Options
Have you ever been refunded by PCGS for a downgrade?
Has anyone ever resubmitted a coin using guaranteed re-submission and received a downgrade plus the difference in market value? If so, please share. Was your "refund" fair? What was the rationale of "market value" they calculated?......difference in PCGS retail?
Collector of Original Early Gold with beginnings in Proof Morgan collecting.
1
Comments
No, have you?
Yes. Maybe 6 or 8 times.
The payout plus the coin at the lower grade, versus the payout and no coin, was reasonable. Not price guide, but not too far from it. No complaints.
Lance.
I've done it a few times. I found the process to be pretty fair and much more then I've heard any other company in this market will do.
One-time their offer, based on market value, seemed a little low to me, so I emailed back some info and a counter offer and they agreed and sent me a check for what I wanted.
The process does take a while, usually several months, but again, it's a great service for them to stand by their guarantees.
Michael Kittle Rare Coins --- 1908-S Indian Head Cent Grading Set --- No. 1 1909 Mint Set --- Kittlecoins on Facebook --- Long Beach Table 700
once and it went smoothly.
Years ago I submitted 2 ms67 steel pennies that had turned crusty white. They send me a check for the priceguide value!
Yes, and PCGS was exemplary in the transaction.
No.
8 years ago I sent in about 20 silver coins with spots. I got a lot of money and think that's why they don't do it on modern silver coins anymore. At least I don't think they do
Not a plug nickel from any grading service.
I could have done once, but I opted to have PCGS buy the coin from me instead.
no, none.