gold. This meant collectors paid roughly a 37% premium over melt for the Uncirculated coin and a 69% premium for the Proof coin.
@mbr33 said:
Because gold spot was roughly $947 per ounce at launch, the 1/10 oz coin contained about $94.70 worth of gold. >This meant collectors paid roughly a 37% premium over melt for the Uncirculated coin and a 69% premium for the >Proof coin.
Thanks for getting the data back from 2008.
When gold falls in price, premiums tend to expand for both classic pre-1933 gold as well as modern coins. So I'm not surprised at seeing a 70% premium to gold for the 1/10th 18 years back.
Who knows....18 years from now....in 2044....gold could be $9,000 an ounce and we could be saying that the pricing for the 1/10th 2045 Buffalo is pretty rich and not anything like the "good deal" we had back in 2026 !!!
@NJCoin said:
But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
If you want bullion, they sell bullion products with much lower markup. That's probably more your speed.
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium. The premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage. You can complain all you want, we'd all like to pay less, but things are worth what they're worth. If you don't see the numismatic value, then you should probably stick with the bullion.
What if I don't want bullion, and also don't want to be ripped off?
What if I want to buy a Ferrari but I don't want to pay MSRP? I guess I don't get a Ferrari. They'll sell it to someone who will.
Also, not sure exactly what you mean by "the premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage," but it's been a while since they've had a sellout this year. This mintage is probably going to be 20K, not the 6K you might be thinking.
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So if it sells out in a reasonable period of time, then what's the issue? The mint has done its job. They will have met market demand and priced it perfectly for the market. Just not perfectly for cheap skates who want numismatics for the price of bullion.
Understood. But this isn't a Ferrari. It's a brand spanking new 1/10 ounce gold coin with $390 worth of gold being sold for a $225 premium, with a mintage of 20K. Hard pass.
And you're getting hung up on material costs vs production costs and numismatic premiums that you don't think you should have to pay.
Maybe I'm a cheapskate. Maybe I just don't like being constantly taken advantage of, and want a little value for my money.
How are you being taken advantage of? If you don't like the value proposition you don't have to buy it. Why do you feel entitled that the world's manufacturers have to set prices to a price you feel is appropriate? I guess you think that if a restaurant is booked solid with lines out the door they can't raise their prices to maximize their profit and throttle back demand? In your world a business is obligated to maintain initial pricing levels and can never adjust them to market conditions or for certain products?
TBD what "market demand is" if they do nothing nothing in the secondary market. The gold Liberty Bells should have taught you that if they taught you anything. In the meantime, you should enjoy.
The secondary market is irrelevant. The mint's only goal is to sell through in a reasonable amount of time.
@ProofCollection said:
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium.
I always thought that the American Buffalo was considered a bullion coin.
They have bullion versions of the buffalos with smaller bullion premiums that are more in line with NJCoin's expectations. But for some reason, he expects a numismatic version to be priced like a bullion offering or he's getting "ripped off."
@NJCoin said:
But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
If you want bullion, they sell bullion products with much lower markup. That's probably more your speed.
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium. The premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage. You can complain all you want, we'd all like to pay less, but things are worth what they're worth. If you don't see the numismatic value, then you should probably stick with the bullion.
What if I don't want bullion, and also don't want to be ripped off?
What if I want to buy a Ferrari but I don't want to pay MSRP? I guess I don't get a Ferrari. They'll sell it to someone who will.
Also, not sure exactly what you mean by "the premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage," but it's been a while since they've had a sellout this year. This mintage is probably going to be 20K, not the 6K you might be thinking.
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So if it sells out in a reasonable period of time, then what's the issue? The mint has done its job. They will have met market demand and priced it perfectly for the market. Just not perfectly for cheap skates who want numismatics for the price of bullion.
Understood. But this isn't a Ferrari. It's a brand spanking new 1/10 ounce gold coin with $390 worth of gold being sold for a $225 premium, with a mintage of 20K. Hard pass.
And you're getting hung up on material costs vs production costs and numismatic premiums that you don't think you should have to pay.
Maybe I'm a cheapskate. Maybe I just don't like being constantly taken advantage of, and want a little value for my money.
How are you being taken advantage of? If you don't like the value proposition you don't have to buy it. Why do you feel entitled that the world's manufacturers have to set prices to a price you feel is appropriate? I guess you think that if a restaurant is booked solid with lines out the door they can't raise their prices to maximize their profit and throttle back demand? In your world a business is obligated to maintain initial pricing levels and can never adjust them to market conditions or for certain products?
TBD what "market demand is" if they do nothing nothing in the secondary market. The gold Liberty Bells should have taught you that if they taught you anything. In the meantime, you should enjoy.
The secondary market is irrelevant. The mint's only goal is to sell through in a reasonable amount of time.
Agree to disagree. I am being taken advantage of if my only two choices are to do without or be asked to pay an unreasonable price. The secondary market really is everything at the end of the day.
Yes, if lines are out the door at a restaurant, one can argue they are not charging enough. And that is certainly the case with certain "hot" Mint products. But not these. Not 4,052 gold bells at $20K per ounce (in spite of first appearances), not 520K Morgan and Peace Dollars at $220 per ounce, and not 20K buffaloes at $6,200 per ounce. Maybe 6K buffaloes, but that's a big TBD.
@NJCoin said:
But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
If you want bullion, they sell bullion products with much lower markup. That's probably more your speed.
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium. The premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage. You can complain all you want, we'd all like to pay less, but things are worth what they're worth. If you don't see the numismatic value, then you should probably stick with the bullion.
What if I don't want bullion, and also don't want to be ripped off?
What if I want to buy a Ferrari but I don't want to pay MSRP? I guess I don't get a Ferrari. They'll sell it to someone who will.
Also, not sure exactly what you mean by "the premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage," but it's been a while since they've had a sellout this year. This mintage is probably going to be 20K, not the 6K you might be thinking.
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So if it sells out in a reasonable period of time, then what's the issue? The mint has done its job. They will have met market demand and priced it perfectly for the market. Just not perfectly for cheap skates who want numismatics for the price of bullion.
Understood. But this isn't a Ferrari. It's a brand spanking new 1/10 ounce gold coin with $390 worth of gold being sold for a $225 premium, with a mintage of 20K. Hard pass.
And you're getting hung up on material costs vs production costs and numismatic premiums that you don't think you should have to pay.
Maybe I'm a cheapskate. Maybe I just don't like being constantly taken advantage of, and want a little value for my money.
How are you being taken advantage of? If you don't like the value proposition you don't have to buy it. Why do you feel entitled that the world's manufacturers have to set prices to a price you feel is appropriate? I guess you think that if a restaurant is booked solid with lines out the door they can't raise their prices to maximize their profit and throttle back demand? In your world a business is obligated to maintain initial pricing levels and can never adjust them to market conditions or for certain products?
TBD what "market demand is" if they do nothing nothing in the secondary market. The gold Liberty Bells should have taught you that if they taught you anything. In the meantime, you should enjoy.
The secondary market is irrelevant. The mint's only goal is to sell through in a reasonable amount of time.
Agree to disagree. I am being taken advantage of if my only two choices are to do without or be asked to pay an unreasonable price. The secondary market really is everything at the end of the day.
LOL, now you are just trolling us.
Now everyone who's offering something for sale (and in particular, non-essential goods) at a price you don't agree with is taking advantage of you. Please.
Yes, if lines are out the door at a restaurant, one can argue they are not charging enough. And that is certainly the case with certain "hot" Mint products. But not these. Not 4,052 gold bells at $20K per ounce (in spite of first appearances), not 520K Morgan and Peace Dollars at $220 per ounce, and not 20K buffaloes at $6,200 per ounce. Maybe 6K buffaloes, but that's a big TBD.
If the mint sells these out within a few weeks, it will be "hot" by any measure. We all know how accurate your crystal ball is.
In 2008 the gold buffalo gold was up for sale for many weeks, and anyone could buy all they wanted. I purchased multiples of the 1/4, 1/10, 1/2 and even 1 ounce. At one point the mint pulled them from sale due to the price of gold surging higher (people then complained about them raising prices). Even before they all sold out it was announced that no more fractionals would be made.
So fractionals available only two years, 2008 and now.
I remember the critics in 2008, one told me the 1/4 ounce graded PCGS 70's would never go over $1000.
That's what my guess this coin is worth RAW after sellout (assuming no more than 20k made).
The reason why is this design is iconic, the mint should be pumping these out in silver all day long. However gold is king. Will past collectors want a 2026 to add to their herd? A baby buffalo?
Comments
I'll get one to keep the collection complete. With that said, I picked the wrong series to collect, but I'm so far into it now.I can't stop. I am sick of these privies beyond all words.
at least it's not 1 with privy and 2% with random privies.
i, too, am tired of privies
I hope it propels more down the road as well 😉
This will be very popular and flippable. 1oz gold coins are out of reach for many, but a 1/10 oz offer is attainable.
Just for grins, I asked AI to take the coin and have it reflect its beauty on Lake Tahoe.
Good looking piece of modern gold I must say.
you're voted to go to lake tahoe and actually recreate this
I would love to, but finding a tiny branch floating in the lake and then putting those tiny gold coins on edge could be quite a challenge. Not to mention water ripples. 😂
Picture of packaging has been added
premium level cardboard
sickening
Ani idea what the price will be?
USN & USAF retired 1971-1993
Successful Transactions with more than 100 Members
@JWP The Mint hasn't posted it yet as far as I can tell, but you can bracket it. The coin holds 0.1000 troy oz of .9999 gold (3.110 g), so the metal alone is worth about 0.1 × $4,043.30 = $404.33 at spot early this afternoon Eastern.
The Mint doesn't price its numismatic gold at a fixed markup over that. It uses a published pricing table that steps the price up or down with the weekly average gold price, and the final number usually shows up on the product page shortly before release. So whatever it lands at, the gap between that price and roughly $404 of gold is the premium you're paying for the anniversary design and the packaging. Expect it to be well above melt, the way the Mint's other fractional collector gold usually is.
If gold moves $100 an ounce between now and release, the gold content only moves about $10, so the price bracket on the table matters more than day-to-day spot.
Just the math on the gold content, not financial advice.
Link to the table: https://www.usmint.gov/content/dam/usmint/shop/Pricing-Grid.pdf -- first column.
(S)WAG ...
Ballparking it from the price guide and the gold spot.
Also, other relative items in the catalog ... (sometimes I'm lazy and go by other similar items current price, not the correct method, I know)
The 2026 1/10 AGE proof is $580 right now. This relates to the $4150-$4199.99 spot.
The 1 oz AGE proof is $5050 at this spot, and the 1 oz Buffalo is $40 higher at $5090.
So, maybe in the $580 to $600 range?? $585 (580 + 1/10 of 40 with "fudge factor")?? shrug
If spot is lower at $4k - $4049.99, 1/10 AGE would be $570, so this maybe $570 or $575+.
I wonder if they add any premium for privy or anything? Cant be much tho.
Damn! I'm liking this coin. Now I really want to pick 1 up.
But going forward I would only keep going with the Buffalo series if they offered 1/4 oz. Gold is too high, making the premium too rich for my blood.
This year the BOM series really sent me for a loop.
Why are you ballparking from other things? It's the first column in the grid
https://www.usmint.gov/content/dam/usmint/shop/Pricing-Grid.pdf?srsltid=AYCX9vL_odc94Ok5Z8VgdRWEIhbreEn1XHZZJeR4IgmPAUOX9gu8DqZL
$4000 gold is $625 for the coin. No further work required.
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
LOL.
For whatever reason I zipped right past that column. derp
LOL. No problem. It's a rather large grid. Easy to miss any particular item.
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
This appeared this morning: If this number holds..............
"id": "26AL",
"productName": "20th Anniversary American Buffalo 2026 One-Tenth Ounce Gold Reverse Proof Coin",
"inStockDate": "Thu Nov 26 2026",
"availabilityStatus": "BACKORDER",
"isPreOrder": false,
"isBackOrder": true,
"ats": 6000,
"perpetual": false
I like the old days when you had a chance to buy these on the U.S. Mint website. Today Gettysburg Quarters on sale and wait time is 57 min and that 20 min prior to 12 pm sales. Looks like I may head to DC gift shop to buy fractional buffalo.
Box of 20
6000 = Instant hit and Unobtanium.
Anyone hoping to buy this through the mint website has the same chance of getting hit by lightning if ats 6000 is correct.
Actually I surprised to grab the Gettysburg quarters this morning. 15 min sellout. The 1/0 buffalos with sellout in 1 minute.
Box of 20
There no chance they only sell 6000 of these! I bet the ATS will be well over 100k when the product is offered. They are greedy and know they can sell a boatload at a substantial profit.
Why didn't they get greedy with the Gettysburg Quarters that sold out in 5 minutes today? They even put a HHL of 2 on them to make sure only half as many could get them.
I could see someone at the mint claiming these bombed in 2008 so they bomb in 2026. Also they had to order the special blanks so I doubt it is high mintage, but maybe you are right. They have changed numbers, and no mintage limit posted yet.
If it is 6000 for us though they will sell out before we can blink.
OMG.....50% markup on the current price of gold for an essentially fractional bullion coin seems excessive.
Why is it "must have" ?
What do they sell for now ? Haven't seen them but also wasn't looking.
Would a PR69 be much cheaper ?
the only frac buffs were made in 2008
at 15k mintage it'd be a good addition.
at 6,000 mintage it's white hot
do you like buffs?
Still.
I was on the fence until I saw Goldbully's post - not that it matters, but for me the coin is WAAAAAAY to gimmicky and the anniversary. garbage on it is just more slam jammed onto a small flan. Yikes! Also the 1/10 oz size is not a good one - 1/4 would have been MUCH better.
Well, just Love coins, period.
The United States Mint is announcing pricing for a new United States Mint numismatic gold product in accordance with the table below:
20th Anniversary American Buffalo One-Tenth Ounce Gold Reverse Proof Coin $625
Just another gold trinket that is not worth the markup. 2008 was a black swan year for gold and silver mint products due to blank scarcity that led to very limited, unplanned mintages. It was a banner year for flippers that will not be seen again until a blank shortage pops up again just after initial sales.
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
That represents a very significant markup to the tenth ounce proof AGE. The AGE had a mintage limit of 29K. I guess it makes sense if they limit these to 20K. But still, it's a lot of money for a tiny gold coin.
It's a 50% markup to gold at the current spot price. But it's still much more affordable than buying a full 1-ounce or even 1/2 ounce coin.
Understood. That said, in addition to it being its usual crazy expensive, it's $60 more than its AGE cousin. What's the justification for that, other than trying milk us for a little more due to the novelty of the coin?
I was kind of excited about it when it was first announced, but I'm really getting turned off by everything the Mint is doing lately. I accepted them jacking prices way up when precious metals were on a tear, even though I always thought premiums should shrink when intrinsic value rises, rather than keeping pace.
But their failure to adjust pricing on the way down, now that precious metals have been on a sustained decline for almost a year, really is inexcusable. I know that doesn't apply to items on the precious metal pricing grid, but they are still finding ways to screw around. By pricing this higher than similar items on the grid, as well as what they are doing with the Trump coin, in spite of its insanely high maximum mintage.
Sure, it's more affordable than coins with more intrinsic value, but it's actually a far worse deal, with an inexcusably high markup, and then another markup on top of that. I'm sure it will sell out, but I have no interest in just getting milked and milked and milked by the Mint.
It's not a hard position to take with precious metals off significantly from their highs, and going nowhere fast, while the Mint clings to the highest pricing ever for everything not on its grid. And creating new categories for every new product on the grid, at higher pricing than existing products.
If you want bullion, they sell bullion products with much lower markup. That's probably more your speed.
Numismatics, as you know, carry a premium. The premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage. You can complain all you want, we'd all like to pay less, but things are worth what they're worth. If you don't see the numismatic value, then you should probably stick with the bullion.
What if I don't want bullion, and also don't want to be ripped off?
Also, not sure exactly what you mean by "the premium in this case is one the market is gladly willing to pay for the expected mintage," but it's been a while since they've had a sellout this year. This mintage is probably going to be 20K, not the 6K you might be thinking.
I agree that it will likely sell out, but I'm not sure it's going to do anything in the secondary with a 20K mintage at $6150 per ounce with gold trading at $3900. At which point they might start going back to the Mint. It's an obnoxious premium over the proof 1/10 ounce AGE, which already sells at an obnoxious premium, for no reason other than they think they can get it.
So, yeah, I like the coins, and, no, I really don't see the numismatic value of $2250 a per ounce premium on a NCLT coin with a mintage of 20K. I was interested, and now I'm not. I will reevaluate if the mintage turns out to be 6K.
What if I want to buy a Ferrari but I don't want to pay MSRP? I guess I don't get a Ferrari. They'll sell it to someone who will.
So if it sells out in a reasonable period of time, then what's the issue? The mint has done its job. They will have met market demand and priced it perfectly for the market. Just not perfectly for cheap skates who want numismatics for the price of bullion.
Understood. But this isn't a Ferrari. It's a brand spanking new 1/10 ounce gold coin with $390 worth of gold being sold for a $225 premium, with a mintage of 20K. Hard pass.
Maybe I'm a cheapskate. Maybe I just don't like being constantly taken advantage of, and want a little value for my money.
TBD what "market demand is" if they do nothing nothing in the secondary market. The gold Liberty Bells should have taught you that if they taught you anything. In the meantime, you should enjoy.
The same thing was said back in 2008 and how did that turn out?
True. How much did they sell for then? And, what was the dollar premium over spot?
I had to go look, as this conversation had me curious:
When the U.S. Mint released the 2008-W $5 (1/10 oz) American Gold Buffalo coins on July 22, 2008, the initial prices to collectors were $159.95 for the Proof version and $129.95 for the Burnished Uncirculated version
The Mint adjusted the proof coin on Nov 13, 2008 to $164.95 during a pricing update.
• Because gold spot was roughly $947 per ounce at launch, the 1/10 oz coin contained about $94.70 worth of gold. This meant collectors paid roughly a 37% premium over melt for the Uncirculated coin and a 69% premium for the Proof coin.
I always thought that the American Buffalo was considered a bullion coin.
Thanks for getting the data back from 2008.
When gold falls in price, premiums tend to expand for both classic pre-1933 gold as well as modern coins. So I'm not surprised at seeing a 70% premium to gold for the 1/10th 18 years back.
Who knows....18 years from now....in 2044....gold could be $9,000 an ounce and we could be saying that the pricing for the 1/10th 2045 Buffalo is pretty rich and not anything like the "good deal" we had back in 2026 !!!
And you're getting hung up on material costs vs production costs and numismatic premiums that you don't think you should have to pay.
How are you being taken advantage of? If you don't like the value proposition you don't have to buy it. Why do you feel entitled that the world's manufacturers have to set prices to a price you feel is appropriate? I guess you think that if a restaurant is booked solid with lines out the door they can't raise their prices to maximize their profit and throttle back demand? In your world a business is obligated to maintain initial pricing levels and can never adjust them to market conditions or for certain products?
The secondary market is irrelevant. The mint's only goal is to sell through in a reasonable amount of time.
They have bullion versions of the buffalos with smaller bullion premiums that are more in line with NJCoin's expectations. But for some reason, he expects a numismatic version to be priced like a bullion offering or he's getting "ripped off."
Agree to disagree. I am being taken advantage of if my only two choices are to do without or be asked to pay an unreasonable price. The secondary market really is everything at the end of the day.
Yes, if lines are out the door at a restaurant, one can argue they are not charging enough. And that is certainly the case with certain "hot" Mint products. But not these. Not 4,052 gold bells at $20K per ounce (in spite of first appearances), not 520K Morgan and Peace Dollars at $220 per ounce, and not 20K buffaloes at $6,200 per ounce. Maybe 6K buffaloes, but that's a big TBD.
LOL, now you are just trolling us.
Now everyone who's offering something for sale (and in particular, non-essential goods) at a price you don't agree with is taking advantage of you. Please.
If the mint sells these out within a few weeks, it will be "hot" by any measure. We all know how accurate your crystal ball is.
In 2008 the gold buffalo gold was up for sale for many weeks, and anyone could buy all they wanted. I purchased multiples of the 1/4, 1/10, 1/2 and even 1 ounce. At one point the mint pulled them from sale due to the price of gold surging higher (people then complained about them raising prices). Even before they all sold out it was announced that no more fractionals would be made.
So fractionals available only two years, 2008 and now.
I remember the critics in 2008, one told me the 1/4 ounce graded PCGS 70's would never go over $1000.
That's what my guess this coin is worth RAW after sellout (assuming no more than 20k made).
The reason why is this design is iconic, the mint should be pumping these out in silver all day long. However gold is king. Will past collectors want a 2026 to add to their herd? A baby buffalo?
Yes, and this isn't a Proof but a Reverse Proof....I thought that might dampen demand.
I'm trying to recall....they've had RP's for AGEs in 1-ounce and fractional sizes, right ?