Goodacre Sac Dollar

Trogi

I sent my Goodacre Sac dollar in for a crossover from the ICG numbered holder that all of them came in. PCGS sent it back saying they don't cross them. Since all of these dollars originated in the ICG holders how does one cross them? I bought it from Goodacre's studio 15 year ago. Kind of confused.

RB1026

You've got me on that one. Once upon a time I owned an MS67 Goodacre that was in PCGS plastic. The seller sent me that coin, as well as the ICG label from the previous slab. I can't provide any additional details BUT I do know first hand this info FWIW. Good luck to you.



BTW....those are really good looking coins

CaptHenway

Collect the coin, not the plastic.

ricko

Did they give a reason? If not, crack it and send it raw....Cheers, RickO

cmerlo1

Originally posted by: CaptHenway
Collect the coin, not the plastic.

Baley

Originally posted by: Trogi

Since all of these dollars originated in the ICG holders how does one cross them? I bought it from Goodacre's studio 15 year ago. Kind of confused.

My question is: WHY cross them?



I'm kind of confused, too.

fivecents

I would leave it in the ICG holder. That is the holder that Ms Goodacre originally had the run of coins submitted to. Kind of historic. imho

AUandAG

Cracking one out of the original ICG holder and getting it in a PCGS holder is akin to cracking

a CC GSA out of it's holder and putting it in a regular PCGS holder......just don't.





bob

cardinal

The PCGS Crossover page clearly says you can "SUBMIT Your NGC, ANACS or ICG coins for PCGS Crossover."

So, maybe there was some other issue with your submission?

oih82w8

Originally posted by: fivecents

I would leave it in the ICG holder. That is the holder that Ms Goodacre originally had the run of coins submitted to. Kind of historic. imho

X2.

LindeDad

Originally posted by: cardinal

The PCGS Crossover page clearly says you can "SUBMIT Your NGC, ANACS or ICG coins for PCGS Crossover."



So, maybe there was some other issue with your submission?

I have one in a PCGS slab so I know it has been done in the past.

DIMEMAN

Originally posted by: oih82w8

Originally posted by: fivecents
I would leave it in the ICG holder. That is the holder that Ms Goodacre originally had the run of coins submitted to. Kind of historic. imho

X2.

Maybe the OP wants it in a PCGS holder so it can be put in the Registry.

What is a "Goodacre" anyway? Is that a variety?

LindeDad

Originally posted by: DIMEMAN

Originally posted by: oih82w8

Originally posted by: fivecents

I would leave it in the ICG holder. That is the holder that Ms Goodacre originally had the run of coins submitted to. Kind of historic. imho

X2.

Maybe the OP wants it in a PCGS holder so it can be put in the Registry.



What is a "Goodacre" anyway? Is that a variety?

Yes the planchets were polised then minted has a diffinate different look.

ScarsdaleCoin

yup paid her $5,000 in 5,000 coins... half went into holders right away the other half later date... maybe 100 she autographed on the ICG holder in black marker... I was there

Trogi

I called to ask why it wasn't crossed but they said that the senior graders were at a show this weekend and it would be next week before I got an answer.

Trogi

So PCGS called and said that since the coin would cross at SP and not MS they didn't grade it. They admitted they should have contacted me. They offered for me to send it back for a free SP crossover and will pay shipping. I am happy as they are fixing the problem. Thanks for everyone's input.

TigersFan2

ANA President, Jeff Garrett, was able to crossover from ICG to PCGS.

ICG to PCGS Crossover