Photoshop fun with 1916 vs 1917 SLQ's

Alltheabove76

-------------------------------------------------------------------

jmj3esq

Now thats cool!

Meltdown

Very Cool, thanks. I'm memorizing the diagnostics.

MFH

THANK YOU !!!!!

I wish I had those images when I was a teenager going thru rolls
of silver quarters. I came upon so many dateless Type One's -
and I couldn't tell a 16 from a 17 without an actual dated example
in front of me.

johnny54321

Great work! Now we just need to create one that gradually "morphs" from the 1916 to 1917. ;-)

jesbroken

What are the actual diagnostics, other than the inner shield, the head into the border, and the flatness of the garment over her right biceps. That's all I know and would appreciate any additional diagnostics.
Thanks
Jim

Alltheabove76

<< <i>Great work! Now we just need to create one that gradually "morphs" from the 1916 to 1917. ;-) >>



How is this?

Dentuck

The laurel that Miss Liberty is holding changes.

PerryHall

<< <i>What are the actual diagnostics, other than the inner shield, the head into the border, and the flatness of the garment over her right biceps. That's all I know and would appreciate any additional diagnostics.
Thanks
Jim >>



Check the oval fold just above the 19. It appears more closed and flat on the 1916.

gonzer

Great visuals. Thanks for the effort behind it.

BillJones

Actually this is a really great way to note the subtle differences in the diework between the 1916 and 1917 Type 1 coins. Thanks for showing us this!

Alltheabove76

I worked a long time on that, I hope someone saves it and puts it on a website somewhere.

Broadstruck

Alltheabove76

DCW

Excellent work here! Very informative, thanks for posting it!

pakasmom

<< <i>I worked a long time on that, I hope someone saves it and puts it on a website somewhere. >>



Or, maybe on a poster to hang in the grading room.

SCDHunter

<< <i>What are the actual diagnostics, other than the inner shield, the head into the border, and the flatness of the garment over her right biceps. That's all I know and would appreciate any additional diagnostics.
Thanks
Jim >>



I am not an expert on these, but I think the 6 and 7 are the easiest diagnostics to identify.

divecchia

Nice morphing job...

Donato

coinguy1

<< <i>

<< <i>What are the actual diagnostics, other than the inner shield, the head into the border, and the flatness of the garment over her right biceps. That's all I know and would appreciate any additional diagnostics.
Thanks
Jim >>



I am not an expert on these, but I think the 6 and 7 are the easiest diagnostics to identify. >>

Not when the coins are so worn that the date doesn't show. And at that point, there are still other diagnostics that do show.

Alltheabove76

<< <i>

<< <i>

<< <i>What are the actual diagnostics, other than the inner shield, the head into the border, and the flatness of the garment over her right biceps. That's all I know and would appreciate any additional diagnostics.
Thanks
Jim >>



I am not an expert on these, but I think the 6 and 7 are the easiest diagnostics to identify. >>

Not when the coins are so worn that the date doesn't show. And at that point, there are still other diagnostics that do show. >>



Not to mention being able to tell altered dates by looking at the other diagnostics.

sinin1

thanks for all the effort

it would be nice in a FR-02 or a P-01 where most people are scratching their heads

HoledandCreative

Nice post. As others have mentioned, it would be very informative to see dateless ones morph. And maybe a set of VFs, VGs, and AGs to watch them wear. Endless possibilities for your talent. Thanks.

QuarterCollector

very cool. great work

MarkInDavis

<< <i>What are the actual diagnostics, other than the inner shield, the head into the border, and the flatness of the garment over her right biceps. That's all I know and would appreciate any additional diagnostics.
Thanks
Jim >>



The diagnostic I find most useful (especially for very worn or dateless coins) is the shape of the curve of the bottom of the gown outside liberty's right foot. I keep hoping to spot a dateless, slabbable 1916.

toyz4geo

Very cool. I gotta get Photoshop!

morgandollar1878

Very cool pictures, and great looking SLQs too.

tumbleweedtrumpet

Wow, thanks!

ebaybuyer

VERY sweet ! i have pics of both but the dfifferences are SO much easier to spot with your morph job. im off to find a dateless 1916

habaraca

Thanks to the OP

oih82w8

I seen this comparison image from another forum years ago.

LanceNewmanOCC

@Alltheabove76 said:

NICE.

you did that before i even joined the forum.

Garfield2022

@pakasmom said:
<< I worked a long time on that, I hope someone saves it and puts it on a website somewhere. >>

Or, maybe on a poster to hang in the grading room.

I was able to save it-just because I think it's cool. Great job!

Atcarroll

@Alltheabove76 said:

It's tricking my brain into hearing it switch, but only when it switches to the 1916

thebeav

That's pretty neat. Nice work

habaraca

@Alltheabove76 said:

can you repost your overlay or PM me a link for it.......