Options
QT or NT
TPRC
Posts: 3,819 ✭✭✭✭✭
I posted these pics elsewhere, but it got no traction. Is the Peace Dollar clearly QT/AT, and why? I think the Morgan is NT and it slabbed.
Next, a good buy and a mistake, probably. Both are toned dollars-one a Morgan and one a Peace. I graded the Morgan as a 64 and the Peace Dollar as a 63/4, but I was a little uncertain on the toning of the Peace Dollar, while knowing that if it graded, it was worth more for the toning. It came back QT, which is disappointing, and which I am not sure I agree with. I still kinda believe in this coin. However, I can't say I was unaware of the risk. What do you think--QT? The other dollar-the 64 Morgan was a good buy.


Tom
0
Comments
The 'thumb print' on the reverse of the Peace dollar tried to make it look authentic, but your not going to fool the graders who see thousands of these annually. That and I think the Morgan is 'fugly'
"Keep your malarkey filter in good operating order" -Walter Breen
NT, looks like a normal lightly circulated half with original surfaces.
I agree that the thumbprint may indicate it's NT. Thumbprints never bothered me, though I know they affect price in a big way and that people hate them. The spot on the neck bothered me. It also may have a tooling mark at 12 o'clock and at 6 o'clock on the rim, but I'm not sure.
I have had a high success rate (about 75%) resubmitting a previously body bagged coin at PCGS for a straight grade, when I believe the coin should be straight graded. But I have little experience with toned coins and I'm not sure I "believe" in this coin.
The Morgan is not the prettiest, particularly the obverse, but it has some nice color.
Tom
Shady, sorry, that was an earlier edit....I had problems with posting these pics and inadvertently posted a half as well. And that half is in a 55 holder and is fully original.
Tom
That Peace Dollar is pretty good looking.
If the toning on the Peace Dollar were on a Morgan, it would be more likely to slab. As a rule, rainbow hued Peace dollars have to pass more stringent quality control. The Morgan looks very NT. The Peace dollar I have no idea but would lean towards "questionable." Where are the variations in color on the deep recesses of the coin?
I like the mottled and vibrant toning on that 1882 Morgan. No doubt I'm in the minority.
From my observations, Peace dollars that are naturally toned are 'splotchy' in coloring (if that is even a numismatic term). This is what I feel looks like NT for a Peace:

The Morgan looks NT to me and while I don't love it, I like it.
I agree with the graders here.
In my opinion, the Morgan is clearly NT (and nice looking IMO), while the Peace is clearly AT.
I like Morgans toned like that.
The Peace is borderline questionable IMO.
The peace looks MA. .The Morgan is fugly and questionable.
The reverse of the Peace is what really makes me lean towards questionable toning.
I actually like the Peace Dollar but I suspect it's AT.
The Morgan I don't like but I do think it's NT.
Not a fan of either.
Thanks to all. Well, that is as clear as mud, except to say "when in doubt, walk away!"
Tom
I've run across several seemingly non-splotchy PCGS peace dollars recently. How do the following look?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1923-Peace-Silver-Dollar-PCGS-MS62-Rainbow-Toning-Color-TONE/192103916481
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1926-Peace-Dollar-PCGS-AU58-MONSTER-RAINBOW-TONING-/401313589117
http://www.ebay.com/itm/1922-Peace-Dollar-PCGS-MS62-MONSTER-RAINBOW-TONING-/401313589140
The Morgan is NT and I really like, but I would not buy the Peace.
@basetsb_coins on Instagram
I do not like the Morgan (surprise) and the Peace is, IMO, AT.... Cheers, RickO
I am in the AT Peace dollar crowd.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
The peace dollar is on the line of MA. Some graders may slab it others may not. Its tough to get a Peace with any modicum of color to slab so don't feel too bad. I would try one or two more times then give up if it doesn't slab.
I would say that the 1923 could be NT as the reverse fits my definition of 'splotchy'. but you can also get that look from about three months of taco bell napkin exposure. I would not be interested in the 26 or the 22. To me it looks like exposure to gas ala edynamic marketing. Seems interesting how so many of the toners are on MS 62-63 coins. These are just my opinions and what I follow when I buy.
I got bagged for QC because of the reverse on this 1928 Peace $:

Apparently Peace $$ do face a higher standard than Morgans regarding toning.
Whatever.
OINK