2,000 Post Giveaway — Lets Play Lowball Golf! **WINNERS ANNOUNCED**
When I first joined this forum back in 2004, I had just been accepted into the inaugural class of the U.S. Mint’s Artistic Infusion Program. I believed that by anonymously conversing with active numismatists that I could covertly better understand what America wants for its modern coinage. For the two years I was in the program, I did gain such insights, but I also gained a lot more.
I began collecting coins as kid in the 1980s, and like many I stopped about when I discovered Rock N’ Roll and girls... (and come to think of it, Rock N' Roll girls). Something I did not have in the 1980s, was the ability to converse with and learn from other collectors - this advent only seems to have been made possibly by computers. For me, this level of engagement reawakened my love of coins, and led me to start collecting again.
Another thing I did not expect to find in coming here, is how many luminary numismatists would be present to just strike up casual conversations with! As a kid, I remember looking at the line for the 1913 Liberty Nickel, and seeing the words “Eliasburg Sale, $200,000.00”, and it made me wonder who Eliasburg was and what it would be like to talk to him? Well, here, at least when I was most active, getting to talk coins with such modern-day Eliasburg-level authorities happened everyday.
When my collection was stolen from my house last month, I came back here for the purpose of forwarding my inventory onto the coin community in hopes that someone, somewhere, my find something. What I ended up getting by doing so, was a lot of support that really helped me. Thank you. It reminded me of why I liked collecting in the first place, and it played a part in my decision not let my collection end in broken window leading out to the night sky, but to restore it as best I can.
And so now that I am back, I find that I am on the verge of 2,000 posts! And I’d to like to do a giveaway!
Out of all my coins that were stolen, one that I oddly find myself missing most, was my 1834 Half Eagle in PCGS FR2. In honor of this coin, lets play a game — I call it Low Ball Golf.
Here are the rules:
Post a lowball gold U.S. coin. It can be yours. It can be from a registry set. It can be from an active or closed auction. It can even be for sale right now. All coins must be certified by our host, or by one of the 2 other most respected companies with numerical grades (no details grades). Points will be given on the following basis:
AG3 = 3 Points
FR2 = 2 Points
PO1 = 1 Point
St. Gaudens $20, Indian Head or Coronet Gold = 4 Points
Classic Head, $3 Gold or $1 Gold = 3 Points
Pre-1834 Gold or Classic Gold Commem = 2 Points
Modern Commem or American Gold Eagle = 1 Point
Lowest score wins! Ties will be decided by whichever competing coin has the lowest mintage. Entires accepted until midnight Sunday, PCT.
1st Prize will be another homage to my collection. Since childhood, I stored my collection in a 1930s green-painted, steel-strong coin roll tray labeled “Dimes - $150.00”. An antique-loving neighbor lady had it, and she agreed to trade it to me for babysitting her child. A couple weeks ago when I decided to collect again, one of my first aims was to find another such tray. Long story short, I came across a few old Steel Strong Coin Trays of different colors and denominations for sale and I bought them, but sadly the green Dime denomination remained elusive. Then I noticed a seller on Ebay who had several Steel Strong brand items listed, and so I contacted them. It turned out, that this person had bought the remains of the Steel Strong company several years ago, and had been slowly liquidating its contents on Ebay over the years — and is it happened, they had exactly 1, NOS, pre-1941 green-painted dime tray that they then sold me. Obviously, I am not going to give away my unique dime tray, but I will give away an orange-painted Quarter tray that I acquired during my hunt - take a look!
These trays are great for housing a coin collection, because they are the exact dimension of a slab laid on its side. Box of 20? How about antique, actually bank-used, might have once held rolls of freshly-minted 1932-S Washington Quarters, Steel Strong coin roll tray of 20!
2nd Prize - the runner up will receive a 2005 Mint Set.
Both prizes will be shipped at my expense.
Good luck!
Fore!!
Comments
Ok, I'll play, although I know there are coins out there that will beat this, especially if you can just pull from auctions or random registry sets. However, this is the lowest-graded gold coin I've actually owned. Very tough S-mint $5 with low CAC population:
Not my coin but this is currently on ebay for $1,500 OBO
https://m.ebay.com/itm/1883-10-Gold-Liberty-PO01-PCGS/311983974308?hash=item48a3b1a7a4:g:zEwAAOSwk-1aAeju
Not my coin but a PO-1
Successful transactions with : MICHAELDIXON, Manorcourtman, Bochiman, bolivarshagnasty, AUandAG, onlyroosies, chumley, Weiss, jdimmick, BAJJERFAN, gene1978, TJM965, Smittys, GRANDAM, JTHawaii, mainejoe, softparade, derryb
Bad transactions with : nobody to date
All right, I give in. If we are just going to post images from anywhere, I submit this one:
This is from another thread from three years ago by @ianrussell. I think it may have even been auctioned subsequently on GreatCollections, IIRC: Very Cool "Worst" U.S. Gold Type Set in Capital Plastic Holder
Successful transactions with : MICHAELDIXON, Manorcourtman, Bochiman, bolivarshagnasty, AUandAG, onlyroosies, chumley, Weiss, jdimmick, BAJJERFAN, gene1978, TJM965, Smittys, GRANDAM, JTHawaii, mainejoe, softparade, derryb
Bad transactions with : nobody to date
That is definitely poor!
That gold type set is amazing!
>>>My Collection
Not my coin. But I thought it was funny with CAC approved. Does it mean it was under graded ? lol
https://www.ebay.com/itm/1836-Block8-Classic-Head-Gold-Quarter-Eagle-2-5-PCGS-PO01-CAC-Lowball-Poor-POP1/281701210330?hash=item4196b358da:g:Vh0AAOSwNSxVYUbf
And the winner is... TurboSnail with his snipe-entry, an 1836 Classic Head Quarter Eagle in PO1, which earns an impressive score of 4!
For the runner up, we have a 2-way tie:
MorganMan with an 1883 Eagle in PO1: 5 Points
Jwitten with a glorious 1804/3 Half Eagle in AG3: 5 Points
1630Boston with a Quarter Eagle in PO1... which would earn 5 points as well, except the date is not legible, and we cannot see the slab, so I don't think we can accept this entry - sorry 1630Boston!
So for the 2 contenders, we now look to the mintages:
1883 Eagle: 208,700
1804/3 Half Eagle: 30,475
jwitten, you are the runner up!
HONORABLE MENTION:
mvs7, that gold type set is spectacular - I would love to find a $3.00 gold that looks like that for my own collection. Alas, none of the coins are certified, and so they do not conform to the rules of this contest, but because this set is just so cool, I will award a special Honorable Mention prize - I will send you a 2005 mint set as well.
TurboSnail, Jwitten, and mvs7, please PM me your addresses and I will send you your prizes.
Thank you all for playing!
>>>My Collection
congrats, I tried to find lower but lets face it cant get lower than 1
Best place to buy !
Bronze Associate member
@Artist
Fun contest, thanks for hosting it
Congrats to the winners
Successful transactions with : MICHAELDIXON, Manorcourtman, Bochiman, bolivarshagnasty, AUandAG, onlyroosies, chumley, Weiss, jdimmick, BAJJERFAN, gene1978, TJM965, Smittys, GRANDAM, JTHawaii, mainejoe, softparade, derryb
Bad transactions with : nobody to date
Thanks for running this giveaway @Artist and for the honorable mention! Even without the giveaway, I enjoyed your OP and the various lowball coins people were able to track down .
I know I'm late but I do like lowball gold
Lafayette Grading Set
That is pretty epic!
>>>My Collection
No gold to post, but glad to hear that you are back in the game.
I’m in
Best place to buy !
Bronze Associate member
One of my all-time favorite coins... never thought I'd see a lowball. Thanks for sharing! What's the reverse look like?