If u have a chance can u LMK your opinion of the coins. Graded properly?
I am starting to believe that the prices on the TPG coins will slip a bit due to concern that they are over graded relative to CACG?
Thoughts?
TY.
I'm curious why you think CACG is any different than PCGS or NGC graded coins. CACG is no more than a single opinion just as the others. The old CAC sticker was a affirmation given on the original slab(2 opinions on the same slab)... JMHO
If u have a chance can u LMK your opinion of the coins. Graded properly?
I am starting to believe that the prices on the TPG coins will slip a bit due to concern that they are over graded relative to CACG?
Thoughts?
TY.
I'm curious why you think CACG is any different than PCGS or NGC graded coins. CACG is no more than a single opinion just as the others. The old CAC sticker was a affirmation given on the original slab(2 opinions on the same slab)... JMHO
Mark
See the CAC threads for details.
The general sentiment is that CACG is being stricter and paying more attraction to things like friction. As such a CACG 63 might be worth more than a PCGS 63.
[Although I'm not sure why the OP seems to be implying that the PCGS price would be going down rather than simply a premium being paid for CACG.]
If u have a chance can u LMK your opinion of the coins. Graded properly?
I am starting to believe that the prices on the TPG coins will slip a bit due to concern that they are over graded relative to CACG?
Thoughts?
TY.
I'm curious why you think CACG is any different than PCGS or NGC graded coins. CACG is no more than a single opinion just as the others. The old CAC sticker was a affirmation given on the original slab(2 opinions on the same slab)... JMHO
Mark
See the CAC threads for details.
The general sentiment is that CACG is being stricter and paying more attraction to things like friction. As such a CACG 63 might be worth more than a PCGS 63.
[Although I'm not sure why the OP seems to be implying that the PCGS price would be going down rather than simply a premium being paid for CACG.]
No different than a PCGS CAC 63 being worth more than a PCGS 63
If u have a chance can u LMK your opinion of the coins. Graded properly?
I am starting to believe that the prices on the TPG coins will slip a bit due to concern that they are over graded relative to CACG?
Thoughts?
TY.
I'm curious why you think CACG is any different than PCGS or NGC graded coins. CACG is no more than a single opinion just as the others. The old CAC sticker was a affirmation given on the original slab(2 opinions on the same slab)... JMHO
Mark
See the CAC threads for details.
The general sentiment is that CACG is being stricter and paying more attraction to things like friction. As such a CACG 63 might be worth more than a PCGS 63.
[Although I'm not sure why the OP seems to be implying that the PCGS price would be going down rather than simply a premium being paid for CACG.]
I’ve seen posts which opine that one of the unintended consequences of CAC is the decline in value of non-CAC coins. Of course, I don’t know how someone can ascertain whether CAC coins trade at a premium or non-CAC coins trade at a discount (or both).😉
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
If u have a chance can u LMK your opinion of the coins. Graded properly?
I am starting to believe that the prices on the TPG coins will slip a bit due to concern that they are over graded relative to CACG?
Thoughts?
TY.
I'm curious why you think CACG is any different than PCGS or NGC graded coins. CACG is no more than a single opinion just as the others. The old CAC sticker was a affirmation given on the original slab(2 opinions on the same slab)... JMHO
Mark
See the CAC threads for details.
The general sentiment is that CACG is being stricter and paying more attraction to things like friction. As such a CACG 63 might be worth more than a PCGS 63.
[Although I'm not sure why the OP seems to be implying that the PCGS price would be going down rather than simply a premium being paid for CACG.]
I’ve seen posts which opine that one of the unintended consequences of CAC is the decline in value of non-CAC coins. Of course, I don’t know how someone can ascertain whether CAC coins trade at a premium or non-CAC coins trade at a discount (or both).😉
Agreed. But it's not exactly logical to me. A PCGS 63, with all the problems they may or may not have, has a price now. Why would that price change just because a CACG is (allegedly) superior?
If u have a chance can u LMK your opinion of the coins. Graded properly?
I am starting to believe that the prices on the TPG coins will slip a bit due to concern that they are over graded relative to CACG?
Thoughts?
TY.
I'm curious why you think CACG is any different than PCGS or NGC graded coins. CACG is no more than a single opinion just as the others. The old CAC sticker was a affirmation given on the original slab(2 opinions on the same slab)... JMHO
Mark
See the CAC threads for details.
The general sentiment is that CACG is being stricter and paying more attraction to things like friction. As such a CACG 63 might be worth more than a PCGS 63.
[Although I'm not sure why the OP seems to be implying that the PCGS price would be going down rather than simply a premium being paid for CACG.]
I’ve seen posts which opine that one of the unintended consequences of CAC is the decline in value of non-CAC coins. Of course, I don’t know how someone can ascertain whether CAC coins trade at a premium or non-CAC coins trade at a discount (or both).😉
Agreed. But it's not exactly logical to me. A PCGS 63, with all the problems they may or may not have, has a price now. Why would that price change just because a CACG is (allegedly) superior.
I agree.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Hey Mark - I'm interested in a couple of coins too. Can you provide your opinion:
Your
Max Bid
(with BP) Current Bid
(with BP) Next
Bid
(with BP) Lot No. Grade Activity Time Left
BIDS
1792 H10C Half Disme, Judd-7, Pollock-7, R.4, VF25 PCGS Early Half Dimes
1792 H10C Half Disme, Judd-7, Pollock-7, R.4, VF25 PCGS....(PCGS# 11020)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$62,500
($75,000.00) $65,000
($78,000.00) 4037 VF25 13 bidders
99 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1792 H10C Half Disme, Judd-7, Pollock-7, R.4, MS62 NGC Early Half Dimes
1792 H10C Half Disme, Judd-7, Pollock-7, R.4, MS62 NGC....(PCGS# 11020)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$165,000
($198,000.00) $170,000
($204,000) 4038 MS62 13 bidders
85 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1889-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1889-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 97191)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$145,000
($174,000.00) $150,000
($180,000) 4141 MS64 13 bidders
92 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1893-S $1 MS63 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1893-S $1 MS63 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7226)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$220,000
($264,000.00) $230,000
($276,000) 4155 MS63 10 bidders
122 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880 $1 PR69 Cameo PCGS Proof Morgan Dollars
1880 $1 PR69 Cameo PCGS....(PCGS# 87315)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$62,500
($75,000.00) $65,000
($78,000.00) 4175 PR69 11 bidders
69 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1804 DT$10 Ten Dollar, Judd-34, Pollock-46, High R.7, PR64 PCGS Patterns
1804 DT$10 Ten Dollar, Judd-34, Pollock-46, High R.7, PR64 PCGS....(PCGS# 11100)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$115,000
($138,000.00) $120,000
($144,000) 4221 PR64 4 bidders
77 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880 $4 Flowing Hair Stella, Judd-1658, Pollock-1858, High R.6, Gilt, PR64+ PCGS. CAC Patterns
1880 $4 Flowing Hair Stella, Judd-1658, Pollock-1858, High R.6, Gilt, PR64+ PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 92043)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$16,500
($19,800.00) $17,000
($20,400.00) 4291 PR64+ 6 bidders
28 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880 $4 Flowing Hair Stella, Judd-1659, Pollock-1859, R.7, Gilt, PR64+ PCGS. CAC Patterns
1880 $4 Flowing Hair Stella, Judd-1659, Pollock-1859, R.7, Gilt, PR64+ PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 82044)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$19,000
($22,800.00) $19,500
($23,400.00) 4292 PR64+ 8 bidders
29 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880 $4 Coiled Hair Four Dollar, Judd-1661, Pollock-1861, Low R.7, Gilt, PR64+ Cameo PCGS. CAC Patterns
1880 $4 Coiled Hair Four Dollar, Judd-1661, Pollock-1861, Low R.7, Gilt, PR64+ Cameo PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 537345)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$20,100
($24,120.00) $21,000
($25,200.00) 4293 PR64+ 7 bidders
26 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1853 G$1 MS69 PCGS. CAC Gold Dollars
1853 G$1 MS69 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7521)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$77,500
($93,000.00) $80,000
($96,000.00) 4299 MS69 11 bidders
61 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Octagonal AU58 PCGS Commemorative Gold
1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Octagonal AU58 PCGS....(PCGS# 7452)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$31,000
($37,200.00) $32,000
($38,400.00) 4420 AU58 6 bidders
39 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1851 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous. AU50 NGC. K-7, R.5 Territorial Gold
1851 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous. AU50 NGC. K-7, R.5....(PCGS# 10214) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$25,000
($30,000.00) $26,000
($31,200.00) 4427 AU50 8 bidders
49 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1852 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous., VF35 PCGS. K-11, R.5 Territorial Gold
1852 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous., VF35 PCGS. K-11, R.5....(PCGS# 10217) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$16,500
($19,800.00) $17,000
($20,400.00) 4428 VF35 8 bidders
45 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1852 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous., AU50 PCGS. CAC. K-11, R.5 Territorial Gold
1852 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous., AU50 PCGS. CAC. K-11, R.5....(PCGS# 10217) $15,555
($18,666.00)
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$16,000
($19,200.00) $16,500
($19,800.00) 4430 AU50 11 bidders
58 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1855 $50 Kellogg & Co. Fifty Dollar PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Kagin-4, High R.6 Territorial Gold
1855 $50 Kellogg & Co. Fifty Dollar PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Kagin-4, High R.6....(PCGS# 804507)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$320,000
($384,000.00) $330,000
($396,000) 4437 PR64 12 bidders
107 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1880-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7118) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$3,600
($4,320.00) $3,700
($4,440.00) 4497 MS68 6 bidders
26 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1881-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1881-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$3,900
($4,680.00) $4,000
($4,800.00) 4511 MS68 7 bidders
27 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1881-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1881-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$3,800
($4,560.00) $3,900
($4,680.00) 4512 MS68 4 bidders
18 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1881-S $1 MS68+ PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1881-S $1 MS68+ PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$9,750
($11,700.00) $10,000
($12,000.00) 4514 MS68+ 8 bidders
22 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1882-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1882-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7140) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$6,250
($7,500.00) $6,500
($7,800.00) 4523 MS68 7 bidders
25 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1915-S Panama-Pacific Copper Frame Commemorative Gold
1915-S Panama-Pacific Copper Frame.... $201
($241.20)
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$1,100
($1,320.00) $1,150
($1,380.00) 5227 Not Graded 7 bidders
19 tracking
4d 0h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1999 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Authentic Hand-Signed, John M. Mercanti. NGC Census: (547). PCGS Population: (65). CDN: $... Modern Bullion Coins
1999 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Authentic Hand-Signed, John M. Mercanti. NGC Census: (547). PCGS Population: (65). CDN: $8,0...(PCGS# 9947) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$2,600
($3,120.00) $2,700
($3,240.00) 92073 MS70 6 bidders
19 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
7d 0h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 15, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1957-D 25C MS66 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (1102/172). NGC Census: (1108/310). CDN: $35 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS... Washington Quarters
1957-D 25C MS66 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (1102/172). NGC Census: (1108/310). CDN: $35 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS66....(PCGS# 5863) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$210
($252.00) $220
($264.00) 52268 MS66 9 bidders
23 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1942 50C MS65 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (5491/3278). PCGS Population: (8256/3801). CDN: $91 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS65. Mi... Walking Liberty Half Dollars:
1942 50C MS65 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (5491/3278). PCGS Population: (8256/3801). CDN: $91 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS65. Minta... --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$115
($144.00) $120
($149.00) 52296 MS65 5 bidders
27 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1947 50C MS64 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (3404/3958). PCGS Population: (5143/6193). CDN: $86 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS64. Mi... Walking Liberty Half Dollars:
1947 50C MS64 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (3404/3958). PCGS Population: (5143/6193). CDN: $86 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS64. Minta... --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$115
($144.00) $120
($149.00) 52314 MS64 4 bidders
22 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1947 50C MS64 NGC. Gold CAC. NGC Census: (3404/3958). PCGS Population: (5143/6193). CDN: $86 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS6... Walking Liberty Half Dollars:
1947 50C MS64 NGC. Gold CAC. NGC Census: (3404/3958). PCGS Population: (5143/6193). CDN: $86 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS64. ... --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$600
($720.00) $625
($750.00) 52315 MS64 6 bidders
31 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1880-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (40017/14969). NGC Census: (36929/16578). CDN: $165 Whsle. Bid for NGC/P... Morgan Dollars:
1880-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (40017/14969). NGC Census: (36929/16578). CDN: $165 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS...(PCGS# 7118) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$480
($576.00) $490
($588.00) 52380 MS65 4 bidders
30 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1880-S $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. PCGS Population: (4806/3661). NGC Census: (3840/2894). CDN: $198 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS... Morgan Dollars:
1880-S $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. PCGS Population: (4806/3661). NGC Census: (3840/2894). CDN: $198 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS6...(PCGS# 7119) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$155
($186.00) $160
($192.00) 52384 MS64 6 bidders
26 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1881-S $1 MS65 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (58801/18465). NGC Census: (57865/23944). CDN: $160 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS M... Morgan Dollars:
1881-S $1 MS65 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (58801/18465). NGC Census: (57865/23944). CDN: $160 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS65...(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$260
($312.00) $270
($324.00) 52407 MS65 5 bidders
21 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1881-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (58787/18465). NGC Census: (57820/23933). CDN: $165 Whsle. Bid for NGC/P... Morgan Dollars:
1881-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (58787/18465). NGC Census: (57820/23933). CDN: $165 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS...(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$210
($252.00) $220
($264.00) 52408 MS65 5 bidders
28 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1937-D 50C Oregon MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (1010/2162). NGC Census: (543/1598). CDN: $240 Whsle. Bid for NG... Commemorative Silver
1937-D 50C Oregon MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (1010/2162). NGC Census: (543/1598). CDN: $240 Whsle. Bid for NGC/P...(PCGS# 9347) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$320
($384.00) $330
($396.00) 52860 MS65 5 bidders
28 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
Tim, don’t sweat it. In order to save us both time and trouble, I’ve placed unlimited bids for you on 9 of the coins. After the sale has ended, I’ll let you know which ones and how much you owe.😉
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Tim, don’t sweat it. In order to save us both time and trouble, I’ve placed unlimited bids for you on 9 of the coins. After the sale has ended, I’ll let you know which ones and how much you owe.😉
LOL, checking my wife's life insurance policy now.
Tim, don’t sweat it. In order to save us both time and trouble, I’ve placed unlimited bids for you on 9 of the coins. After the sale has ended, I’ll let you know which ones and how much you owe.😉
LOL, checking my wife's life insurance policy now.
Tim
If she sees these posts, she’ll be checking YOUR life insurance policy.🫢
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Tim, don’t sweat it. In order to save us both time and trouble, I’ve placed unlimited bids for you on 9 of the coins. After the sale has ended, I’ll let you know which ones and how much you owe.😉
LOL, checking my wife's life insurance policy now.
Tim
If she sees these posts, she’ll be checking YOUR life insurance policy.🫢
If so, she'll know for a fact I'm worth more dead than alive....
Tim, don’t sweat it. In order to save us both time and trouble, I’ve placed unlimited bids for you on 9 of the coins. After the sale has ended, I’ll let you know which ones and how much you owe.😉
LOL, checking my wife's life insurance policy now.
Tim
If she sees these posts, she’ll be checking YOUR life insurance policy.🫢
If so, she'll know for a fact I'm worth more dead than alive....
T
If she kills you, make sure she doesn't sell your coins for what you told her you paid.
If u have a chance can u LMK your opinion of the coins. Graded properly?
I am starting to believe that the prices on the TPG coins will slip a bit due to concern that they are over graded relative to CACG?
Thoughts?
TY.
I'm curious why you think CACG is any different than PCGS or NGC graded coins. CACG is no more than a single opinion just as the others. The old CAC sticker was a affirmation given on the original slab(2 opinions on the same slab)... JMHO
Mark
See the CAC threads for details.
The general sentiment is that CACG is being stricter and paying more attraction to things like friction. As such a CACG 63 might be worth more than a PCGS 63.
[Although I'm not sure why the OP seems to be implying that the PCGS price would be going down rather than simply a premium being paid for CACG.]
I’ve seen posts which opine that one of the unintended consequences of CAC is the decline in value of non-CAC coins. Of course, I don’t know how someone can ascertain whether CAC coins trade at a premium or non-CAC coins trade at a discount (or both).😉
It's easy. Look at the coins. If the CAC coin looks overpriced for what it is, it trades at a premium. And if the non-CAC coin looks like a bargain for what it is, it trades at a discount.
Andy Lustig
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
jkrk
Posts: 972 ✭✭✭✭✭
Comments
I want those also and I already bid them to full CPG/PCGS value. Sorry.
Chopmarked Trade Dollar Registry Set --- US & World Gold Showcase --- World Chopmark Showcase
I specifically put my ‘bid sniper’ in on those exact coins….so I will win at the last second…and you can’t do anything about it….🤔😂
See my PM. And next time, PM or email me the particulars, instead of starting a thread.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Oh all Double eagles!
I'm curious why you think CACG is any different than PCGS or NGC graded coins. CACG is no more than a single opinion just as the others. The old CAC sticker was a affirmation given on the original slab(2 opinions on the same slab)... JMHO
Mark
Jus’ shon’ awf.
See the CAC threads for details.
The general sentiment is that CACG is being stricter and paying more attraction to things like friction. As such a CACG 63 might be worth more than a PCGS 63.
[Although I'm not sure why the OP seems to be implying that the PCGS price would be going down rather than simply a premium being paid for CACG.]
No different than a PCGS CAC 63 being worth more than a PCGS 63
I’ve seen posts which opine that one of the unintended consequences of CAC is the decline in value of non-CAC coins. Of course, I don’t know how someone can ascertain whether CAC coins trade at a premium or non-CAC coins trade at a discount (or both).😉
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Agreed. But it's not exactly logical to me. A PCGS 63, with all the problems they may or may not have, has a price now. Why would that price change just because a CACG is (allegedly) superior?
I agree.
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
Hey Mark - I'm interested in a couple of coins too. Can you provide your opinion:
Your
Max Bid
(with BP) Current Bid
(with BP) Next
Bid
(with BP) Lot No. Grade Activity Time Left
BIDS
1792 H10C Half Disme, Judd-7, Pollock-7, R.4, VF25 PCGS Early Half Dimes
1792 H10C Half Disme, Judd-7, Pollock-7, R.4, VF25 PCGS....(PCGS# 11020)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$62,500
($75,000.00) $65,000
($78,000.00) 4037 VF25 13 bidders
99 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1792 H10C Half Disme, Judd-7, Pollock-7, R.4, MS62 NGC Early Half Dimes
1792 H10C Half Disme, Judd-7, Pollock-7, R.4, MS62 NGC....(PCGS# 11020)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$165,000
($198,000.00) $170,000
($204,000) 4038 MS62 13 bidders
85 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1889-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1889-CC $1 MS64 Deep Mirror Prooflike PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 97191)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$145,000
($174,000.00) $150,000
($180,000) 4141 MS64 13 bidders
92 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1893-S $1 MS63 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1893-S $1 MS63 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7226)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$220,000
($264,000.00) $230,000
($276,000) 4155 MS63 10 bidders
122 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880 $1 PR69 Cameo PCGS Proof Morgan Dollars
1880 $1 PR69 Cameo PCGS....(PCGS# 87315)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$62,500
($75,000.00) $65,000
($78,000.00) 4175 PR69 11 bidders
69 tracking
2d 19h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1804 DT$10 Ten Dollar, Judd-34, Pollock-46, High R.7, PR64 PCGS Patterns
1804 DT$10 Ten Dollar, Judd-34, Pollock-46, High R.7, PR64 PCGS....(PCGS# 11100)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$115,000
($138,000.00) $120,000
($144,000) 4221 PR64 4 bidders
77 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880 $4 Flowing Hair Stella, Judd-1658, Pollock-1858, High R.6, Gilt, PR64+ PCGS. CAC Patterns
1880 $4 Flowing Hair Stella, Judd-1658, Pollock-1858, High R.6, Gilt, PR64+ PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 92043)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$16,500
($19,800.00) $17,000
($20,400.00) 4291 PR64+ 6 bidders
28 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880 $4 Flowing Hair Stella, Judd-1659, Pollock-1859, R.7, Gilt, PR64+ PCGS. CAC Patterns
1880 $4 Flowing Hair Stella, Judd-1659, Pollock-1859, R.7, Gilt, PR64+ PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 82044)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$19,000
($22,800.00) $19,500
($23,400.00) 4292 PR64+ 8 bidders
29 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880 $4 Coiled Hair Four Dollar, Judd-1661, Pollock-1861, Low R.7, Gilt, PR64+ Cameo PCGS. CAC Patterns
1880 $4 Coiled Hair Four Dollar, Judd-1661, Pollock-1861, Low R.7, Gilt, PR64+ Cameo PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 537345)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$20,100
($24,120.00) $21,000
($25,200.00) 4293 PR64+ 7 bidders
26 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1853 G$1 MS69 PCGS. CAC Gold Dollars
1853 G$1 MS69 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7521)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$77,500
($93,000.00) $80,000
($96,000.00) 4299 MS69 11 bidders
61 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Octagonal AU58 PCGS Commemorative Gold
1915-S $50 Panama-Pacific 50 Dollar Octagonal AU58 PCGS....(PCGS# 7452)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$31,000
($37,200.00) $32,000
($38,400.00) 4420 AU58 6 bidders
39 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1851 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous. AU50 NGC. K-7, R.5 Territorial Gold
1851 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous. AU50 NGC. K-7, R.5....(PCGS# 10214) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$25,000
($30,000.00) $26,000
($31,200.00) 4427 AU50 8 bidders
49 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1852 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous., VF35 PCGS. K-11, R.5 Territorial Gold
1852 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous., VF35 PCGS. K-11, R.5....(PCGS# 10217) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$16,500
($19,800.00) $17,000
($20,400.00) 4428 VF35 8 bidders
45 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1852 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous., AU50 PCGS. CAC. K-11, R.5 Territorial Gold
1852 $50 RE Humbert Fifty Dollar, Reeded Edge, 887 Thous., AU50 PCGS. CAC. K-11, R.5....(PCGS# 10217) $15,555
($18,666.00)
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$16,000
($19,200.00) $16,500
($19,800.00) 4430 AU50 11 bidders
58 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1855 $50 Kellogg & Co. Fifty Dollar PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Kagin-4, High R.6 Territorial Gold
1855 $50 Kellogg & Co. Fifty Dollar PR64 Cameo PCGS. CAC. Kagin-4, High R.6....(PCGS# 804507)
FEATURED
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$320,000
($384,000.00) $330,000
($396,000) 4437 PR64 12 bidders
107 tracking
3d 0h 14m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 11, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1880-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1880-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7118) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$3,600
($4,320.00) $3,700
($4,440.00) 4497 MS68 6 bidders
26 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1881-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1881-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$3,900
($4,680.00) $4,000
($4,800.00) 4511 MS68 7 bidders
27 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1881-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1881-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$3,800
($4,560.00) $3,900
($4,680.00) 4512 MS68 4 bidders
18 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1881-S $1 MS68+ PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1881-S $1 MS68+ PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$9,750
($11,700.00) $10,000
($12,000.00) 4514 MS68+ 8 bidders
22 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1882-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC Morgan Dollars
1882-S $1 MS68 PCGS. CAC....(PCGS# 7140) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$6,250
($7,500.00) $6,500
($7,800.00) 4523 MS68 7 bidders
25 tracking
3d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1915-S Panama-Pacific Copper Frame Commemorative Gold
1915-S Panama-Pacific Copper Frame.... $201
($241.20)
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$1,100
($1,320.00) $1,150
($1,380.00) 5227 Not Graded 7 bidders
19 tracking
4d 0h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 12, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1999 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Authentic Hand-Signed, John M. Mercanti. NGC Census: (547). PCGS Population: (65). CDN: $... Modern Bullion Coins
1999 $1 Silver Eagle MS70 NGC. Authentic Hand-Signed, John M. Mercanti. NGC Census: (547). PCGS Population: (65). CDN: $8,0...(PCGS# 9947) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$2,600
($3,120.00) $2,700
($3,240.00) 92073 MS70 6 bidders
19 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
7d 0h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 15, 2024.
$
Save $ When You Resell
1957-D 25C MS66 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (1102/172). NGC Census: (1108/310). CDN: $35 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS... Washington Quarters
1957-D 25C MS66 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (1102/172). NGC Census: (1108/310). CDN: $35 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS66....(PCGS# 5863) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$210
($252.00) $220
($264.00) 52268 MS66 9 bidders
23 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1942 50C MS65 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (5491/3278). PCGS Population: (8256/3801). CDN: $91 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS65. Mi... Walking Liberty Half Dollars:
1942 50C MS65 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (5491/3278). PCGS Population: (8256/3801). CDN: $91 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS65. Minta... --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$115
($144.00) $120
($149.00) 52296 MS65 5 bidders
27 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1947 50C MS64 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (3404/3958). PCGS Population: (5143/6193). CDN: $86 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS64. Mi... Walking Liberty Half Dollars:
1947 50C MS64 NGC. CAC. NGC Census: (3404/3958). PCGS Population: (5143/6193). CDN: $86 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS64. Minta... --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$115
($144.00) $120
($149.00) 52314 MS64 4 bidders
22 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1947 50C MS64 NGC. Gold CAC. NGC Census: (3404/3958). PCGS Population: (5143/6193). CDN: $86 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS6... Walking Liberty Half Dollars:
1947 50C MS64 NGC. Gold CAC. NGC Census: (3404/3958). PCGS Population: (5143/6193). CDN: $86 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS64. ... --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$600
($720.00) $625
($750.00) 52315 MS64 6 bidders
31 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1880-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (40017/14969). NGC Census: (36929/16578). CDN: $165 Whsle. Bid for NGC/P... Morgan Dollars:
1880-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (40017/14969). NGC Census: (36929/16578). CDN: $165 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS...(PCGS# 7118) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$480
($576.00) $490
($588.00) 52380 MS65 4 bidders
30 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1880-S $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. PCGS Population: (4806/3661). NGC Census: (3840/2894). CDN: $198 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS... Morgan Dollars:
1880-S $1 MS64 Prooflike PCGS. PCGS Population: (4806/3661). NGC Census: (3840/2894). CDN: $198 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS6...(PCGS# 7119) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$155
($186.00) $160
($192.00) 52384 MS64 6 bidders
26 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1881-S $1 MS65 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (58801/18465). NGC Census: (57865/23944). CDN: $160 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS M... Morgan Dollars:
1881-S $1 MS65 PCGS. CAC. PCGS Population: (58801/18465). NGC Census: (57865/23944). CDN: $160 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS MS65...(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$260
($312.00) $270
($324.00) 52407 MS65 5 bidders
21 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1881-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (58787/18465). NGC Census: (57820/23933). CDN: $165 Whsle. Bid for NGC/P... Morgan Dollars:
1881-S $1 MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (58787/18465). NGC Census: (57820/23933). CDN: $165 Whsle. Bid for NGC/PCGS...(PCGS# 7130) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$210
($252.00) $220
($264.00) 52408 MS65 5 bidders
28 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
$
1937-D 50C Oregon MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (1010/2162). NGC Census: (543/1598). CDN: $240 Whsle. Bid for NG... Commemorative Silver
1937-D 50C Oregon MS65 PCGS. Gold CAC. PCGS Population: (1010/2162). NGC Census: (543/1598). CDN: $240 Whsle. Bid for NGC/P...(PCGS# 9347) --
Bid Protection :
Select (0 increments)
$320
($384.00) $330
($396.00) 52860 MS65 5 bidders
28 tracking
Signature® Internet Session - No Floor or Phone Bidding (Mail, Fax, Internet, and Heritage Live)
13d 20h 44m
for Proxy Bidding.
Live auction on Jan 22, 2024.
Tim
Tim, don’t sweat it. In order to save us both time and trouble, I’ve placed unlimited bids for you on 9 of the coins. After the sale has ended, I’ll let you know which ones and how much you owe.😉
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
LOL, checking my wife's life insurance policy now.
Tim
If she sees these posts, she’ll be checking YOUR life insurance policy.🫢
Mark Feld* of Heritage Auctions*Unless otherwise noted, my posts here represent my personal opinions.
If so, she'll know for a fact I'm worth more dead than alive....
T
If she kills you, make sure she doesn't sell your coins for what you told her you paid.
It's easy. Look at the coins. If the CAC coin looks overpriced for what it is, it trades at a premium. And if the non-CAC coin looks like a bargain for what it is, it trades at a discount.
Doggedly collecting coins of the Central American Republic.
Visit the Society of US Pattern Collectors at USPatterns.com.
Well, at least now I know the lots to bid up!
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
That can be a dangerous game to play.
Wow what a strange thread !