PR04. On a scale of 1 to 5?

Weiss

Not mine, it was a recent NEN offering.

1 = not at all cool
5 = ubercool

Where does it fall on the spectrum to you?

ajaan

5

I LOVE it!!!!

PerryHall

It's a cool coin so I'd give it a 4.5.

TommyType

5

The only "uncool" thing about it is that it's STILL out of my price range.

USMarine6

Certainly out of the ordinary. I'd give it a 4

khayse

Very cool. 4.

-KHayse

BustHalfBrian

5, easy

GBurger717

5 cause I like it!

BustCuds

An easy 5

Flatwoods

I'd give it a 5.

Tookybandit

NumisOxide

5

TomB

5!

blu62vette

To find one of those unmolested in that grade is hard to find. Very cool.

Coin Finder

5 for sure

Overdate

How did the coin arrive at that grade? It's hard to imagine that it remained in active circulation for decades.

CoinRaritiesOnline

I'd say 5 for wholesomeness.

CaptHenway

4

sparky64

4.9

mbogoman

What's not to like? 5

LogPotato

4.5, only because of the rim bump @ 7 o'clock on the reverse.

jdimmick

cool as he11

ms70

Scrape that stupid sticker off so the label can be read.

Very nice coin! I'd give it a 5.

DIMEMAN

Easy 5!!

messydesk

(dupe)

messydesk

5 bells! And throw in a Hector Salamanca BOOM for extra coolness.

Shamika

Hmmm... I have to give it a 2.

TheRaven

5 for me.

BillJones

I'm going to be the contrarian and call this piece a 3. It is remarkable that a Gobrecht dollar could sustain this much wear and not have an injury. It is a classic example of the well preserved pocket piece.

Still I like coins with a bit more meat on them, and that's why this would be a "3" for me.

DennisH

5 all the way.
I have wanted a Gobrecht for a very, very long time.

illini420

Sure it's cool, but my favorite part of the Gobrecht is the reverse design with the flying eagle and the stars in the background. On a low grade piece like this one, you really don't see a good portion of that design so I couldn't ever give this coin a 5. Probably a 3 or 3.5 for me.

The most surprising part is that someone wasted the time/money to get a CAC sticker on that one, haha!!

fivecents

5 and it has already sold.

BryceM

I see it mostly like Bill Jones. It's not one I'd pursue and I'd rather go without than have missing details. However, simply due to the actual scarcity of the issue and lack of distracting marks I'd vote 4.

Bullsitter

If coins could talk.

3.5 for coolness...

RareBronzeCollector

Unequivocably a 5

ChangeInHistory

4, it has a nice wear pattern, but I'd like a bit more detail.

drei3ree

Not for me, but cool. 3

2ltdjorn

neat item, what was the ask price for it?

lkeigwin

Very cool, IMO. Not something I'd buy but certainly special. 5.
Lance.

Weiss

<< <i>neat item, what was the ask price for it? >>



$8,500. And I believe it wasn't underlined, indicating non-negotiable.

leothelyon

cmerlo1

6

coindeuce

1.8 squared.

HoledandCreative

At least a 5 because it is what it is.

Broadstruck

Wasn't this TDN's Pocket Piece

Higashiyama

I agree with TomB: 120

rec78

Uber COOL. Definately a 5. Is this the lowest graded proof coin? Does anyone know of a Proof (Any proof) coin in a lower grade? Is there such a thing as a PR01 coin?

Bob

johnny9434

ill go with a 4.5

swhuck

4.8 only because I don't like the wear on the reverse.

jayPem

If I had seen it in time, I would have bought it. Definitely a 5 in my book, wish I could have added it to my dollar set

mr1931S

I don't get the green bean for a coin with this much wear.Cool coin but the bean is out of place for this coin,IMO.I give it "4" in spite of the bean.