Options
When collecting toned coins
Along
Posts: 473 ✭✭✭✭
When collecting toned coins - does it matter if only one side is toned? If it is only toned on one side, does it matter if the toning is on the obverse or reverse?
1
Comments
For me it matter's. I would imagine for most as well? I would like my entire vehicle to have a nice wax then half of it.
Generally Obverse toned coins are more sought after / revered than reverse toned coins. Everything is always subjective and depends on the coin though. To have nice toning on the obverse and reverse can certainly be a plus.
Not really looking for much these days but if I were, it might be a toner.
it depends on the coin and the source. for example, a coin in a whitman holder or some presentation set, may only have toning on one side. whereas a coin in a pci holder will have rim toning that is on both sides.
It has been said that the obverse is the money side when it comes to toning. This is especially true for Morgans and American Silver Eagles. Eye appealing toning on both sides would always be a plus, no matter the denomination. The following is an example of why I would not rule out purchasing a one sided toner. The quality and eye appeal of the toning is far more important than what side it is on.
Then there is the best of both worlds.............
I like 'em with both sides toned but I would make an exception for the first coin shown above. It's a beauty!
Obverse toners fetch the most money, especially for the so called "monster" Morgan Dollar market.
I like 2 sided toners but money side is always on the obverse especially Morgan like others already mentioned
Wow - now that is a money side!
Like was already said, it's subjective.
A clean reverse with a nicely toned reverse can make for a stunning coin.
So many possibilities.......but that's one of the things that makes this hobby great.
Other things being equal, two-sided toners will be worth the most, followed by obverse, then reverse. The most important factor is the quality of the toning itself. Vibrant colors with great luster will go for a ton of money.
Reverse toners can get quite expensive too, if they are nice enough.
This is easily my best reverse toner. If the color were on the obverse, it would probably be worth 2-3 times as much.
it depends...
Agree. Both sides is best but if the toning only appears on one side, the obverse wins. Four or five colors and all bets are off.
both sides are better
It does indeed make a difference to some collectors... for example... NO tarnish is my preference....
Cheers, RickO
If I had a gorgeous reverse toned coin in 66 or better I'd request it flipped over when submitting. There are quite a few series with gorgeous reverses. JFK for a more modern example.
I don’t know about every series but on Morgan dollars look for green
I was once told that green equals money!
when collecting anything, collect what YOU like
if you want to see coins with colors that add multiples to price guides, look at major auctions with closing prices (I like Legend auctions for my personal color guide)