Options
Barber dime
logger7
Posts: 9,761 ✭✭✭✭✭
Just thought I'd get a few opinions on this 1895-o Barber dime that is bent. Authentic or no?
0
Comments
Not an expert but looks real
There is some kind of black substance on the surface; also on the bent issue I used a vice with plexiglass to get it out and made some progress.
Tough to tell…..the black stuff. Looks horrible.
Would suggest a dip but seems too far gone. Obv rim damaged.
Start it at 98c on the Bay, get rid of it lol.
Looks legit to me, just has seen some better days.
Custom album maker and numismatic photographer.
Need a personalized album made? Design it on the website below and I'll build it for you.
https://www.donahuenumismatics.com/.
It has an appearance similar to some silver coins I have dug up metal detecting. That might also explain the scrapes?
Young Numismatist • My Toned Coins
Life is roadblocks. Don't let nothing stop you, 'cause we ain't stopping. - DJ Khaled
woof woof. Recommended is to try to get the black stuff off the coin. Soak the piece in acetone for a few hours and then try to work the black stuff off using your finger nail. So, soak it, fingernail it, reshoot the photo and repost it here for us Barber coin experts to reevaluate.
Appears to be authentic with a good amount of detail still remaining.
“People like to know you're listening, and something as simple as a clarification question shows not only that you are listening but that you also care about what they're saying.”---Travis Bradberry
This quote reflects the idea that clarification is not just about resolving confusion, but also about deepening understanding, shaping thought, and fostering better communication.
"Fingernail it"?? That's a numismatic crime.
Young Numismatist • My Toned Coins
Life is roadblocks. Don't let nothing stop you, 'cause we ain't stopping. - DJ Khaled
To bad bout the nick @4:oo
This is one of those cases in which the coin is so ugly that it may actually benefit from a cleaning. Since it is a much better date (and an expensive one at that) care needs to be taken. A "budget" album collector is likely to be the eventual buyer so a cleaning may actually enhance the appeal of the coin to collectors of that kind. It is too bad it is damaged but there is nothing you can do about that.
Overnight soak did not do much so may send it to one of the services to see if they have better chemicals/methods. Is there anything stronger than acetone, ie xylene available at hardware stores?
"Fingernail it"?? That's a numismatic crime.
Fingernailing this piece won't hurt it a bit. If no fingernails are available use a soft toothpick that will "mushroom." Definitely do not use anything abrasive or harder than the metal for this job. All we're trying to do here is get the black stuff off using acetone and a little gentle encouragement from a fingernail or soft toothpick.
“People like to know you're listening, and something as simple as a clarification question shows not only that you are listening but that you also care about what they're saying.”---Travis Bradberry
This quote reflects the idea that clarification is not just about resolving confusion, but also about deepening understanding, shaping thought, and fostering better communication.
Did you encourage the black stuff removal by fingernailing the piece after its acetone soak?
“People like to know you're listening, and something as simple as a clarification question shows not only that you are listening but that you also care about what they're saying.”---Travis Bradberry
This quote reflects the idea that clarification is not just about resolving confusion, but also about deepening understanding, shaping thought, and fostering better communication.
No real improvement with overnight soak and tried to move the black stuff off.
Some improvement but the coin has too many problems.
Cleaning this piece would be a mistake in my opinion. The scrapes are a bigger deal than the discoloration. In other words, if acetone and fingernailing doesn't get the black stuff, let it be. I would say the piece is worth a few hundred as it stands but would sell easier IF the black could be removed. It's bent as well as being discolored. The keen observer can detect a coin that has been bent no matter how slight even if the bend is "fixed" in a vise.
“People like to know you're listening, and something as simple as a clarification question shows not only that you are listening but that you also care about what they're saying.”---Travis Bradberry
This quote reflects the idea that clarification is not just about resolving confusion, but also about deepening understanding, shaping thought, and fostering better communication.
At the right price a budget collector will love it!
The only question is who destroyed this tough date Barber?
Cool date, but it’s had one rough life. Wow. Really too bad. Still cool though!!!
Dave
Congrats, it looks like you got about 80% of the black stuff off!
Most circ examples of this tough date are worn out, but not yours!
Somewhere out there is a collector for this very coin!
30+ years coin shop experience (ret.) Coins, bullion, currency, scrap & interesting folks. Loved every minute!
It would be a great coin to complete a Barber Album
Mr_Spud