Options
My Submission results
jabba
Posts: 3,177 ✭✭✭✭✭
Did ok this time waiting for true views
now some of these where raw but the 38D is labeled genuine UNC wrap Machine damage was in a rattler that was in bad shape guess I should have just submitted for beholder it’s got awesome reverse toning DOH 🙄 I can’t see the damage.
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/quarters/washington-quarters-major-sets/washington-quarters-date-set-circulation-strikes-1932-present/publishedset/209923
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/quarters/washington-quarters-major-sets/washington-quarters-date-set-circulation-strikes-1932-present/album/209923
0
Comments
Never......key word.....NEVER crack a coin out of a PCGS holder! NEVER.
Why never? Sometimes there is no downside.
So what was the grade on the original rattler?
Nice grades....Too bad about the crackout....I agree with DIMEMAN....Cheers, RickO
I disagree. There's actually no upside considering PCGS will crack them for you if submitted for regrade or reholder. One downside of cracking it yourself is possibly damaging the coin in the process. Another is that PCGS will downgrade (or worse, Genuine) the coin the next time through. You have no guarantee to fall back on at that point.
For coins in non-PCGS holders, the argument for cracking vs. Crossover has more merit. OTOH, I recently cracked a coin in an NGC MS67 holder with a CAC sticker that came back MS65 from PCGS. I was hoping for MS66+ and figured MS66 was the worst possible outcome. Sometimes you play the game and lose.
That is a shame about the crack out. You could always try it again...
"It's like God, Family, Country, except Sticker, Plastic, Coin."
Usually never isn’t never.
What if I want to put it in an album or study the rims? If it’s essentially a bullion coin the slab adds little to no real value. Not every coin needs to spend the rest of eternity in a plastic tomb. It’s also quite simple to get a coin out of a slab without damaging it. If the TPGs can do it, so can I.
it is called the crack-out game for a reason.
Use the reconsideration service for PCGS holdered coins.
I took my cue from the OP and assumed we were talking about a PCGS coin that was about to be resubmitted to PCGS. If you want to crack out a coin to have it raw, that's your own business. I remember when I joined the forum in the mid-2000s, cracking nice PCGS coins to put in one's Dansco 7070 album was all the rage. Times seem to have changed on that front.
I was mostly referring to the response given by @DIMEMAN. Seemed a bit over the top to me, that's all.
There's a time and place for cracking out coins for re-submission too. It's not something most people should do commonly, but there's plenty of people who have great success with it.
Again, the distinction needs to be made between cracking out PCGS and non-PCGS coins for resubmission to PCGS. There is ZERO benefit to doing the former at any time for any reason. I'm stressing this because it's a very common mistake that newbies around here make. Non-PCGS coins is another story, as I stated in my original post.
I disagree about there being "zero benefit at any time for any reason." Newbies generally shouldn't do it though.
Could you provide a scenario? I might learn something.
what if PCGS put it in a genuine holder you disagree with?
I never purchase Genuine coins but, unless I'm mistaken, sending it in for a Regrade in the holder will be exactly equivalent to cracking it. The only difference is PCGS cracks it for you and is liable for any damage to the coin in so doing. The graders do not know the coin's prior grade (or no-grade) when they evaluate it either way.
Not true. If you send it in for regrade the grade will not go down if left in the holder. If you crack it out then it is raw.
OK, I guess that policy still applies for the details grade on a Genuine coin. As I say, I don't own or submit them, so just overlooked that. I'm still waiting to hear of any valid reason to crack a PCGS coin before resubmitting it to PCGS.
No reason I can think of unless it is in a Genuine holder and you feel it should straight grade. I forgot about this possibility.
Well, that's the crux of the question. I assumed they'd consider giving a Genuine coin a straight grade if simply submitted via Regrade. If they can change their opinion on a numerical grade, why not on whether the coin was cleaned, damaged, etc.?
If you submit enough raw coins, you will get a genuine cleaned or questionable color that you disagree with. Why would you resubmit via re-grade?
sorry for hijacking your thread with awesome buffalos, jabba
I rarely submit raw coins anymore, but do send in coins for Regrade on occasion. If you have a bunch of raw coins to submit, then yes, cracking the coin to add them to that order makes economic sense. Abstractly however, Regrade would be the preferred option for reasons that I've already beaten to death above.
In the case of this type I would crack and send raw. There is nothing to lose on a Genie. JMHO
Your chance of “making” a big coin is higher with a crackout than with a regrade. Stuff like 67+ Peace dollars or 69 Morgans. The graders might not see the coin’s previous grade on a regrade, but I’d be very, very surprised if the finalizer didn’t have in from of him/her the whole history of the coin.
To be very clear, the risk is much higher too. Only people who can grade with the best of them can consistently win at that game. I am not one of them.
I’ve done some cracking in my time it seems to me it’s easier to get better grades that way now had I sent this coin in for true view and re-holder they could have still bagged the coin for damage that wasn’t caught the first time around.


Photo of coin before I cracked it
After
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/quarters/washington-quarters-major-sets/washington-quarters-date-set-circulation-strikes-1932-present/publishedset/209923
https://www.pcgs.com/setregistry/quarters/washington-quarters-major-sets/washington-quarters-date-set-circulation-strikes-1932-present/album/209923
I don't have definitive information on exactly what the finalization process entails, but I'm guessing you don't either. My understanding, based on what I've read here over the years, is that the finalizer's primary role is to resolve disagreements between multiple graders of the coin. What you are suggesting is a bit of a slippery slope. Does the finalizer know and consider who submitted the coin, and at which service level? Do they take into consideration how long it's been since the coin was last submitted or how many times in the recent past? I'd like to believe they do not.
These questions aside, my advice stands for all but perhaps the <1% who are seasoned industry professionals.
I stand by these words!!!
Certainly I have no idea about the fine details of how the TPGs work. All the same, there are folks who have actual money in the game who have determined that cracking out (certain) coins consistently maximizes their ROI. I also know some high-volume dealers who don’t crack out very many coins.
I just think that advice to NEVER do something is overly simplified. Knowing when to make rare exceptions to excellent rules is important.
Fair enough, although the above-cited "folks" really don't know if the results would have been worse had they opted for Regrade over cracking those PCGS-holdered coins out. My hunch is that the nicer the coin for the grade, the more emboldened a submitter would be to crack, which could lead to higher upgrade success for their cracked coins, which would reinforce their bias toward cracking. Or............ I may be overthinking it.
In any case, the true pros aren't paying attention to my advice anyway. For the other 99%, I maintain they'll come out ahead by observing the "never rule". We can agree to disagree.