Grade the Peace $ Reverse. (Poll)

Peaceman

This is a 1923 Peace $. Based on the reverse only, what would you grade it:

lkeigwin

66? Could even be 67.

But I don't think I want it.
Lance.

abitofthisabitofthat

Our hosts have been, at least to me, brutal on grading Peace dollars lately. I have stopped sending them in. It is tough to get a feel for the luster of this coin from the photo, but I suspect that it is somewhat subdued.

Peaceman

The coin above is actually blinding balst white. Here's a 67 from an OGH, 1923

abitofthisabitofthat

Now that coin has some luster!

DoubleEagle59

the OP's coin has got to be an ms65 at least!

I'm voting for an ms66.

Peaceman

And a 68, although a 24.

Peaceman

The first picture has as much luster as this coin (different coin).

relicsncoins

32.5, it's half way to 65.

Peaceman

Looks like 8 or 7 now.... Seriously, it's a 7 all day long even with the strike not all being there. Obverse is clean but border 7, we'll see what PCGS says.

sinin1

I was gonna go with the 63 option, but not there


I am not a PEACEMAN, but blazing luster because of die erosion, is not my favorite


why are you showing and asking about the reverse?

reverses usually do not add to a grade, just bring it down


so - I could see that reverse on anything from an AU58 through MS67


had to edit after looking again - I am assuming that is die erosion rather than some light whizzing

Peaceman

lol... I can't grade Ikes either...

johnny9434

an obverse pic would help nail it

ricko

Appears to be a nice coin, but the picture is so large, it is hard to evaluate the actual surface. Everything is magnified to a point beyond what a visual 'in hand' evaluation would show. Cheers, RickO

lkeigwin

Let's see the obverse which counts more.
Lance.

bluelobster

I'd say 66 on the reverse, but who knows what the grade is without the obverse.

Peaceman

I only have the rev pic from the recycle bin. I'll get the coin at the bank Monday and take some better pics....