Options
Help in pricing Walking Liberty Half set
I have a circulated set of Walking Liberty halves in a Dansco album, missing only the 1921-D.
I had wanted to complete it and keep it for life. Instead, I have decided to sell it for as much as I can get to reinvest the proceeds in a special "Box of 20" coin or two. Admittedly, the early coins are quite low grade, maybe even single digits. I realize condition matters, but these are low.
I would expect the 1916's, 1917's, 1919's, 1921's, and the 1938-D to bring more than other dates. Any others? I see price guide but don't have a Greysheet. Would the others just bring junk silver money from a dealer?
Any suggestion in pricing a really low grade set would be appreciated.
Yorkshireman,Obsessed collector of round, metallic pieces of history.Hunting for Latin American colonial portraits plus cool US & British coins.
0
Comments
You will likely need pictures to get answers.... and whether you will sell individually or as a whole set. Also, how much work do you want to do? Selling as a whole collection, to a dealer, will likely bring the lowest bid... individually, say on the BST or ebay, will probably bring more $$, but also considerably more work. You might try the BST with both options first... Cheers, RickO
I would not expect much, given the market and the condition you are indicating.
I saw several Dansco sets with higher grade coins than yours being shopped around at Summer FUN, and they weren't even getting lowball offers.
Ricko probably has the best suggestion - pop out the semi-keys and offer them separately, then offer the rest at some price over melt, leaving a little room for price reductions.
Best of luck in any event!
Maybe a year ago, a semi-local dealer was selling sets like that for $1,000. Said he bought 10 sets from a wholesaler. If you are fortunate to even find someone who wants it maybe $650 would work depending upon condition of the coins. A dealer would likely want just a few of the coins. Try CraigsList with an $800 or offer pricing.
How can anyone disagree with the OP's post? Whatever opinion(s) they stated seem fairly reasonable....ie the teener slugs should bring more than 1940's slugs....even if just pennies more. Last I checked, Walkers can or do bring a premium to regular junk Franklin/JFK halves. For the most part, they want opinions. How can you disagree with that? And if disagreeing, exactly which one of the multiple statements or opinions do you disagree with?
Ironically, if you have any PO-01 candidates, those would bring sizable premiums....maybe $20-$50 per coin? Ironic that someone collecting only place filler slugs would have a "primo" and hotly desired collection today. FR and AG coins not so much. The fact that the set is complete but one coin makes it an item that cannot be duplicated without hours of work. That's worth something imo above Junk metal prices. If it were me. I'd get a circ 21-d to finish it off. Sell it only as a set. It is worth a premium either complete or 1 coin short.
I'd like to see pics if & when you have them .......
I sold a low grade set a few years ago and got spit for it, however, I didn't have much in it.
Evaluate the 16-S, the two 21s your set has, and the 38-D for clear rims and a good circ look. Wholesome eye appealing examples of each of these could carry their weight as individual lots.
If any of your other early examples have these attributes, then bunch them as a lot.
Remaining are worth a slight premium over normal junk silver value as noted above.
Don't sell now. Wait until silver hits at least $25/oz.
That said, if I was selling my circulated Walker set now, I'd break it up.
-- Sell the key dates individually.
-- Sell the interesting dates/conditions in lots. For instance, a complete set of 1917's (all obv & rev mintmarks). Or maybe a complete set of all 1930's (include the 38-d). Worth a shot, but not sure this would work.
-- Sell the remaining "junk" dates/conditions as one lot, at melt value.
Successful BST transactions with forum members thebigeng, SPalladino, Zoidmeister, jacrispies, coin22lover, coinsarefun, jwitten, CommemKing.