Assess these cards for a grade and a contest

cpettimd

Recent pickups for PSA submission. The 1962 Aaron is a raw purchase. The 58 Aaron Mantle is not in a PSA holder, but will be cracked and submitted. The Clemente pic was in a lot of items.
(1)1962 Aaron what do you think this will grade?
(2) 1958 Aaron Mantle what do you think this will grade ?

(3) The contest. I need to identify what this Clemente photo card is (year and manufacturer etc) , as well as a source reference (wondering if anyone will grade this). I will send someone a HOF collectible to the first person who helps me with accurate info on this.

I put up some graded 62's for comparison. I am not so good with these 1962's. The edges and corners look pretty solid on the Aaron to me ?

here is a 62 in 8 and 7 for comparison I do not see any chipping on the aaron edges or corners.

itzagoner

'62 Hank looks good for a 7.....i sincerely hope that SGC gasket isn't creating the crimp marks on the top border reverse of the '58, but i'll say 7 on that one as well.

don't know about the Clemente, but it certainly doesn't surprise me that you are the one who has it.

cincyredlegs

62 Aaron - I would say a 6.5. It may be the scan but the top LH edge looks a little suspect.
58 Aaron/Mantle - I would say a 6

I have seen the Clemente before but can't remember who produced it.


Mark

OAKESY25

my guess..
7 aaron
8 mantle /aaron

and the clemente picture I actually own and my grades just popped yesterday

12 1 17237886 N9: NOT GRADED NO SPEC INFO, NO GRADE VOUCHER Card US

I figured it was a team issue from like 1957.. but psa doesn't know either

swartz1

Yes - 7 on the Aaron...

good call on those marks from the SGC holder - that is a shame...