It's hard to say of it is under graded without knowing the grade assigned. It is not a coin that I would select.
Retired dealer and avid collector of U.S. type coins, 19th century presidential campaign medalets and selected medals. In recent years I have been working on a set of British coins - at least one coin from each king or queen who issued pieces that are collectible. I am also collecting at least one coin for each Roman emperor from Julius Caesar to ... ?
My opinion would be AU58 with the rub on the cheek and beard keeping it from getting a mint state designation. Those of you guessing 40 and 45, have you seen xf45 slabbed Lincon's from PCGS???? Tough crowd! Shag
<< <i>My opinion would be AU58 with the rub on the cheek and beard keeping it from getting a mint state designation. Those of you guessing 40 and 45, have you seen xf45 slabbed Lincon's from PCGS???? Tough crowd! Shag >>
I would agree with AU53, but am not a lincoln collector. Price-wise, this is a pretty small difference from AU50 up to AU58, right? Unless it is like a VG8 holder or something really odd, it seems like the cost difference versus the regrading fees might not be worth it. Feel free to educate me if there is a bigger cost spread on these in circulated grades.
For the guys who are grading it less than AU, is that because of impaired luster? Would love to hear your thoughts and learn.
With the reengraved die from 1916 the beard and hair detail will be very vivid on a 55 or especially a 58. There is wear viisible on the bust but not enough wear on the wheat stalks to take it to XF.
These designs were so meticulously well-engraved that the slightest wear tends to show up most prominently on these. This one has streaks of wood-graining, too, which tend to be confused with wear, sometimes, especially in pictures. Based on these two sets of pictures, I'd give this one a technical, middle-of-the-road AU. The wear I see is on the face (ear, cheek, jaw, chin), hardly nothing on the coat. If the TPG got it right, and if these pictures tell the whole story, they market graded this one AU55.
<< <i>My opinion would be AU58 with the rub on the cheek and beard keeping it from getting a mint state designation. Those of you guessing 40 and 45, have you seen xf45 slabbed Lincon's from PCGS???? Tough crowd! Shag >>
AU may very well be the case. The coin has a nice wholesome look and few hits. Plus, we all know about mint-marked Lincolns from the teens and 20's and how miserable the strikes and planchets were.
But XF is not out of the question. Here's a recently graded XF40 for comparison. I'll grant you it is baggier and without the eye appeal of the OP's but wear is consistent. I'd give the OP's coin a grade bump or two over this one but I just don't see high AU.
<< <i>My opinion would be AU58 with the rub on the cheek and beard keeping it from getting a mint state designation. Those of you guessing 40 and 45, have you seen xf45 slabbed Lincon's from PCGS???? Tough crowd! Shag >>
AU may very well be the case. The coin has a nice wholesome look and few hits. Plus, we all know about mint-marked Lincolns from the teens and 20's and how miserable the strikes and planchets were.
But XF is not out of the question. Here's a recently graded XF40 for comparison. I'll grant you it is baggier and without the eye appeal of the OP's but wear is consistent. I'd give the OP's coin a grade bump or two over this one but I just don't see high AU.
But I've been wrong a lot lately... Lance. >>
Lance, the hits may take down the market grade on yours, some, but I do see the wear on your coin's coat as technical, XF-level wear. I'll tell you right now, though, I'm not very good with these numbers, nor at assigning market grades.
EDIT: I know, I know, you don't have to say it, it shows.
If you had only shown me the first photo I would have guessed AU55; if you had only shown me the second I would have guessed XF45. I guess I'll split the difference and call it an AU50.
If the holder says AU-anything I would not consider it as an upgrade candidate, if it is in an XF holder then I could see it, though I doubt the value would increase enough to offset the cost.
Sean Reynolds
Incomplete planchets wanted, especially Lincoln Cents & type coins.
"Keep in mind that most of what passes as numismatic information is no more than tested opinion at best, and marketing blather at worst. However, I try to choose my words carefully, since I know that you guys are always watching." - Joe O'Connor
<< <i>If you had only shown me the first photo I would have guessed AU55; if you had only shown me the second I would have guessed XF45. I guess I'll split the difference and call it an AU50.
If the holder says AU-anything I would not consider it as an upgrade candidate, if it is in an XF holder then I could see it, though I doubt the value would increase enough to offset the cost.
Sean Reynolds >>
Smokincoin, I think you need to show Sean one more set of pictures.
Just a point. Judging from the AU58 wear on you coin's ear, cheek, and jaw, were the beard and chin hair detail as defined as is typical on the FY 1916 strikes, that wear would likely show up, there, too. It doesn't on yours, of course, as, by that FY, ol' Honest Abe just so happened to have been more cleanly-shaven.
I learned alot! Thanks! I thought it ought to be AU55. edited to add: No, I'm not wanting or trying to get an upgrade. Just trying to learn and this thread's been wonderful!
<< <i>If you had only shown me the first photo I would have guessed AU55; if you had only shown me the second I would have guessed XF45. I guess I'll split the difference and call it an AU50.
If the holder says AU-anything I would not consider it as an upgrade candidate, if it is in an XF holder then I could see it, though I doubt the value would increase enough to offset the cost.
Sean Reynolds >>
Smokincoin, I think you need to show Sean one more set of pictures. >>
I just saw the photo of the coin in the slab. Definitely an AU50
Sean Reynolds
Incomplete planchets wanted, especially Lincoln Cents & type coins.
"Keep in mind that most of what passes as numismatic information is no more than tested opinion at best, and marketing blather at worst. However, I try to choose my words carefully, since I know that you guys are always watching." - Joe O'Connor
Comments
Empty Nest Collection
RMR: 'Wer, wenn ich schriee, hörte mich denn aus der Engel Ordnungen?'
CJ: 'No one!' [Ain't no angels in the coin biz]
Eric
Lance.
guessing 40 and 45, have you seen xf45 slabbed Lincon's from PCGS???? Tough crowd! Shag
Bob
Lordmarcovan, WTCG, YogiBerraFan, Phoenin21, LindeDad, Coll3ctor, blue594, robkoll, Mike Dixon, BloodMan, Flakthat and others.
<< <i>My opinion would be AU58 with the rub on the cheek and beard keeping it from getting a mint state designation. Those of you
guessing 40 and 45, have you seen xf45 slabbed Lincon's from PCGS???? Tough crowd! Shag >>
For the guys who are grading it less than AU, is that because of impaired luster? Would love to hear your thoughts and learn.
luster doesnt need to be present on a 50 BN.
<< <i>My opinion would be AU58 with the rub on the cheek and beard keeping it from getting a mint state designation. Those of you
guessing 40 and 45, have you seen xf45 slabbed Lincon's from PCGS???? Tough crowd! Shag >>
AU may very well be the case. The coin has a nice wholesome look and few hits. Plus, we all know about mint-marked Lincolns from the teens and 20's and how miserable the strikes and planchets were.
But XF is not out of the question. Here's a recently graded XF40 for comparison. I'll grant you it is baggier and without the eye appeal of the OP's but wear is consistent. I'd give the OP's coin a grade bump or two over this one but I just don't see high AU.
But I've been wrong a lot lately...
Lance.
<< <i>
<< <i>My opinion would be AU58 with the rub on the cheek and beard keeping it from getting a mint state designation. Those of you
guessing 40 and 45, have you seen xf45 slabbed Lincon's from PCGS???? Tough crowd! Shag >>
AU may very well be the case. The coin has a nice wholesome look and few hits. Plus, we all know about mint-marked Lincolns from the teens and 20's and how miserable the strikes and planchets were.
But XF is not out of the question. Here's a recently graded XF40 for comparison. I'll grant you it is baggier and without the eye appeal of the OP's but wear is consistent. I'd give the OP's coin a grade bump or two over this one but I just don't see high AU.
But I've been wrong a lot lately...
Lance. >>
Lance, the hits may take down the market grade on yours, some, but I do see the wear on your coin's coat as technical, XF-level wear. I'll tell you right now, though, I'm not very good with these numbers, nor at assigning market grades.
EDIT: I know, I know, you don't have to say it, it shows.
WS
If the holder says AU-anything I would not consider it as an upgrade candidate, if it is in an XF holder then I could see it, though I doubt the value would increase enough to offset the cost.
Sean Reynolds
"Keep in mind that most of what passes as numismatic information is no more than tested opinion at best, and marketing blather at worst. However, I try to choose my words carefully, since I know that you guys are always watching." - Joe O'Connor
My Collection of Old Holders
Never a slave to one plastic brand will I ever be.
<< <i>If you had only shown me the first photo I would have guessed AU55; if you had only shown me the second I would have guessed XF45. I guess I'll split the difference and call it an AU50.
If the holder says AU-anything I would not consider it as an upgrade candidate, if it is in an XF holder then I could see it, though I doubt the value would increase enough to offset the cost.
Sean Reynolds >>
Smokincoin, I think you need to show Sean one more set of pictures.
<< <i>Here's a PCGS AU58: >>
That one grades D, Delicious!
Just a point. Judging from the AU58 wear on you coin's ear, cheek, and jaw, were the beard and chin hair detail as defined as is typical on the FY 1916 strikes, that wear would likely show up, there, too. It doesn't on yours, of course, as, by that FY, ol' Honest Abe just so happened to have been more cleanly-shaven.
I learned alot! Thanks! I thought it ought to be AU55.
edited to add: No, I'm not wanting or trying to get an upgrade. Just trying to learn and this thread's been wonderful!
<< <i>
<< <i>If you had only shown me the first photo I would have guessed AU55; if you had only shown me the second I would have guessed XF45. I guess I'll split the difference and call it an AU50.
If the holder says AU-anything I would not consider it as an upgrade candidate, if it is in an XF holder then I could see it, though I doubt the value would increase enough to offset the cost.
Sean Reynolds >>
Smokincoin, I think you need to show Sean one more set of pictures.
I just saw the photo of the coin in the slab. Definitely an AU50
Sean Reynolds
"Keep in mind that most of what passes as numismatic information is no more than tested opinion at best, and marketing blather at worst. However, I try to choose my words carefully, since I know that you guys are always watching." - Joe O'Connor
60 years into this hobby and I'm still working on my Lincoln set!