PCGS Submission GTG - Irish Edition

Boosibri

Going to PCGS on Tuesday. Any GTG takers?





1933 1/2P





1935 6P





1945 6P





1947 6P





1933 Shilling





1934 2/6d





1942 2/6d





...and one more which will go in the package to PCGS



1749 Farthing ex. Colin Cooke collection

mikeystrikes

1933 shilling 64/65

brg5658

I don't think my grade guesses would be very good when I can only see pictures for one of the seven coins listed.

brg5658

I keep checking back, Boosibri, please post these! I like Irish coins a lot, would love to see more of your eye candy!

Boosibri

They show just find for me on my Mac... I guess I can try a different photo host

brg5658

I can see them now.



My guesses based on the photos:



=====================================



1933 1/2P: MS64RB



1935 6P: MS63



1945 6P: MS64



1947 6P: MS64/65



1933 Shilling: MS63



1934 2/6d: MS64



1942 2/6d: MS65/66 (really like this one!)



1749 Farthing ex. Colin Cooke collection: MS64RB

marcmoish

This is what these SHOULD grade...





1933 1/2P: MS65RB



1935 6P: MS62



1945 6P: MS63



1947 6P: MS64



1933 Shilling: MS64



1934 2/6d: MS65



1942 2/6d: MS67



1749 Fart MS64RB+

Boosibri

FWIW, here are my guesses with the benefit of having the coins in hand. My pictures on the 35's are over exaggerating the issues :



1933 1/2P: MS65RD



1935 6P: MS64



1945 6P: MS65



1947 6P: MS65



1933 Shilling: MS64



1934 2/6d: MS65



1942 2/6d: MS66



1749 Fart MS64RB+

brg5658

That '42 Half Crown is a super coin!



Looks like we mostly agree (same ballpark). My thoughts on the 1933 1/2 penny would be market graded to MS64 because of the staining and spots. Also given that it's the "key" of the series, MS65 is a pretty ballsy grade if PCGS is so inclined to give it that.



Best of luck with these. All really nice coins.

Boosibri

Originally posted by: brg5658

That '42 Half Crown is a super coin!



Looks like we mostly agree (same ballpark). My thoughts on the 1933 1/2 penny would be market graded to MS64 because of the staining and spots. Also given that it's the "key" of the series, MS65 is a pretty ballsy grade if PCGS is so inclined to give it that.



Best of luck with these. All really nice coins.

Chris Denton said it was the nicest 1933 he had ever seen, which says a lot. I think the staining could put some off but it is worse in my pics than in hand. We will see, in about a month... I will post an update regardless.

brg5658

Originally posted by: Boosibri

Originally posted by: brg5658

That '42 Half Crown is a super coin!



Looks like we mostly agree (same ballpark). My thoughts on the 1933 1/2 penny would be market graded to MS64 because of the staining and spots. Also given that it's the "key" of the series, MS65 is a pretty ballsy grade if PCGS is so inclined to give it that.



Best of luck with these. All really nice coins.

Chris Denton said it was the nicest 1933 he had ever seen, which says a lot. I think the staining could put some off but it is worse in my pics than in hand. We will see, in about a month... I will post an update regardless.

PCGS has graded one other MS65RD and 2 in 65RB; unfortunately, no pictures for any of them. NGC has graded an additional 2 in 65RB, with none in 65RD. If Chris Denton is not the person you bought it from, I'm more inclined to give his opinion full credit. Good luck, nonetheless.

coinkat

terrific coins

the 1933 1/2 should go 65 but I see RB

1935 6d-MS64
1945 6d-MS65
1947 6d-MS64
1933 shilling- I think the image may capture a look leading on to undergrade this one- 64
1934 2/6- MS65 plus
1942 2/6- MS67- amazing

1749 Farthing- great strike- color may not be enough for RB. I would call it 65 brown but 64 brown seems more probable