Trying to get a handle on grading Morgan Dollars

ajaan

I received four Morgan Dollars. Given the rough images, what would you grade each one of these? Thanks in advance. The 1881-S has more lustre than the image shows.

relicsncoins

64
64
63+ (Maybe a low end 64)
64

ajaan

hmmm . . . interesting. Thanks.

bestclser1

64,65,64,64

lordmarcovan

What relicsncoins said. Those were my thoughts exactly.



<< <i>64
64
63+ (Maybe a low end 64)
64 >>



Coins #1 and #4, to my eyes (using a real horrible monitor) might have a squeakin' chance at 65. Dunno.

ricko

64, 65, 64, 64..... Cheers, RickO

Edscoin

65
64
63
64

MisterBungle

I'll take a stab at these...

1880-S MS64 Classic 64.

1881-S MS64 This one is dark in the focal area of the obverse, so it's hard to say.

1888-O MS64 Looks like it could maybe use an acetone dip.

1898-O MS65 Could be downgraded by whatever's going on in the first "8", and on the revese though.

~

Windycity

Always hard to grade by photos but getting them to the TPG's on a good day might result is as follows:

65
65
64
65

golfer72

The only one with a shot at 65 is the 81. the 98 reverse keeps it from 65