What do you think these cards would grade?

RMac

Hi,

Thanks to all of those that have read my posts and given me your opinions on grading. I'm going to build up about 10 or 15 that I (and you all) think are gradable, so far I've got two set aside. What do you think these Durocher and Cash cards would grade?










Thanks,
R-Mac

OAKESY25

6MK

5

OAKESY25

6 ST NOT MK

123Slider

5 and 5

scmavl

5 on both.

miconelegacy

5.5/6 ST
4.5/5

swartz1

7 w/qual or 5
6

Piggs

5.5 or 6 on Durocher ST qualifier

5 on the Cash

Nicely centered with clean pictures, nice cards. Doug

milbroco

5 st
4

WinPitcher

4 and 4.5

I'm not so sure that PSA will give that card a ST qualifier.

They generally only do that for wax and gum.


They will net grade it down though, thus my 4.

divecchia

I would say the 4-5 range for both.

Donato

Probstein123

5 st
4.5

Dialj

Leo - 4 ST
Norm - 5