Which one would you Choose between these two buffaloes

FullHorn · March 6, 2020 8:31PM

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1921-5c-PCGS-MS66-Pretty-Toning-Buffalo-Nickel-Pretty-Toning/352992746322?hash=item523001db52:g:6zEAAOSwWxxeN3Lr

OR

https://www.ebay.com/itm/1921-Buffalo-Nickel-PCGS-MS-66-PQ-White-Coin-Nice-Strike-Better-Date/352785525982?hash=item5223a7ecde:g:0FsAAOSwbeZdd-v-

ironmanl63 · March 6, 2020 8:37PM

The cheaper one!

mcarney1173 · March 6, 2020 8:42PM

Definitely the David Lawrence coin. Much more original-looking, the other ones looks too washed out- I like a little bit of color on Buffalos. Strike looks better on the first one too

coinbuf · March 6, 2020 8:48PM

Two for one deal.

coinbuf · March 6, 2020 8:49PM

@mcarney1173 said:
Definitely the David Lawrence coin. Much more original-looking, the other ones looks too washed out- I like a little bit of color on Buffalos. Strike looks better on the first one too

You might want to check the cert numbers.

koynekwest · March 6, 2020 8:51PM

Number two. Too much carbon spotting on number one.

MasonG · March 6, 2020 8:53PM

@koynekwest said:
Number two. Too much carbon spotting on number one.

Psst... might want to check the post above yours.

Smudge · March 6, 2020 9:22PM

The cheaper one.

lkeigwin · March 6, 2020 9:49PM

Same coin.
Lance.

ParlousJoe · March 6, 2020 11:11PM

If it was me spending that kind of money for that year of nickel, I'm passing on both of those and waiting to find one without all of the spotting on it. I would think there are nicer ones that you could find in that grade without any or less spots than those two, might take a little time to find one but I would continue to look and might even find a nicer one for less money too.

Commencents · March 7, 2020 2:35AM

Both look like they have smallpox. Oh wait, ...it's the same coin.

keets · March 7, 2020 3:23AM

do people actually look at the links or read the replies before they post??

coinwizard1 · March 7, 2020 5:33AM

Hi what do yall think of this set up for auction?

https://auctions.stacksbowers.com/lots/view/3-LYWMK/year-set-of-1944-s-coinage-pcgs

ricko · March 7, 2020 5:47AM

The two auctions are the same coin....a little different lighting, but the same. Cheers, RickO

isaiah58 · March 7, 2020 6:00AM

I sent each seller a message and a link to the other sellers listing.

jabba · March 7, 2020 7:52AM

I have gotten a couple of coins from great southern and have not been disappointed so maybe that’s a bias but number 2

1Bufffan · March 7, 2020 8:09AM

After checking both coins seem to be the same, photos show the two and half feathers, same carbon spots, flecks are toned down on the one, but are a definite distraction, personally I would pass on either one.

isaiah58 · March 7, 2020 8:15AM

At least one of the two sellers appear to be selling consigned coins, without taking physical possession.

ike126 · March 7, 2020 8:55AM

Pass

johnny9434 · March 7, 2020 9:15AM

yeah, right. pass

Barndog · March 7, 2020 9:24AM

no like spots

BuffaloIronTail · March 7, 2020 9:33AM

My My. What a difference a picture makes.

That's what I've been alluding to all along about pictures. (I failed to look at the Cert#s initially).

Pete

divecchia · March 7, 2020 9:34AM

Same coin and "No Bueno" for me. Spots all over it.

Donato

Cougar1978 · March 7, 2020 10:34AM

Neither / both same coin same Cert number. What’s going on?

Don’t Like coin like would shop around. Even at lower price your paying full retail. CPG 1500. Auc last two / $1110 Pcgs 66 plus and CAC, $1200 Pcgs 66 cac

Pass on coin and price.

Which one would you Choose between these two buffaloes

Comments

Leave a Comment

Categories