Grade opinion for Morgan please.........

DoubleEagle59

Your opinion would be much appreciated.
All four pictures are of the same coin.
True color is the first and third pictures.
Second and fourth pics are reflected light to show the surface flaws better (not much on the reverse, but moreso on the obverse).

relicsncoins

Looks to be a touch of rub........AU55.

doh

Nice looking 55 to me

coinguy1

AU58, with a shot at AU55.

morgandollar1878

AU 55

JJM

I agree with the rest...in the 50's

coinkat

55

jmj3esq

AU55..maybe AU58 on a good day.

Windycity

AU58

SurfinxHI

too many dings on the obverse for MS...AU 53 maybe 58...I'm with the herd.

Greg

RedHerring

53 would be the conservative grade. 58 would be liberal.

magikbilly

"...too many dings on the obverse for MS...AU 53 maybe 58...I'm with the herd." - Surfinx HI


Hi there,

Same - 55. The coment above mine quoted above - I don't think "dings" preclude Mint State, just keep it at 60 or wherever it belongs for the hypothetical.

Best,
Eric

chucknra

55 to me.

ricko

AU 50/53... the tarnish conceals a lot... Cheers, RickO

buffalohunter

MS60

kryptonitecomics

55

magikbilly

pardon the double post

magikbilly

Hi again,

now that I am awake - 50.

Best,
Eric

kurtdog

This one really isn't that "flawed." Were it MS, it would be pushing 63-64. It lacks the luster for that, though, for one, it's pretty "flat." Plus, there is wear. You can make that out most easily in pics 1 and 3.

I'll go solid 55 as a technical or condition grade on this one. That nice, uniform, "antique" toning, though, should, rightfully, be compensated for, and as such should put a premium on this one. Overall, IMHO, this is an eye-appealing, lightly-circulated coin.

LRCTom

Looks like an AU-58 to me, but because it's an 01-P, the services might give it extra scrutiny, and call it a 55, or a 53 on a bad day. Nice coin.

...Tom

keets

if the rim is as bad as the bottom picture makes it look they might NG for rim damage.

metalmeister

Looks 53-55 maybe
AT?

ziggy29

I'd say 53, maybe 55. A 1901-P is a condition rarity so I'd imagine little to no benefit of the doubt given to it. Also it's hard to discern the amount of remaining luster on the coin from the image, and in the AU range that's a significant factor in the grade.