And... Today's Memorabilia Haul...

Sean1125

Do these look good to you guys?














Who are these?

VitoCo1972

very interested in Payne Stewart. LMK what you have

kards

JOE DELAMIELLEURE hof 2003
Lem Barney hof 1992
Rene Robert (Buffalo Sabres)

NickM

I don't like the second or third footballs - I'm not sure who the first is.
Lem Barney and Ernie Banks look good. If that Magic/MJ is Upper Deck Authenticated, there's nothing to worry about there. Tomlinson looks authenticated by someone - if they're trustworthy, so is the piece.
On the oldtimers baseball picture, Wills, Robinson, and Rose look good. I don't have enough knowledge of the other 3 players' sigs to opine on them.
I've never seen a Willie Mays signed golf ball before. I'd be leery of that piece just because it's Mays.
For the other pieces, I don't know enough to have an opinion.

Nick

daddymc

I don't like any of the footballs.

daddymc

Or the Manning and Marino photo.

GR

The manning Marino and footballs look real bad. All the minis are sweet though, no doubts on them!

Sean1125

There isn't a Marino football, and the Favre was the ball I thought looked pretty good,,, the Peyton is close, I've had quite a few Peyton's before but don't have any currently to compare it to.

brianwintersfan

<< <i>There isn't a Marino football, and the Favre was the ball I thought looked pretty good,,, the Peyton is close, I've had quite a few Peyton's before but don't have any currently to compare it to. >>



Football's are all junk...Sorry

daddymc

<< <i>There isn't a Marino football, and the Favre was the ball I thought looked pretty good,,, the Peyton is close, I've had quite a few Peyton's before but don't have any currently to compare it to. >>



Peyton Mannings are all bad IMO.

Sean1125

What about the Mays & Banks? I looked at those and thought them to be good as well.

brianwintersfan

And my expertise on the Favre comes from working at a card shop in Milwaukee for 8 years. We got stuff directly from his company and none of it looked like that. I would also lay money that all three footballs were signed by the same person.

daddymc

<< <i>What about the Mays & Banks? I looked at those and thought them to be good as well. >>



I like the Banks. While the Mays doesn't look bad to me, from what I've heard, there is no way that guy has been able to sign something like a golf ball and have it look like that for quite some time. Any way to date the golf ball?

JMDVM

<< <i>I don't like any of the footballs. >>


Agree on the FBs and the photos

Sean1125

The Mays has got a hologram, I can't figure out the company though. The ball is an Intech Titanium 1, is marked "TI distance 432" cert # is VM10005 so I have no idea

daddymc

<< <i>The Mays has got a hologram, I can't figure out the company though. The ball is an Intech Titanium 1, is marked "TI distance 432" cert # is VM10005 so I have no idea >>



Mays items typically have his Say Hey hologram on them.

brianwintersfan

Hope you got this stuff dirt cheap

orioles93

On the one photo, brooks, palmer, rose, carlton, and gibson all look good. Dont know enough about wills, but i would assume its good if the others are. Mays and Banks look good as well.

Sheamaster

I'm no expert, but it does not seem that the footballs of Payton, Favre or Manning are legit. First of all, it looks like they were all signed with the same marker. The way the numbers are written boldly looks unusual. If they were signed with the same marker, they probably would have been signed at the same place or show. It is unlikely that Walter Payton and Peyton Manning were signing around the same time. Payton passed in November 1999 and was sick for the last several months (or more) of his life. Manning was a rookie in 1998 and I recall him doing a show in Chicago but probably wasn't a huge signer then. In summary, if someone happened to have autos of Payton, Favre and Manning, chances are they would not be signed with the same/similar pen and same style.

1980scollector

My opinion-

Payton ball -NG
Manning ball-NG
Favre ball-NG

Willie Mays golf ball- G
Paul H helmet- not sure the P looks weird but the last name looks alright.

MJ/MJ- NG

Manning/Marino- Hell no

The six signed photo looks pretty good but not sure and could be wrong.

The Banks ball looks good to me.


The rest I am too tired to check out right now.

KaKa

Unless in person...faked.

Tabe

Dunno about the autograph itself but the jersey in the Tomlinson picture is a bootleg.

Tabe

otwcards

How soon until the post that says, "I didn't buy this, yet. Was just considering it . . . but now I'll pass."

pmcollectour

Take some time to read this whole article. It's worth it.

handyman

I also agree most of those look faked.

Sean1125

I learned my lesson the first time Scott...

MooseDog

The group baseball photo is good.

I had a Banks sig on a card that looked just like the ball there and it got rejected by PSA.

I don't know recent football very well but the three signed footballs all look no good to me. On the Manning/Marino picture I have my doubts. Marino would NEVER sign over is own face and his normal style used to be to sign through the middle part of any item.

metrotheme

The multi-signed baseball piece looks good.

miconelegacy

I've never used it, but how much is the PSA quick service for authentication?

brianwintersfan

<< <i>I've never used it, but how much is the PSA quick service for authentication? >>



In the $7 range per auction. I trust the guys here and on SCN as much as I trust PSA. Consensus is a lot of it is bad. Why throw more money away on the deal.

csmtampa

That football that WP is on looks brand new. No way that thing was made before his death.

The Manning/Marino is hilarious.

otwcards

<< <i>I learned my lesson the first time Scott... >>



What lesson was that? Are you saying that you don't own this? But if it was a haul, that suggests that you do own it. Me thinks the BS meter is spiking hard to the right...

**Edit to clarify...

Sean1125

Bs meter? When did i once suggest i dont own the stuff?

Ehen i said i learned my lesson i mean saying i didnt get something

cardsnbeads

What you got here looks like some real autographs fixed in with the some fakes. The lesser stuff like the mini-helmets are ok but the footballs look fake especially the Walter Payton. The Manning and Marino is no good. The Banks Ball and the Old Timers photo looks good. Basically the cheap stuff in there is ok. The big ticket items are no good.

swartz1

Old timer photo is pretty cool...

dont let the others get your goat...

1980scollector

I really like the six signature photo of the old timers.

Archaninator

.

miconelegacy

Sean you told me about the seller being a local umpire and coach. I can't see why he would sell you fake stuff while working in the public.

I have know idea about Auto's so I stay far away. I bought all those balls from diamandman, assuming they are all real Auto's, but that's the only time.

Hopefully you can go back to the guy and his wife. Are any if these that are questionable worth paying for authentication? Sean which ones have Authenticity Certs with them? You had mentioned a few yesterday. PSA, GAI, Stiener I thought.

scashaggy

I don't like the Marino.