Do you think this coin could cross from ANACS to PCGS at a higher grade?

TopographicOceans

Or did ANACS get it right?

rec78

No.

Rampage

ANACS got it right.

Steve27

I agree, ANACS got it right:

PCGS PO-1:

291fifth

At least VF35 by current standards!

LogPotato

<< <i>At least VF35 by current standards! >>



Dang gradeflation again!

ricko

No....Cheers, RickO

BUFFNIXX

poor now, poor yesterday, and poor in the future. no matter where it is sent!!

Shamika

Hmmm... I think there's still some meat on that bone. It's too close to call.

winky

Not ever !

dynamic

Would not be surprised if it came back Fair. Host is seems fair(ly) consistent on Morgans (not my focus).
I have seen PCGS bust coins that look far worse and were Fair.

Wabbit2313

There is still one lower grade available. Counterfeit.

LindeDad

Rock tumbler wear usually obscures that.

telephoto1

Send it to CAC to see if it gets the gold bean.

mr1931S

ANACS almost got it right. The holder should say PO 1 BU. The "U" would be for ugly.

SeattleSlammer

If I had a '1' I'd want it to look exactly like that. Excellent example.

davewesen

I guess I disagree with previous posters - I feel it will get a 2 at PCGS
the reverse is a 1, but the obverse is a 2 and obverse trumps reverse at PCGS

To get a 1 at PCGS you need less than half the date showing AND all the letters on the periphery

Heritage example

I guess I don't even have to mention the elephant in I feel the coin on ebay is listed 4-5 times its worth.

Broadstruck

<< <i>At least VF35 by current standards! >>