What would you guys grade this 1936 Wheatie ??

GrimReaper

It's Red all the way , is it worth slabbing ?? Didn't know if it would make a 66 or 67 !!

LotsoLuck

Since it is not a key date I see no problem bagging a 67.

seanq

IMHO the three possible outcomes are:

- possibly no grade if the spot by IN is active contamination;
- probably MS64RD due to the carbon spot in the left obverse field;
- best case scenario MS65RD, not worth the fees to submit.


Sean Reynolds

TexasNationals

Not worth it

GrimReaper

<< <i>IMHO the three possible outcomes are:

- possibly no grade if the spot by IN is active contamination;
- probably MS64RD due to the carbon spot in the left obverse field;
- best case scenario MS65RD, not worth the fees to submit.


Sean Reynolds >>



The carbon spot is there but the others are flip pieces !! Just curious as to what you guys thought !!

numobri

The cabon spot kills it for me,

If it's the best you have, I would keep it.

Nice coin.


Brian

BigE

I think its a great coin for a album, maybe if you were short a coin for an economy submission, send it in, but I think 64 maybe 65, but pcgs may be worried about the guarantee to grade any higher because of the spot---------BigE

Type2

I'll go with MS65/66RD but the cabon spot will only get bigger in time. Nice Cent.

robkool

MS65RD... That small carbon spot will keep it out of a 66RD.

Bigrig52

Not worth slabbing

BillJones

I'd give it an MS-65, Red. "Carbon spots" bug me so I might be harder on this piece than most people.

RedTiger

I vote 65RD, spot and hit in the field, not worth submission fees.

metalmeister

Nice as is.

SamByrd

66 red . Not worth the slab though.

1Mike1

66

MikeInFL

Spot limits grade to 65 red, IMO.