Options
For die-polish fans (or post your most die polished coin...)
TequilaDave
Posts: 271 ✭✭✭
I dunno, maybe it's just me, but I really like the whole heavy die polish look on coins. This one, a 1953 un decimo de balboa (presumably minted in the US?) has a particularly heavily polished obverse.
5
Comments
Good heavens! I wonder which of the U.S. Mints struck that piece?
Umm. I'm a huge fan of "scrubbed dies"
Here's a couple at hand
Not my coin unfortunately, saw this on eBay, it was buy it now but I was at work and was having connection issues and couldn't purchase it, sold before I could get a connection.
Here's an interesting steel Lincoln. Unlike typical die polish, this over achiever polished into the devices. I wonder what the chances are a TPG would interrupt this as "improperly cleaned"?
Can't say I'm a big fan of die polished coins, for the reason already alluded to: They look harshly cleaned from afar!!
Not that some die polish isn't interesting. It's just distracting.
(Of course, I think wild colors are often distracting too....But the rest of the coin world doesn't seem to pay me any mind.
)
How about this specimen 1982 West African States 5000 CFA in gold?
Well, just Love coins, period.
I tend to not like DPLs so most of my coins don't have them. This one shows quite a bit on the reverse. On this coin they don't bother me so much:
I can understand why some experts recommend avoiding coins with heavy die polish lines but I find them very attractive. It is gratifying to know I'm not alone!
Love this thread and I hope folks keep posting more!
Your 1878-S dollar appears to have a partially sunken obverse die.
When do "polishing lines" become "die scratches" become "file lines" become "defaced die?"
That's a great question! I hope someone smarter than me can answer it.
Die file lines are just a thicker version of die polishing lines and die scratches are typically singular or a random spread out patch of singular scratches. A defaced die is just that a die that has had most or all of its devices stripped away. I get your point though Roger lol.
I think this one is pretty cool but probably not my most polished.
I'd call that "die scratched."
Awesome!!
"If I say something in the woods and my wife isn't there to hear it.....am I still wrong?"
My Washington Quarter Registry set...in progress
It seems the first couple years of Morgans had these. Tom Bush photography.
Blue62vette, that is a great coin! Love it!! As my teenager would say "that's sick"
Do brillo pads caused raised or recessed lines? I'd hate to think this can be faked for added value too.
While the obverse has a good deal of polish, take a good look at the reverse! Some serious scrubbing there!
There's no way to effectively mimic this look that will fool an expert. When you use a brillo pad or anything else it pushes the metal around. The lines on true die polishing are on the die and transferred directly to the planchet during the strike. If these become popular enough in the future and start garnering huge premiums I'm sure doctors will start putting time into doing a good enough job to fool novices however.
- Bob -
MPL's - Lincolns of Color
Central Valley Roosevelts
I hope a dremmel tool also leaves tail-tell signs of skullduggery.
Yes. Any external force pushes metal to create the lines and that metal being pushed is a dead giveaway. You can't fake a polished die that wil fool anything above a novice.
PCGS called it PL.
Here's a couple more..
A run of the mill...change at CostCo.
Lance.
Wow, that is intense!! It almost looks like someone laid fiberboard over the die and pressed it in.
oops
http://www.pcgs.com/SetRegistry/publishedset.aspx?s=142753
https://www.autismforums.com/media/albums/acrylic-colors-by-rocco.291/
I admit I'm not a fan of heavy die polish.
I think it detracts from the coin and in some cases can lessen the assigned grade.
I'm a huge fan, and even moreso after seeing these amazing pictures. You ladies and gents are awesome!
Right up my alley. Check out the spot behind Jefferson's eye.
That 41-S Winged Liberty tho..
Awe yeah.
I would guess San Francisco. Lot of the coins from the early 50's come heavily die polished from the San Francisco mint.
This is an awesome thread!! I love heavy die polish like these.
I do not care for die polish coins... If, however, I found one in change, I would keep it as a specimen... Some of those shown in this thread are amazing though... I have never seen such heavily die polished coins as some of these.... Yes, I would certainly keep those.... I just would not want one of my 'special' coins to look like that. Cheers, RickO
Most of this was done by a careless worker with an emery stick. (San Francisco preferred to use lime at least until about 1890.)
I like a "tasteful" amount of polishing and how it affects the luster.
Makes a unique look.
"If I say something in the woods and my wife isn't there to hear it.....am I still wrong?"
My Washington Quarter Registry set...in progress
AmazonX's 1948-S nickel wins the contest!
It also can act like a fingerprint if your coin is ever stolen and broken out / resubmitted. Toning can be dipped away but die polish lines are not going anywhere (unless you're a thief willing to change an MS coin into a VG/F coin)
Reverse of a 1924P Mercury Dime.
I finally did some more peeking at 1983 cent rolls I put away and it sure was a tough year for die abuse.
Quite a few times I would be looking at one side and think it might grade high and then flip it over and see something like this:
Successful BST deals with mustangt and jesbroken. Now EVERYTHING is for sale.
Not really. Its just an indication of a specific die stage of a specific die pairing. Although I get what you're saying. If you go to a local pawn shop a month later and see that same coin in the same die stage you would be looking at every other coin they recently purchased.
Great thread!
My YouTube Channel
Under the flag and under the motto.
“I may not believe in myself but I believe in what I’m doing” ~Jimmy Page~
My Full Walker Registry Set (1916-1947)
https://www.ngccoin.com/registry/competitive-sets/16292/
I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that coin did not leave the mint looking like that....
Is the yellow pennie brass?