Options
Please help me grade this 1894 Indian Head
Romankow
Posts: 148 ✭✭✭
Had this is in a 2x2 holder for 30 years. Took it out today and am considering slabbing it in order to sell it. Thoughts on the grade or whether it's worth it to slab it?!

0
Comments
Cleaned AU details, at least that’s how it appears on my iPhone.
Slightly better late date in the series but certainly not worth slabbing.
XF45 Details, Cleaned
AU
How can you gents tell that it is cleaned? I didn't clean it, Btw ( scouts honor ).
It may not be. Anyway, you don't know the history of the coin. Take some images in a different light for us.
I have found that many folks call every coin they see that is posted on a forum "CLEANED." It is very unfortunate.
Now, as to your AU coin...
The color is "off." I suspect this is due to the lighting. Otherwise, the only characteristic of possible cleaning that I see on your coin is what I learned in the 1970's. I named it the "halo" effect. It shows as a contrast in color between the flat part of the field and the point where the relief starts. Any mechanical cleaning will rarely reach the approx. 90-degree angle on the coin at that juncture.
PS On your coin the field just looks circulated (dark) and there is mint luster (bright) next to the relief.
I don't think it would be worth grading as PCGS price guide says $65 in AU-55. If it does get a numerical grade I think 55 would be tops.
XF details cleaned.
Xf details cleaned
HAPPY COLLECTING
I grade by the picture presented!
I see wear on the ribbon and curl. If the coins is sent for grading with our hosts, they will look at the coin in a controlled environment and not by picture posted to the internet. If they do not see the coin as cleaned I could definitely see it coming back as a 55.
It's an AU and the color looks a little too bright or vivid for a 120+ year old, circulated copper coin. It may straight grade, but wouldn't be worth the fees to have done, in my opinion.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
*
Thanks for the image of an Uncirculated coin which is of no help as this coin looks nothing like the OP's coin and buggers up the thread.
Hopefully, others will not let this image sidetrack the discussion about an XF or AU coin that is either cleaned or is not! Unfortunately, I don't think that will be the case.
*
I do not see clear evidence of cleaning in the picture... though I do agree with TomB's assessment... Probably not worth slabbing - unless the coin is special to you and you want to preserve it. Cheers, RickO
The first initial impression my brain received was that the coin was AU55, cleaned.
It may just be the pic/lighting, but the coin looks cleaned and unnatural.
Not worth the trip to the grading room.