PCGS AG-3 1916 SLQ on Heritage. Very Questionable.

swhuck

Mark Van Winkle and Lee Abramson have seen the coin, and both concur that it's no good. (I've seen it as well and agree with them, but they don't pay me to authenticate ). The coin has been removed from the auction, and we are working with the consignor and PCGS directly.

By all means, please contact us if there are any issues with coins in our auctions. Thanks to everyone who posted in this thread!

Barndog

<< <i>Mark Van Winkle and Lee Abramson have seen the coin, and both concur that it's no good. (I've seen it as well and agree with them, but they don't pay me to authenticate ). The coin has been removed from the auction, and we are working with the consignor and PCGS directly.

By all means, please contact us if there are any issues with coins in our auctions. Thanks to everyone who posted in this thread! >>

Broadstruck

<< <i>Mark Van Winkle and Lee Abramson have seen the coin, and both concur that it's no good. (I've seen it as well and agree with them, but they don't pay me to authenticate ). The coin has been removed from the auction, and we are working with the consignor and PCGS directly.

By all means, please contact us if there are any issues with coins in our auctions. Thanks to everyone who posted in this thread! >>



swhuck, With the auction end following right after the weekend I wasn't expecting this.

Moldnut

Is the PCGS holder good?

mdwoods

Good job guys and kudos to Heritage for being so responsive. I expect PCGS will show the concern.

coinguy1

<< <i>Mark Van Winkle and Lee Abramson have seen the coin, and both concur that it's no good. (I've seen it as well and agree with them, but they don't pay me to authenticate ). The coin has been removed from the auction, and we are working with the consignor and PCGS directly.

By all means, please contact us if there are any issues with coins in our auctions. Thanks to everyone who posted in this thread! >>

Stewart, thank you and Heritage for your efforts.

pakasmom

Thank you, Johnny54321 for catching it.

Thank you Mr. Feld for lending your voice.

And thank you Heritage for doing the right thing...

cmerlo1

WTG Heritage! I'm confident PCGS will do the right thing...

johnny54321

Great News! Thanks to Stewart and Mr. Stone for looking into this.

kaz

Good news!

frnklnlvr

Looks like PCGS has taken care of this.

BUFFNIXX

You can tell right away that this coin is a 1917 as there is not a break in the beeds above ms. liberty's head. a no question 1917 and I am surprised that pcgs did not get this one right. buffnixx

johnny54321

Way to go PCGS!!

I have another one for you guys, ICG this time.
Don't ICG slabs usually have a number and barcode? Fake slab maybe?



Link