Original color of US silver coins
RogerB
Posts: 9,009 ✭✭✭✭✭
The point of interest in this thread is that what we think of as “original” surfaces on silver coins, were actually almost pure silver due to acid cleaning and removal of surface copper prior to coinage.
The following excerpt refers to a long letter describing possible introduction of high quality steel finishing rolls for coinage strips. This would eliminate use of the drawbench, strip annealing and also pickling of planchets in acid to remove fire scale from annealing. The subject requires further investigation to determine when (or if) these changes were adopted.
[Excerpt from letter dated November 26, 1877 to Pollock from Bosbyshell, Coiner.]
“…I may add in conclusion that I believe it is practicable to dispense with the pickling of planchets, the source of the greatest loss in this Department. Treating the strips as stated, will leave the planchets with a fine polished surface – these places in closed boxes and annealed, will prevent discoloration. The coin thus produced will present a nickel polished 9/10ths fine silver surface instead of the present fine silver surface – will be in color what it is in fineness, and not as now presenting a pure silver appearance, when in reality 1/10th of it is base.
“I have in my possession, as before stated a lot of quarter dollars treated in this way, that were submitted to you, and also examined by the other officials of the Mint – all agreeing that in appearance they are equally as elegant as out usual coinage, except in the matter of color – and this was believed to be an improvement over the dead white pure silver surface of our coin….”
(The above letter and related items were located by accident - misfiled by more than 2 years in archival letter boxes.)
Comments
There is a letter in box 109 dated Oct 27, 1877 also from Bosbyshell to Pollock.
https://archive.org/details/RG104Entry1Box109GeneralCorrespondenceAugust1877toNovember1877/page/n553
Another long letter that sounds like his ideas to do what he did in your letter.
Towards the end of this letter, pertaining to color, he writes:
"Experiments are now underway to determine whether it is possible to mill an annealed planchet - which if successful, will enable us to produce coin from strips annealed but once and in [cannisters?] This will do away with the process of whitening. Provided the mint authorities are prepared to issue a coin without so bright a fine silver surface as those at present."
"You Suck Award" - February, 2015
Discoverer of 1919 Mercury Dime DDO - FS-101
Yep. The annealing change included putting the planchets in sealed iron (or copper) canisters to prevent surface oxidation, rather than in an open furnace and then pickling then in acid.
The canisters were eventually adopted. They were made of copper and the openings sealed with wet clay. They were called "annealing canisters," or "annealing cylinders."
Is he referring to the loss of silver in the Coining Department as a result of the pickling process? My understanding is that pickling resulted in about a .01% loss of silver. Doesn't sound like much. You'd think M&R sweeps would be much more.
Or maybe he is referring to the total cost to draw, anneal, and pickle?
He's referring to the direct loss of silver. Some of this is recovered when the acid is treated to precipitate silver or silver compounds. Processing cost would also be included in the final examination to see if the overall savings warranted a change.
0.01% of each million ounces is 100 oz worth about $108. The 1877 Annual Report shows that about 31.7 million ounces of silver were operated on that year. The savings could be as high as $3,400. That's the salary of the Engraver plus lots of coffee money.
Quit gherkin us around!
Sweet !
Some may need the bread and butter!
Most interesting. Though I can't say that I've noticed a different in toning between pre-1877 silver coins and those after.
Dilly Dilly!
You could always post all the crazy letters relating and baths/rinses/special whitening/soaking and other concoctions Hubble had Linderman and Pollock jumping through hoops trying to make his Goloid dollars meet his expectations.
"You Suck Award" - February, 2015
Discoverer of 1919 Mercury Dime DDO - FS-101
The Hubbell fiasco is the subject of a book to be published in a couple of months. All the the special recipes and sauces Hubbell wanted used on his goloid nuggets are included in sufficient detail for anyone to open their own "Goloid Arches" establishment.
Are there contemporary pics of this discussion?
It would be interesting to see the original color of silver versus an ‘unoriginal’ color.
The internal discussions of processes and materials is always interesting to me. I spent a career in operational manufacturing and process improvements were always sought. These included those for cost reductions, reliability, manufacturability and quality of product. This discussion was applicable to three of those categories. Cheers, RickO
In 1877 there was no viable method of color photography or of accurate color measurement. Maybe comparing modern 0.999 silver with a new 0.900 coin will help. I recall new 0.900 silver coins having a slight yellow cast to them.