Options
Is it possible for some athletes to choke under big time pressure ?
1970s
Posts: 3,093 ✭✭✭✭✭
in Sports Talk
Looks like Clayton Kershaw just melts down in the post-season.
Is there any other player you remember in any sport that has uncharacteristically bad performances in the post season like Kershaw ?
In hockey I can think of Rick Nash. The guy is horrible in the post season.
Is there any other player you remember in any sport that has uncharacteristically bad performances in the post season like Kershaw ?
In hockey I can think of Rick Nash. The guy is horrible in the post season.
0
Comments
<< <i>Is there any other player you remember in any sport that has uncharacteristically bad performances in the post season like Kershaw ? >>
No, but I can certainly think of a manager, and it is killing me because I am a huge fan. What a disaster.
Collecting 1970s Topps baseball wax, rack and cello packs, as well as PCGS graded Half Cents, Large Cents, Two Cent pieces and Three Cent Silver pieces.
<< <i>
<< <i>Need a much larger sample size before drawing a conclusion about Kershaw. Players almost always revert to their career mean if given enough opportunities. These guys wouldn't be at the major league level in the first place if they couldn't handle pressure. >>
I've heard this before, but may I ask why a larger sample size is needed ?
If you look at Kershaw's regular season W-L's, he wins every 2 out of 3 games.
Put those numbers in the post season and he should be 4-2 now with a 2 something era.
In my opinion, as of now, Kershaw is a choker in the postseason, but he still has time to change that fact.
2013 Kershaw was 16-9 with a 1.83 era in the regular season. Post-season he was horrible.
2014 Kershaw was 21-3 with a 1.77 era. Post-season has begun as another disaster.
Is it safe to say that as of now Kershaw chokes in the post-season, but he still has a long time to redeem himself ? >>
Jack Morris is almost universally considered a "clutch" postseason pitcher due to his outstanding performance in the 1991 postseason, but when you look at his entire record in the postseason, you see his career postseason ERA is actually 3.80, or 1/10 of a run below his career ERA of 3.90.
Barry Bonds was considered an abject failure in the postseason till 2002, when he hit .470 with 4 HRs and a .700 OBP% in the World Series.
Collecting 1970s Topps baseball wax, rack and cello packs, as well as PCGS graded Half Cents, Large Cents, Two Cent pieces and Three Cent Silver pieces.
<< <i>You're most likely right Grote.
However, Rick Nash is just about a point per game guy in the NHL regular season.
In the post-season he has played 41 games with only 18 points. One could argue that in the post-season the competition gets much
tougher.
Perhaps Kershaw is just suffering from facing tougher opponents in the post-season, especially the Cardinals, where Kershaw has a 3.40
era against them lifetime. >>
That is a valid point~the competition in the postseason is obviously at a higher level than the regular season where Kershaw doesn't get to feast upon sub .500 teams. Still, for a pitcher of his talent, given enough opportunities, I believe he will at least resemble the dominant pitcher he is. I would be shocked if he doesn't pitch very well in Game 4.
Collecting 1970s Topps baseball wax, rack and cello packs, as well as PCGS graded Half Cents, Large Cents, Two Cent pieces and Three Cent Silver pieces.
I will say this, however. A portion of the blame needs to be extracted from Kershaw and transformed into credit for St. Louis. If any team can put aside insurmountable odds and overcome, it's the Cardinals. Lest we forget they were a strike away from defeat in Game 6 of the WS back in '11, yet ultimately won a championship. The very next season they were down 6-0 in the 3rd inning of Game 5 of the NLDS. When the 9th inning rolled around, they were down to their final strike five times against the Nationals. When the next series got underway, it was St. Louis playing and not Washington.
And for the record, I'm not a Cards fan. I'm just a baseball junkie who can appreciate an organization that has perfected the art of cultivating a winning atmosphere.
<< <i>Barry Bonds was considered an abject failure in the postseason till 2002, when he hit .470 with 4 HRs and a .700 OBP% in the World Series. >>
This is exactly who came to mind for me too. Although maybe Kershaw needs to add a little something to his diet to be more successful!?
I would not yet conclude that Kershaw is a choker in the post season. Hopefully he'll have about 4 more starts this post season to prove this theory wrong.
<< <i>I will say this, however. A portion of the blame needs to be extracted from Kershaw and transformed into credit for St. Louis. If any team can put aside insurmountable odds and overcome, it's the Cardinals. Lest we forget they were a strike away from defeat in Game 6 of the WS back in '11, yet ultimately won a championship. The very next season they were down 6-0 in the 3rd inning of Game 5 of the NLDS. When the 9th inning rolled around, they were down to their final strike five times against the Nationals. When the next series got underway, it was St. Louis playing and not Washington. >>
I agree. The St. Louis Cardinals are an incredible organization.
<< <i>
<< <i>I will say this, however. A portion of the blame needs to be extracted from Kershaw and transformed into credit for St. Louis. If any team can put aside insurmountable odds and overcome, it's the Cardinals. Lest we forget they were a strike away from defeat in Game 6 of the WS back in '11, yet ultimately won a championship. The very next season they were down 6-0 in the 3rd inning of Game 5 of the NLDS. When the 9th inning rolled around, they were down to their final strike five times against the Nationals. When the next series got underway, it was St. Louis playing and not Washington. >>
I agree. The St. Louis Cardinals are an incredible organization. >>
They are the NL version of the Yankees, Mike..
Collecting 1970s Topps baseball wax, rack and cello packs, as well as PCGS graded Half Cents, Large Cents, Two Cent pieces and Three Cent Silver pieces.
<< <i>They are the NL version of the Yankees, Mike.. >>
I just told my wife that very same thing only one hour ago. Unfortunately, she does not find these postseason games as exciting as I do. She just left for Walmart to purchase some Halloween decorations.
<< <i>
<< <i>They are the NL version of the Yankees, Mike.. >>
I just told my wife that very same thing only one hour ago. Unfortunately, she does not find these postseason games as exciting as I do. She just left for Walmart to purchase some Halloween decorations. >>
Collecting 1970s Topps baseball wax, rack and cello packs, as well as PCGS graded Half Cents, Large Cents, Two Cent pieces and Three Cent Silver pieces.
Lafayette Grading Set
<< <i>Buffalo Bills lose in the Super Bowl 4 times. Do they need 2 more tries in order to call it a choke? >>
So the whole team collectively could not take the pressure of the SB? Cmon.
I remember the University of Minnesota in one of the bowl games about 6 or 7 years ago had a 30+ point lead against Texas Tech in the second half. Sure enough Graham Harrell got on a roll in the second half and Minnesota couldn't seem to tackle anybody. They were taking the wrong angles, guys out of position, not wrapping up, all the classic things to give up big plays. The Gophers could have run a prevent defense the whole 2nd half and still won that game, but no, they wanted to miss tackles and let a 7 yard play turn into a 30 yard play. Harrell just waited till the defense started playing tighter coverage and then hit them on deeper routes.
I also remember a Monday night game between the Jets and Dolphins, it was a while ago maybe 12 years or something. Vinny Testaverde was quarterbacking the Jets and they were down 30-7 going into the 4th quarter. Normally the Jets that year would have just went through the motions and called it a night, but this was the Dolphins and it was a rivalry game for the Jets. So they just attacked the Dolphins relentlessly in that 4th quarter, you kept expecting the Dolphins defense to eventually make a play, I mean Testaverde had made some bad throws late in games before. And that was the problem, the Dolphins kept playing not to lose instead of staying aggressive and sure enough Vinny with his strong arm began zipping balls past defenders throwing it where only his guys could catch it. I remember at the end of he 3rd quarter the fans were booing pretty loud and the announcers started talking about next weeks game and trying to take attention away from all the fans filing out of the stadium. However two scores later they started coming back in and the boos changed to cheers as all of sudden this game became a really big deal. The Dolphins began trying to hard on offense trying to make plays that weren't there and getting away from the match-ups they had success with in the first half. zach Thomas was one of the leaders on that Dolphin's defense and he was a tackling machine. He should got everyone together and made sure they were on the same page as to how they were going to slow down that Jets offense. But ultimately they blew the lead and the game and that loss took more than a couple weeks to get over I can tell you that. It looked like Wayne Chrebet could not be covered out there, he was just running around like a little rocket darting this way and that finding the soft spots in the defense. And once he catches it, its like trying to tackle one of those scat backs on punt returns. Chrebet didn't have great straight line speed, but he could stop and change direction with the best of them. I would say the Dolphins did more than struggle in the 4th quarter that Monday night.
Family, Neighborhood, Community,
make the World a better place.
<< <i>Buffalo Bills lose in the Super Bowl 4 times. Do they need 2 more tries in order to call it a choke? >>
Personally, I think winning the AFC conference championship four straight seasons and reaching the Super Bowl four straight years is a tremendous feat in itself..
Collecting 1970s Topps baseball wax, rack and cello packs, as well as PCGS graded Half Cents, Large Cents, Two Cent pieces and Three Cent Silver pieces.
<< <i>Personally, I think winning the AFC conference championship four straight seasons and reaching the Super Bowl four straight years is a tremendous feat in itself.. >>
You must be a New York Jets fan.
Just about every time the Yankees needed him to hit or team hit...he struck out or popped up.
Just horrible to watch
1948-76 Topps FB Sets
FB & BB HOF Player sets
1948-1993 NY Yankee Team Sets
<< <i>AROD or Achoke
Just about every time the Yankees needed him to hit or team hit...he struck out or popped up.
Just horrible to watch >>
When compared to their own average, who has hit better in their career with men on base, Jeter or ARod? Surprise......ARod has. How about "late & close" situations? They're tied. How about high leverage situations? ARod. Playoffs? Jeter.
Basically what I'm saying is, ARod isn't nearly the choker that people think he is, and Jeter isn't exactly "Captain Clutch".
<< <i>I am shocked to see MLB Fan 2 hijack a thread about athletes choking under big-time pressure in order to bash Derek Jeter. >>
To be fair, I'm bashing the Jeter overraters, not Jeter himself.
<< <i>To be fair, I'm bashing the Jeter overraters, not Jeter himself. >>
Fair enough.
If you love baseball, watching STL play is a beautiful thing to behold. An intrepid bunch, year in and year out.
<< <i>If you love baseball, watching STL play is a beautiful thing to behold. >>
I totally agree.
<< <i>
<< <i>If you love baseball, watching STL play is a beautiful thing to behold. >>
I totally agree. >>
True. Should be a good series with the Giants.
As for Kershaw he pitched great... for 6. If the game only ended there. Right now I have to 1970s is right and Kershaw is a choker. Hopefully next year he can come back strong.
That said, I don't think Kershaw is a choker. He was money for them throughout the season. For some reason the Cards seem to be able to get him off his game though.
If anyone choked in the NLDS it was Yasiel Puig. 8 strikeouts, whined like a baby after each one, beat up his bat...I don't blame Mattingly for pulling him from the Game 4 lineup. He certainly wasn't helping the team. First smart managerial move Mattingly did in the whole series.
RIP Mom- 1932-2012
Family, Neighborhood, Community,
make the World a better place.
Many sports stars have said that being relaxed during competition makes them better, I am sure some get tense during a critical moment and their performance suffers.