Options
Did I over react?
crypto79
Posts: 8,623 ✭
I bought a coin recently off of the Bay (is there any where else to buy coins?) and I got a cool coin at a great price. The problem was I received the coin incredibly poorly packaged, it came in a bubble envelope and in the a milk colored soft PVC flip and that's it. I pulled the raw trade dollar out and it was completely covered in PVC but it was fresh so it came off (after 5 dirty Q-tips) with no damage and looking at the flip you could tell that it housed a half dollar for a long time as you could see the outline and some green film. Not only had the guy used a PVC flip he had reused one.
I decided to leave nutral feedback with all 5 star DSR's as I didn't want to return the coin but other buyers need to be on the look out on the coins they recive. Mind you the seller has a 4000+ rating and mostly does coins, I felt he should know better. I left this
""Fair price, quick shipping but was sent in a soft PVC flip, PVC=poison for coins""
The guy is rip roaring mad and calling me unreasonable, am I?
I decided to leave nutral feedback with all 5 star DSR's as I didn't want to return the coin but other buyers need to be on the look out on the coins they recive. Mind you the seller has a 4000+ rating and mostly does coins, I felt he should know better. I left this
""Fair price, quick shipping but was sent in a soft PVC flip, PVC=poison for coins""
The guy is rip roaring mad and calling me unreasonable, am I?
0
Comments
If I was in a foul mood, I may have neg'd him.
<< <i>Did you contact him before you left your Neutral? >>
No I didn't, I saw no point as I didn't want a "partial refund" (aka extortion) or to return the coin. There was nothing he could do and what did I think he would say.....SUUUURE Neutral sounds fair to me, go ahead and leave it and thank you for the feedback.
<< <i>I'd have done about the same except for the DSRs, which would have all been 1's.
If I was in a foul mood, I may have neg'd him. >>
almost did just what you said but I waited a day and cooled down
full disclosure here is the coin
It should also be noted that the coin is a G6 at best and he graded it Fine but I gave him a pass for that.
<< <i>I bought a coin recently off of the Bay (is there any where else to buy coins?) and I got a cool coin at a great price. The problem was I received the coin incredibly poorly packaged, it came in a bubble envelope and in the a milk colored soft PVC flip and that's it. I pulled the raw trade dollar out and it was completely covered in PVC but it was fresh so it came off (after 5 dirty Q-tips) with no damage and looking at the flip you could tell that it housed a half dollar for a long time as you could see the outline and some green film. Not only had the guy used a PVC flip he had reused one.
I decided to leave nutral feedback with all 5 star DSR's as I didn't want to return the coin but other buyers need to be on the look out on the coins they recive. Mind you the seller has a 4000+ rating and mostly does coins, I felt he should know better. I left this
""Fair price, quick shipping but was sent in a soft PVC flip, PVC=poison for coins""
The guy is rip roaring mad and calling me unreasonable, am I? >>
Nope!
If a seller doesn't want neg. FB then he should act accordingly. This transaction had numerous problems... used PVC contaminated flip, PVC contaminated coin, and poor packaging. One of these would be a reason to contact seller, all three indicate he doesn't really care about his business or his feedback! You did better than I would have, I'd have left a fully justified negative!
Successful BST xactions w/PCcoins, Drunner, Manofcoins, Rampage, docg, Poppee, RobKool, and MichealDixon.
<< <i>
<< <i>I'd have done about the same except for the DSRs, which would have all been 1's.
If I was in a foul mood, I may have neg'd him. >>
almost did just what you said but I waited a day and cooled down >>
Waiting a day or two before leaving a neg or even a neutral is a good practice except in the most egregious cases.
<< <i>You probably did the right thing. I would have contacted the seller first, if I could return the coin to my satisfaction. I would probably not leave a nuetral, but keep the same write up. However, your arguement for leaving a nuetral is valid. >>
If I left a positive it would slide down the page never to be read again and nobody would be warned. My thinking was if it didn't come out well I would have returned it.
.
____I just returned a group of over 1,000 raw Morgans to a dealer from a memo, where the dealer had left them stored in vinyl flips for over three years before delivering them to me. Every single coin had PVC residue on it, some with noticeable damage.
"Everything is on its way to somewhere. Everything." - George Malley, Phenomenon
http://www.american-legacy-coins.com
Governments can print currency. Only the people can print faith in it — and they’re running low on ink.
You did the right thing by mentioning the PVC soft flip. As long as you didn't neg him/her
then the seller shouldn't get his panties in a wad. Sellers should realize that buyers expect
well packaged shipments and anything less is unacceptable. PVC soft flips should never be
used - we all know better than that .
~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coin collecting is not a hobby, it's an obsession !
New Barber Purchases
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so.
Russ, NCNE >>
I agree. The OP in my opinion did over react.
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so. >>
So it's your position that buyers should educate sellers?
I think he did just that with his neutral feedback.
eBay feedback is a valuable tool in assessing a seller's credibility and in this instance, the seller got what he deserved.
If I'd have gotten a PVC covered coin, I would have probably returned it and given the seller a well deserved negative, so as to instruct him to be more careful in the future!
look at. No big deal for him, if he changes his ways. One neutral will lead to negs
if he repeatedly does this tactic. He should wake up and you did him a kind favor by
not negging the guy.
bob
<< <i>I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him. >>
Agree with Russ. Rather than hurt his future sales, you could have helped him by educating him. I wouldn't be surprised if a few others reading this thread also blocked you.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so.
Russ, NCNE >>
The sum of all three problems is eggregious! The SELLER should have thought about what he was doing BEFORE he sent the PVC contaminated coin, in a dirty used PVC flip, in a simple bubble envelope! I don't know about everyone else, but I EXPECT nice things when I choose to spend my money! Why is it acceptable to anyone to receive this type of a "product!" As I have indicated in earlier threads, PRAISE people when they meet or exceed your expectations, OTOH when someone serves up a mess such as this transaction let it be known! The e-bay FB/rating system works best when everyone is honest!!!
Successful BST xactions w/PCcoins, Drunner, Manofcoins, Rampage, docg, Poppee, RobKool, and MichealDixon.
<< <i>The e-bay FB/rating system works best when everyone is honest!!!
There is a coterie of posters here who side with the dealer no matter how egregious the conduct.
As a buyer on eBay I have the right to:
1: receive the item exactly as described and/or pictured
2: receive the item promptly
3: have the item well packed so as to avoid any damage in transit
If a seller fails to meet these criteria (which don't seem particularly onerous to me), he doesn't deserve a positive feedback.
<< <i>The SELLER should have thought about what he was doing BEFORE he sent the PVC contaminated coin, in a dirty used PVC flip, in a simple bubble envelope! >>
There's no reason to use a dirty flip, but what's wrong with bubble envelopes?
The problem is the feedback system just flat out does't work any more. It has become a one way street with all the mud to sling on one side of the street if the seller could of given you a nuetral feedback too would you have given him one. Or would you os sent a message first in that case?
<< <i>
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so. >>
So it's your position that buyers should educate sellers? >>
It's my position that damaging somebody's reputation should not be the action of first resort. It's not like the seller is some dirtbag who tried to rip off the buyer. He made a mistake that was more than likely born of ignorance, not malice. I'm sure he didn't wake up that morning and think to himself, "Hey, I think I'll ruin this coin just because I have nothing better to do". It takes little effort to send the seller an eMail explaining one's concerns and determine how he reacts before jumping to publicly slamming him.
Russ, NCNE
<< <i>Only thing I see he did wrong is the PVC flip and many raw coin dealers are still using them.
The problem is the feedback system just flat out does't work any more. It has become a one way street with all the mud to sling on one side of the street if the seller could of given you a nuetral feedback too would you have given him one. Or would you os sent a message first in that case?
It is a good question and yes I would have, I don't really care what my ebay feedback is.
<< <i>It is a good question and yes I would have, I don't really care what my ebay feedback is. >>
If there was a buyer's fee on eBay and buyers who received poor feedback from sellers had to pay more than those who hadn't, would you care then?
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so. >>
So it's your position that buyers should educate sellers? >>
It's my position that damaging somebody's reputation should not be the action of first resort. It's not like the seller is some dirtbag who tried to rip off the buyer. He made a mistake that was more than likely born of ignorance, not malice. I'm sure he didn't wake up that morning and think to himself, "Hey, I think I'll ruin this coin just because I have nothing better to do". It takes little effort to send the seller an eMail explaining one's concerns and determine how he reacts before jumping to publicly slamming him.
Russ, NCNE >>
I don't see the neutral FB in question as damaging the dealer's rep.
A buyer is under absolutely no obligation to educate a seasoned dealer, no matter how many times you insist that he should.
eBay FB only works if people leave realistic FB.
If one doesn't wish to receive neutral or negative feedback on eBay, one shouldn't conduct oneself in a manner that merits such ratings.
The seller in question should have known better.
If he did know better and did it anyway, he deserves a negative for being a gonif.
If he didn't know better, he deserves a neutral for being a dunce and should chalk it up as the price of an education.
<< <i>
<< <i>It is a good question and yes I would have, I don't really care what my ebay feedback is. >>
If there was a buyer's fee on eBay and buyers who received poor feedback from sellers had to pay more than those who hadn't, would you care then? >>
I sell plenty on ebay too and I wouldn't care even if there was a buyers fee. That said if the hit was too large from a negative rating I would leave ebay or create an alt. to do my dirty work.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so. >>
So it's your position that buyers should educate sellers? >>
It's my position that damaging somebody's reputation should not be the action of first resort. It's not like the seller is some dirtbag who tried to rip off the buyer. He made a mistake that was more than likely born of ignorance, not malice. I'm sure he didn't wake up that morning and think to himself, "Hey, I think I'll ruin this coin just because I have nothing better to do". It takes little effort to send the seller an eMail explaining one's concerns and determine how he reacts before jumping to publicly slamming him.
Russ, NCNE >>
logical and a voice of reason. Contact the seller first at least with your concerns before non positive feedback.
If the decision was to keep the coin, you decided it was acceptable.
Would I have left a neutral at that point? Would depend on the response (or lack of response) from the seller.
He was trying to save a dime. The seller, of ALL people, should know better.
I was happy with my purchase but wanted to warn other buyers of his to look out for PVC if they weren't in the know about such things. I am not worried about the kind of buyer on this board I am worried about the guy who buys it and puts it right into his drawer or safety deposit box and comes back down the road and the coin is scrap.
As for the people who said I should have reached out to him first, what should I have said? Should I have blackmailed him for some money or let him wessal out of the feedback so no one in the future is warned? Don't just say I am wrong tell me the proper thing to do. What good of reaching out is there.
<< <i>Before resorting to damaging the seller's feedback, I would have contacted him, explained his bad practice and why he should change it. It's common courtesy to do so.
Russ, NCNE >>
This reads as a logical strategy. However, one would never know if this seller habitually used these flips and was repeatedly warned by buyers if everyone who encountered the practice kept it confidential. Truly, I think no harm was done to the seller by the neutral.
In honor of the memory of Cpl. Michael E. Thompson
<< <i>To clarify
I was happy with my purchase but wanted to warn other buyers of his to look out for PVC if they weren't in the know about such things. I am not worried about the kind of buyer on this board I am worried about the guy who buys it and puts it right into his drawer or safety deposit box and comes back down the road and the coin is scrap.
As for the people who said I should have reached out to him first, what should I have said? Should I have blackmailed him for some money or let him wessal out of the feedback so no one in the future is warned? Don't just say I am wrong tell me the proper thing to do. What good of reaching out is there. >>
One wonders why you're so conflicted.
The usual suspects ganged up on you for failing to instruct a (presumably) professional numismatist not to use PVC flips.
Their opinions are predictable and wrong.
I definitely would have left AT LEAST a neutral and more likely a negative had I rec'd such a coin.
To reiterate: eBay feedback is only useful if buyers give honest ratings.
<< <i>
<< <i>I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him. >>
Agree with Russ. Rather than hurt his future sales, you could have helped him by educating him. I wouldn't be surprised if a few others reading this thread also blocked you. >>
Hoard the keys.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him. >>
Agree with Russ. Rather than hurt his future sales, you could have helped him by educating him. I wouldn't be surprised if a few others reading this thread also blocked you. >>
For some reason, there is a coterie of posters here who feel that the average collector should educate a dealer.
All the polite emails in the world don't pack the educational wallop that a neutral and/or a negative feedback does.
IMO the seller in this instance got off easy and should have got a negative.
I applaud the buyer for his service to the numismatic community in warning potential buyers of this seller's careless attitude.
<< <i>
<< <i>
<< <i>I sent him a link to the tread, I am sure I am still blocked but I hope this will complete the learning process for him. >>
Agree with Russ. Rather than hurt his future sales, you could have helped him by educating him. I wouldn't be surprised if a few others reading this thread also blocked you. >>
I think crypto has doubts that he did the right thing and started this thread to seek validation for his actions.
Worry is the interest you pay on a debt you may not owe.
"Paper money eventually returns to its intrinsic value---zero."----Voltaire
"Everything you say should be true, but not everything true should be said."----Voltaire
My FB rating is over 1000, all as a buyer. If I get blocked by anyone based on this attitude so be it. I am not unreasonable, I just expect a certain standard. I have purchased many things on ebay from many sellers on this forum. I don't think I've neg'd anyone here.
A coin with PVC, sent in a used PVC contaminated holder will get a seller a negative. The only exception would be if I had transactions in the past with a seller that were smooth. If that would have been done on the first transaction BAM - a negative. Getting blocked from a seller that offers that product and service would be considered a positive!
Successful BST xactions w/PCcoins, Drunner, Manofcoins, Rampage, docg, Poppee, RobKool, and MichealDixon.
<< <i>... Maybe he did not have any other flips. ... >>
Gosh, maybe he should have just dumped the coin into a #10 envelope and stuck a 1st Class stamp on it.
Maybe he didn't have another flip! - is there any end to the dealer butt-kissing that goes on on this board?
If that seller is really unhappy about the feedback he can:
1) start being less sloppy in his business
2) complain to ebay about the feedback system
Ebay made it this way. Don't blame the buyer for telling the truth.
I knew it would happen.
siliconvalleycoins.com
<< <i>You overreacted IMO. >>
<< <i>
<< <i>You overreacted IMO. >>
That is funny. >>
Nothing funny about an honest opinion , the funniest threads are when old timers crack a light on who the coin drs etc are , now those are entertaining.Too bad we dont see more of those dont you think ?
Too many white gloves employed here for protecting the chastity of the "poor" dealer who incidentally has thousands of feedbacks.
The coin was covered in green goo and rather than a FINE as described, it was a Good+. The OP demonstrated excellent restraint imo. I wouldn't have been as kind.
With 99% of ebayers having 99-100% positive feedback, it's a pretty useless system. And now that everyone also probably has 4-5 stars on their level of service, it's still no better.
If a single neutral with all 5's gets a seller rip-roaring mad, then maybe they should get out of the customer service business. It's not his first neutral.
.....OFFERS AN 1875 TRADE SILVER DOLLAR IN ABOUT FINE CONDITION WITH SEATED LIBERTY. HOWEVER, I AM NOT A GRADER OF COINS. PLEASE SEE SCANS. ALTHOUGH THE COIN IS WELL CIRCULATED, IT IS STILL A VERY COLLECTABLE COIN CONTAINING 120 GRAINS OF 900 FINE SILVER. THE TRADE DOLLARS ARE RARE COINS ESPECIALLY WITHOUT CHOP MARKS FROM CIRCULATION IN THE ORIENT. WITH THE PRICE OF SILVER AT $50 AN OUNCE, SILVER COINS ARE A GOOD INVESTMENT.
Trade dollars rare, esp w/o chopmarks? This silver coin is a good investment because of its bullion content? Fwiw silver was nowhere near $50/oz when this auction was running as it had long since crashed. Maybe the seller needs some further education for his neutral. The way I read this ad the seller is not a candidate for sainthood, but just another hustler with the usual hype who is still lucky to have 100% positive FB. Maybe after 4,000 FB's the seller just might invest a little time to become a "grader of coins?"
The seller currently offers for sale about a half dozen colonials, but he's not a grader or "expert" on those either....lol. Here's just one:
....OFFERS A 1795 TALBOT, ALLUM & LEE CENT WHICH APPEARS TO BE THE TYPE W-8620, RARITY URS-13, IN ABOUT VERY GOOD-FINE CONDITION; HOWEVER, I AM NOT AN EXPERT GRADER IN COLONIAL COINS. THIS COIN HAS VERY DISCERNABLE DETAILS. MUCH OF THE DETAIL IS VERY VISIBLE. THE LETTERING AND DATE ARE VISIBLE. THE COIN APPEARS WITHOUT ANY CORROSION OR GRANULATION ON A SMOOTH CHOCOLATE PLANCHET. PLEASE CHECK SCANS. THIS COIN WOULD ADEQUATELY FIT IN ANY COLONIAL U.S. COLLECTION
roadrunner
I probably wouldn't have done anything since the OP said the PVC came right off and couldn't have been that big a deal on a VG coin exposed for the time of mailing. IF I was sensitive enough to be upset by the sellers carelessness, I MAY have contacted him via the EBAY system about the item and informed him I was disappointed to see that he had packaged and mailed the coin in a sloppy manner. I would have advised him that some buyers are picky about those sorts of things and that he might be fishing for negative feedback if he continues to be careless about shipping procedures.
The point made by Russ, that the OP over reacted by making his neutral feedback a first course of action is correct IMO. I'm not condoning the poor shipping practice and the seller should know better...I'm just addressing the OP's original question "did I over react?" IMO, yes.
Greg Hansen, Melbourne, FL Click here for any current EBAY auctions Multiple "Circle of Trust" transactions over 14 years on forum