Which one should I ship out to our Host? Warning: big pictures

joeykoins

Here is one more photo of the toned obverse
I'm in a pickle, I only want to send one of my 1957 "B Reverse" quarters. but which one? Is it the beautiful toned or is it the beautiful lustered one? Please help me decide, thanks guy's. -joey

ModCrewman

I'd send the toned and get the TrueView...but that's just me.

grip

Easy for me.The lustered one. I love toned coins just not that one.

joeykoins

Thanks, I too am split between the two. I am leaning towards the "lustered" one. I think, maybe, I don't know!!!

kenwright396

lustered one for me, no debate

johnny9434

either one for me. the reverse is a tad to toned for me but just the same

morgandollar1878

Send in the bright white example. It also has the double die reverse, check the inside lower loop of the "O" and above the top of the "O".

Coinlearner

Send the one that more closely match the other coins in your collection...

justcollecting

Send the toned one send me the other.

SanctionII

Send in both to relieve your indecision.

AMRC

Buy a third one that is already attributed. It will probably be cheaper.

joeykoins

@AMRC said:
Buy a third one that is already attributed. It will probably be cheaper.

Thanks guys for all your suggestions but I think this one might be best?

joeykoins

@morgandollar1878 said:
Send in the bright white example. It also has the double die reverse, check the inside lower loop of the "O" and above the top of the "O".

Maybe doubled?

joeykoins

a

rainbowroosie

Which will grade higher?

1630Boston

Really, truly no offense but I would not send either.

1630Boston

PS: Unless you want to. That's all that matters is what you want to do.

ricko

If you are determined to send one, send the lustrous coin.... Cheers, RickO

DollarAfterDollar

Either way the coins are of less value than the grading fees. If you were matching it to something then I'd consider sending it in but otherwise (unless one grades MS 67) you're just losing money.

Obverse toning is always more desirable if that's a consideration.

Type2

I would send in the top one or you can do a two coin holder with end roll toning out that will be kind of cool.

mannie gray

Hard to tell....are the coins

1. Obv end roller, white reverse...coin #2 White obverse, end-roller rev?

Or....am I confused?.......well, more than usual anyway.......ltys (instead of "lol"....laugh to yourself silently)....

mannie gray

Wow, don't know why the font went jumbo on me there.....

joeykoins

@mannie gray said:
Hard to tell....are the coins

1. Obv end roller, white reverse...coin #2 White obverse, end-roller rev?

Or....am I confused?.......well, more than usual anyway.......ltys (instead of "lol"....laugh to yourself silently)....

You know what? The way I took the picture can be confusing. They're both 1957 B Reverses but side by side, I shot one toned obverse then next to it, I shot the untoned reverse. Then, visa versa. Sorry about that!

davewesen

I am not sure if you are familiar with the website devoted to type-B's - here is the address

washingtontype-b.com/

mannie gray

OK, so one coin is completely toned and one is blast white.
If I were to choose one, I think the white coin would grade higher.