Guess the grades: 1954 Topps #250 Ted Williams

PSASAP

How many grade points separate these two cards?


[URL=http://s197.photobucket.com/user/dgtom/media/54teds_zpsfe630b8b.jpg.html][/URL]

orioles93

left 4
right 6

sportscardstop

3.5 left

6 right

1954

left 3 and right 5.5

PSASAP

My crappy scanner (Epson all-in-one) makes the corners on the card to the right look much softer than they are. So add one grade to whatever your guess is.

VitoCo1972

3.5 / 5

Dialj

Left 3
Right 5.5

MBMiller25

Left : 4
Right: 8

firedawg45

psa 3 and psa 6

ToppsFan

3.5, 7

TF

PSASAP

I'll post the answer as soon as there is a correct guess. Hint: one guess is only a half grade from being correct.

thedutymon

Morning,

My guess and should be correct is a 4 and a 6.

Neil

Dodgerfanjohn

Left 4, right 5

TonyC

3 and 5

psychump

L-4
R-5.5

Redglobe

Hello,

L-3.5
R-6.5

Rob

BunchOBull

3 & 6

Stingray

3 & 5.5

Baez578

I'm thinking it's 4 left and 7 right

jgrigali

2.5/5

ElvisP

3 and 7

JeffD27177

Upper corners on the left one are rough

I feel the grades SHOULD be 3/6

My guess is that they actually ARE 4 and 5

PSASAP

The answer is 3 and 7. Nice job Elvis!

DetroitSquirreL

3 / 6

DetroitSquirreL

didnt see final post till after I posted...I was close