Options
What's the highest graded PCGS coin you have cracked out and sent in raw again to PCGS?
Just curious as I've been on the edge of this exact thing with a couple of my coins.
Been kinda hard talking myself into taking the hammer to the slabs without some reinforcements from you guys...
My luck they'll come back as problem coins ![]()
![]()
![]()
0
Comments
Cracked a bunch of 55 and 58 bust coins. Maybe one or two 62-63
Cracked and sent in a bunch of 69s once... ended up with some 70s after that
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 700
MS66 and PF68
Modern or 200 year old coin? Big difference.
Lance.
A few rattler Peace dollars in the 63/64 range. All have upgraded so far.
64 Morgan that came back 63+ (I had hoped for a 64+ as it had wonderful vibrant toning).
Only crackout I've ever done.
bob:)
Regrade is always an option, no downside.
1995??..I bought a 1911 sandblasted Proof 64 NGC 2.5 IND for 21K from a dealer friend of mine. I immediately asked him to crack it out of the NGC slab, then about a month later I took the coin to Long Beach show and did the $100 PCGS walk through service and the coin came back PR65. I don't crack many coins but when I do I usually get the upgrade on the first try. All my crack outs were either 63 or 64. One Barber half upgraded from PR64 to PR66
Many MS 66s, looking for 67s. Some took a few tries, but the vast majority eventually made it.
MS 66 trying for a top pop dime.....failed. Oh well.
Just made a decision to cross rather than crack a MS 62 gold piece, price drop between 1 and 2 was too big of a risk. Crossed at 62. Was hoping for a plus or a 63. Oh well.
Never sent in a cracked out coin. Submitted them in the holder and trusted them to properly grade or regrade them.
68 Proof 1939 Walker. It came back the same
mark
Fellas, leave the tight pants to the ladies. If I can count the coins in your pockets you better use them to call a tailor. Stay thirsty my friends......
PCGS MS65 Norfolk Commem cracked out and sent back in raw. Came back MS67 and I still think its a MS68.
I have been considering one..... tough decision... Cheers, RickO