guess the grade : buffalo's and roosevelt's : and the results are ------

deltadimeman

give me your opinion on the pcgs grades . no cheating please


1914 -- ms63 ouch! I just knew this one would grade ms65 !
1916 -- ms62 ouch again ! I thought it was a lock ms64 ?
1947-s -- ms67fb
1952-s -- ms67fb
1964 -- ms66

[URL=http://s992.photobucket.com/user/deltadimeman/media/1914nickel_zps8d55593c.png.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s992.photobucket.com/user/deltadimeman/media/1916nickel_zps4843a54e.png.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s992.photobucket.com/user/deltadimeman/media/1947sdime_zps24ec5cd1.png.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s992.photobucket.com/user/deltadimeman/media/1952sdime_zps220d20f6.png.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s992.photobucket.com/user/deltadimeman/media/1964dime_zps0af7e731.png.html][/URL]

nwcoast

Nice coins!
I'll take a crack at em....
65
66+
66
65
64

(might want to search the archives for the photobucket thread which addresses the bug which pushes photos off to the side. There is a fix for this) sorry I can't link you directly.

daOnlyBG

(1) Probably an MS63, judging by little marks I see on the obverse.

(2) Hmm... MS61? It seems to have a weaker strike than the others

(3) MS67FB

(4) MS65FB

(5) MS66

smokincoin

Very nice buffs!!!

CoinJunkie

Gorgeous Roosies!

I'll guess:

67FB
67
67

steveben

no idea...but, very nice coins! that last roosie looks like the joker: green hair, splotchy white face. wild!

ad4400

I agree there appears to be a disconnnect between the images and the grades on the buff nickels. Do the images accurately capture any hits (or lack thereof), luster and color? I would have guessed a much higher grade on the 1914. The 1916 has really nice eye appeal too, but I detect a slight flatness over the real leg, so maybe the graders decided on an AU62?

gyocomgd

I would imagine the weakness in the central obverse had something to do with the MS62 grade on that 1916. Strike notwithstanding, it's a beautiful piece.

sparky64

Great eye appeal on those Buff's regardless of the grade. (Judging by the photos)
I like that '47-S also.