GTG 1845 & 1846-O Seated Liberty halves

Smittys

Sorry bout the pic quality

bigjpst

fine details rim bums

vf details rev cleaning

Boosibri

I don't think either would straight grade

LindeDad

Originally posted by: Boosibri

I don't think either would straight grade

Borderline worth submitting.

USMarine6

I'm still trying to figure out how to have a GTG with a raw coin but I would say 30 and 40

grip

Originally posted by: Boosibri
I don't think either would straight grade

Agree!

mannie gray

F15/genny, depending on mood of grader ,

Improper rev cleaning

291fifth

VF details, rim damage, on the first and XF details, cleaned, on the second.

kaz

The 1846 O looks like VF details but won't grade due to rim bumps and deliberate cuts on the rim at 3:00 rev, IMO.

The 1845 appears to be XF but the rev. appears to have been cleaned, to me.

BryceM

I agree with many others. Likely no-grade on both.



Congrats on 10k posts!

golden

Originally posted by: Boosibri
I don't think either would straight grade

VanHalen

The 1845 has a shot at straight (net) grade of perhaps VF30. The New Orleans Half is pretty torn up with VF Details.

GotTheBug

.

roadrunner

Would have straight graded them VF30 and VF35 on details alone. Then account for any surface issues or hits.



I think that 2nd coin could straight grade.

ziggy29

VF25 and XF40 details, respectively. Don't like their chances to straight grade out into a holder; the first one due to rim damage and the second ones due to cleaning.

dogwood

The 46o has a great look for a Dansco but the rims might cause a details.
The 45p has a good shot at xf40, but if the grader is feeling antsy, maybe 35. I'd not be worried about "cleaning", I've seen lots of theses straight graded in worse shape.

Bob1951

F-15, VF-35