Home› U.S. Coin Forum
Options

NEWP Amazing MS 64 Buffalo OBH. Video AddedThoughts Please

WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭
edited November 11, 2026 2:07PM in U.S. Coin Forum

I saw this coin from a seller on EBay that only sells coins occasionally. Normally I don’t buy MS 64, but the photos grabbed me. Just received today. Coin has the most incredible luster with a great strike, mainly reverse sharp strike. I think maybe the coin is a first strike off the dies. Also minor contact marks for a 64. Your feedback most appreciated. Thanks.
Seller Photos First

My Photos




«1

Comments

  • Options
    Morgan13Morgan13 Posts: 2,930 ✭✭✭✭✭

    I am sure its a nice coin but the images aren't that good.
    It would be worth the effort if you could get some better shots.
    Id really like to see it.

    Student of numismatics and collector of Morgan dollars
    Successful BST transactions with: Namvet Justindan Mattniss RWW olah_in_MA
    Dantheman984 Toyz4geo SurfinxHI greencopper RWW bigjpst bretsan MWallace logger7 JWP BruceS bigjpst
    JWP PROMETHIUS88

  • Options
    P0CKETCHANGEP0CKETCHANGE Posts: 3,949 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Morgan13 said:
    I am sure its a nice coin but the images aren't that good.
    It would be worth the effort if you could get some better shots.
    Id really like to see it.

    Here are the seller close-ups from the eBay listing:

    Superb collections are built more by omission than by addition.

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 9, 2026 3:56PM

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:

    @Morgan13 said:
    I am sure its a nice coin but the images aren't that good.
    It would be worth the effort if you could get some better shots.
    Id really like to see it.

    Here are the seller close-ups from the eBay listing:

    What do you think of the coin? I can get a few better shots if you like

  • Options
    TomBTomB Posts: 23,368 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Looks like a great coin, but better shots would certainly be appreciated by all. The holder is also my favorite of the blue insert series as these were issued from around October, 1998 through February, 2002. The cert number, which I know they were not issued sequentially, is also consistent with a 1999 submission as I have some I submitted at that time with numbers around the same range.

    Thomas Bush Numismatics & Numismatic Photography

    In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson

    image
  • Options
    Morgan13Morgan13 Posts: 2,930 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:

    @Morgan13 said:
    I am sure its a nice coin but the images aren't that good.
    It would be worth the effort if you could get some better shots.
    Id really like to see it.

    Here are the seller close-ups from the eBay listing:

    Oh yea thats a really nice coin. The luster really shows up and the strike is nice!

    Student of numismatics and collector of Morgan dollars
    Successful BST transactions with: Namvet Justindan Mattniss RWW olah_in_MA
    Dantheman984 Toyz4geo SurfinxHI greencopper RWW bigjpst bretsan MWallace logger7 JWP BruceS bigjpst
    JWP PROMETHIUS88

  • Options
    WalkerfanWalkerfan Posts: 10,444 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 9, 2026 4:08PM

    Awesome! I love it!!

    I have a similar story:

    Bought this one about seven or eight years ago at the ANA convention. At $75, I ‘overpaid’ because I liked the PCGS 2.1. Retail is $160 now and that is without taking the holder into consideration.

    I get it. It isn’t about the money or the fact that it’s a common date. It’s just a nice coin in a cool holder…. Just like yours. ;)



    Sometimes, it’s better to be LUCKY than good. 🍀 🍺👍

    My Full Walker Registry Set (1916-1947):

    https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @TomB said:
    Looks like a great coin, but better shots would certainly be appreciated by all. The holder is also my favorite of the blue insert series as these were issued from around October, 1998 through February, 2002. The cert number, which I know they were not issued sequentially, is also consistent with a 1999 submission as I have some I submitted at that time with numbers around the same range.

    Tom here are 2 more pictures. Let me know if these are good. Thanks

  • Options
    BigFrankieBigFrankie Posts: 116 ✭✭✭

    Fully struck Rev. And well struck Obv.

    A very nice coin! Holder type is one of my favorites as well.

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 9, 2026 4:47PM

    @TomB said:
    Looks like a great coin, but better shots would certainly be appreciated by all. The holder is also my favorite of the blue insert series as these were issued from around October, 1998 through February, 2002. The cert number, which I know they were not issued sequentially, is also consistent with a 1999 submission as I have some I submitted at that time with numbers around the same range.

    Tom in hand the coin actually looks slightly mirrored and proof like. But the reverse looks it much more

  • Options
    ChrisH821ChrisH821 Posts: 7,251 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Very good value coin at that grade with that sort of eye appeal.

    Collector, occasional seller

  • Options
    TomBTomB Posts: 23,368 ✭✭✭✭✭

    It appears kind of PL in some of those images.

    Thomas Bush Numismatics & Numismatic Photography

    In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson

    image
  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @BigFrankie said:
    Fully struck Rev. And well struck Obv.

    A very nice coin! Holder type is one of my favorites as well.

    Love the PNG blue holder look. My favorite even more than the OGH

  • Options
    U1chicagoU1chicago Posts: 7,058 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Looks nice and the semi pl look is a bonus.

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @TomB said:
    It appears kind of PL in some of those images.

    After reviewing the coin further it looks like it has the characteristics of a brilliant proof 1936, not a typical uncirculated piece

  • Options
    BuffaloIronTailBuffaloIronTail Posts: 7,794 ✭✭✭✭✭

    It has proof attributes but is a little to beat up for the designation. Great coin, A little too much chatter on Iron Tails chin IMHOP. Might be why it's only a 64.

    Pete

    "I tell them there's no problems.....only solutions" - John Lennon
  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 9, 2026 9:08PM

    @BuffaloIronTail said:
    It has proof attributes but is a little to beat up for the designation. Great coin, A little too much chatter on Iron Tails chin IMHOP. Might be why it's only a 64.

    Pete

    .

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Walkerlover said:

    @BuffaloIronTail said:
    It has proof attributes but is a little to beat up for the designation. Great coin, A little too much chatter on Iron Tails chin IMHOP. Might be why it's only a 64.

    Pete

    .
    The coin has the l appearance of a MS 67-68 grade due to its incredible insane luster with the proof like reflectivity

  • Options
    airplanenutairplanenut Posts: 22,815 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Walkerlover said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @BuffaloIronTail said:
    It has proof attributes but is a little to beat up for the designation. Great coin, A little too much chatter on Iron Tails chin IMHOP. Might be why it's only a 64.

    Pete

    .
    The coin has the l appearance of a MS 67-68 grade due to its incredible insane luster with the proof like reflectivity

    I bet a large number of these coins have insane lustre with the prooflike reflectivity and yet, for some reason, there are but 5 67s and not one of them graded 68

    JK Coin Photography - eBay Consignments | High Quality Photos | LOW Prices | 20% of Consignment Proceeds Go to Pancreatic Cancer Research
  • Options
    ChrisH821ChrisH821 Posts: 7,251 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerfan said:
    Awesome! I love it!!

    I have a si.
    @Walkerlover said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @BuffaloIronTail said:
    It has proof attributes but is a little to beat up for the designation. Great coin, A little too much chatter on Iron Tails chin IMHOP. Might be why it's only a 64.

    Pete

    .
    The coin has the l appearance of a MS 67-68 grade due to its incredible insane luster with the proof like reflectivity

    Spoil sport alert…
    I’m sincerely happy for you that you’re so enamored with your new acquisition.
    However, even though PCGS rewards eye-appeal, despite whatever attributes the coin has, after examining it in hand, they graded it a pedestrian (non-PL) MS64.

    Of all the coins I’ve seen posted here, many of which were graded multiple points higher than this one, I don’t recall any that were described with more hype than this one: “Amazing”, “incredible insane luster”, etc.

    Based on the images, I suspect that the post by @U1chicago might have presented a more realistic description:
    “Looks nice and the semi pl look is a bonus.”

    To be fair, PCGS was not awarding PL to anything but Morgan dollars during the blue holder era. If regraded today, maybe there's a chance? I also have a 1936 with PL qualities, so they definitely are out there. Without actually seeing it we can't really tell.

    Collector, occasional seller

  • Options
    ChrisH821ChrisH821 Posts: 7,251 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @airplanenut said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @BuffaloIronTail said:
    It has proof attributes but is a little to beat up for the designation. Great coin, A little too much chatter on Iron Tails chin IMHOP. Might be why it's only a 64.

    Pete

    .
    The coin has the l appearance of a MS 67-68 grade due to its incredible insane luster with the proof like reflectivity

    I bet a large number of these coins have insane lustre with the prooflike reflectivity and yet, for some reason, there are but 5 67s and not one of them graded 68

    Well a DMPL 83CC $1 is a far cry from a 1936 5C. ;)

    Collector, occasional seller

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 10, 2026 7:32AM

    @ChrisH821 said:

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerfan said:
    Awesome! I love it!!

    I have a si.
    @Walkerlover said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @BuffaloIronTail said:
    It has proof attributes but is a little to beat up for the designation. Great coin, A little too much chatter on Iron Tails chin IMHOP. Might be why it's only a 64.

    Pete

    .
    The coin has the l appearance of a MS 67-68 grade due to its incredible insane luster with the proof like reflectivity

    Spoil sport alert…
    I’m sincerely happy for you that you’re so enamored with your new acquisition.
    However, even though PCGS rewards eye-appeal, despite whatever attributes the coin has, after examining it in hand, they graded it a pedestrian (non-PL) MS64.

    Of all the coins I’ve seen posted here, many of which were graded multiple points higher than this one, I don’t recall any that were described with more hype than this one: “Amazing”, “incredible insane luster”, etc.

    Based on the images, I suspect that the post by @U1chicago might have presented a more realistic description:
    “Looks nice and the semi pl look is a bonus.”

    To be fair, PCGS was not awarding PL to anything but Morgan dollars during the blue holder era. If regraded today, maybe there's a chance? I also have a 1936 with PL qualities, so they definitely are out there. Without actually seeing it we can't really tell.

    Very fair (as in very good) point. Sure, maybe there’s a chance, though, based on the images, despite its flash, the coin doesn’t appear to be PL.

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

  • Options
    P0CKETCHANGEP0CKETCHANGE Posts: 3,949 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Superb collections are built more by omission than by addition.

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    What’s your thinking in recommending a CAC submission?

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

  • Options
    P0CKETCHANGEP0CKETCHANGE Posts: 3,949 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @MFeld said:
    What’s your thinking in recommending a CAC submission?

    OP believes it is far better than the holdered grade. While I can't tell whether that's accurate by the photos, a CAC submission (with a chance for gold) would be a reasonable way to test the hypothesis. I have seen a decent number of Buffalos in "OBH" holders with Gold CACs. And OP has frequently stated he wants his coins with CAC, and has submitted others, so it could be pooled with other coins on a submission.

    Superb collections are built more by omission than by addition.

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:

    @MFeld said:
    What’s your thinking in recommending a CAC submission?

    OP believes it is far better than the holdered grade. While I can't tell whether that's accurate by the photos, a CAC submission (with a chance for gold) would be a reasonable way to test the hypothesis. I have seen a decent number of Buffalos in "OBH" holders with Gold CACs. And OP has frequently stated he wants his coins with CAC, and has submitted others, so it could be pooled with other coins on a submission.

    Thank you.

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

  • Options
    RedRocketRedRocket Posts: 2,077 ✭✭✭✭✭

    It'll be interesting to see if the seller will raise or lower his asking price when this nickel is returned.

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Yes I got a green sticker.

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @RedRocket said:
    It'll be interesting to see if the seller will raise or lower his asking price when this nickel is returned.

    @RedRocket said:
    It'll be interesting to see if the seller will raise or lower his asking price when this nickel is returned.

    LOL will never be returned. Why would I return such a unique looking, fully struck coin with an intense luster that looks like a neon light brilliant proof?
    I am going to send this to CAC in the next few days. Your statement is absurd and foolish. The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 10, 2026 9:32AM

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerfan said:
    Awesome! I love it!!

    I have a si.
    @Walkerlover said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @BuffaloIronTail said:
    It has proof attributes but is a little to beat up for the designation. Great coin, A little too much chatter on Iron Tails chin IMHOP. Might be why it's only a 64.

    Pete

    .
    The coin has the l appearance of a MS 67-68 grade due to its incredible insane luster with the proof like reflectivity

    Spoil sport alert…
    I’m sincerely happy for you that you’re so enamored with your new acquisition.
    However, even though PCGS rewards eye-appeal, despite whatever attributes the coin has, after examining it in hand, they graded it a pedestrian (non-PL) MS64.

    Of all the coins I’ve seen posted here, many of which were graded multiple points higher than this one, I don’t recall any that were described with more hype than this one: “Amazing”, “incredible insane luster”, etc.

    Based on the images, I suspect that the post by @U1chicago might have presented a more realistic description:
    “Looks nice and the semi pl look is a bonus.”

    Mr. Feld the only thing I can say is the coin in hand looks similar to a brilliant 1936 proof with intense flash. So I am thinking this was one of the first coins off of new dies giving it this unique look. It definitely does not look like a normal uncirculated standard issue. And I have never seen a MS 64 coin with this spectacular proof like eye appeal.

  • Options
    lermishlermish Posts: 5,200 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Walkerlover said:
    The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.

    It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Yes I got a green sticker.

    So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?

    chopmarkedtradedollars.com

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @lermish said:

    @Walkerlover said:
    The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.

    It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Yes I got a green sticker.

    So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?

    Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Walkerlover said:

    @lermish said:

    @Walkerlover said:
    The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.

    It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Yes I got a green sticker.

    So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?

    Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.

    You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

  • Options
    RedRocketRedRocket Posts: 2,077 ✭✭✭✭✭

    It must be a pleasant delusion to live in a world where you believe your vision for a coin is superior to those who have previously owned it.
    The original seller obviously didn't believe this MS64 was a "MS67 or even an MS68" nor did PCGS or the number of other potential buyers who viewed this coin either in hand or on eBay before you came along.
    What is the secret potion you take that allows for this type of thinking and behavior?
    I'm not discounting it as the pleasure you derive from taking it must be immeasurable.

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @lermish said:

    @Walkerlover said:
    The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.

    It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Yes I got a green sticker.

    So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?

    Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.

    You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?

    I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.

    Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.



  • Options
    ChrisH821ChrisH821 Posts: 7,251 ✭✭✭✭✭

    When I have a coin I believe is under-graded, I crack it out and send it back in. An MS64 1936 Buffalo Nickel is a very low risk coin that I would have no hesitation to crack out if I believed in it. A 64PL would be a nice catch.

    Collector, occasional seller

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @RedRocket said:
    It must be a pleasant delusion to live in a world where you believe your vision for a coin is superior to those who have previously owned it.
    The original seller obviously didn't believe this MS64 was a "MS67 or even an MS68" nor did PCGS or the number of other potential buyers who viewed this coin either in hand or on eBay before you came along.
    What is the secret potion you take that allows for this type of thinking and behavior?
    I'm not discounting it as the pleasure you derive from taking it must be immeasurable.

    I never said it was MS 67 or MS 68. I said it has the luster strike and eye appeal of a 67-68. There are a few moderate contact marks. So I think 65++ is a reasonable regrade chance. Hence I think I have a good shot for gold at CAC.

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Walkerlover said:

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @lermish said:

    @Walkerlover said:
    The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.

    It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Yes I got a green sticker.

    So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?

    Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.

    You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?

    I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.

    Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.



    You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.

    If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

  • Options
    TomBTomB Posts: 23,368 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @ChrisH821 said:
    When I have a coin I believe is under-graded, I crack it out and send it back in. An MS64 1936 Buffalo Nickel is a very low risk coin that I would have no hesitation to crack out if I believed in it. A 64PL would be a nice catch.

    That is an interesting strategy that you would undertake the cost of resubmission for the payoff of a compressed upward value instead of submitting the coin to CAC to receive a crisp, free $500 bill from the marketplace if it generated a gold sticker as you likely believe it should since you would be wiling to sink funds into a regrade.

    Thomas Bush Numismatics & Numismatic Photography

    In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson

    image
  • Options
    braddickbraddick Posts: 25,249 ✭✭✭✭✭

    I don't completely understand the OP's purchasing habits, yet after reading this full thread I found it has much in common with a prior thread from the same author:
    https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll/p1

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @braddick said:
    I don't completely understand the OP's purchasing habits, yet after reading this full thread I found it has much in common with a prior thread from the same author:
    https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll/p1

    The author tends to be consistent.😉

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

  • Options
    coinbufcoinbuf Posts: 12,655 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Silent net grade for the graffiti on the cheek.

    My Lincoln Registry
    My Collection of Old Holders

    Never a slave to one plastic brand will I ever be.
  • Options
    ChrisH821ChrisH821 Posts: 7,251 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @TomB said:

    @ChrisH821 said:
    When I have a coin I believe is under-graded, I crack it out and send it back in. An MS64 1936 Buffalo Nickel is a very low risk coin that I would have no hesitation to crack out if I believed in it. A 64PL would be a nice catch.

    That is an interesting strategy that you would undertake the cost of resubmission for the payoff of a compressed upward value instead of submitting the coin to CAC to receive a crisp, free $500 bill from the marketplace if it generated a gold sticker as you likely believe it should since you would be wiling to sink funds into a regrade.

    This may have formatted weirdly:

    • Cost of submission is not that much, even for express, as long as you are sending in other coins.
    • What if it "only" got a green bean? CAC is notoriously strict sometimes. We've seen plenty of stories about green stickered coins upgrading and then green stickering again. Why weren't they gold before?
    • A gold stickered MS64 common date buff will not get an additional $500 in the marketplace when MS66 sells for what? $150? Other coins, sure that may be, but see the point made above.
    • An upgrade is worth registry points
    • I don't think CAC considers PL vs non-PL when awarding green or gold, only numeric grade. So the coin in question here I don't think has any chance at gold.
    • The only reason I would suggest submitting this coin is in hopes of getting it labeled as PL

    Collector, occasional seller

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @coinbuf said:
    Silent net grade for the graffiti on the cheek.

    I can’t get a clear look at the marks on the cheek and jaw - what makes you say it’s graffiti, rather than unintentional contact marks.

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

  • Options
    Morgan13Morgan13 Posts: 2,930 ✭✭✭✭✭

    As @MFeld once put it to me.....why dont you just enjoy the coin for what it is.

    My thoughts are that you cant go wrong sending it into CAC.
    I believe this coin is graded properly.
    Whatever choice you make I hope it works out for you.
    Best of luck!

    Student of numismatics and collector of Morgan dollars
    Successful BST transactions with: Namvet Justindan Mattniss RWW olah_in_MA
    Dantheman984 Toyz4geo SurfinxHI greencopper RWW bigjpst bretsan MWallace logger7 JWP BruceS bigjpst
    JWP PROMETHIUS88

  • Options
    WalkerloverWalkerlover Posts: 1,118 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @lermish said:

    @Walkerlover said:
    The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.

    It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Yes I got a green sticker.

    So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?

    Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.

    You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?

    I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.

    Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.



    You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.

    If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.

    No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation

  • Options
    coinbufcoinbuf Posts: 12,655 ✭✭✭✭✭
    edited November 10, 2026 12:49PM

    @MFeld said:

    @coinbuf said:
    Silent net grade for the graffiti on the cheek.

    I can’t get a clear look at the marks on the cheek and jaw - what makes you say it’s graffiti, rather than unintentional contact marks.

    Look at the seller images that were posted above by @PocketChange you can clearly see this mark in that obv image. This does not appear in the image as three distinct marks but rather one continuous mark. It may in fact be a strike through, but it is the only thing I can see that would hold the grade to 64 vs 65 or better if it was considered as graffiti back when this was graded.

    My Lincoln Registry
    My Collection of Old Holders

    Never a slave to one plastic brand will I ever be.
  • Options
    marcmoishmarcmoish Posts: 6,987 ✭✭✭✭✭

    Gosh, this thread has gone off the rails, hey OP, just send the coin in to CAC, lets see what they say.

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @Walkerlover said:

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @MFeld said:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @lermish said:

    @Walkerlover said:
    The coin has the eye appeal of a 67 or 68.

    It's a very nice coin but no, it doesn't. And this is where your thread goes off the rails. Again, it's a nice coin for what it is, but what it ISN'T is a Superb Gem. To quote myself:

    @Walkerlover said:

    @P0CKETCHANGE said:
    Send it to the Certified Acceptance Corporation. Speaking of which, have you gotten results from the 38-D you shared a month ago? https://forums.collectors.com/discussion/1126010/newp-buffalo-nickel-from-an-original-roll#latest

    Yes I got a green sticker.

    So do you want to send me money via Zelle or Venmo or something else?

    Well it is difficult to get a gold sticker going from 66 to 67+. I agree I overrated that particular coin. But I am willing to state that I have a great chance on this coin, as I only have to go from 64 to 65++ to receive a gold sticker. And I can state with confidence that I have never seen a 64 with that kind of unique eye appeal. That look combined with no serious contact marks just does not exist in a 64. My only caveat is if the coin was net graded for some issue that I cannot see.

    You post as if you see a lot of coins and have a very good feel for how yours compare to others of the same grade. On average, how many shows do you attend each year?

    I don’t see a lot of coins.1 show. But I have a good eye and this coin even though I don’t have the experience of seasoned numismatists, stands out as something exceptional for a 64.

    Here are 2 better photos showing the proof like surfaces.



    You’ve also raved about other coins you’ve posted, but which didn’t appear to be special. Since you don’t see large quantities of coins in hand, you’re lacking a critical grading aid - perspective.

    If you’re convinced that the coin deserves the PL designation, you should submit it to PCGS.

    No I don’t want to lose my OBH. I am more interested in taking a shot at CAC for gold sticker. Prefer the sticker over a PL designation

    Are you sure?
    $3840 https://coins.ha.com/itm/buffalo-nickels/1937-d-5c-ms63-prooflike-ngc-pcgs-3981-/a/1376-3192.s?ic4=GalleryView-ShortDescription-071515

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

  • Options
    MFeldMFeld Posts: 17,537 ✭✭✭✭✭

    @ChrisH821 said:

    @TomB said:

    @ChrisH821 said:
    When I have a coin I believe is under-graded, I crack it out and send it back in. An MS64 1936 Buffalo Nickel is a very low risk coin that I would have no hesitation to crack out if I believed in it. A 64PL would be a nice catch.

    That is an interesting strategy that you would undertake the cost of resubmission for the payoff of a compressed upward value instead of submitting the coin to CAC to receive a crisp, free $500 bill from the marketplace if it generated a gold sticker as you likely believe it should since you would be wiling to sink funds into a regrade.

    This may have formatted weirdly:

    • Cost of submission is not that much, even for express, as long as you are sending in other coins.
    • What if it "only" got a green bean? CAC is notoriously strict sometimes. We've seen plenty of stories about green stickered coins upgrading and then green stickering again. Why weren't they gold before?
    • A gold stickered MS64 common date buff will not get an additional $500 in the marketplace when MS66 sells for what? $150? Other coins, sure that may be, but see the point made above.
    • An upgrade is worth registry points
    • I don't think CAC considers PL vs non-PL when awarding green or gold, only numeric grade. So the coin in question here I don't think has any chance at gold.
    • The only reason I would suggest submitting this coin is in hopes of getting it labeled as PL

    I asked CAC about this years ago. And I was told that when making their stickering decisions, they do consider designations such as PL

    Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.

Leave a Comment

BoldItalicStrikethroughOrdered listUnordered list
Emoji
Image
Align leftAlign centerAlign rightToggle HTML viewToggle full pageToggle lights
Drop image/file