Walking Liberty Upgrade? - Edited to correct photo

nags

Any opinions on whether it's worth a shot to attempt to re-grade this coin? It looks to be a large % of increase in value at the next level. I stopped at a shop about 100 miles from home (in a small, remote town) and they had numerous of the old pcgs holders priced around pcgs price guide. - Thanks

ricko

Very risky if profit is your motive... Cheers, RickO

Justacommeman

I would think about sending them to CAC if you think they are upgrade candidates. Maybe you will get really really really lucky and score a gold sticker and then you have the best of both worlds. Highly desirable. Personally I would keep them in the present slabs for allure alone.

Hard to tell from the photos. The right obverse file looks pretty clean from what I can tell.


JMHO. MJ

golfer72

regrade which one?

Walkerguy21D

Like MJ said, hard to tell from these (or really any) photos......the strike on the 42S may limit it's grade, and the luster appears muted or otherwise unspectacular.
I can't tell what may be going on in the right obverse field of the '47, looks to be some lines or marks, unless it's the haze or a trick of the camera I'm seeing.

relicsncoins

The strike on the 42 S is fine.......It's the rare "stump" variety. She lost her hand fighting in the big one.

breakdown

With the scans, it's nearly impossible to know how these coins would grade. About all I can tell is they look fairly clean and the 42-S does not have a split hand (most don't).