Does PCGS slab any US coin club medals (like they do for China)?

Zoins · March 8, 2017 9:18AM

I've always found it interesting that PCGS slabs many Chinese ANA and coin club medals but I haven't seen any US coin club medals or ones from other countries certified.

Does PCGS slab US coin club medals say from the ANA, California State Numismatic Association, Colorado Springs Coin Club, Denver Coin Club, Glendale Coin Club, Pacific Coast Numismatic Society, etc.

Here are some examples from the Great China Hong Kong Collectors Association and ANA Anaheim.

Zoins · March 10, 2017 10:38PM

The answer is yes, PCGS slabbed at least 1 US ANA medal, the 50 Yr. ANA Member Gold John Jay Pittman LM-152: #613795/81762530. I wonder if they would slab the more common ones as well.

TrueView:

ricko · March 11, 2017 8:54AM

That China, Hong Kong medal is really nice.... Cheers, RickO

coinsarefun · January 22, 2019 1:31PM

I sure hope they do for the PCNS Medals. I just got this Pacific Coast Numismatic Society 1982 800th meeting octagonal.
.
And the 60TH ANNIVERSARY in NGC MS 67...I haven't received this one yet as its coming up on a month but I sure hope it arrives as it is one of my most favorite designs.
.
,

Timbuk3 · January 22, 2019 6:17PM

Interesting topic, thanks for sharing !!!

MoneyMonkey1 · January 23, 2019 4:33PM

Pacific Coast.......Montana, Utah,Arizona,Nevada?

blu62vette · January 23, 2019 6:36PM

I thought Mike had some Glendale coin club medals slabbed?

@illini420

coinsarefun · January 23, 2019 6:59PM

Yes, but in ANACS.......if that’s what your referring to.

illini420 · January 23, 2019 10:51PM

@blu62vette said:
I thought Mike had some Glendale coin club medals slabbed?

@illini420

Not yet by PCGS. All GCC medals we graded have been ANACS, though I think I saw one in ICG as well.

But we did have PCGS make some slabs with our club name on the label for the 2016 Anaheim ANA that had Australian Kangaroos.

Zoins · January 23, 2019 11:18PM

@illini420 said:

@blu62vette said:
I thought Mike had some Glendale coin club medals slabbed?

@illini420

Not yet by PCGS. All GCC medals we graded have been ANACS, though I think I saw one in ICG as well.

But we did have PCGS make some slabs with our club name on the label for the 2016 Anaheim ANA that had Australian Kangaroos.

Were the PCGS ones graded?

If not, have there been discussions to have PCGS grade your club medals?

Zoins · January 24, 2019 12:14AM

Here's a PCGS graded medal for the 2015 Macao Coin Expo:

https://www.pcgs.com/cert/80294571

Here's a PCGS graded medal for the 2015 3rd China Panda Coin Collection Expo

https://www.pcgs.com/cert/80251536

Zoins · January 24, 2019 12:15AM

Given the seeming popularity of Chinese coin club and expo medals, even for PCGS, I wonder if this period of collecting Chinese coins coincides with an earlier period of collecting US coins, say in the 1960s?

Would be great for PCGS to start slabbing US club medals

illini420 · January 24, 2019 5:50AM

@Zoins said:

@illini420 said:

@blu62vette said:
I thought Mike had some Glendale coin club medals slabbed?

@illini420

Not yet by PCGS. All GCC medals we graded have been ANACS, though I think I saw one in ICG as well.

But we did have PCGS make some slabs with our club name on the label for the 2016 Anaheim ANA that had Australian Kangaroos.

Were the PCGS ones graded?

If not, have there been discussions to have PCGS grade your club medals?

To my knowledge, PCGS has never graded any of our Glendale Coin Club medals. The only club medals I have seen PCGS grade are maybe some of the ANA medals, not remembering any others. Never asked PCGS to encapsulate or grade our club medals as it was hard enough just to get them to make a special label for us. Here's what we had them make for the 2016 Anaheim ANA show:

illini420 · January 24, 2019 5:53AM

Also, I'm thinking the fact that our Glendale Coin Club medals are minted by Daniel Carr would make it a bit tougher to get them into a PCGS slab as PCGS has seemed pretty hesitant thus far to encapsulate any of his productions.

thefinn · January 24, 2019 7:30AM

They probably only encase ones struck by a government mint. The Chinese mints are the only ones I know of doing it now.

Zoins · January 24, 2019 7:55AM

@thefinn said:
They probably only encase ones struck by a government mint. The Chinese mints are the only ones I know of doing it now.

The ANA John Jay Pittman medal above wasn’t struck by a government mint but that’s the only PCGS slabbed US coin club medal I’ve run across so far. I have Newman’s medal which I’ll likely submit. Not sure about the others.

TwoSides2aCoin · January 24, 2019 7:55AM

China rules, like Google, Twitter, Facebook, and Bing rile. Thankfully our host isn't banned there. I wonder if the Chinese get to search CoinFacts , too. Strange world of dominion we live in. I hope this is not a bannable post.

dcarr · January 24, 2019 8:42PM

@illini420 said:
Also, I'm thinking the fact that our Glendale Coin Club medals are minted by Daniel Carr would make it a bit tougher to get them into a PCGS slab as PCGS has seemed pretty hesitant thus far to encapsulate any of his productions.

With the recent changes at the top at PCGS, maybe it is time for someone to try submitting another Carr "1964-D" Peace.
After all, the PCGS Tokens and Medals policy still states that valid items include: "•Krause Unusuals listed in the US Section, from the reference "Unusual World Coins, 6th Edition" by Krause Publications." : https://pcgs.com/tokensandmedals
The Carr "1964-D" Peace is listed in that approved catalog.

thefinn · January 26, 2019 6:45AM

@dcarr said:

@illini420 said:
Also, I'm thinking the fact that our Glendale Coin Club medals are minted by Daniel Carr would make it a bit tougher to get them into a PCGS slab as PCGS has seemed pretty hesitant thus far to encapsulate any of his productions.

With the recent changes at the top at PCGS, maybe it is time for someone to try submitting another Carr "1964-D" Peace.
After all, the PCGS Tokens and Medals policy still states that valid items include: "•Krause Unusuals listed in the US Section, from the reference "Unusual World Coins, 6th Edition" by Krause Publications." : https://pcgs.com/tokensandmedals
The Carr "1964-D" Peace is listed in that approved catalog.

SOMEONE like you?

dcarr · January 26, 2019 1:33PM

@thefinn said:

@dcarr said:

@illini420 said:
Also, I'm thinking the fact that our Glendale Coin Club medals are minted by Daniel Carr would make it a bit tougher to get them into a PCGS slab as PCGS has seemed pretty hesitant thus far to encapsulate any of his productions.

With the recent changes at the top at PCGS, maybe it is time for someone to try submitting another Carr "1964-D" Peace.
After all, the PCGS Tokens and Medals policy still states that valid items include: "•Krause Unusuals listed in the US Section, from the reference "Unusual World Coins, 6th Edition" by Krause Publications." : https://pcgs.com/tokensandmedals
The Carr "1964-D" Peace is listed in that approved catalog.

SOMEONE like you?

Maybe I will.

coinsarefun · February 9, 2019 12:12PM

I posted earlier the PCN medal for the 800th meeting........which I'm hoping Pcgs will holder.
.
.
This one finally arrived after several month's waiting for it.
This one is in a NGC holder but hope to submit a re-holder.
.
.

Zoins · May 3, 2020 10:56PM

PCGS now slabs the 1971 Western Reserve Numismatic Club medals. Definitely making progress.

https://www.pcgs.com/cert/38921603

Does this club still exist?

Gluggo · May 4, 2020 8:15AM

@dcarr said:

@illini420 said:
Also, I'm thinking the fact that our Glendale Coin Club medals are minted by Daniel Carr would make it a bit tougher to get them into a PCGS slab as PCGS has seemed pretty hesitant thus far to encapsulate any of his productions.

With the recent changes at the top at PCGS, maybe it is time for someone to try submitting another Carr "1964-D" Peace.
After all, the PCGS Tokens and Medals policy still states that valid items include: "•Krause Unusuals listed in the US Section, from the reference "Unusual World Coins, 6th Edition" by Krause Publications." : https://pcgs.com/tokensandmedals
The Carr "1964-D" Peace is listed in that approved catalog.

I think I will! Hi Dan! I have thank 6th Edition here too.

Zoins · March 14, 2021 1:27PM

I keep hoping to see PCGS slab PCNS and Dan's club medals.

Here's one from the London Numismatic Society.

1887 Numismatic Society of London Golden Jubilee Medal - Silver - PCGS SP65 Secure - Ex. Michael Druck

https://www.pcgs.com/cert/82284881

coinsarefun · March 14, 2021 3:05PM

@Zoins said:
I keep hoping to see PCGS slab PCNS and Dan's club medals.

.
.
It sure would be nice!! I have a bunch to send them

Does PCGS slab any US coin club medals (like they do for China)?

Comments

Leave a Comment