@MsMorrisine said:
I thought those receiving discounts couldn't undercut the mint by dealer agreement
I was thinking the same 🤔
Looks like the "undercut" rule only applies to products that have been discounted.
Is it possible that this specific item was not offered to NBPP members at a discount?
No way. Not with that mintage. Dealers never would have ponied up.
My guess would be that either they are not enforcing that, OR everyone is agreeing that coins in slabs are not the same product, so the rule doesn't apply.
I am pretty sure that all bulk products are, by definition, discounted. If the product is "hot" and not discounted, I don't think it's made available to bulk dealers at all. The Advance Purchase program is something else entirely, given that those coins are sold at a premium, not a discount.
I do not have any 'insider' knowledge. So, I was just offering a potential explanation.
This is a great resource for centralizing information, but it's far too easy to misread the "Mintage" vs "Remaining / sold" columns. e.g. The Supergirl gold piece says "Mintage: 10,000" and "1,264 left / 87% sold". The "Mintage" is the limit, while the "Remaining" figure is the ATS. Supergirl started with 1800 ATS and I highly doubt that the 87% "Sold" figure is an accurate measure against the 10k mintage limit. (Edit to add/clarify: 87% is correct if the entire 10k mintage limit were produced and all but the 1264 have been sold. This is almost certainly not the case.)
This is a great resource for centralizing information, but it's far too easy to misread the "Mintage" vs "Remaining / sold" columns. e.g. The Supergirl gold piece says "Mintage: 10,000" and "1,264 left / 87% sold". The "Mintage" is the limit, while the "Remaining" figure is the ATS. Supergirl started with 1800 ATS and I highly doubt that the 87% "Sold" figure is an accurate measure against the 10k mintage limit. (Edit to add/clarify: 87% is correct if the entire 10k mintage limit were produced and all but the 1264 have been sold. This is almost certainly not the case.)
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
I love the pair at spot ish.
It will happen as unloved gifts will get cashed out.
$375 for $90 ish in silver is way too big an ask.
Coin hobby repeats, I will get this two based on spot this year, next year or whenever as thats what dealers will pay. Thats what ebay auctions will end at.
These 2026 silver offers are appallingly over priced this year.
Next year everything will languish at inflated premiums and plethora of dog rich designs
I think many here are a bit cynical. Their value as an investment vehicle is not their only bastion of merit. They are not power prisms collectible cards designed to give a return on investment. Just because the mint has the authority to put their thumb on the scale that they should. Creating artificial scarcity ad nauseam dilutes the definition of special.
The peace/Morgan sets will look dope in a Dansco with the rest of their respective set and will represent a store of value (silver + presentation) and that more aligned with the actual hobby.
All of you with multiples in your cart (but only if it’s a guaranteed winner) is why they lifted the limit now being bemoaned.
@Crypto said:
I think many here are a bit cynical. Their value as an investment vehicle is not their only bastion of merit. They are not power prisms collectible cards designed to give a return on investment. Just because the mint has the authority to put their thumb on the scale that they should. Creating artificial scarcity ad nauseam dilutes the definition of special.
The peace/Morgan sets will look dope in a Dansco with the rest of their respective set and will represent a store of value (silver + presentation) and that more aligned with the actual hobby.
All of you with multiples in your cart (but only if it’s a guaranteed winner) is why they lifted the limit now being bemoaned.
Maybe. And maybe, just maybe, asking over 4x spot for something with a maximum mintage over a quarter million is just unreasonable. In the past, various world mints sold similar items at high prices with mintages of 5-10K, and even those did not hit 4x spot.
Kind of like gas stations with gas prices, the US Mint was fairly efficient at pulling silver coins from sale and repricing when spot took off last year, but seems to be taking its time on the downside as silver is down around 60% from its high ($49.50 as I type this), while the Mint is trying to sell 520K silver coins at $218.28 per ounce. Shame on the Mint, and good for everyone who likes the coins but are controlling themselves on principle.
Will admit had second thoughts after seeing actual pics online and with this now in hand it is very nice. The way the luster shifts in the diamond pattern field combined with the contrasting devices is really neat and unexpected.
A few planchet flaws may be in fields and once seen takes a lot of re-angling to make reappear.
Really like this and after being shut out on silver bell this takes care of my semi sequential itch.
I like the enhanced detail in Liberty's hair and the eagle's feathers on both coins, but don't particularly care for the diamond design, which I see as just another gimmick to sell more coins. I'd rather see the regular versions (MS and proof) with the improved detail. The US Mint is catching up with Canada and Great Britain in the production of a never-ending variety of coins, making it difficult or impossible for collectors to buy them all.
I bit the bullet and ordered via subscription. Arrived yesterday and going back today. Quality was terrible on the Morgan, abrasion across the cheek. Refund instead of replacement.
@Crypto said:
I think many here are a bit cynical. Their value as an investment vehicle is not their only bastion of merit. They are not power prisms collectible cards designed to give a return on investment. Just because the mint has the authority to put their thumb on the scale that they should. Creating artificial scarcity ad nauseam dilutes the definition of special.
The peace/Morgan sets will look dope in a Dansco with the rest of their respective set and will represent a store of value (silver + presentation) and that more aligned with the actual hobby.
All of you with multiples in your cart (but only if it’s a guaranteed winner) is why they lifted the limit now being bemoaned.
Maybe. And maybe, just maybe, asking over 4x spot for something with a maximum mintage over a quarter million is just unreasonable. In the past, various world mints sold similar items at high prices with mintages of 5-10K, and even those did not hit 4x spot.
Kind of like gas stations with gas prices, the US Mint was fairly efficient at pulling silver coins from sale and repricing when spot took off last year, but seems to be taking its time on the downside as silver is down around 60% from its high ($49.50 as I type this), while the Mint is trying to sell 520K silver coins at $218.28 per ounce. Shame on the Mint, and good for everyone who likes the coins but are controlling themselves on principle.
problem with the gas analogy is gas is basically a utility or commodity. While silver is a commodity the coin it's self is a worthless luxury. It isn't a silver vehicle so much as it is a vehicle that uses silver. There are cheaper ways to buy silver and no one is depriving anyone. Let me tell you how much I paid for my daughters silver Tiffiny bracelet, I could have bought almost 3 of these sets for the one piece and it has about the same silver content as one of these sets. The mint put way more work into these then Tiffiny did on a simple chain bracelet with a stamped heart.
@Crypto said:
I think many here are a bit cynical. Their value as an investment vehicle is not their only bastion of merit. They are not power prisms collectible cards designed to give a return on investment. Just because the mint has the authority to put their thumb on the scale that they should. Creating artificial scarcity ad nauseam dilutes the definition of special.
The peace/Morgan sets will look dope in a Dansco with the rest of their respective set and will represent a store of value (silver + presentation) and that more aligned with the actual hobby.
All of you with multiples in your cart (but only if it’s a guaranteed winner) is why they lifted the limit now being bemoaned.
Maybe. And maybe, just maybe, asking over 4x spot for something with a maximum mintage over a quarter million is just unreasonable. In the past, various world mints sold similar items at high prices with mintages of 5-10K, and even those did not hit 4x spot.
Kind of like gas stations with gas prices, the US Mint was fairly efficient at pulling silver coins from sale and repricing when spot took off last year, but seems to be taking its time on the downside as silver is down around 60% from its high ($49.50 as I type this), while the Mint is trying to sell 520K silver coins at $218.28 per ounce. Shame on the Mint, and good for everyone who likes the coins but are controlling themselves on principle.
problem with the gas analogy is gas is basically a utility or commodity. While silver is a commodity the coin it's self is a worthless luxury. It isn't a silver vehicle so much as it is a vehicle that uses silver. There are cheaper ways to buy silver and no one is depriving anyone. Let me tell you how much I paid for my daughters silver Tiffiny bracelet, I could have bought almost 3 of these sets for the one piece and it has about the same silver content as one of these sets. The mint put way more work into these then Tiffiny did on a simple chain bracelet with a stamped heart.
Yeah. My only point was that prices rise quickly and fall slowly, if at all.
@RichR said:
Honest question...based on the declining spot price...what are the chances these are repriced lower? Or does that rarely if ever happen?
I ordered two based on a long placed subscription, but I might return 1 for a refund based solely on the price.
They do not regularly reprice silver. They may reprice everything at some point, but it won't be as much of an adjustment as you think. I would guess no more than $30 or so (on a one ounce). After all, they repriced up when silver was in the $80s
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
This is a great resource for centralizing information, but it's far too easy to misread the "Mintage" vs "Remaining / sold" columns. e.g. The Supergirl gold piece says "Mintage: 10,000" and "1,264 left / 87% sold". The "Mintage" is the limit, while the "Remaining" figure is the ATS. Supergirl started with 1800 ATS and I highly doubt that the 87% "Sold" figure is an accurate measure against the 10k mintage limit. (Edit to add/clarify: 87% is correct if the entire 10k mintage limit were produced and all but the 1264 have been sold. This is almost certainly not the case.)
Thanks for the detailed feedback. You were right, and it’s fixed. Sold numbers now come from the Mint’s weekly cumulative sales report (Adj. Net Demand). Between reports, the tracker adds the ATS drops it sees, then resets to the official figure each Tuesday, so returns and cancellations get corrected. ATS now shows separately as “available now,” “Mintage” is labeled “Product limit,” and the % is sold against the limit. Each product page shows exactly where its number comes from. Supergirl gold now reads about 504 of 10,000 (5%) instead of 87%. If anything else looks off or incorrect please let us know.
@RichR said:
Honest question...based on the declining spot price...what are the chances these are repriced lower? Or does that rarely if ever happen?
I ordered two based on a long placed subscription, but I might return 1 for a refund based solely on the price.
They do not regularly reprice silver. They may reprice everything at some point, but it won't be as much of an adjustment as you think. I would guess no more than $30 or so. After all, they repriced up when silver was in the $80s
This ^^^. They seem to like around 3x spot for numismatic silver, and they don't reprice up and down every time silver moves $10 or $20.
If silver stays here for a prolonged period of time, they will reprice at some point in response to declining sales at 4x+ spot. They will reprice even more at some point if silver continues its decline. I.e., if it goes back to $30, look for pricing to go back to what it was 2 years ago.
OTOH, if it heads back up, as many predict, you'll never see a reprice. Because, as I said in an earlier post, they are all over repricing when current pricing works in our favor, and really like to take their time when it does not.
Received my set. To the eye there are some very tiny shiny spots in the fields of the Morgan, when shifted in hand, left of her chin on obv and right of the wing on rev. Is this to be expected with this diamond finish or better to return for exchange. Sorry, no good with posting photos, just wondering if others see this and your thoughts.
This is a great resource for centralizing information, but it's far too easy to misread the "Mintage" vs "Remaining / sold" columns. e.g. The Supergirl gold piece says "Mintage: 10,000" and "1,264 left / 87% sold". The "Mintage" is the limit, while the "Remaining" figure is the ATS. Supergirl started with 1800 ATS and I highly doubt that the 87% "Sold" figure is an accurate measure against the 10k mintage limit. (Edit to add/clarify: 87% is correct if the entire 10k mintage limit were produced and all but the 1264 have been sold. This is almost certainly not the case.)
Thanks for the detailed feedback. You were right, and it’s fixed. Sold numbers now come from the Mint’s weekly cumulative sales report (Adj. Net Demand). Between reports, the tracker adds the ATS drops it sees, then resets to the official figure each Tuesday, so returns and cancellations get corrected. ATS now shows separately as “available now,” “Mintage” is labeled “Product limit,” and the % is sold against the limit. Each product page shows exactly where its number comes from. Supergirl gold now reads about 504 of 10,000 (5%) instead of 87%. If anything else looks off or incorrect please let us know.
Welcome to the group. It sounds like you are from the mint. If so, great! We will now have someone to complain too!
Yeah. If, if, if. Repricings are far and few between, and tend to only go one way -- up. I only remember one reduction in price in the past 20 years, and it was very short lived.
So, if, if, if. If, if, if silver stays where it is or goes lower, we are likely to see a lowering of prices as sales continue to fall off a cliff. Not before then, and not "if" silver starts to recover. Or, "if" people accept pricing at 4x+ spot, and sales hold up. If, if, if.
Quality is terrible.
Small digs and marks in the face on both Morgan and Peace, also on the prime focal area of Eagle on reverse of Peace.
I went thru 8 sets, only found one that is a candidate for 70
IMO - if you want a 70 set - buy one.
There are a small handful of sets sold on eBay at a loss as BIN. What is the reasoning vs returning to mint? The sets have been in hand less than a week.
Comments
I do not have any 'insider' knowledge. So, I was just offering a potential explanation.
Thanks for sharing your perspective.
This is a great resource for centralizing information, but it's far too easy to misread the "Mintage" vs "Remaining / sold" columns. e.g. The Supergirl gold piece says "Mintage: 10,000" and "1,264 left / 87% sold". The "Mintage" is the limit, while the "Remaining" figure is the ATS. Supergirl started with 1800 ATS and I highly doubt that the 87% "Sold" figure is an accurate measure against the 10k mintage limit. (Edit to add/clarify: 87% is correct if the entire 10k mintage limit were produced and all but the 1264 have been sold. This is almost certainly not the case.)
Seeing actual images on eBay now
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
Did you have a screen grab? I still see nothing but artist renderings
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
https://ebay.io/m/uVH9S4
Thank you for providing this link. It's a godsend!
Looks nice. Overpriced but nice. I passed on this one.
This set is ordered and on the way with intention of only keeping the peace.
Seeing actual pics still interested but less as much. Will eventually decide between either diamond field or the enhanced uncirculated.
Tough call.
I'm adding these to my 1776-2026 album I made to complete the album
Thank you.
I don't love it. I also don't hate it. It's kind of meh...
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
I love the pair at spot ish.
It will happen as unloved gifts will get cashed out.
$375 for $90 ish in silver is way too big an ask.
Coin hobby repeats, I will get this two based on spot this year, next year or whenever as thats what dealers will pay. Thats what ebay auctions will end at.
These 2026 silver offers are appallingly over priced this year.
Next year everything will languish at inflated premiums and plethora of dog rich designs
I think many here are a bit cynical. Their value as an investment vehicle is not their only bastion of merit. They are not power prisms collectible cards designed to give a return on investment. Just because the mint has the authority to put their thumb on the scale that they should. Creating artificial scarcity ad nauseam dilutes the definition of special.
The peace/Morgan sets will look dope in a Dansco with the rest of their respective set and will represent a store of value (silver + presentation) and that more aligned with the actual hobby.
All of you with multiples in your cart (but only if it’s a guaranteed winner) is why they lifted the limit now being bemoaned.
11.5$ Southern Dollars, The little “Big Easy” set
Maybe. And maybe, just maybe, asking over 4x spot for something with a maximum mintage over a quarter million is just unreasonable. In the past, various world mints sold similar items at high prices with mintages of 5-10K, and even those did not hit 4x spot.
Kind of like gas stations with gas prices, the US Mint was fairly efficient at pulling silver coins from sale and repricing when spot took off last year, but seems to be taking its time on the downside as silver is down around 60% from its high ($49.50 as I type this), while the Mint is trying to sell 520K silver coins at $218.28 per ounce. Shame on the Mint, and good for everyone who likes the coins but are controlling themselves on principle.
Will admit had second thoughts after seeing actual pics online and with this now in hand it is very nice. The way the luster shifts in the diamond pattern field combined with the contrasting devices is really neat and unexpected.
A few planchet flaws may be in fields and once seen takes a lot of re-angling to make reappear.
Really like this and after being shut out on silver bell this takes care of my semi sequential itch.
I like the enhanced detail in Liberty's hair and the eagle's feathers on both coins, but don't particularly care for the diamond design, which I see as just another gimmick to sell more coins. I'd rather see the regular versions (MS and proof) with the improved detail. The US Mint is catching up with Canada and Great Britain in the production of a never-ending variety of coins, making it difficult or impossible for collectors to buy them all.
I bit the bullet and ordered via subscription. Arrived yesterday and going back today. Quality was terrible on the Morgan, abrasion across the cheek. Refund instead of replacement.
Per listings on eBay, it seems ANACS and NGC are grading the top Morgan and Peace diamond field coins as MS70. But PCGS is grading them as SP70.
I just received my coins yesterday and they both look flawless to me. I really like the Peace Dollar and very happy with the purchase.
Here is my Washington Quarter Variety Registry Set
This is my Washington Quarter Proof Variety Registry Set
Just a small tilt of the coins and a flashlight shows imperfections in the ‘diamond field’ pretty easily. Quality is mediocre….
problem with the gas analogy is gas is basically a utility or commodity. While silver is a commodity the coin it's self is a worthless luxury. It isn't a silver vehicle so much as it is a vehicle that uses silver. There are cheaper ways to buy silver and no one is depriving anyone. Let me tell you how much I paid for my daughters silver Tiffiny bracelet, I could have bought almost 3 of these sets for the one piece and it has about the same silver content as one of these sets. The mint put way more work into these then Tiffiny did on a simple chain bracelet with a stamped heart.
11.5$ Southern Dollars, The little “Big Easy” set
Mine arrived today and now on the way back. I admit I forgot to cancel them.
INYNWHWeTrust-TexasNationals,ajaan,blu62vette
coinJP, Outhaul ,illini420,MICHAELDIXON, Fade to Black,epcjimi1,19Lyds,SNMAN,JerseyJoe, bigjpst, DMWJR , lordmarcovan, Weiss,Mfriday4962,UtahCoin,Downtown1974,pitboss,RichieURich,Bullsitter,JDsCoins,toyz4geo,jshaulis, mustanggt, SNMAN, MWallace, ms71, lordmarcovan,JWP,dantheman984,olah_in_MA,USMC_6115
Yeah. My only point was that prices rise quickly and fall slowly, if at all.
what's up with the "IN" in "In God We Trust" ?
I do like the look of the set just not enough to buy it.
To that end, thank you all for sharing!
I hope everyone who purchased them like them ..... they just are not for me
I was excited, then reality of the 2026 so~so QC I received and at 4x spot & I moved on.
250th 2026 was odd for me as I do not collect normal coins.
If these go the distance, 262,500, I will own them for spot in next 3 years.
Instead today I bought a one trip 40 foot high cube shipping container delivered after turkey day for a bit more than USMINT order I cancelled.
Silver at 4x spot VERSUS 360 Square feet of 9 & 1/2 foot tall and 8,800 pounds of tan paint steel delivered.
Acreage and No HOA.
How Cool is That ?
No regrets.
There's always something else to shop for...
Happy Shopping !
Honest question...based on the declining spot price...what are the chances these are repriced lower? Or does that rarely if ever happen?
I ordered two based on a long placed subscription, but I might return 1 for a refund based solely on the price.
I got mine yesterday. I like them very much. But I buy US Mint offerings not as "investments," but because I like them.
They do not regularly reprice silver. They may reprice everything at some point, but it won't be as much of an adjustment as you think. I would guess no more than $30 or so (on a one ounce). After all, they repriced up when silver was in the $80s
All comments reflect the opinion of the author, even when irrefutably accurate.
That is why they will hold off, they just shipped these.
Thanks for the detailed feedback. You were right, and it’s fixed. Sold numbers now come from the Mint’s weekly cumulative sales report (Adj. Net Demand). Between reports, the tracker adds the ATS drops it sees, then resets to the official figure each Tuesday, so returns and cancellations get corrected. ATS now shows separately as “available now,” “Mintage” is labeled “Product limit,” and the % is sold against the limit. Each product page shows exactly where its number comes from. Supergirl gold now reads about 504 of 10,000 (5%) instead of 87%. If anything else looks off or incorrect please let us know.
This ^^^. They seem to like around 3x spot for numismatic silver, and they don't reprice up and down every time silver moves $10 or $20.
If silver stays here for a prolonged period of time, they will reprice at some point in response to declining sales at 4x+ spot. They will reprice even more at some point if silver continues its decline. I.e., if it goes back to $30, look for pricing to go back to what it was 2 years ago.
OTOH, if it heads back up, as many predict, you'll never see a reprice. Because, as I said in an earlier post, they are all over repricing when current pricing works in our favor, and really like to take their time when it does not.
If, if, if...
Received my set. To the eye there are some very tiny shiny spots in the fields of the Morgan, when shifted in hand, left of her chin on obv and right of the wing on rev. Is this to be expected with this diamond finish or better to return for exchange. Sorry, no good with posting photos, just wondering if others see this and your thoughts.
Welcome to the group. It sounds like you are from the mint. If so, great! We will now have someone to complain too!
Gary TheGasMan - Retired Hank Hill
Yeah. If, if, if. Repricings are far and few between, and tend to only go one way -- up. I only remember one reduction in price in the past 20 years, and it was very short lived.
So, if, if, if. If, if, if silver stays where it is or goes lower, we are likely to see a lowering of prices as sales continue to fall off a cliff. Not before then, and not "if" silver starts to recover. Or, "if" people accept pricing at 4x+ spot, and sales hold up. If, if, if.
Quality is terrible.
Small digs and marks in the face on both Morgan and Peace, also on the prime focal area of Eagle on reverse of Peace.
I went thru 8 sets, only found one that is a candidate for 70
IMO - if you want a 70 set - buy one.
Under 5x/10x magnification you can see the issues quite clearly.
QC was bad on this issue.
All the rest of my sets were returned.
There are a small handful of sets sold on eBay at a loss as BIN. What is the reasoning vs returning to mint? The sets have been in hand less than a week.
My guess is they are unacceptable for the price ?