New Alex Cooper auction

Chesspagan · September 20, 2015 5:43AM

In the Alex Cooper auction of Oct 1, I cataloged lots 201-510 and below are some of the nice PCGS coins.

Lot # : 426 - [US] 1926 $2.50 Sesquicentennial Gold Com PCGS-63
Lot # : 491 - [US] 1881 Coronet $10 Gold Eagle – PCGS Proof-61 - https://alexcooper.hibid.com/lot/21468353/-us--1881-coronet--10-gold-eagle?tab=0&cpage=10
Very rare coin, perhaps a dozen exist and this is the only 61 Cameo
Lot # : 492 - [US] 1899 Coronet $10 Gold Eagle – PCGS-64 - https://alexcooper.hibid.com/lot/21468354/-us--1899-coronet--10-gold-eagle?tab=0&cpage=10
Lot # : 494 - [US] 1851 Coronet $20 Gold Double Eagle No Motto Type 1 - https://alexcooper.hibid.com/lot/21468356/-us--1851-coronet--20-gold-double-eagle-no-motto-t?tab=0&cpage=10
Lot # : 495 - [US] 1856-S Coronet $20 Gold Double, Ty.2 PCGS Unc Details Scratch - https://alexcooper.hibid.com/lot/21468357/-us--1856-s-coronet--20-gold-double--ty-2?tab=0&cpage=10
This is 63-64 quality if not for the scratches at the date - $20-$30,000 list without the scratches, what is it worth with the scratches?
Lot # : 498 - [US] 1907 High Relief Wire Edge $20 St. Gaudens PCGS-62 - https://alexcooper.hibid.com/lot/21468360/-us--1907-high-relief-wire-edge--20-st--gaudens?tab=0&cpage=10

Mostly raw coins, Overall, 230+ gold coins, almost complete set of commems. D-C-CC minted gold coins

https://alexcooper.hibid.com/catalog/64732/coins-and-currency---october-1--2015?tab=0

bolivarshagnasty · September 20, 2015 6:04AM

Loved his "Schools out for Summer" song.

lasvegasteddy · September 20, 2015 6:08AM

<<< loved his..."no more mr.nice guy"

he likes mock hanging of himself on the gallows at shows

MrEureka · September 20, 2015 6:39AM

Lot # : 491 - [US] 1881 Coronet $10 Gold Eagle – PCGS Proof-61

Pretty sexy coin if it's really a proof, but I have my doubts. First, the date does come PL. Second, on a quick look, I'm not convinced that the position of the date is correct for a proof. Do your homework before bidding.

Zoins · September 20, 2015 6:47AM

<< 

<< Lot # : 491 - [US] 1881 Coronet $10 Gold Eagle – PCGS Proof-61 >>

Pretty sexy coin if it's really a proof, but I have my doubts. First, the date does come PL. Second, on a quick look, I'm not convinced that the position of the date is correct for a proof. Do your homework before bidding. >>

Here's the link and CoinFacts image for comparison:

- Alex Cooper lot #491
- PCGS Cert #29813767

coindeuce · September 20, 2015 7:10AM

Is the OP a discussion point, or is it straight up SPAM ? Last I knew, ads for items for sale belonged in the BST forum.

Tibor · September 20, 2015 7:25AM

I thought his name was Alice Cooper, not Alex Cooper.

MrEureka · September 20, 2015 7:39AM

For those with high speed connections, you may want to click on this high resolution image of a no-questions proof. Check out the position and direction of the dentils vs. the digits of the date, and compare to the Cooper coin.

BTW, I have not yet tried to figure out if there are multiple die varieties for the proof, but it seems unlikely.

Zoins · September 20, 2015 7:45AM

<< For those with high speed connections, you may want to click on this high resolution image of a no-questions proof. Check out the position and direction of the dentils vs. the digits of the date, and compare to the Cooper coin.

BTW, I have not yet tried to figure out if there are multiple die varieties for the proof, but it seems unlikely. >>

For comparison:

PCGS #29813767 - Alex Cooper (full size photo)

PCGS #28471004 - Larry Pyle (full size photo)

Tibor · September 20, 2015 8:08AM

I can't see the differences that were recommended. To my eye
it looks like left over Proof Dies (Pyle) striking a "for circulation"
coin (Cooper).

MrEureka · September 20, 2015 5:59PM

…and compare the rims.

coinkat · September 20, 2015 8:21PM

Point, game and match goes to MrE

MrEureka · September 20, 2015 11:25PM

…and look at the detail on the eagle's talons.

Chesspagan · September 21, 2015 1:16PM

If you look at the actual auction page for the coin, and not this bad photograph presented earlier, the photo is better and much more clear. The coin was sent in on 2-day walk through, a week before I started cataloging the lots and didn't come back for 3 weeks. PCGS seemed to want to make sure it was a proof because of their guarantee and any buyer has that guarantee should it not be a proof.

Zoins · September 21, 2015 1:21PM

<< If you look at the actual auction page for the coin, and not this bad photograph presented earlier, the photo is better and much more clear. >>

By the "bad photograph presented earlier" do you mean the TrueView / CoinFacts photo taken by Phil and the PCGS team (the only photos posted on this thread)?

Who is the photographer for the auction photos?

Here's the full size PCGS photo for a clearer view, now also linked above.

Chesspagan · September 21, 2015 10:37PM

<< 

<< If you look at the actual auction page for the coin, and not this bad photograph presented earlier, the photo is better and much more clear. >>

By the "bad photograph presented earlier" do you mean the TrueView / CoinFacts photo taken by Phil and the PCGS team (the only photos posted on this thread)?

Who is the photographer for the auction photos?

Here's the full size PCGS photo for a clearer view, now also linked above. >>

Yes, the PCGS TrueView photo does not capture the coin at all. https://alexcooper.hibid.com/lot/21468353/-us--1881-coronet--10-gold-eagle?tab=0&cpage=10 If you click on the auction photo, you can see the cameo effect. The True view image does not capture the cameo and seems to highlight the hairlines which make it a Proof-61.
With all due respect to the True view team, they didn't do a great job on this coin or the 2 Draped Bust Halves in the auction. Those 2 coins are white coins, no damage at all but white, probably dipped at some point coins. The TrueView images seem to add colors and toning that are not there. I have seen PCGS photos that are great in the past and was surprised by these 3 photographs. Having seen all three coins in my hand and under the loop, and looking at the True View images, I think I can make that observation.
There are 2 photographers at the auction house, both professional photographers and graduates of Maryland Institute College of Art.

DaveWcoins · September 21, 2015 11:01PM

Chesspagan -- I have to ask. Do you have a financial interest in these coins?

Chesspagan · September 21, 2015 11:38PM

<< Chesspagan -- I have to ask. Do you have a financial interest in these coins? >>

Not in the least, I just cataloged lots 201-510. 0 coins belong to me. My job is done no matter what happens now. I was conservative in the grading and I suspect many of the gold coins to grade higher than my listing.
I will be there on the first preview day helping out, as well as the morning of the auction.

If I put in a signature, it could be

Michael Atkins - Member ANA, Bust Half Nuts, Liberty Seated Collectors.
Former Member EAC and JRCS. Former webmaster - Alexandria Coin Club
Current webmaster - Baltimore Coin Club. 50 year collector

DaveWcoins · September 21, 2015 11:56PM

<< 

<< Chesspagan -- I have to ask. Do you have a financial interest in these coins? >>

Not in the least, I just cataloged lots 201-510. 0 coins belong to me. My job is done no matter what happens now. I was conservative in the grading and I suspect many of the gold coins to grade higher than my listing.
I will be there on the first preview day helping out, as well as the morning of the auction.

If I put in a signature, it could be

Michael Atkins - Member ANA, Bust Half Nuts, Liberty Seated Collectors.
Former Member EAC and JRCS. Former webmaster - Alexandria Coin Club
Current webmaster - Baltimore Coin Club. 50 year collector >>

OK -- thank you for clarifying this.

Chesspagan · October 1, 2015 5:29AM

1881 $10 Proof-61 Cam sold for $10,300 today in the auction (8500+BP).

New Alex Cooper auction

Comments

Leave a Comment