Post your first submission results

TopographicOceans · December 8, 2014 2:23AM

I was checking my current order and see that PCGS still remembers every order I placed.
My first one was a modern from 9/4/2002 and it only took 15 days - and I think it was about $8 a coin back then.
I did get a MS70 from a coin I bought directly from the mint. Others, well not so good.

How did you do first time out?

Order #10073893 / Submission #3015301

Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 60041339 15003 2002-D SAC$1 USA MS64
2 1 60041340 15002 2002-P SAC$1 USA MS67
3 1 60041341 9772 1999-P $1 Dolley Madison USA PR69DC
4 1 60041342 99959 2002-W $1 Silver Eagle USA PR69DC
4 2 60041343 921000 2002-W $1 West Point USA PR69DC
5 1 60041344 921000 2002-W $1 West Point USA PR69DC
6 1 60041345 9771 1999-P $1 Dolley Madison USA MS69
7 1 60041346 9772 1999-P $1 Dolley Madison USA PR69DC
7 2 60041347 21000 2002-W $1 West Point USA MS70
8 1 60041348 9762 1997-P $1 Officers USA PR69DC
9 1 60041349 9761 1997-P $1 Officers USA MS68
10 1 60041350 9747 1997-P $1 Botanical USA PR68DC
11 1 60041351 9600 1982-D 50C Washington USA MS66
12 1 60041352 99596 1999-P SBA$1 USA PR69DC

Total Items: 14
Date Received: 9/4/2002
Date Shipped: 9/19/2002
Order Status: Shipped

lasvegasteddy · December 8, 2014 2:35AM

$8 a coin for modern...how nice

this was mine

had this truviewed...was an anacs 61brn...1st crackout...that landed 63...i was happy

my questionable color 1963 nickel #24833734 i understand might now be a pr67...prettiest blazing blue neon nickel i had laid eyes on
thought it was too good...sold it in shame

don't know what happened to that 1958 proof lincoln as it was a stunner too...more like a darn moose

AUandAG · December 8, 2014 2:49AM

Here is mine from 2005:

Order #10358325 / Submission #3344887
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 22086366 7081 1878-CC $1 USA MS62PL
2 1 22086367 7144 1883-CC $1 USA MS65
3 1 22086368 7152 1884-CC $1 USA MS63
4 1 22086369 1154 1829 1/2C USA Genuine (92 - Cleaned)
5 1 22086370 1169 1835 1/2C USA Genuine (92 - Cleaned)
6 1 22086371 5791 1932-D 25C USA XF45
7 1 22086372 2233 1908-S 1C USA Genuine (92 - Cleaned)
8 1 22086373 2239 1909-S 1C Indian USA Counterfeit

robec · December 8, 2014 3:12AM

My first.

DIMEMAN · December 8, 2014 3:19AM

1 1 09915971 4597 1852 10C USA AU55
2 1 09915972 4668 1874 10C Arrows USA AU55
3 1 09915973 4477 1805 10C 4 Berries USA VG08
4 1 09915974 4561 1837 10C No Stars, Large Date USA Genuine (94 - Altered Surf.)
5 1 09915975 4826 1901-S 10C USA MS62
6 1 09915976 4832 1903-S 10C USA AU53
7 1 09915977 4585 1844 10C USA XF40
8 1 09915978 4817 1898-S 10C USA MS62

BryceM · December 8, 2014 4:00AM

My first was an absolute train wreck....... and the reason I joined the boards.

If anyone recalls, I submitted a 2009 UHR Double eagle along with a few other odds & ends.

The UHR coin was from a sealed mint box, submitted in the original capsule. It came back "cleaned"....... WTH???

I made a few phone calls and it was regraded at MS65. Whoop-dee-do. The other coins in the submissions proved that I couldn't tell the difference between a Peace dollar slider and an MS specimen. Not exactly an auspicious beginning.

TwoSides2aCoin · December 8, 2014 4:13AM

These were 2000 Wide AM cents. Did not meet minimum grade of MS 64.
Subsequent to this order I paid twice as much outside of "BULK" to see. They were MS 64 after all.

My first desires were to do "bulk" submissions but the underlying message was "This game's not for you, Joe".

1 1 73177585 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 2 73177586 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 3 73177587 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 4 73177588 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 5 73177589 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 6 73177590 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 7 73177591 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 8 73177592 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 9 73177593 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 10 73177594 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 11 73177595 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 12 73177596 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 13 73177597 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 14 73177598 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 15 73177599 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 16 73177600 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 17 73177601 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 18 73177602 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 19 73177603 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 20 73177604 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 21 73177605 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 22 73177606 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 23 73177607 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 24 73177608 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 25 73177609 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 26 73177610 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 27 73177611 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 28 73177612 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 29 73177613 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 30 73177614 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 31 73177615 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 32 73177616 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 33 73177617 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 34 73177618 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 35 73177619 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 36 73177620 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 37 73177621 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 38 73177622 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 39 73177623 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 40 73177624 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 41 73177625 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 42 73177626 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 43 73177627 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 44 73177628 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 45 73177629 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 46 73177630 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 47 73177631 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 48 73177632 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 49 73177633 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 50 73177634 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 51 73177635 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 52 73177636 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 53 73177637 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 54 73177638 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 55 73177639 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 56 73177640 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 57 73177641 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 58 73177642 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 59 73177643 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 60 73177644 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 61 73177645 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 62 73177646 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 63 73177647 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 64 73177648 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 65 73177649 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 66 73177650 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 67 73177651 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 68 73177652 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 69 73177653 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 70 73177654 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 71 73177655 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 72 73177656 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 73 73177657 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 74 73177658 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 75 73177659 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 76 73177660 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 77 73177661 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 78 73177662 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 79 73177663 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 80 73177664 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 81 73177665 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 82 73177666 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 83 73177667 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 84 73177668 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 85 73177669 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 86 73177670 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 87 73177671 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 88 73177672 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 89 73177673 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 90 73177674 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 91 73177675 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 92 73177676 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 93 73177677 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 94 73177678 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 95 73177679 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 96 73177680 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 97 73177681 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 98 73177682 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 99 73177683 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 100 73177684 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0
1 101 73177685 50005 RETURN FOR RETURN N/A NG0

and now

Ten Years After

Like Alpha / Omega , here's my last.

1 1 30816679 9177 1924 $20 USA MS66
2 1 30816680 9186 1927 $20 USA MS64
3 1 30816681 9052 1907 $20 Liberty USA MS61
4 1 30816682 8991 1879-S $20 USA XF45
5 1 30816683 8760 1906-D $10 USA AU55
5 2 30816684 8760 1906-D $10 USA XF45
6 1 30816685 8709 1886-S $10 USA F15
7 1 30816686 8859 1908 $10 Motto USA AU58
8 1 30816687 8510 1908 $5 Indian USA Genuine - AU Details (95 - Scratch)
9 1 30816688 8520 1911 $5 USA AU55
10 1 30816689 8358 1882 $5 USA Genuine - AU Details (92 - Cleaned)
11 1 30816690 8382 1892-S $5 USA Genuine - AU Details (92 - Cleaned)
12 1 30816691 8406 1902-S $5 USA Genuine - AU Details (98 - Damage)
13 1 30816692 7767 1853 $2.50 USA VF30
14 1 30816693 7857 1905 $2.50 USA Genuine - UNC Details (92 - Cleaned)
15 1 30816694 7560 1862 G$1 USA Genuine - AU Details (95 - Scratch)
16 1 30816695 7524 1853-O G$1 USA Genuine - UNC Details (98 - Damage)
17 1 30816696 7939 1908 $2.50 USA XF45
18 1 30816697 7940 1909 $2.50 USA AU58
18 2 30816698 7940 1909 $2.50 USA AU53
19 1 30816699 7941 1910 $2.50 USA AU53
20 1 30816700 7942 1911 $2.50 USA AU58
21 1 30816701 7944 1912 $2.50 USA AU58
22 1 30816702 7945 1913 $2.50 USA Genuine - AU Details (92 - Cleaned)
23 1 30816703 7947 1914-D $2.50 USA MS61
24 1 30816704 7948 1915 $2.50 USA AU55
25 1 30816705 7949 1925-D $2.50 USA MS61
26 1 30816706 7950 1926 $2.50 USA Genuine - UNC Details (92 - Cleaned)
26 2 30816707 7950 1926 $2.50 USA AU58
27 1 30816708 7951 1927 $2.50 USA Genuine - UNC Details (92 - Cleaned)
28 1 30816709 7952 1928 $2.50 USA MS61
28 2 30816710 7952 1928 $2.50 USA MS63
29 1 30816711 7953 1929 $2.50 USA MS64
30 1 30816712 9822 1988 $25 Gold Eagle USA MS68

fivecents · December 8, 2014 4:23AM

Submitted in 2002:

Order #10027729 / Submission #42000
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 21125648 9744 1996-W $5 Smithsonian USA MS69
2 1 21125649 9792 2001-W $5 Capitol Visitor USA MS69
2 2 21125650 9792 2001-W $5 Capitol Visitor USA MS69
2 3 21125651 9792 2001-W $5 Capitol Visitor USA MS69
2 4 21125652 9792 2001-W $5 Capitol Visitor USA MS69
2 5 21125653 9792 2001-W $5 Capitol Visitor USA MS69
2 6 21125654 9792 2001-W $5 Capitol Visitor USA MS69
2 7 21125655 9792 2001-W $5 Capitol Visitor USA MS69
3 1 21125656 9745 1996-W $5 Smithsonian USA PR69DC
4 1 21125657 9742 1996-D $1 Smithsonian USA MS69
5 1 21125658 9785 2000-P $1 Leif Ericson USA MS69
5 2 21125659 9785 2000-P $1 Leif Ericson USA MS69
6 1 21125660 9798 2002-P $1 Olympics-SLC USA MS69

Oney · December 8, 2014 4:34AM

Submission in 2004, All coins submitted raw:
1 1 21774571 7264 1900 $1 USA MS64
2 1 21774572 7266 1900-O $1 USA MS66
3 1 21774573 7300 1921-S $1 USA MS64
4 1 21774574 7357 1922 $1 USA MS65
5 1 21774567 7092 1879-S $1 USA MS65
6 1 21774568 7134 1882-CC $1 USA MS64
7 1 21774569 7144 1883-CC $1 USA MS66
8 1 21774570 7152 1884-CC $1 USA MS64

LindeDad · December 8, 2014 4:46AM

First in 2009.
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 14135778 150430 2007-W $25 Gold Eagle USA MS70
2 1 14135779 152123 2007-W $10 Jefferson's Liberty USA PR70DC
3 1 14135780 395708 2008-W $10 Jackson's Liberty USA PR69DC
4 1 14135781 395710 2008-W $10 Van Buren's Liberty USA PR69DC

Bubblehead · December 8, 2014 5:50AM

Order #10081646 / Submission #3015666

Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 30022426 7134 1882-CC $1 USA MS63
1 2 30022427 7134 1882-CC $1 USA MS63
2 1 30022428 7144 1883-CC $1 USA MS64
2 2 30022429 7144 1883-CC $1 USA MS63
3 1 30022430 7152 1884-CC $1 USA MS63
3 2 30022431 7152 1884-CC $1 USA MS64

Total Items: 6
Date Received: 10/7/2002
Date Shipped: 10/25/2002
Order Status: Shipped

bosco5041 · December 8, 2014 6:00AM

bosco5041 · December 8, 2014 6:04AM

1 1 29394782 6950 1860-O $1 USA VF35
2 1 29394783 4564 1838-O 10C No Stars USA XF40
3 1 29394784 5314 1806 25C USA VG10
4 1 29394785 5525 1891-O 25C USA VF35
5 1 29394786 5515 1883 25C USA AU58
6 1 29394787 5313 1805 25C USA F15
7 1 29394788 6148 1828 50C Curl 2, No Knob USA AU50
8 1 29394789 5474 1869 25C USA XF40

BigMoose · December 8, 2014 6:24AM

order #20513079 submission #4452378

BillJones · December 8, 2014 7:02AM

My very first submission was via JJ Teaparty back in the late 1980s. Back then you had to submit your coins through a dealer. Part of the idea was that the dealer could screen the coins before they were submitted to filter out any body bags and resulting hard feelings.

This was back in the "rattler age" when the grading was overly conservative. It was all gold coins, and this is as much as I can remember. I will guarantee you that every one of these pieces has been cracked out by now. I know at least three of them were because I cracked them myself and resubmitted them.

$5 Liberty, came back as an MS-64. I thought that it should have gotten an MS-65. I later traded this coin in a deal for a 1794 half dime in AU-50 when gold was hot and the half dime was not. I'll bet you it is in an MS-65 holder now.

1909 $5 Indian came back as an AU-58. I cracked it out and later got it into an MS-63 holder which was closer to the truth.

1901 $10 Liberty came back as an MS-64. I cracked it out and later got it into an MS-65 holder.

1913 $10 Indian came back as an MS-62. I cracked it out and later got it into an MS-63 holder.

darktone · December 8, 2014 7:50AM

My first submission was to ANACS in the 1980's. I actually got much better grades than I hoped for. My next submission did not go so well.

jdimmick · December 8, 2014 8:18AM

Order #10177621 / Submission #3136797

Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 21431263 2426 1909-S VDB 1C USA XF40BN

Total Items: 1
Date Received: 12/8/2003
Date Shipped: 1/9/2004
Order Status: Shipped
Share Order

This is the first listed. Looks to have been a cc freebie

TennesseeDave · December 8, 2014 8:39AM

Order #20086694 / Submission #3602205
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 03973647 7365 1925 $1 USA MS63
2 1 03973648 7130 1881-S $1 USA MS65
3 1 03973649 7240 1896 $1 USA MS64
4 1 03973650 7118 1880-S $1 USA MS65
5 1 03973651 7166 1886 $1 USA MS64
6 1 03973652 7166 1886 $1 USA MS64
7 1 03973653 7168 1886-O $1 USA AU58
Total Items: 7
Date Received: 2/19/2007
Date Shipped: 3/8/2007
Order Status: Shipped

Goldbully · December 8, 2014 8:46AM

Casman · December 8, 2014 8:48AM

Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 10993950 89991 2006-W $1 Silver Eagle-20th Anniversary USA MS68
2 1 10993951 89993 2006-W $50 Gold Eagle-20th Anniversary USA MS69

JerseyJoe · December 8, 2014 9:32AM

dragon · December 9, 2014 4:21AM

Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 21007187 7092 1879-S $1 USA MS67
2 1 21007188 97127 1881-CC $1 USA MS64DM
3 1 21007189 7144 1883-CC $1 USA MS67
4 1 21007190 87328 1893 $1 USA PR63CA

Total Items: 4
Date Received: 11/6/2001
Date Shipped: 11/15/2001
Order Status: Shipped
Share Order

puffer · December 9, 2014 4:35AM

I like record keeping that can go back indefinitely. I guess the government has an advantage in that regard, as theoretically they can go back as far as they want to. Since I have nothing to hide, records are on my side and I have almost total recall.

My first submission was through the ANA since the local coin shop refused to do submissions for customers--bad for their business or so they said.

A 1932 quarter graded MS65 that I paid $30 for, toning was ugly but after light dipping it was nice. An "O" mint $20 graded much higher at NGC that had been PCGS AU50 old holder.

One of the first obstacles to get past with sending off valuables in the anxiety of feared loss. Even with insurance there is fear. Many people still do not have enough trust to send off valuable coins for grading with possible loss or theft.

123cents · December 9, 2014 5:02AM

Order #20144423 / Submission #3739175
Line # Item # Cert # PCGS No. CoinDate Denomination Variety Country Grade
1 1 12251194 39413 1810 50C USA XF40
2 1 12251195 39645 1824/4 50C USA XF40
3 1 12251196 39827 1830 50C Small 0 USA AU58
4 1 12251197 39620 1823 50C Broken 3 USA F15
5 1 12251198 39646 1824 50C Over Various Dates USA XF40
6 1 12251199 39833 1830 50C Large 0 USA XF40
7 1 12251200 6103 1813 50C USA DNC
8 1 12251201 39964 1836 50C 50/00, Lettered Edge USA VF20
Total Items: 8
Date Received: 12/4/2007
Date Shipped: 2/6/2008
Order Status: Shipped
Share Order

Post your first submission results

Comments

Leave a Comment