what's the point even having neutral feedback on ebay, if not for a situation like this one? should he have left positive feedback?
"Men who had never shown any ability to make or increase fortunes for themselves abounded in brilliant plans for creating and increasing wealth for the country at large." Fiat Money Inflation in France, Andrew Dickson White (1912)
There is no requirement that you leave any feedback. I have had a couple of occassions where I was less than thrilled with some part of the buying experience and I just did not leave feedback, but rather contacted the seller to advise them of the issue I had and encouraged them to consider whether they may want to change their procedure in the future.
In response to the question, 'should he have left positive feedback?' I think we can universally agree that's a no. But the leaving positive, negative or neutral feedback are not the ONLY options available. I'm not sure why that point is so hard for some to get their arms around.
<< <i>There is no requirement that you leave any feedback. I have had a couple of occassions where I was less than thrilled with some part of the buying experience and I just did not leave feedback, but rather contacted the seller to advise them of the issue I had and encouraged them to consider whether they may want to change their procedure in the future. >>
By your failure to leave appropriate feedback, you put other potential buyers at risk. Hardly the high ethical standard which you apparently advocate for others.
I LMAO everytime I read forum members who claim that their primary motivation for leaving feedback after a negative experience is to 'warn other buyers'. If that's the case, what do you do when your happy with the transaction...leave none since they don't need protecting?
It's clear the 'protecting other buyers' excuse is a canard and in almost every occasion (this one included IMO) the true motivation for the buyer leaving neutral or negative feedback was because of THEIR unhappiness with the deal...not for some altrustic purpose to protect other buyers.
<< <i>I LMAO everytime I read forum members who claim that their primary motivation for leaving feedback after a negative experience is to 'warn other buyers'. If that's the case, what do you do when your happy with the transaction...leave none since they don't need protecting? It's clear the 'protecting other buyers' excuse is a canard and in almost every occasion (this one included IMO) the true motivation for the buyer leaving neutral or negative feedback was because of THEIR unhappiness with the deal...not for some altrustic purpose to protect other buyers. >>
If a neutral or negative FB is merited by the transaction, the motive is immaterial.
<< <i>So it's your position that buyers should educate sellers? >>
It appears the OP thinks so: "I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him.
edited to add... From eBay:
Should I leave neutral or negative Feedback for a seller?
Feedback comments become a permanent part of a seller's record. If you are a buyer, contact your seller to try to resolve any issues before leaving neutral or negative Feedback.
<< <i>So it's your position that buyers should educate sellers? >>
It appears the OP thinks so: "I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him.
edited to add... From eBay:
Should I leave neutral or negative Feedback for a seller?
Feedback comments become a permanent part of a seller's record. If you are a buyer, contact your seller to try to resolve any issues before leaving neutral or negative Feedback. >>
Are you trying to complete the learning process for the OP?
<< <i>Are you trying to complete the learning process for the OP? >>
Not at all. Based on this thread, I believe the OP has already made up his mind on the matter. I'm just presenting information related to the topic in the event there might be those who are interested in knowing what eBay's policies are.
<< <i>I'd have done about the same except for the DSRs, which would have all been 1's. If I was in a foul mood, I may have neg'd him. >>
Ebay counts on all sellers to run across a buyer like you at least once/year to keep our DSR ratings down and increase ebay fees by 15%. You should buy stock in ebay as you're adding to their bottom line. --jerry
<< <i>I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him. >>
Maybe you should have started to "learning process" by sending him an email where you can use as many words as you like and explain in detail.
What would you have done if he had replied, "Thanks for your note. I received the coin last week in the flip I shipped it in. I left it in the flip so that you could see what caused the damage in hopes of helping with your conservation efforts. I hope that you are successful in removing the PVC. Thanks for your purchase and best of luck to you with the coin."
<< <i>Ebay counts on all sellers to run across a buyer like you at least once/year to keep our DSR ratings down and increase ebay fees by 15%. You should buy stock in ebay as you're adding to their bottom line. --jerry >>
So no matter how egregious a seller's actions may be, you don't think their FB should be anything but 100% positive, right? Another of the dealer-worshiper coterie heard from.
The Straw Man fallacy is committed when a person simply ignores a person's actual position and substitutes a distorted, exaggerated or misrepresented version of that position. This sort of "reasoning" has the following pattern:
1. Person A has position X. 2. Person B presents position Y (which is a distorted version of X). 3. Person B attacks position Y. 4. Therefore X is false/incorrect/flawed.
<< <i>Ebay counts on all sellers to run across a buyer like you at least once/year to keep our DSR ratings down and increase ebay fees by 15%. You should buy stock in ebay as you're adding to their bottom line. --jerry >>
So no matter how egregious a seller's actions may be, you don't think their FB should be anything but 100% positive, right? Another of the dealer-worshiper coterie heard from. >>
No I'm not a dealer worshiper, I'm a dealer. I sell 6-7 figures on ebay every year. I pay them thousands in fees every year, sometimes every month. Contrary to popular belief, the increase in fees is born by the BUYER, not the seller. because if I can't sell at a reasonable proit, I WON'T BOTHER. So your costs are going up as a result of your actions.
I recently got my Top Rated Seller tag back after a couple of low star ratings from buyers A YEAR AGO who were unhappy with the shipping time associated with registered mail. Yes, that cost me thousands in additional fees and if they had contacted me I would have explained that I shipped next day and that registered mail really is that slow. Since then I've switched to express mail.
No, bad sellers who mislead people, purposely perform badly, or don't care if they perform badly, deserve bad feedback. There are some sellers like that on ebay, you can tell by their feedback. They don't even try for the lower fee levels. But as Russ stated well, this guy didn't wake up and say, "I' think I'll ruin a coin and ship it poorly today." Give him a chance to explain.
I don't think I'll change your attitude. I think you are proud to be unreasonable and will be that way until you die, but others may be reading. --jerry
<< <i>I recently got my Top Rated Seller tag back after a couple of low star ratings from buyers A YEAR AGO who were unhappy with the shipping time associated with registered mail. Yes, that cost me thousands in additional fees and if they had contacted me I would have explained that I shipped next day and that registered mail really is that slow. Since then I've switched to express mail. >>
How bad is it for a seller to get a neutral rating? Can a few neutrals cause a seller to lose a Top Rated Seller tag or lead to some other consequence with financial ramifications?
<< <i>I recently got my Top Rated Seller tag back after a couple of low star ratings from buyers A YEAR AGO who were unhappy with the shipping time associated with registered mail. Yes, that cost me thousands in additional fees and if they had contacted me I would have explained that I shipped next day and that registered mail really is that slow. Since then I've switched to express mail. >>
How bad is it for a seller to get a neutral rating? Can a few neutrals cause a seller to lose a Top Rated Seller tag or lead to some other consequence with financial ramifications? >>
That is a good question that I haven't been able to find the answer to and hopefully someone who knows the answer will pipe up. here is what I do know:
1. you can receive no more that 2 or .5% of your star ratings as 1's or 2's in a 12 month period.
2. you can have no more than two buyer protection cases opened against you (whether valid or not) in a 12 month period. I currently have one against me. A buyer opened a case for some PCGS empty blue boxes shipped Parcel Post because they were slow. The case was closed when the boxes arrived.
3. Your average DSR rating has to be above 4.6. that seems kindo low since mine are all above 4.9 and I'm still struggling with requirement 1 above.
<< <i>Ebay counts on all sellers to run across a buyer like you at least once/year to keep our DSR ratings down and increase ebay fees by 15%. You should buy stock in ebay as you're adding to their bottom line. --jerry >>
So no matter how egregious a seller's actions may be, you don't think their FB should be anything but 100% positive, right? Another of the dealer-worshiper coterie heard from. >>
No I'm not a dealer worshiper, I'm a dealer. I sell 6-7 figures on ebay every year. I pay them thousands in fees every year, sometimes every month. Contrary to popular belief, the increase in fees is born by the BUYER, not the seller. because if I can't sell at a reasonable proit, I WON'T BOTHER. So your costs are going up as a result of your actions.
I recently got my Top Rated Seller tag back after a couple of low star ratings from buyers A YEAR AGO who were unhappy with the shipping time associated with registered mail. Yes, that cost me thousands in additional fees and if they had contacted me I would have explained that I shipped next day and that registered mail really is that slow. Since then I've switched to express mail.
No, bad sellers who mislead people, purposely perform badly, or don't care if they perform badly, deserve bad feedback. There are some sellers like that on ebay, you can tell by their feedback. They don't even try for the lower fee levels. But as Russ stated well, this guy didn't wake up and say, "I' think I'll ruin a coin and ship it poorly today." Give him a chance to explain.
I don't think I'll change your attitude. I think you are proud to be unreasonable and will be that way until you die, but others may be reading. --jerry >>
<< <i>What is the consequence of a neutral vs. a negative for receiving a rebate? >>
From what's indicated on the eBay site, fee discounts are based on DSR ratings only. That doesn't change the fact that reading this message board for just a short period of time is enough to understand there are plenty of buyers who consider a neutral to be essentially a neg-lite... half the calories, but all the scumminess and unreliability of a regular negative.
<< <i>What is the consequence of a neutral vs. a negative for receiving a rebate? >>
From what's indicated on the eBay site, fee discounts are based on DSR ratings only. That doesn't change the fact that reading this message board for just a short period of time is enough to understand there are plenty of buyers who consider a neutral to be essentially a neg-lite... half the calories, but all the scumminess and unreliability of a regular negative. >>
OK. Given that, I'd rather have a neg and 5's on DSRs than a positive and 1's. I have good enough feedback that buyers won't be scared by a single neg. 1's cost me money and make it harder to compete with other dealers on low margin, high volume items. I've also seen a significant increase in buying interest since I got the top rated seller tag back. I think it makes a difference to buyers. --Jerry
# Follow all eBay policies. # Have a minimum of 100 transactions and $3,000 in sales over the past 12 months with US buyers. # Receive at least a 4.60 average from US buyers across all 4 detailed seller ratings (DSRs). # For all transactions with US. buyers, have no more than 0.50% of transactions with low DSRs (1s or 2s) on each criteria--item as described, communication, shipping time, and shipping and handling charges. (For sellers who have less than 400 annual transactions, the maximum will be 2 instances, instead of 0.50%.) # For all transactions with US buyers, have no more than 0.5% of your transactions result in an opened eBay Buyer Protection or PayPal Buyer Protection case. In addition, no more than 0.3% of your total transactions with US buyers may result in closed cases without seller resolution. (For sellers with less than 400 annual transactions, the maximum will be 2 instances, instead of either the 0.5% for opened cases or 0.3% for closed cases without seller resolution.)
The above are the ways Ebay can take away your top rated seller status. (taken from the site)
I lost mine just before I was to get a rebate 3 months ago. Why? 3 cards someone did not receive in 5 days caused him to open 3 cases against me. When the cards arrived he dropped the case. For 3 months I have not sold anything on the bay yet my 'top rated status' has mysteriously returned.
So, in closing I was wrong regarding the neutral affecting his rebate. At least at this point it didn't, last week, last year who knows.
<< <i> 1's cost me money and make it harder to compete with other dealers on low margin, high volume items. >>
Oh boo hoo! Where is it written that you are somehow entitled to a profit on low margin, high volume items? Or for that matter, where is it written that you are entitled to make a profit at all? The marketplace can be a hard taskmaster. If you can't take the heat, stay out of the kitchen!
If anybody is really interested in how neutrals are perceived on eBay, all you need to know is that people whined so badly about getting them (along with negs, of course) that eBay decided to protect buyers from ever having to get them, however deserved.
I guess that whole "providing a warning to others" reasoning for leaving bad (neutral, neg, whatever) feedback goes out the window when it's the buyer who's the unreliable party in the transaction.
<< <i>I LMAO everytime I read forum members who claim that their primary motivation for leaving feedback after a negative experience is to 'warn other buyers'. If that's the case, what do you do when your happy with the transaction...leave none since they don't need protecting? >>
May I suggest a primary course in logic. The above segue is just silly.
If you think about it, the ONLY reason to leave feedback (of any sort) AT ALL is for the benefit of other buyers. YOU already know how you feel about the seller.
Edit: I, for one, would be very grateful to a previous buyer for noting the OP's experience in the feedback history of the seller.
I was happy with my purchase but wanted to warn other buyers of his to look out for PVC if they weren't in the know about such things. I am not worried about the kind of buyer on this board I am worried about the guy who buys it and puts it right into his drawer or safety deposit box and comes back down the road and the coin is scrap.
As for the people who said I should have reached out to him first, what should I have said? Should I have blackmailed him for some money or let him wessal out of the feedback so no one in the future is warned? Don't just say I am wrong tell me the proper thing to do. What good of reaching out is there. >>
You were happy and then left crappy feedback. I will say the seller should have known better but dinging him as a way to warn others was worthless. Most buyers are not going to take the time on a low dollar coin and those that do will probably think that he got a fruit loop that left the feedback. You probably did your self more harm than the seller.
I do not understand how you can be happy with the coin and then ding the guy? Blackmail? You wanted the seller to conform to the way you think he should run His business?
Mark NGC registry V-Nickel proof #6!!!! working on proof shield nickels # 8 with a bullet!!!!
<< <i> 1's cost me money and make it harder to compete with other dealers on low margin, high volume items. >>
Oh boo hoo! Where is it written that you are somehow entitled to a profit on low margin, high volume items? Or for that matter, where is it written that you are entitled to make a profit at all? The marketplace can be a hard taskmaster. If you can't take the heat, stay out of the kitchen! >>
You're right. I don't have to sell things, especially to you.
But this is the United States of America where free enterprise is traditionally supported. Hard work and a good business plan generally makes you a profit.
but you missed my point entirely. if I'm not making a profit, i'll pass on that product. it seems that somewhere in your perverted sense of humor you want to smirk at ebay sellers who run on the endless treadmill selling products at a loss. Let me give you a clue, we're not that stupid.
I was happy with my purchase but wanted to warn other buyers of his to look out for PVC if they weren't in the know about such things. I am not worried about the kind of buyer on this board I am worried about the guy who buys it and puts it right into his drawer or safety deposit box and comes back down the road and the coin is scrap.
As for the people who said I should have reached out to him first, what should I have said? Should I have blackmailed him for some money or let him wessal out of the feedback so no one in the future is warned? Don't just say I am wrong tell me the proper thing to do. What good of reaching out is there. >>
You were happy and then left crappy feedback. I will say the seller should have known better but dinging him as a way to warn others was worthless. Most buyers are not going to take the time on a low dollar coin and those that do will probably think that he got a fruit loop that left the feedback. You probably did your self more harm than the seller.
I do not understand how you can be happy with the coin and then ding the guy? Blackmail? You wanted the seller to conform to the way you think he should run His business? I always say there is always that 1 in a 1000 and we found it here. >>
Little accusational of you, but I will try to clarify or dumb it down for you to help digest it.
Imagine you buy a great car at a great price and a truck comes by and delivers it to you. Being a gear head you check the fluids and find it has no oil in it so you are forced to put some in. Unsure if the dealer is an idiot or just cheep you would want to leave warning for others who might not check the oil before buying & driving.
I still like the coin but I didn't like the dealer experience and i disagree about buyer thinking all non-good feedback is the 1 in a 1000. I know for all my big purchases or ones i need a warm an fuzzy before buying, I look and then also consider the source. If I saw a feedback written just like mine I would consider it valid and factor it in. I did not leave crappy feed back I left good DSRs and neutral feed back.
Don't get mad at me if Ebays system is askewed and for it doing more damage to me is laughable at best, any retread who would be likely to block me for this was unlikely to ever earn my business in the first place and even in the small chance i miss out on a random coin of theirs, it is my bank account that will be larger for it not theirs....doesn't sound like 'I probably did your self more harm than the seller' to me. I will be fine
Little accusational of you, but I will try to clarify or dumb it down for you to help digest it.
Imagine you buy a great car at a great price and a truck comes by and delivers it to you. Being a gear head you check the fluids and find it has no oil in it so you are forced to put some in. Unsure if the dealer is an idiot or just cheep you would want to leave warning for others who might not check the oil before buying & driving.
Thanks, you made me see the light with this example.
Mark NGC registry V-Nickel proof #6!!!! working on proof shield nickels # 8 with a bullet!!!!
<< <i>Let's see if I got this correctly. Some posters here, like Russ think one neutral out of 4000+ positives is going to hurt his future sales? That is funny. I will buy from folks with a 99.6 or better feedback as long as I don't see fraudulent activity. A neutral with the benign explanation given will not hurt his sales one tiny bit. If he fixes the problem in the long run it will HELP his sales.
We now live in wamby pamby land. Come on fellas let's act like men here. >>
Lead by example.
Mark NGC registry V-Nickel proof #6!!!! working on proof shield nickels # 8 with a bullet!!!!
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so.
Russ, NCNE >>
I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
This is ironic, because the one time I decided to contact a dealer first before returning an item, it came back to cost me $500. I made several attempts to contact the dealer starting the first 24 hrs from receipt. They finally did respond after I negged them due to non-communications, but that was weeks later. They then claimed they had never received any of the half dozen or so notifications from me and declared the issue closed (ie. no returns allowed due to time expiring). Ebay didn't care as they sided with the seller...even though my attempts to reach them were through their ebay PM's. Only years later did I find out that those guys employed multiple Ebay ID's to bury all the negative feedback they had accumulated over the years (4 separate ID's). These days I'm far less likely to give any benefit of a doubt where a potential loss exists. Much better to overract than to underreact if a sizeable loss is possible.
<< <i>I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
This is ironic, because the one time I decided to contact a dealer first before returning an item, it came back to cost me $500. I made several attempts to contact the dealer starting the first 24 hrs from receipt. They finally did respond after I negged them due to non-communications, but that was weeks later. They then claimed they had never received any of the half dozen or so notifications from me and declared the issue closed (ie. no returns allowed due to time expiring). Ebay didn't care as they sided with the seller...even though my attempts to reach them were through their ebay PM's. Only years later did I find out that those guys employed multiple Ebay ID's to bury all the negative feedback they had accumulated over the years (4 separate ID's). These days I'm far less likely to give any benefit of a doubt where a potential loss exists. Much better to overract than to underreact if a sizeable loss is possible.
roadrunner >>
Generally, if a seller doesn't return my email within 48 hours, I'll request his contact information from eBay and try calling him on the phone. If I still can't get a hold of him, I will file a complaint with eBay and/or Paypal for item SNAD and let the seller sweat it out. If a sale gets to the point I have to file a claim with eBay/Paypal, the seller is going to get a negative a 1's for DSRs.
<< <i>I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
This is ironic, because the one time I decided to contact a dealer first before returning an item, it came back to cost me $500. I made several attempts to contact the dealer starting the first 24 hrs from receipt. They finally did respond after I negged them due to non-communications, but that was weeks later. They then claimed they had never received any of the half dozen or so notifications from me and declared the issue closed (ie. no returns allowed due to time expiring). Ebay didn't care as they sided with the seller...even though my attempts to reach them were through their ebay PM's. Only years later did I find out that those guys employed multiple Ebay ID's to bury all the negative feedback they had accumulated over the years (4 separate ID's). These days I'm far less likely to give any benefit of a doubt where a potential loss exists. Much better to overract than to underreact if a sizeable loss is possible.
roadrunner >>
Generally, if a seller doesn't return my email within 48 hours, I'll request his contact information from eBay and try calling him on the phone. If I still can't get a hold of him, I will file a complaint with eBay and/or Paypal for item SNAD and let the seller sweat it out. If a sale gets to the point I have to file a claim with eBay/Paypal, the seller is going to get a negative a 1's for DSRs. >>
Everyone here should just block you now and get it over with. You really nead to chill out.
<< <i>I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
This is ironic, because the one time I decided to contact a dealer first before returning an item, it came back to cost me $500. I made several attempts to contact the dealer starting the first 24 hrs from receipt. They finally did respond after I negged them due to non-communications, but that was weeks later. They then claimed they had never received any of the half dozen or so notifications from me and declared the issue closed (ie. no returns allowed due to time expiring). Ebay didn't care as they sided with the seller...even though my attempts to reach them were through their ebay PM's. Only years later did I find out that those guys employed multiple Ebay ID's to bury all the negative feedback they had accumulated over the years (4 separate ID's). These days I'm far less likely to give any benefit of a doubt where a potential loss exists. Much better to overract than to underreact if a sizeable loss is possible.
roadrunner >>
Generally, if a seller doesn't return my email within 48 hours, I'll request his contact information from eBay and try calling him on the phone. If I still can't get a hold of him, I will file a complaint with eBay and/or Paypal for item SNAD and let the seller sweat it out. If a sale gets to the point I have to file a claim with eBay/Paypal, the seller is going to get a negative a 1's for DSRs. >>
Everyone here should just block you now and get it over with. You really nead to chill out. >>
So you think I should wait for days for a seller to respond to me? You need to chill out!
<< <i>So you think I should wait for days for a seller to respond to me? >>
Unless you know for a fact the seller is ignoring you, yes- you should wait. As far as anybody else is concerned, I don't suppose the guy who gave me a hard time for not getting back to him right away 8 years ago when he had a question would really be that big a deal. That my mother was admitted to intensive care and passed away shortly after was more important to me than his question about where his package was. So sue me.
<< <i>So you think I should wait for days for a seller to respond to me? >>
Unless you know for a fact the seller is ignoring you, yes- you should wait. As far as anybody else is concerned, I don't suppose the guy who gave me a hard time for not getting back to him right away 8 years ago when he had a question would really be that big a deal. That my mother was admitted to intensive care and passed away shortly after was more important to me than his question about where his package was. So sue me. >>
Waiting 48 hours for a response to an email AND attempting to contact a seller by phone isn't enough for you? I daresay if I said I waited a month, that your response would still be the same.
<< <i>Bobbo50 would you be kind enough to supply your Ebay name? >>
Why, so you can harass me over there too? Get a life. >>
So I can block you, I don't think I or anyone else could satisfy you. >>
That is belied by the hundreds of positives FBs I've given over the years. Tell you what, you give me your SSN, DL#, credit card #s and other pertinent information and maybe I'll think about it. In the meantime: GET A LIFE!
Comments
In response to the question, 'should he have left positive feedback?' I think we can universally agree that's a no. But the leaving positive, negative or neutral feedback are not the ONLY options available. I'm not sure why that point is so hard for some to get their arms around.
Greg Hansen, Melbourne, FL Click here for any current EBAY auctions Multiple "Circle of Trust" transactions over 14 years on forum
<< <i>To clarify
I was happy with my purchase -------------- >>
You way overreacted
<< <i>There is no requirement that you leave any feedback. I have had a couple of occassions where I was less than thrilled with some part of the buying experience and I just did not leave feedback, but rather contacted the seller to advise them of the issue I had and encouraged them to consider whether they may want to change their procedure in the future. >>
By your failure to leave appropriate feedback, you put other potential buyers at risk.
Hardly the high ethical standard which you apparently advocate for others.
It's clear the 'protecting other buyers' excuse is a canard and in almost every occasion (this one included IMO) the true motivation for the buyer leaving neutral or negative feedback was because of THEIR unhappiness with the deal...not for some altrustic purpose to protect other buyers.
Greg Hansen, Melbourne, FL Click here for any current EBAY auctions Multiple "Circle of Trust" transactions over 14 years on forum
<< <i>I LMAO everytime I read forum members who claim that their primary motivation for leaving feedback after a negative experience is to 'warn other buyers'. If that's the case, what do you do when your happy with the transaction...leave none since they don't need protecting?
It's clear the 'protecting other buyers' excuse is a canard and in almost every occasion (this one included IMO) the true motivation for the buyer leaving neutral or negative feedback was because of THEIR unhappiness with the deal...not for some altrustic purpose to protect other buyers. >>
If a neutral or negative FB is merited by the transaction, the motive is immaterial.
<< <i>So it's your position that buyers should educate sellers? >>
It appears the OP thinks so: "I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him.
edited to add... From eBay:
Should I leave neutral or negative Feedback for a seller?
Feedback comments become a permanent part of a seller's record. If you are a buyer, contact your seller to try to resolve any issues before leaving neutral or negative Feedback.
<< <i>
<< <i>So it's your position that buyers should educate sellers? >>
It appears the OP thinks so: "I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him.
edited to add... From eBay:
Should I leave neutral or negative Feedback for a seller?
Feedback comments become a permanent part of a seller's record. If you are a buyer, contact your seller to try to resolve any issues before leaving neutral or negative Feedback. >>
Are you trying to complete the learning process for the OP?
<< <i>Are you trying to complete the learning process for the OP?
Not at all. Based on this thread, I believe the OP has already made up his mind on the matter. I'm just presenting information related to the topic in the event there might be those who are interested in knowing what eBay's policies are.
<< <i>I'd have done about the same except for the DSRs, which would have all been 1's.
If I was in a foul mood, I may have neg'd him. >>
Ebay counts on all sellers to run across a buyer like you at least once/year to keep our DSR ratings down and increase ebay fees by 15%. You should buy stock in ebay as you're adding to their bottom line. --jerry
<< <i>I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him. >>
Maybe you should have started to "learning process" by sending him an email where you can use as many words as you like and explain in detail.
What would you have done if he had replied, "Thanks for your note. I received the coin last week in the flip I shipped it in. I left it in the flip so that you could see what caused the damage in hopes of helping with your conservation efforts. I hope that you are successful in removing the PVC. Thanks for your purchase and best of luck to you with the coin."
--Jerry
<< <i>Ebay counts on all sellers to run across a buyer like you at least once/year to keep our DSR ratings down and increase ebay fees by 15%. You should buy stock in ebay as you're adding to their bottom line. --jerry >>
So no matter how egregious a seller's actions may be, you don't think their FB should be anything but 100% positive, right?
Another of the dealer-worshiper coterie heard from.
The Straw Man fallacy is committed when a person simply ignores a person's actual position and substitutes a distorted, exaggerated or misrepresented version of that position. This sort of "reasoning" has the following pattern:
1. Person A has position X.
2. Person B presents position Y (which is a distorted version of X).
3. Person B attacks position Y.
4. Therefore X is false/incorrect/flawed.
<< <i>
<< <i>Ebay counts on all sellers to run across a buyer like you at least once/year to keep our DSR ratings down and increase ebay fees by 15%. You should buy stock in ebay as you're adding to their bottom line. --jerry >>
So no matter how egregious a seller's actions may be, you don't think their FB should be anything but 100% positive, right?
Another of the dealer-worshiper coterie heard from. >>
No I'm not a dealer worshiper, I'm a dealer. I sell 6-7 figures on ebay every year. I pay them thousands in fees every year, sometimes every month. Contrary to popular belief, the increase in fees is born by the BUYER, not the seller. because if I can't sell at a reasonable proit, I WON'T BOTHER. So your costs are going up as a result of your actions.
I recently got my Top Rated Seller tag back after a couple of low star ratings from buyers A YEAR AGO who were unhappy with the shipping time associated with registered mail. Yes, that cost me thousands in additional fees and if they had contacted me I would have explained that I shipped next day and that registered mail really is that slow. Since then I've switched to express mail.
No, bad sellers who mislead people, purposely perform badly, or don't care if they perform badly, deserve bad feedback. There are some sellers like that on ebay, you can tell by their feedback. They don't even try for the lower fee levels. But as Russ stated well, this guy didn't wake up and say, "I' think I'll ruin a coin and ship it poorly today." Give him a chance to explain.
I don't think I'll change your attitude. I think you are proud to be unreasonable and will be that way until you die, but others may be reading. --jerry
<< <i>I recently got my Top Rated Seller tag back after a couple of low star ratings from buyers A YEAR AGO who were unhappy with the shipping time associated with registered mail. Yes, that cost me thousands in additional fees and if they had contacted me I would have explained that I shipped next day and that registered mail really is that slow. Since then I've switched to express mail. >>
How bad is it for a seller to get a neutral rating? Can a few neutrals cause a seller to lose a Top Rated Seller tag or lead to some other consequence with financial ramifications?
<< <i>The problem with Ebay is that a neutral is viewed essentially the same as a negative. >>
Bingo, and if he qualified for a rebate at the end of the month, I believe with that action he no longer does.
That is why he freaked. That is why the OP should have done like Russ explained.
Steve
<< <i>
<< <i>The problem with Ebay is that a neutral is viewed essentially the same as a negative. >>
Bingo, and if he qualified for a rebate at the end of the month, I believe with that action he no longer does.
That is why he freaked. That is why the OP should have done like Russ explained.
Steve >>
What do you mean by 'essentially the same'? What is the consequence of a neutral vs. a negative for receiving a rebate?
<< <i>
<< <i>I recently got my Top Rated Seller tag back after a couple of low star ratings from buyers A YEAR AGO who were unhappy with the shipping time associated with registered mail. Yes, that cost me thousands in additional fees and if they had contacted me I would have explained that I shipped next day and that registered mail really is that slow. Since then I've switched to express mail. >>
How bad is it for a seller to get a neutral rating? Can a few neutrals cause a seller to lose a Top Rated Seller tag or lead to some other consequence with financial ramifications? >>
That is a good question that I haven't been able to find the answer to and hopefully someone who knows the answer will pipe up. here is what I do know:
1. you can receive no more that 2 or .5% of your star ratings as 1's or 2's in a 12 month period.
2. you can have no more than two buyer protection cases opened against you (whether valid or not) in a 12 month period. I currently have one against me. A buyer opened a case for some PCGS empty blue boxes shipped Parcel Post because they were slow. The case was closed when the boxes arrived.
3. Your average DSR rating has to be above 4.6. that seems kindo low since mine are all above 4.9 and I'm still struggling with requirement 1 above.
--jerry
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Ebay counts on all sellers to run across a buyer like you at least once/year to keep our DSR ratings down and increase ebay fees by 15%. You should buy stock in ebay as you're adding to their bottom line. --jerry >>
So no matter how egregious a seller's actions may be, you don't think their FB should be anything but 100% positive, right?
Another of the dealer-worshiper coterie heard from. >>
No I'm not a dealer worshiper, I'm a dealer. I sell 6-7 figures on ebay every year. I pay them thousands in fees every year, sometimes every month. Contrary to popular belief, the increase in fees is born by the BUYER, not the seller. because if I can't sell at a reasonable proit, I WON'T BOTHER. So your costs are going up as a result of your actions.
I recently got my Top Rated Seller tag back after a couple of low star ratings from buyers A YEAR AGO who were unhappy with the shipping time associated with registered mail. Yes, that cost me thousands in additional fees and if they had contacted me I would have explained that I shipped next day and that registered mail really is that slow. Since then I've switched to express mail.
No, bad sellers who mislead people, purposely perform badly, or don't care if they perform badly, deserve bad feedback. There are some sellers like that on ebay, you can tell by their feedback. They don't even try for the lower fee levels. But as Russ stated well, this guy didn't wake up and say, "I' think I'll ruin a coin and ship it poorly today." Give him a chance to explain.
I don't think I'll change your attitude. I think you are proud to be unreasonable and will be that way until you die, but others may be reading. --jerry >>
another voice of reason
<< <i>What is the consequence of a neutral vs. a negative for receiving a rebate? >>
From what's indicated on the eBay site, fee discounts are based on DSR ratings only. That doesn't change the fact that reading this message board for just a short period of time is enough to understand there are plenty of buyers who consider a neutral to be essentially a neg-lite... half the calories, but all the scumminess and unreliability of a regular negative.
IIRC back when Ebay made some changes a neutral was perceived to be the same as a negative.
That is why I said "I believe' he may no longer qualify fir the end of the month fee rebate program.
For all I know Ebay has changed it yet again.
Steve
<< <i>
<< <i>What is the consequence of a neutral vs. a negative for receiving a rebate? >>
From what's indicated on the eBay site, fee discounts are based on DSR ratings only. That doesn't change the fact that reading this message board for just a short period of time is enough to understand there are plenty of buyers who consider a neutral to be essentially a neg-lite... half the calories, but all the scumminess and unreliability of a regular negative. >>
OK. Given that, I'd rather have a neg and 5's on DSRs than a positive and 1's. I have good enough feedback that buyers won't be scared by a single neg. 1's cost me money and make it harder to compete with other dealers on low margin, high volume items. I've also seen a significant increase in buying interest since I got the top rated seller tag back. I think it makes a difference to buyers. --Jerry
# Have a minimum of 100 transactions and $3,000 in sales over the past 12 months with US buyers.
# Receive at least a 4.60 average from US buyers across all 4 detailed seller ratings (DSRs).
# For all transactions with US. buyers, have no more than 0.50% of transactions with low DSRs (1s or 2s) on each criteria--item as described, communication, shipping time, and shipping and handling charges. (For sellers who have less than 400 annual transactions, the maximum will be 2 instances, instead of 0.50%.)
# For all transactions with US buyers, have no more than 0.5% of your transactions result in an opened eBay Buyer Protection or PayPal Buyer Protection case. In addition, no more than 0.3% of your total transactions with US buyers may result in closed cases without seller resolution. (For sellers with less than 400 annual transactions, the maximum will be 2 instances, instead of either the 0.5% for opened cases or 0.3% for closed cases without seller resolution.)
The above are the ways Ebay can take away your top rated seller status. (taken from the site)
I lost mine just before I was to get a rebate 3 months ago. Why? 3 cards someone did not receive in 5 days caused him to open
3 cases against me. When the cards arrived he dropped the case. For 3 months I have not sold anything on the bay yet my 'top rated status'
has mysteriously returned.
So, in closing I was wrong regarding the neutral affecting his rebate. At least at this point it didn't, last week, last year who knows.
<< <i> 1's cost me money and make it harder to compete with other dealers on low margin, high volume items. >>
Oh boo hoo!
Where is it written that you are somehow entitled to a profit on low margin, high volume items?
Or for that matter, where is it written that you are entitled to make a profit at all?
The marketplace can be a hard taskmaster.
If you can't take the heat, stay out of the kitchen!
I guess that whole "providing a warning to others" reasoning for leaving bad (neutral, neg, whatever) feedback goes out the window when it's the buyer who's the unreliable party in the transaction.
<< <i>I LMAO everytime I read forum members who claim that their primary motivation for leaving feedback after a negative experience is to 'warn other buyers'. If that's the case, what do you do when your happy with the transaction...leave none since they don't need protecting? >>
May I suggest a primary course in logic. The above segue is just silly.
If you think about it, the ONLY reason to leave feedback (of any sort) AT ALL is for the benefit of other buyers.
YOU already know how you feel about the seller.
Edit: I, for one, would be very grateful to a previous buyer for noting the OP's experience in the feedback
history of the seller.
<< <i>if it weren't for eBay, we wouldn't have any fun here ! >>
ya darn tootin'! time to bid on somethin'...
<< <i>To clarify
I was happy with my purchase but wanted to warn other buyers of his to look out for PVC if they weren't in the know about such things. I am not worried about the kind of buyer on this board I am worried about the guy who buys it and puts it right into his drawer or safety deposit box and comes back down the road and the coin is scrap.
As for the people who said I should have reached out to him first, what should I have said? Should I have blackmailed him for some money or let him wessal out of the feedback so no one in the future is warned? Don't just say I am wrong tell me the proper thing to do. What good of reaching out is there. >>
You were happy and then left crappy feedback. I will say the seller should have known better but dinging him as a way to warn others was worthless. Most buyers are not going to take the time on a low dollar coin and those that do will probably think that he got a fruit loop that left the feedback. You probably did your self more harm than the seller.
I do not understand how you can be happy with the coin and then ding the guy? Blackmail? You wanted the seller to conform to the way you think he should run His business?
NGC registry V-Nickel proof #6!!!!
working on proof shield nickels # 8 with a bullet!!!!
RIP "BEAR"
<< <i>
<< <i> 1's cost me money and make it harder to compete with other dealers on low margin, high volume items. >>
Oh boo hoo!
Where is it written that you are somehow entitled to a profit on low margin, high volume items?
Or for that matter, where is it written that you are entitled to make a profit at all?
The marketplace can be a hard taskmaster.
If you can't take the heat, stay out of the kitchen! >>
You're right. I don't have to sell things, especially to you.
But this is the United States of America where free enterprise is traditionally supported. Hard work and a good business plan generally makes you a profit.
but you missed my point entirely. if I'm not making a profit, i'll pass on that product. it seems that somewhere in your perverted sense of humor you want to smirk at ebay sellers who run on the endless treadmill selling products at a loss. Let me give you a clue, we're not that stupid.
Go back under your bridge.
--jerry
<< <i>
<< <i>To clarify
I was happy with my purchase but wanted to warn other buyers of his to look out for PVC if they weren't in the know about such things. I am not worried about the kind of buyer on this board I am worried about the guy who buys it and puts it right into his drawer or safety deposit box and comes back down the road and the coin is scrap.
As for the people who said I should have reached out to him first, what should I have said? Should I have blackmailed him for some money or let him wessal out of the feedback so no one in the future is warned? Don't just say I am wrong tell me the proper thing to do. What good of reaching out is there. >>
You were happy and then left crappy feedback. I will say the seller should have known better but dinging him as a way to warn others was worthless. Most buyers are not going to take the time on a low dollar coin and those that do will probably think that he got a fruit loop that left the feedback. You probably did your self more harm than the seller.
I do not understand how you can be happy with the coin and then ding the guy? Blackmail? You wanted the seller to conform to the way you think he should run His business? I always say there is always that 1 in a 1000 and we found it here. >>
Little accusational of you, but I will try to clarify or dumb it down for you to help digest it.
Imagine you buy a great car at a great price and a truck comes by and delivers it to you. Being a gear head you check the fluids and find it has no oil in it so you are forced to put some in. Unsure if the dealer is an idiot or just cheep you would want to leave warning for others who might not check the oil before buying & driving.
I still like the coin but I didn't like the dealer experience and i disagree about buyer thinking all non-good feedback is the 1 in a 1000. I know for all my big purchases or ones i need a warm an fuzzy before buying, I look and then also consider the source. If I saw a feedback written just like mine I would consider it valid and factor it in. I did not leave crappy feed back I left good DSRs and neutral feed back.
Don't get mad at me if Ebays system is askewed and for it doing more damage to me is laughable at best, any retread who would be likely to block me for this was unlikely to ever earn my business in the first place and even in the small chance i miss out on a random coin of theirs, it is my bank account that will be larger for it not theirs....doesn't sound like 'I probably did your self more harm than the seller' to me. I will be fine
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>To clarify
Little accusational of you, but I will try to clarify or dumb it down for you to help digest it.
Imagine you buy a great car at a great price and a truck comes by and delivers it to you. Being a gear head you check the fluids and find it has no oil in it so you are forced to put some in. Unsure if the dealer is an idiot or just cheep you would want to leave warning for others who might not check the oil before buying & driving.
Thanks, you made me see the light with this example.
NGC registry V-Nickel proof #6!!!!
working on proof shield nickels # 8 with a bullet!!!!
RIP "BEAR"
<< <i>Let's see if I got this correctly. Some posters here, like Russ think one neutral out of 4000+ positives is going to hurt his future sales?
That is funny. I will buy from folks with a 99.6 or better feedback as long as I don't see fraudulent activity. A neutral with the benign
explanation given will not hurt his sales one tiny bit. If he fixes the problem in the long run it will HELP his sales.
We now live in wamby pamby land. Come on fellas let's act like men here.
NGC registry V-Nickel proof #6!!!!
working on proof shield nickels # 8 with a bullet!!!!
RIP "BEAR"
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so.
Russ, NCNE >>
I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
NGC registry V-Nickel proof #6!!!!
working on proof shield nickels # 8 with a bullet!!!!
RIP "BEAR"
This is ironic, because the one time I decided to contact a dealer first before returning an item, it came back to cost me $500. I made several attempts to contact the dealer starting the first 24 hrs from receipt. They finally did respond after I negged them due to non-communications, but that was weeks later. They then claimed they had never received any of the half dozen or so notifications from me and declared the issue closed (ie. no returns allowed due to time expiring). Ebay didn't care as they sided with the seller...even though my attempts to reach them were through their ebay PM's. Only years later did I find out that those guys employed multiple Ebay ID's to bury all the negative feedback they had accumulated over the years (4 separate ID's). These days I'm far less likely to give any benefit of a doubt where a potential loss exists. Much better to overract than to underreact if a sizeable loss is possible.
roadrunner
NGC registry V-Nickel proof #6!!!!
working on proof shield nickels # 8 with a bullet!!!!
RIP "BEAR"
<< <i>I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
This is ironic, because the one time I decided to contact a dealer first before returning an item, it came back to cost me $500. I made several attempts to contact the dealer starting the first 24 hrs from receipt. They finally did respond after I negged them due to non-communications, but that was weeks later. They then claimed they had never received any of the half dozen or so notifications from me and declared the issue closed (ie. no returns allowed due to time expiring). Ebay didn't care as they sided with the seller...even though my attempts to reach them were through their ebay PM's. Only years later did I find out that those guys employed multiple Ebay ID's to bury all the negative feedback they had accumulated over the years (4 separate ID's). These days I'm far less likely to give any benefit of a doubt where a potential loss exists. Much better to overract than to underreact if a sizeable loss is possible.
roadrunner >>
Generally, if a seller doesn't return my email within 48 hours, I'll request his contact information from eBay and try calling him on the phone.
If I still can't get a hold of him, I will file a complaint with eBay and/or Paypal for item SNAD and let the seller sweat it out.
If a sale gets to the point I have to file a claim with eBay/Paypal, the seller is going to get a negative a 1's for DSRs.
<< <i>
<< <i>I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
This is ironic, because the one time I decided to contact a dealer first before returning an item, it came back to cost me $500. I made several attempts to contact the dealer starting the first 24 hrs from receipt. They finally did respond after I negged them due to non-communications, but that was weeks later. They then claimed they had never received any of the half dozen or so notifications from me and declared the issue closed (ie. no returns allowed due to time expiring). Ebay didn't care as they sided with the seller...even though my attempts to reach them were through their ebay PM's. Only years later did I find out that those guys employed multiple Ebay ID's to bury all the negative feedback they had accumulated over the years (4 separate ID's). These days I'm far less likely to give any benefit of a doubt where a potential loss exists. Much better to overract than to underreact if a sizeable loss is possible.
roadrunner >>
Generally, if a seller doesn't return my email within 48 hours, I'll request his contact information from eBay and try calling him on the phone.
If I still can't get a hold of him, I will file a complaint with eBay and/or Paypal for item SNAD and let the seller sweat it out.
If a sale gets to the point I have to file a claim with eBay/Paypal, the seller is going to get a negative a 1's for DSRs. >>
Everyone here should just block you now and get it over with. You really nead to chill out.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>I see it the same. It's just common courtesy to contact the seller if there is a problem. Both sides learn from it and have the chance to fix it. How the seller reacts to that contact is what a buyer should be looking at. Too many folks don't take the time to communicate before taking it to a higher level. It's really cool how a quick email or call can end a situation.
This is ironic, because the one time I decided to contact a dealer first before returning an item, it came back to cost me $500. I made several attempts to contact the dealer starting the first 24 hrs from receipt. They finally did respond after I negged them due to non-communications, but that was weeks later. They then claimed they had never received any of the half dozen or so notifications from me and declared the issue closed (ie. no returns allowed due to time expiring). Ebay didn't care as they sided with the seller...even though my attempts to reach them were through their ebay PM's. Only years later did I find out that those guys employed multiple Ebay ID's to bury all the negative feedback they had accumulated over the years (4 separate ID's). These days I'm far less likely to give any benefit of a doubt where a potential loss exists. Much better to overract than to underreact if a sizeable loss is possible.
roadrunner >>
Generally, if a seller doesn't return my email within 48 hours, I'll request his contact information from eBay and try calling him on the phone.
If I still can't get a hold of him, I will file a complaint with eBay and/or Paypal for item SNAD and let the seller sweat it out.
If a sale gets to the point I have to file a claim with eBay/Paypal, the seller is going to get a negative a 1's for DSRs. >>
Everyone here should just block you now and get it over with. You really nead to chill out. >>
So you think I should wait for days for a seller to respond to me? You need to chill out!
<< <i>So you think I should wait for days for a seller to respond to me? >>
Unless you know for a fact the seller is ignoring you, yes- you should wait. As far as anybody else is concerned, I don't suppose the guy who gave me a hard time for not getting back to him right away 8 years ago when he had a question would really be that big a deal. That my mother was admitted to intensive care and passed away shortly after was more important to me than his question about where his package was. So sue me.
<< <i>
<< <i>So you think I should wait for days for a seller to respond to me? >>
Unless you know for a fact the seller is ignoring you, yes- you should wait. As far as anybody else is concerned, I don't suppose the guy who gave me a hard time for not getting back to him right away 8 years ago when he had a question would really be that big a deal. That my mother was admitted to intensive care and passed away shortly after was more important to me than his question about where his package was. So sue me. >>
Waiting 48 hours for a response to an email AND attempting to contact a seller by phone isn't enough for you?
I daresay if I said I waited a month, that your response would still be the same.
<< <i>Bobbo50 would you be kind enough to supply your Ebay name? >>
Why, so you can harass me over there too?
Get a life.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Bobbo50 would you be kind enough to supply your Ebay name? >>
Why, so you can harass me over there too?
Get a life. >>
So I can block you, I don't think I or anyone else could satisfy you. >>
That is belied by the hundreds of positives FBs I've given over the years.
Tell you what, you give me your SSN, DL#, credit card #s and other pertinent information and maybe I'll think about it.
In the meantime: GET A LIFE!